Politics 12:11 05/04/2011

Cemal Pasha’s Grandson Says Genocide, Morgenthau’s Great Granddaughter doesn’t

Hundreds of Armenians turned out at UCLA last Thursday night to hear with great apprehension Hasan Cemal, the grandson of Cemal Pasha -- one of the top three Turkish butchers of the Armenian nation. This unique and controversial event, titled "From Der Zor to Dzidzernagapert: A Conversation with Hasan Cemal," was organized by AGBU Asbeds.

Understandably, there was great tension in the air. The large hall was filled to capacity and many were turned away due to lack of room. The presence of armed policemen and security guards inside the hall was both reassuring and disturbing. Cemal confirmed that he was cautioned against coming to Los Angeles, but fortunately everything proceeded calmly. The most shocking thing that evening was not what Cemal said, but what another speaker, Dr. Pamela Steiner, the great granddaughter of Amb. Henry Morgenthau, did not say!

Kurken Berksanlar, Chairman of ABGU Asbeds, welcomed everyone to "an open-minded conversation." While admitting that some Armenians view with great suspicion Turks who acknowledge the Genocide, he believed that "progressive” Turks, who are speaking openly about the evens of 1915…, appear to be above and beyond the reach and control of today’s Turkish government." Berksanlar then introduced the keynote speaker Hasan Cemal and the two discussants, Dr. Pamela Steiner, and Prof. Richard Hovannisian.

A columnist at Milliyet newspaper, Cemal immediately won over his skeptical audience by greeting them in Armenian -- "parev harkeli paregamner" -- and telling them: "I came here to open my heart and open my mind to you…. I know your pain, your grief of Genocide, your grief of Meds Yeghern." Ignoring Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code which bans the use of the term Armenian Genocide, he courageously repeated those words several more times during his talk. He also condemned the Turkish government’s denial of the Armenian Genocide, calling it "colluding in the crime!"

Cemal described his deeply moving 2008 visit to the Armenian Genocide Monument in Yerevan, where he laid three carnations in memory of his close friend, Hrant Dink, the Armenian journalist who was assassinated in Istanbul by Turkish extremists. While visiting Yerevan, he had a startling encounter with Armen Gevorkyan, grandson of the man who in 1922 assassinated his grandfather, Cemal Pasha.

Cemal described the progress made in Turkey during the past three decades on the recognition of the Armenian Genocide, going from total denialism to an apology campaign, restoration of Armenian churches, and holding academic conferences on this topic. He asked Armenians to come to Turkey to participate in the "recovery of memory." He urged them never to forget the past, without becoming its captives.

While Cemal’s candid remarks left a good impression on the audience, Dr. Steiner turned off the attendees with her adamant and intentional refusal to use the word genocide. Instead, she used such typical Turkish denialist terminology as "tragedy,” “suffering,” and “events of 1915." As director of the Inter-Communal Trust-Building Project, she spoke about "possible steps towards building trust between Armenians and Turks." She stunned the audience by asking Armenians to acknowledge that "the Turkish people [who] suffered horrendously during World War I … need and deserve acknowledgment for that!" As if that request was not outrageous enough, she went on to urge Armenians to "consider acknowledging Turkish suffering before they receive an acknowledgment for theirs!"

During the question and answer period, when I pointed out the irony of Cemal Pasha’s grandson freely using the term Armenian Genocide, while the great granddaughter of Amb. Morgenthau would not, Dr. Steiner’s response was inadequate. Her justification was that she was playing the role of a “facilitator,” seeking "conciliation" between Armenians and Turks.

The final discussant, Prof. Hovannisian, in a stern voice, gave a polite, yet powerful response to the previous speakers. He told Hasan Cemal that the large Armenian audience had come not to listen to him as a Turkish journalist, but as the grandson of Cemal Pasha. He explained that understanding the Turkish perpetrators’ mindset cannot in any way justify their actions. He cautioned everyone not to equate Armenian suffering resulting from intentional destruction with the suffering of Turks as a result of war. He emphasized that Armenians were seeking not only recognition, but, more importantly, restitution of their confiscated properties. He urged the Turkish government to return the hundreds of Armenian churches in Turkey to the Armenian Patriarchate of Istanbul. Finally, in a direct allusion to Dr. Steiner, Prof. Hovannisian emphasized that "conciliation" required "acts of contrition." His remarks were greeted with a standing ovation.

I found Cemal to be both candid and brave. He could have easily avoided the use of the term Armenian Genocide, maintaining that doing so could land him in jail. However, he made no excuses and used the genocide term several times. Considering his grandfather responsible for "the Great Catastrophe," he described today’s Turkey as "a manic-depressive country!"

Although it is not easy to forget that Hasan Cemal is the grandson of one of the three masterminds of the Armenian Genocide, it would be wrong to hold children responsible for the sins of their parents. His position has dramatically evolved since his Boston appearance two years ago, when he avoided the term Armenian Genocide. I asked him privately at the end of his UCLA talk if he was not concerned that he could be taken to court for using the word genocide. Even though he said he did not think so, he found it important enough to mention my concern in a column he wrote in Milliyet upon his return to Istanbul.

The only sour note in Cemal’s words that evening was his rejection of demands for the return of Armenian territories from Turkey. Nevertheless, it is not surprising to hear a Turk, no matter how tolerant, defend his country’s territorial integrity. He did state, however, that the Turkish government should apologize to Armenians and pay compensation to them.

On the other hand, Dr. Steiner, as a Jewish-American and direct descendant of Amb. Morgenthau, cannot be excused for her persistent refusal to use the term genocide, despite her self-avowed good intentions. Anyone who does not acknowledge the truth of the Armenian Genocide loses the moral authority to play a constructive role in Armenian-Turkish relations. One cannot remain neutral between a victim and victimizer. She should heed the wise words of Holocaust survivor and Nobel Laureate Elie Wiesel who stated: "Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim!"

As facilitator between the two communities, Dr. Steiner probably believes that she should not take sides. But telling the truth is not taking sides between Armenians and Turks, anymore than acknowledging the Holocaust is siding with Jews. Furthermore, it is not clear what exactly her role is as facilitator. Genocide is not a dispute that requires the services of a mediator. How can she reconcile two nations without the victimizer first making amends for what her own great grandfather called "The Murder of a Nation!"

Two days after her talk at UCLA, Dr. Steiner sent me a lengthy e-mail explaining further her role as facilitator and insisting that Amb. Morgenthau would have supported her work. I cannot pretend to know her great grandfather better than her, but being familiar with the Ambassador’s humanitarian efforts during and after the Genocide, I have no doubt that he would have done everything possible to bring justice to Armenians, rather than remaining neutral between the perpetrators and their victims.

By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier
 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

20:15
Nearly 550 people are rescued trying to cross from Libya to Europe
At least five migrants have drowned off the Libyan coast today after the heavily overcrowded boat they were on overturned, the Italian navy has...
20:03
Convicted women on the arena
Final day of the sport event launched since May 24 and conducting by the RA Ministry of Sport and Youth Affairs was held in...
19:20
Serzh Sargsyan congratulates Argentine President on Revolution Day
President Serzh Sargsyan today sent a congratulatory message to President Mauricio Macri of the Argentine Republic on the occasion the...
18:58
Armenian Deputy Defense Minister holds meetings in Georgia
Delegation headed by the first Deputy Minister of Defense of Armenia Davit Tonoyan participates in the Georgia Defense and Security annual...
18:17
Azerbaijani media: Famous journalist Khadija Ismayilova conditionally released from prison
Host of RFE/RL Azerbaijani service, Khadija Ismayilova, has been released by the Azerbaijan’s Supreme Court decision, the Azerbaijani...
18:07
Chairman of Yerevan Press Club on preparing for next round of negotiations
The most important thing during the past few days after the Vienna meeting is preparing for the negotiations, said Chairman of the Yerevan Press...
18:06
Anatoli Grigoryan’s exhibition at Albert & Tove Boiajian Gallery
“Kind, honest and willing to help. His soul is just like his paintings bright, rich and colourful. Looking at his paintings, one fills...
14:41
Erdogan threatens to block EU migration deal
Recep Tayyip Erdogan has warned the European Union that Turkey would block laws related to the landmark deal to stem the flow of migrants to...
14:05
RA Foreign Ministry spokesperson responds Aliyev’s propaganda attacks
“Obviously Novruz Mammadov is the best speechwriter & adviser in President’s [Aliyev’s] staff,” reads the sarcastic...
13:39
Artsakh Foreign Ministry: NKR ready to host special monitoring mission
“For its part, the NKR is ready to host a special monitoring mission for an on-site study of all the facts and investigation of the...
13:04
AF GS representatives leave for Moscow
According to a bilateral cooperation plan between Ministries of Defense of the Republic of Armenia and the Russian Federation signed in 2016,...
13:02
Children destroy glass art installation as adults film them
The bottom of Shelly Xue's 'Angel is Waiting' was destroyed while on display at Shanghai Museum of Glass, writes The...
12:28
Oil prices rising again
As a result of e-commerce in London and New York stock exchanges, world oil prices are rising, Gazeta.ru reports. According to the source,...
12:27
Defense Ministry of Armenia reports few cases of violations
The situation on the Armenian-Azerbaijani state border was calm on the night of May 24-25, reports public relations department of Defense...
11:11
NKR Defense Army: No fire overnight
On the night of May 24-25 no violation of the ceasefire arrangement occurred on the Line of Contact between Nagorno Karabakh and Azerbaijan, NKR...
11:10
Azerbaijani authorities continue assimilation policy towards Talysh people evenresorting to machinations in football
Talysh football club KhazarLankaranended the match with Baku Ravanclub in the conclusive round in a 2:2 drawdue toan unfair penalty against the...
21:25
Another pantheon-style memorial unveiled in Yerevan - dedicated to Marshal Babajanian
Yerevan residents actively discuss the statue of the Hero of the USSR, Chief Marshal of the USSR armored troops Hamazasp Babajanian on social...
20:01
Artsakh President meets with French National Assembly deputies
Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan received on May 24 French National Assembly deputy, chairman of the France-Artsakh friendship circle...
19:46
Two pilots injured in jet fighter crash before take off
IRNA reporter in Hamedan said that one of the pilots got recovered, but the other pilot is in critical condition.
19:33
Davit Harutyunyan not excluding merger of state bodies
Chief of RA Government Staff, Davit Harutyunyan recommended not expecting rapid actions in response to a question what should follow government...
19:04
Oil prices continue dropping
As a result of sales and purchases in London and New York stock exchanges, the oil prices are falling, Gazeta.ru reports. According to the...
17:16
Human remains from EgyptAir crash indicate blast
An Egyptian forensic official says human remains from the crashed EgyptAir flight indicate there had been an explosion on board, writes Sky...
16:41
The culture of sharing the bread at school
Armenian Minister of Education and Science Levon Mkrtchyan and Country Director and Representative of the World Food Programme Pascale Micheau...
15:49
Armenian National Football Team leaves for the USA
Armenian National Team will play 2 friendly matches in USA, reports the Football Federation of Armenia. The team will face Guatemala on May 28...
14:02
Sergei Lavrov to raise question of Iran joining SCO
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov plans to raise the question of Iran’s accession to the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO)...
13:26
I call all our compatriots to spend summer holidays in Artsakh, Vic Darchinyan says In an interview with Artsakhpress
In an interview with Artsakhpress Vic Darchinyan told that he didn’t visit Artsakh within two decades and he is very glad to be...
13:14
Greece begins moving migrants from Idomeni camp
Greece has begun evacuating thousands of stranded migrants from the makeshift Idomeni camp on its northern border with Macedonia, writes the...
13:03
Armenian cheese export to Russia doubles
For the first time, after the use of food embargo, an increase has been recorded in the foreign cheese share in Russian consumer market....
11:59
OSCE PA special representative to prepare reports on his visits to Armenia and Azerbaijan
Vice President of the National Assembly, Eduard Sharmazanov presented OSCE PA Special Representative on South Caucasus, Kristian Vigenin...
11:02
Defense Ministry of Armenia reports calm situation on state border
Situation on the Armenian-Azerbaijani state border was relatively calm on the night of May 23-24, reports information and public relations...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}