Society 09:38 23/01/2015

To stem violence without undermining democracy: Europe’s challenge for 2015

In an interview with Sputnik News, Marie-Hélène Caillol, Head of the European Laboratory of Political Anticipation, speaks about challenges and threats for Europe to face in the nearest future.

Is the Charlie Hebdo tragedy an episode or rather a beginning of a chain of similar events that may plunge Europe in a deep internal conflict?

Marie-Hélène Caillol: Current crisis did not occur in the vacuum: it is a logical result of previous actions. Observing the dynamics of Western policy inside and outside Europe, many experts and analysts had anticipated that the explosion of tensions in the Middle East would have a rapid impact on European societies, bringing great risks to our democracies.

The European crisis has revealed a structural weakness in the European political system technically disconnected from its citizens. The great fear that Europe had in 2014 of going to war with a neighbour led, in 2015, to a real return of politics: we saw a Juncker Commission that decided to legitimize its political decisions, national governments finally aware of the need for effective political action, highly mobilized citizens.

Did it produce any tangible results? Made European politics more effective?

Marie-Hélène Caillol: All this would be rather reassuring if conditions had stabilized. But this is not the case since Europe is preparing to sustain a series of shocks associated with terrorist activities that are sure to be perpetrated by individuals or groups of individuals living in Europe but poorly integrated and connected to the terrible developments that the Middle East is currently experiencing. Now, in such a context, the return of politics can take an undesirable shape.

The year has quickly brought itself up to date with this bloody attack against the employees of the French satirical magazine, Charlie Hebdo, and the murderous chase which followed.

What impact may it have on the moods of ordinary Europeans? Do you see a danger of radicalization, especially from the far-right?

Marie-Hélène Caillol: Obviously, we have to keep in mind that beyond the chain of events that a regional scale conflict would have on the entire planet, a particularly worrying point for the time being taking into account the consequences that the outburst of hatred between Middle East’s communities would have on Europe. The verbal violence between Jews and Arabs is already huge, sporadically degenerating into more serious clashes. The explosion of anti-Semitism and racism is inevitably on the EU programme if the tensions develop in the way we are now observing. And this violence will also inevitably lead to the tipping of our weakened democracies which will be unable to stem it other than outside the rule of law.

Do you see any signs of recovery, positive reaction?

Marie-Hélène Caillol: Unfortunately the event is an opportunity to usher in a racist outbreak in France, but also in the whole of Europe and beyond, combined with the introduction of draconian measures.

But for once, Europeans were entitled to a nice surprise: almost exemplary crisis communications led by François Hollande, capitalizing on the more acceptable fears — that of a social explosion, managed to change the collective emotional reaction a priority with racist hints to a demand for non-linkage, no libertarian drift and union.

On 11 January, a rally of almost four million citizens in France and throughout the world, as well as the presence of 40 heads of state at the head of the procession, is truly an historic event and conveys a truly positive message, whatever one thinks of the true motivation for the gathering.

Actually, in fact, many questions arise on what has really reunited all these people: a mixture of a reaffirmation of badly understood republican principles and true concern for the preservation of democratic values, an expression of exasperation vis-à-vis a poorly integrated Muslim community and a will to bring together the moderates of all the religious communities, seeking order and seeking freedom, lack of discrimination and tolerance,… there was a little of everything in this rally. But regardless, the dominant message is generous and rather successful.

That was a very important but rather symbolic manifestation that may not influence the situation in the long therm. And what about specific political measures — and their possible impact?

Marie-Hélène Caillol: This major gathering is not the end of the story. Anti-Muslim acts have multiplied since the attack; the police are on red alert and the young of Arabic origin are being checked hand over fist; ideas of a European style “Patriot Act” crisscross society; once again the Muslim community is offended by a front-page publication on the current issue of Charlie Hebdo caricaturing their Prophet… so many reactions which will inevitably feed the ranks of identity fanaticism and increase the risk of violence.

Furthermore, the demand for freedom of expression is in the process of ending the lock which had been placed on criticism of Israel and the Jews. If the cartoons of Mohammed are no longer racism, then many “jokes” may no longer be called anti-Semitic too. On the merits, this release of the right to mock and criticize others would probably be a good thing but it comes at the worst possible moment. Everyone knows that 2015 runs huge risks of racist and anti-Semitic drift (since we must distinguish between the two). And just at this moment, the safeguards of intergroup communication have been lowered.

Is Europe ready — institutionally, legally, morally — for such a clash? Are there any other models that could be implemented to avoid the clash between communities?

Marie-Hélène Caillol: However French and European laws, born out of a history of religious wars and intolerance, do not advocate complete freedom of expression. This claim is actually modelled on the US where freedom of expression is absolute and sacred… even if it’s only respected in the context of non-public expression. The organs and public figures have, in turn, speech extremely controlled by the famous “political correctness”, particularly on all questions of minorities and religion. In Europe on the other hand, “political correctness” is applied less precisely because freedom of expression has a legal framework here.

One thing is certain. If European Muslims are forced to accept what corresponds to very strong cultural baiting in a context of public expression which remains tightly controlled for other cultural groups (homosexuals, Jews, etc…), there will be division. The challenge is to balance the freedom of expression in order that it doesn’t degenerate into provocations and racist abuse from all sides; all the same it’s going to be necessary to reiterate the rules of communication which are certainly free but also responsible.

Beyond the great, generous impulse of 11 January, countless questions remain on how to stem the wave of racist and terrorist violence that has begun to sweep over Europe, with respect to our democratic principles. This is the big challenge in 2015.
 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

12:50
Rep. Schiff commemorates Armenian Genocide anniversary
U.S. Representative Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), Vice Chair of the Congressional Armenian Caucus, released the following statement to...
12:35
Protesters block Yerevan-Gyumri highway
People in Armenia's Shirak Province on Thursday blocked the Yerevan-Gyumri highway in protest against the Armenian government’s...
12:05
School students go on strike in Armenia's Tavush
School students in Baghanis, a border village in Armenia’s Tavush Province, walked out of classes on Thursday to protest against the...
11:35
Azerbaijan removes coat of arms from Artsakh government building
A video circulating on social media shows Azerbaijani occupants removing Artsakh’s coat of arms and Armenian inscriptions from the Artsakh...
11:15
USAID chief pays tribute to Armenian Genocide victims
USAID Administrator Samantha Power commemorated the Armenian Genocide victims on the 109th anniversary of the tragedy marked on Wednesday....
11:00
42 Armenians missing after Azeri attack on Nagorno-Karabakh, report says
A total of 42 Armenians, including 12 civilians, went missing following Azerbaijan’s military takeover...
17:05
Political analyst: Pashinyan has long lost his status as Armenian PM
Nikol Pashinyan has long ceased to be Armenia’s prime minister, becoming Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev's “ambassador”...
16:34
Catholicos Karekin II commemorates Armenian Genocide victims
His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians, accompanied by the members of the Brotherhood of the Mother See of...
15:49
Support for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to Tsitsernakaberd
This year, on the 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, banners could be seen at the top of Tsitsernakaberd, reading, "Free Armenian...
15:19
Biden pays tribute to Armenian Genocide victims
U.S. President Joe Biden commemorated the 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide in a statement on Wednesday. The full...
15:05
Greek president marks Armenian Genocide anniversary
Acknowledgement and vigilance is required for the victims of the Armenian Genocide, Greek President Katerina Sakellaropoulou said in a statement...
14:36
'Nikol, murderer'. Pashinyan's wife booed at Tsitsernakaberd
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's spouse, Anna Hakobyan, was booed while visiting the Tsitsernakaberd Memorial Complex in Yerevan to...
14:15
U.S. State Department report reveals torture, arbitrary detentions in Armenia
The U.S. Department of State has released its annual 2023 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices, saying significant human rights issues in...
13:35
Genocide threat still present in the world – Foreign Ministry
The Armenian Foreign Ministry issued a statement on the 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide marked on April 24. The full statement is...
13:25
Armenia’s decision on CSTO membership its sovereign choice, chief says
The choice of Armenia’s authorities to remain in the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) or leave it will be the...
13:11
'A complete lack of transparency': Ruben Vardanyan's son talks about his detention in Baku
CNN's Christiane Amanpour speaks with David Vardanyan, son of Ruben Vardanyan, the former leader of the Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh)...
12:46
Macron commemorates Armenian Genocide anniversary
French President Emmanuel Macron has marked the 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire. “Today, France...
12:27
LIVE: March to Tsitsernakabert Memorial on Armenian Genocide anniversary
People have been marching to the Tsitsernakabert Memorial Complex in Yerevan since early Wednesday morning to commemorate the 109th anniversary...
12:00
Serzh Sargsyan: Armenian leaders trying to send Armenian Genocide into oblivion
Third Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan issued a message on the 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide commemorated on April 24. His full...
11:45
What will Pashinyan do next, demolish the Genocide Museum?
By Harut Sassounian TheCaliforniaCourier.com Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his equally incompetent underlings have been making for...
11:33
Freedom House concerned by reports of police violence in Armenia
Freedom House has expressed concern over mounting reports of police violence in Armenia. “We urge Armenian authorities to investigate...
11:15
Noubar Afeyan issues global call to prevent a second Armenian genocide
The Aurora Humanitarian Initiative today announced that co-founder Noubar Afeyan has issued a global call to action to prevent a second Armenian...
11:00
Today marks 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
Today, on April 24, Armenians around the world commemorate the 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, also known as Medz Yeghern...
17:03
Expert: Start of Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush essential for Baku
Karen Igityan, an expert on regional issues and co-founder of the Armenian Project NGO, claims the start of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border...
16:34
Armenian expert reacts to Erdogan's statement
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has reiterated that Armenia needs to stop campaigning for international recognition of the 1915 Armenian...
16:05
Aliyev: Baku has agreed to Armenia-Azerbaijan talks in Kazakhstan
Baku has accepted Kazakhstan's proposal to host a meeting of the Azerbaijani and Armenian foreign ministers, Azerbaijani President Ilham...
15:33
Record number of parliamentarians to attend Armenian Genocide commemorations in Australia
As Sydney and Melbourne's Armenian community prepare to commemorate the 109th Anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, the Armenian National...
15:12
Armenian deputy mayor deplores unilateral concessions to Baku
The Armenian government’s decision to hand over four border villages to Azerbaijan poses threats to the Noyemberyan community in Tavush...
14:35
Protesters block Yerevan-Sevan highway
Fresh protests erupted in Armenia on Tuesday after the Interior Ministry announced the launch of border delimitation with Azerbaijan which would...
13:56
Armenian community leaders warn of border delimitation risks
The delimitation of the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan at the section of Baghanis and Voskepar, border villages in the Noyemberyan...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}