Analysis 10:11 18/04/2015

Nuclear deal or no nuclear deal? That is the question

By Catherine Shakdam, RT

As neocons are working to destroy Iran's tentative nuclear deal, US President Obama will have to either reinvent America's policy or give in to Israel's lobby and Saudi Arabia's paranoiac fear of Shia Islam.

If months of intense political wrangling were crowned earlier this April by the confirmation that Iran and the P5+1 countries reached a tentative framework agreement over one of the most contentious issue of the past three decades - Iran's nuclear dossier - it appears such diplomatic respite could prelude to a dangerous political standoff.

If by any account Iran's nuclear negotiations were going to be trying, especially since Tehran's nuclear ambitions do not necessarily sit at the center of this internationally staged quarrel, Israel's neocon war campaign against the Islamic Republic risks pushing the world toward yet another lengthy conflict- a global one at that.

With the fires of war already burning bright in the MENA region - Middle East and North Africa - the fall of another domino could prove one too many for the word to handle. From a purely geostrategic standpoint a war with Iran, however pleasing to Tel Aviv’s avid warmongers, would likely force Western powers and their Arab allies to commit more military power than they can handle. Bearing in mind that the US has already committed troops and resources to Afghanistan, Libya, Pakistan, Yemen, Syria, Iraq, and of course Ukraine, how much farther can imperial America really stretch?

However grand the US might think itself to be, and however solid the US might think its alliances to be, Washington has yet to win a war. Claiming victory as George W. Bush did in Iraq on May 1, 2003 did not exactly make it so. And though America basked in the glorious light of its military supremacy over the "Iraqi enemy," its joy was short-lived as reality soon came knocking. And though starting a war might seem an easy enough business for neocon America, it is really the art of peace this belligerent nation has failed to master so far.

But back to Iran's nuclear deal.

To the surprise of many skeptics, Iran and the P5+1 did reach a deal - and while there were a few near misses, a deal was nevertheless brokered; proof experts actually insisted that Tehran is more interested in diplomacy than its detractors gives it credit for. Iran's concessions attest to its officials' determination to engage with the international community and integrate back into mainstream international politics.

As Gareth Porter wrote in a report for CounterPunch this April, "The framework agreement reached on Thursday night [April 2, 2015] clearly gives the P5+1 a combination of constraints on Iran’s nuclear program that should reassure all but the most bellicose opponents of diplomacy."

And although Iran gave every assurance its government will not seek to weaponize its nuclear program, no amount of concessions might prove sufficient enough or comprehensive enough to assuage Washington's fears vis-a-vis its "great Satan" - especially if the Saudis and Israelis have a say in it.

With the ink of the nuclear framework agreement still left to dry, both the powerful Israeli lobby and Al Saud's petrodollars went on overdrive, telling the world what a catastrophe Iran's nuclear deal would be.

One trip to US Congress and a few well-chosen words against its mortal enemy later, Israel seems satisfied it forever drove a wrench into the yet to be formulated and signed nuclear agreement.

As Yuval Steinitz, Israel minister for intelligence and strategic affairs so eloquently told the world on April 6, Israel would try to persuade the P5 +1 “not to sign this bad deal or at least to dramatically change or fix it”. 

Echoing his minister's narrative, Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu determined that since Iran represents a threat to Israel's very existence, America should abandon all diplomacy and instead beat the war drums. And we don’t really need to know why, only that it is so - If Netanyahu's drawing did not convince your idle mind of Iran's evil in 2012 then nothing will!

Just as Israel's lobby bullied its way through the Oval office, cornering U.S. President Barak Obama into relenting power to Congress, Saudi Arabia declared war on Yemen, adding a new layer of complication to an already impossible mesh of over-lapping and over-conflicting alliances in the Middle East, thus weaving a dangerous noose around peace's neck.

Interestingly, if war requires no US Congress oversight you can be sure that peace does!

Caught in between a rock at home and a hard place in the Middle East, US President Obama is faced with one mighty dilemma - one which will determine not his presidency but his very legacy.

If recent tensions between President Obama and the Israeli Premier are anything to go by, it would appear Israel's lobby suit of armor is not as thick and potent as it'd like it to be, or maybe just maybe, it simply exhausted Americans' patience. Israel's greatest ally and supporter, the one power which has quite literally and almost single-handedly carried the Jewish State into being and helped it survive adverse winds since its very inception in 1948: vetoing UNSC resolutions when needed, propping its military and economy when needed, acting a political champion when needed, could be running out of road.

If Israel and Saudi Arabia's foreign agenda stand now in perfect alignment - their ire directed not at one another but at Iran, changes in the region and fast-moving geostrategic interests have forced the US to re-evaluate its position vis-a-vis Iran and the so-called mythical Shia crescent the world has learnt to be wary of without quite understanding why.

In Netanyahu's officials' own words we are to believe that Islamic radicalism, a perverted, acetic and reactionary interpretation of Islam which has mapped itself around Saudi Arabia's Wahhabism movement would be preferable to seeing Iran gain a greater footing in the Arab world. In September 2013, the Israeli Ambassador to the United States Michael Oren told the Jerusalem Post that Israel favored the Sunni extremists over Assad and the Shiites. “The greatest danger to Israel is by the [Shiite] strategic arc that extends from Tehran, to Damascus to Beirut. And we saw the Assad regime as the keystone in that arc,” Oren said in an interview.

“We always wanted Bashar Assad to go, we always preferred the bad guys who weren’t backed by Iran to the bad guys who were backed by Iran.” He said this was the case even if the “bad guys” were affiliated with al-Qaeda.

Obviously Saudi Arabia would rather eat its own foot than allow the all so devilish Iran from reclaiming its standing in the region, especially since it would essentially mean relenting power to rising calls for democratic reforms in the Gulf monarchies - Bahrain being the flagship of such a desire for change.

Why do that when you can wage senseless wars to assert your dominion?

Iran's nuclear deal is more than just a nuclear deal. If signed, this deal would become the cornerstone of a broad shift in alliances, the moment when the US would actually choose to put its national interests over that of Tel Aviv and over Riyadh's billions. Where Israel has bullied the US for decades, Saudi Arabia has bought its policies for decades.

With nothing left to lose but his good name and his legacy, President Obama could be just the man to break this self-destructing cycle and reinvent America's foreign policy.

And that's not even wishful thinking it would actually make sense for America to make peace with Iran - economically, politically and in terms of energy security and counter-terrorism Iran could be a more helpful and potent ally than Saudi Arabia. Bearing in mind that Riyadh's fingerprints are all over al-Qaeda, ISIS and whatever terror offshoots radicals created those days, Washington might want to consider another ally in its fight against radicalism.

Thing is, America wants change! What it needs now is mastering the courage of its desire.

America is a superpower running out of steam, and more importantly running out of standing in the world. America's exceptionalism is on its last leg. Too many double-standards, too many incoherencies in its alliances, too many double-talks, double-entendres and double-crossings. America needs a deal.

And though the July deadline seems very far away indeed, especially since Yemen's war came to yank at diplomacy's already stretched out rope; not signing the nuclear deal would be far worse than ruffling Israel and Saudi Arabia's feathers.

For the sake of argument, why not ask Israel to pay the world the courtesy of practicing what it preaches in terms of nuclear transparency. That would be the nuclear deal of the century!
 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:06
Armenian villagers protest over lack of irrigation water
More than a hundred residents of Vardanashen, a village in Armenia’s Armavir Province, on Friday blocked the Yerevan-Margara highway...
16:45
Angelina Jolie accuses Brad Pitt of trying to 'bleed her dry'
It's a breakup that's lasted almost as long as the relationship that preceded it. Dubbed 'the war of the rosés,'...
16:35
Court in Yerevan rejects police lawsuit against oppositionist
The Administrative Court in Yerevan has rejected a lawsuit filed by the police against Karen Vrtanesyan, an expert on military and warfare...
15:59
Exhibition of sculptures dedicated to Charles Aznavour to be held in Yerevan
Yerevan's Two Arcs Art Space will be hosting an interactive exhibition of sculptures created by sculptor Mkrtich Mazmanian and...
15:40
Ruben Vardanyan launches hunger strike in Baku, demands release of all Armenian prisoners
The family of illegally detained philanthropist, Ruben Vardanyan, announced today that he entered into a hunger strike to demand the immediate...
15:06
Lavrov: Russia still considers Armenia an ally
Russia still considers Armenia an ally not only legally, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov has said, highlighting Moscow's...
14:33
Stepantsminda-Larsi road closed to trucks
The Rescue Service has warned drivers about closed roads in Armenia on Friday afternoon. In particular, the roads linking the Amberd high...
14:14
Expert: What Russia gains from troop withdrawal from Artsakh?
The withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) could signal a new conspiracy against Armenia, says Armen Petrosyan, a...
13:34
Opposition MP: Pashinyan lying about possible territory swap with Azerbaijan
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has brushed aside Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s claims about a possible swap of territories with...
12:34
Cyprus parliament honors Armenian Genocide victims
The Cyprus House of Representatives on Thursday evening observed a minute’s silence for the victims of the Armenian genocide, with the...
12:15
EFJ and UJA demand immediate release of Narek Samsonyan and Vazgen Saghatelyan
The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) joined its affiliate in Armenia, the Union of Journalists of Armenia (UJA), in denouncing the...
11:36
Baku must fulfil number of requirements to return to PACE, rapporteur says
Norwegian MP Lise Christoffersen, a PACE co-rapporteur on Azerbaijan, said that the Committee of Ministers is holding talks on Azerbaijan's...
11:16
Azerbaijan destroyed Kanach Zham in Shushi
Azerbaijan has destroyed the Armenian church of St. Hovhannes Mkrtich (St. John the Baptist) in Shushi, Artsakh, the Caucasus...
11:00
Iranian air defenses down three drones near Isfahan
Iranian state media said the country’s air defences brought down three small drones over the central city of Isfahan, hours after United...
17:05
Political prisoner Vazgen Saghatelyan blasts Pashinyan for crackdown on critics
Political prisoner Vazgen Saghatelyan, co-host of the Imnemnimi podcast who is currently held in pre-trial detention in the Armavir...
16:34
Iran threatens Israeli nuclear sites should its own be attacked
Iran could review its nuclear doctrine, says a senior Iranian Revolutionary Guards commander, according to state media agency Tasnim....
16:11
Mkhitaryan calls chance for Inter to clinch Serie A title 'crazy' and 'historic'
Henrikh Mkhitaryan feels that the chance for Inter Milan to clinch the Serie A title against AC Milan is “crazy” and...
15:35
Russian-Turkish monitoring center in Karabakh to close down
The joint Russian-Turkish monitoring center in Nagorno-Karabakh will cease its operations, Turkish National Defense Ministry...
15:06
Rep. Eshoo: We must not wait another century to hold Azerbaijan accountable for crimes against Armenians
The United States must not wait another century to hold Azerbaijan accountable for its ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh...
14:31
Protest to 'stop' Pashinyan held outside Armenian government
A group of people led by activist Vahagn Chakhalyan on Thursday staged a protest outside the Armenian government building in central Yerevan,...
13:55
Artsakh's entire cultural heritage at risk of destruction, expert warns
April 18 is observed annually as the International Day for Monuments and Sites, whose establishment was approved by the 22nd UNESCO General...
13:30
GRECO calls for stronger oversight and accountability in top executive functions and police in Armenia
The Council of Europe’s Group of States against Corruption (GRECO), in a report published today, calls on Armenia to pursue its efforts to...
12:58
U.S. State Dept comments on withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Artsakh
The withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) is yet another indication that Russia “is not a trustworthy...
12:36
Withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Artsakh not a surprise, expert says
The withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) is no surprise, says analyst Sergei Melkonian, a research fellow at...
12:13
Protesters briefly block street in central Yerevan
A group of protesters briefly blocked Abovyan Street near the Yeritasardakan subway station in central Yerevan on Thursday morning. Police...
11:35
Conference in Antelias to address Azerbaijan's genocidal acts against Artsakh Armenians
Under the auspices of His Holiness Catholicos Aram I, the Cilicia Analytical Platform will host a pan-Armenian conference titled...
11:15
Activist Samvel Vardanyan released on bail, placed under house arrest
Activist Samvel Vardanyan, an Armenian government critic who was detained after confronting a pro-government MP on Monday, has been released on...
11:00
Rep. Sherman calls for expanded U.S. assistance for Artsakh Armenians
Rep. Brad Sherman (D-CA) - who spearheaded the first U.S. aid package to Artsakh in 1998 - stressed the importance of expanding assistance to...
17:14
Pashinyan meets with Voskepar residents
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Wednesday met with residents of Voskepar, a village in Tavush Province, to assure them that the...
16:35
Official: Decision on peacekeepers’ pullout from Karabakh made by top leadership of Azerbaijan, Russia
The decision to withdraw Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh was made jointly by the top leadership of Azerbaijan and Russia, TASS...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}