Analysis 09:18 18/10/2013

Karzai’s last-minute game with the Americans

Iranian Diplomacy’s interview with Pirmohammad Mollazehi, an expert on Afghan affairs

- The security agreement between Afghanistan and the US is still in a coma state. Why is there a delay in signing this part of the strategic pact?

- A part of the strategic pact which was adopted between the US and Afghanistan was the issue of the security agreement. At that time, due to the serious protests of the Afghan intellectuals and among the people and even the countries of the region, there were discussions about not signing this agreement. Therefore, Afghanistan and the US decided to postpone it to a later time when the conditions were more suitable and then the security agreement which is part of this strategic pact could be signed. Right now the issue is that Hamed Karzai has set certain conditions for this agreement and on the other hand, the Americans attempt to sign this agreement before the presidential elections and prefer to impose this agreement on Karzai whose position is weaker now.

- What is the main objective of the US with this agreement? What have the major obstacles been until now?

- The main objective of the US is for the US and member countries of NATO to take out a major part of their forces from Afghanistan in 2014 and based on Obama’s plan. But the problem is that the Americans do not intend to completely leave this country and they have rather proposed to build 9 military bases in different regions of Afghanistan and maintain a part of their forces in these safe bases. This is the main issue with regard to these two countries and their relations. Also, Afghanistan seeks to be able to try any American soldier who might commit a crime in Afghanistan in Afghanistan’s tribunals, but the Americans believe that this would be impossible because it is against the constitution of this country. The US experience in different parts of the world shows that they have not accepted such a demand in any country that they have had military agreement with and they have somehow imposed to the host country that they do not recognize the competency of the local courts with regard to crimes committed by Americans. This is the main problem and public opinion in Afghanistan believes that this measure violates the national pride of Afghanistan legally which is based on capitulation which since long has been abolished.

- To what extent would the Americans have open hands with regard to political and military interference in Afghanistan?

- The experience of other countries wherein US military forces are stationed, such as Japan, South Korea and in the past the Philippines and the former Germany shows that the extent of the interference and influence of the Americans depends on the resistance of these countries against the demands of the Americans. With regard to Afghanistan, it must be said that this country is not in a position to show its national power and the presence and influence of the Americans will be more than other countries. For example, a comparison with Japan shows that Japan is an economic power and is able to limit the influence of the Americans. But this cannot be expected of Afghanistan because this country is in a weak position and, with the establishment of US military bases, the US will have a certain power inside that country and can even violate the national integrity of Afghanistan without fearing the reaction of the government. This is a fact and completely depends on the extent of the establishment of national power in this country and whether it would be able to safeguard the interests of the people. But if the same weak position continues, the American will have the power to influence.

- Based on Karzai’s remarks, how possible is the signing of this agreement during his presidency, in your opinion?

- It seems that Karzai’s statements are not very serious. Karzai plays with public opinion and seeks another objective, otherwise he would sign the agreement. The fact that he has stated that the Loya jirga will meet in the next month and he does not intend to send this agreement to the parliament is because he is worried that they might not adopt this agreement. But since he has selected certain people in the Loya jirga who agree with the signing of this agreement, it seems that Karzai will sign this agreement before the presidential election and until March. But his intention behind such statements and pretending to show his opposition to the signing of this agreement or setting conditions for it is to impact public opinion for the election. He attempts to attract public opinion towards his team or those of whom he approves, but the agreement will be signed during this period and it can even be said that it might be signed within the next month.

- Another issue is peace with the Taliban, one of the conditions of which is the political and military absence of foreign forces in this country. If this agreement is signed, is it possible that this issue would be transformed into one of the major challenges between the government and the Taliban?

- Of course, there is this possibility because the Taliban knows that if the American and NATO forces gain bases in this country and remain there, their expectation to return to power and revive the Islamic rulership will be severely weakened. Furthermore, if the Americans reach an agreement with the Afghans, the policy of the Pakistanis might change and become hopeless about helping the Taliban to gain power. Therefore, from the Taliban’s point of view, the continuation of the Americans’ presence is very dangerous because they will create obstacles for them. But it can have other consequences as well. When the Taliban becomes hopeless about gaining power through the usage of forces, they might be encouraged to compromise with the government through which they could gain part of the power and since they have strong social bases among the Pashtun tribes, they can even participate in the democratic process and reach power. But under the present circumstances, my analysis is that until the signing of the agreement, the Taliban will exert maximum pressure both politically and militarily to prevent it but when it is signed they would be forced to review their policies.

- Have any of the candidates taken positions in this regard? How is the atmosphere of public opinion?

- The fact is that the candidates have so far attempted to bypass this issue so that it would not have negative effects on their votes.

The other issue is that the main groups which seek the signing of this agreement are, contrary to assumptions, the northern groups whose candidate is Abdullah Abdullah. They are concerned that if the Americans completely leave Afghanistan, the Taliban might gain power by force and make them return to Saidabad and it would be similar to the time prior to the entrance of the Americans when these groups cooperated with the US. Thus, this concern has caused them to be the main proponents of this agreement. This is while these groups are considered the closest group to Iran because they are Persian-speakers, Uzbeks and people who are culturally closer to Iran. But on the other hand, the Pashtuns and the Taliban are against this agreement because they believe that the government which now administers the country (despite the fact that Karzai’s ancestors are Pashtun) and the US’ interference have destroyed the historical power of the Pashtuns who have had it for the last 250-300 years. That is why they are strongly against the continuation of the presence of the Americans, but the military presence of the US is to the benefit of the Shiite Hazara, Tajik, and Uzbek minorities.

- Russia is also among the countries which is very concerned about the continuation of US presence in Afghanistan. What is the reason behind the Russians’ opposition and do their views impact the decision-making process of the Afghans?

- The Russians’ concerns are similar to those of the Iranians. Russia, China, Iran and to some extent India are concerned about US military bases in Afghanistan and its long presence in the region. The Russians, in particular, are afraid that if the Americans are present in Afghanistan, they will gradually attempt to take Central Asia out of the hands of the Russians and the same big game which has existed since the 19th century would end to the benefit of the Americans. Therefore, the Russians are very concerned. Of course, they have another concern as well and that is that if the Americans are permanently present in Afghanistan and compromise with the Taliban, then the radical groups which live in Chechnya and Uzbekistan and the Uyghurs who are in China will find the power to maneuver and intensify their opposition and continue their war against Russia. It is possible that these groups might gain the support of the West and an international competition between China and Russia would form. The Russians are concerned about this issue as well and believe that the events that happen in Afghanistan, particularly the influence of the Taliban in the Badakhshan region, will engage China, Russia and the Central Asian countries. The Americans might compromise with those groups who are fighting against them like al-Qaeda and its subgroups like the Hizb ut-Tahrir in Uzbekistan or the Chechen Liberation Front or the East Turkestan Movement and use radical groups against Russia and China. Thus, they attempt to prevent this event and discourage Afghanistan from signing this agreement but it seems that their power to maneuver is very limited.


 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

18:43
3 candidates for Armenian ombudsman officially nominated
Three candidates for Armenia’s Human Right Defender (Ombudsman) have been proposed to the National Assembly’s Standing Committee on...
18:06
Anush Sedrakyan: War is the only industry where Russia may succeed
Russia has no industry. It has two competitive things: dictatorship that it tries to export to a number of states and in some cases it does it...
17:45
Karabakh observes all international norms related to Sarsang reservoir: Seyran Ohanyan
Political forces of Armenia have done work aimed at preventing the adoption of anti-Armenian resolutions in the Parliamentary Assembly of the...
17:02
American teenagers are eating better: study
A study finds that adolescents are starting to make better food choices, but we shouldn’t be so quick to credit the dietary guidelines,...
16:41
Germany and Turkey vow to step up efforts to end Aleppo violence
As tens of thousands of Syrians fleeing violence massed at Turkey’s border, Turkish and German leaders pledged Monday to redouble...
16:33
Orange Armenia encourages safe internet use: Today is Safe Internet Day
Today more than 100 countries are celebrating Safe Internet Day. On the occasion of this day, for the fifth time in a row, Orange Armenia,...
12:58
Emigration rates grow: Armenian demographer
35,000 people left Armenia and did not return in 2012-2015, demographer Ruben Yeganyan told Panorama.am when speaking about the results of a...
11:25
Housewarming in the borderland village of Khachik
Three families celebrated housewarming in the borderland village of Khachik, Vayots Dzor region. Owing to the partnership between VivaCell-MTS...
11:09
Hacker publishes 9,000 DHS employees’ info, says 20,000 FBI officials’ data is next
A hacker has published the personal information of more than 9,000 employees at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) ahead of a data dump...
10:33
Press review
Zhamanak: Yerevan municipality sues Hrazdan Stadium for debt Yerevan Municipality filed a lawsuit against the owner of Hrazdan Stadium who...
22:29
President Sargsyan receives Serbian NA Speaker Maja Gojkovic
Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan received today Speaker of Serbia’s National Assembly Maja Gojkovic, according to the presidential press...
22:00
German tourist who climbed the Great Pyramid ‘banned’ from entering Egypt
Egypt’s Ministry of Antiquities has banned 18-year-old German tourist Andrej Ciesielski from entering Egypt ever again for illegally...
21:51
S. Sargsyan: Armenia anticipates success in talks on comprehensive legal document with EU
Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan received today President of European Conservatives and Reformists Group of the European Parliament Jan...
20:32
VivaCell-MTS is the first mobile operator sending SMS messages to its subscribers in Armenian
February 7 has been declared the Day of using Armenian letters on the network. The initiative aims at preventing the loss of Armenian writing in...
20:23
American athletes fearing Zika virus should skip Rio Olympics: USOC
The United States Olympic Committee told U.S. sports federations that athletes and staff concerned for their health over the Zika virus should...
19:01
EAEU does not hold talks over Azerbaijan’s membership because ‘they did not apply’
The Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) does not conduct any talks with Azerbaijan regarding the latter’s accession to EAEU, Tatyana Valovaya...
18:38
Harutyun Khachatryan elected chairman of Armenian National Film Academy
Harutyun Khachatryan – a member of the European Film Academy, director of ‘Golden Apricot’ Yerevan International Film Festival...
18:06
Five Nobel Prize winners to deliver lectures in Armenia
Yerevan State Medical University after Mkhitar Heratsi is organizing an unprecedented event on February 11-16: five Nobel Prize winners in...
17:12
Two candidates for Armenian ombudsman proposed so far
Two candidates for Armenia’s ombudsman (human rights defender) have been proposed so far to National Assembly’s Standing Committee...
16:22
GM Hrant Melkumyan participates in Chess Bundesliga
Armenian GM Hrant Melkumyan participated in German Bundesliga during weekend. Melkumyan was playing on the first board of “Berlin”...
16:03
Armenia condemns North Korea ballistic ‪‎missile launch
Armenia's Foreign Ministry issued a statement Sunday, February 7, condemning North Korea's rocket launch. “We condemn the launch...
15:54
Armenia to join EAEU agreement on information exchange in financial sphere
Armenia, which became a member of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) of Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, and Armenia last year, will join the...
15:10
An exploding bus movie stunt sparks concerns in London
A bus has exploded in central London — but this time it's only for a movie. City officials Sunday reassured the public that the...
14:46
Georgia to try to balance relations with neighbors, West and Russia: expert
In the foreseeable future, it is hard to imagine that NATO will accept Georgia as its member, taking into account the Russian factor as well, an...
13:50
Burberry to slash number of catwalk shows, speed up sales
Luxury fashion retailer Burberry says it will combine its menswear and womenswear catwalk shows into a single presentation, and slash the amount...
13:23
Bottles from the cradle of wine: Armenia and Georgia
“Zorah Karasi Areni Noir, Armenia 2013 (from £21.95, Slurp; Corking Wines) An idle question prompted by the vivid opening chapter of...
12:40
Iran prepared to increase fivefold gas exports to Armenia
Executive Director of Iran’s National Iranian Gas Export Company Alireza Kameli said today that gas exports from Iran to Armenia could...
11:53
Number of Armenian outbound travelers increases
The number of outbound travelers from Armenia’s Zvartnots Airport in January 2016 exceeded the number of inbound travelers. 137, 303...
11:19
Some roads barely passable in Armenia
Motorways in Armenia were mostly open as of 9:00 am today, on February 8, according to Ministry of Territorial Administration and Emergency...
10:47
Hollande, Merkel stress migrant crisis needs EU solution
German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Francois Hollande stressed on Sunday the migrant crisis, which brought more than a million...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}