Politics 10:55 17/02/2014

Scholars call for reexamination of ECHR judgment on Genocide denial case

Concerned genocide scholars issued an open letter highlighting ”historical and conceptual inaccuracies” in the European Court’s decision on Dogu Perinçek v. Switzerland, and called on the government of Switzerland to request a reexamination of the Court’s judgment, The Armenian Weekly reports. 

Below is the full text of the letter, released on Feb. 14.

An Open Letter to:
Madame la Conseillère fédérale
Simonetta Sommaruga
Cheffe du Département fédéral de justice et police (DFJP)
Palais fédéral ouest
CH-3003 Berne

After having read the European Court’s decision on Dogu Perinçek v. Switzerland (ECHR. 370, 230, 17 December, 2013) we, as concerned genocide scholars, believe it imperative to respond to historical and conceptual inaccuracies that are articulated in the decision, and we believe those inaccuracies have serious ethical and social significance.

We do not take issue with the notion of freedom of expression, something that scholars agree is most often an essential part of open, democratic society. We are, however, concerned about elements of the Court’s reasoning that are at odds with the facts about the historical record on the Armenian genocide of 1915 and at odds with an ethical understanding of denialism.

The decision asserts that: 1) “genocide as a precisely defined legal concept was not easy to prove”; 2) “the Court doubted that there could be a general consensus as to the events such as those at issue, given that the historical research was by definition open to discussion and a matter of debate, without necessarily giving rise to a final conclusion or to the assertion of objective and absolute truths”; the court uses the phrase “heated debate” in referring to the current political context surrounding the Armenian genocide.

First, it is the overwhelming conclusion of scholars who study genocide (hundreds of independent scholars, who have no affiliations with governments, and whose work spans many countries and nationalities and the course of decades) that the Ottoman mass killings of Armenians conforms to all the aspects of Article 2 of the U.N. CPPC definition of genocide.

In 1997, the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS), the major body of scholars who study genocide, passed a resolution unanimously recognizing the Ottoman massacres of Armenians as genocide. The International Center for Transitional Justice (ICTJ) prepared an analysis for the Turkish Armenian Reconciliation Commission (TARC) in 2003, stating that “the Events [of 1915] include all of the elements of the crime of genocide as defined in the Convention (UNCPPCG).

In 2000, 100 leading Holocaust scholars signed a petition in The New York Times affirming the events of 1915 were genocide and urging worldwide recognition. An Open Letter from the IAGS to Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan, in June, 2005, enjoined the Turkish government to own up to “the unambiguous historical record on the Armenian genocide.” The only three histories of genocide in the 20th century that genocide-studies theorists (such as William Schabas) agree on are the cases of the Armenians in Turkey, in 1915; the Jews in Europe, in 1940–45; and the Tutsis in Rwanda, in 1994. The destruction of the Armenians was central to Raphael Lemkin’s creation of the concept of genocide as a crime in international law, and it was Lemkin who coined and first used the term Armenian Genocide in 1944.

The idea put forth by the Court that crimes of genocide may only apply to the events in Rwanda and at Srebrenica because they were tried at the ICC is incomplete. Crimes of genocide have been assessed as historical events by scholars for decades now, and both the crimes committed against the Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 and those committed against the Jews of Europe by the Nazis in the 1940s were deemed genocide by Lemkin. As legal scholars have noted, crimes of genocide can be tried retroactively, and William Schabas has pointed out that in the Eichmann trial in Jerusalem, in 1961, the word genocide was used retroactively to designate crimes committed against the Jews.

Further, under Article 10, “the Court clearly distinguished the present case from those concerning the negation of the crimes of the Holocaust. . . . because the acts that they had called into question had been found by an international court to be clearly established.” We would note that the perpetrators of the Holocaust were prosecuted at the Nuremberg Trials (1945–46), not for the crime of genocide, but for “crimes against humanity,” even though Raphael Lemkin had previously created the term “genocide.” The Armenian case, contrary to the Court’s assertion, does have a clear legal basis for its authenticity. First, “crimes against humanity” was the very phrase coined by France, the United Kingdom, and Russia in their 1915 joint declaration in response to the massacres of the Armenians by the Ottoman Turkish government. After WWI, the Ottoman government convened military tribunals (1919–20) to try 200 high-level members of the military and government for premeditated mass murder of the Armenian population. The ICTJ decision of 2006 also affirms such a legal basis.

The Court also decided, on the basis of Article 17 (prohibition of abuse of rights), that “The rejection of the legal characterization as ‘genocide’ of the 1915 events was not such as to incite hatred against the Armenian people.” Yet the ECtHR states (para 19) that “the negation of the Holocaust is today the principal motor of anti-Semitism.” We would note similarly that the denialism of the Armenian genocide in Turkey resulted in the assassination of Armenian Turkish journalist Hrant Dink, and has resulted in violence to others in Turkey.

In referring to the Armenian genocide as “an international lie,” Mr. Perençik reveals a level of extremism that belies all sense of judgment. We believe that the Court makes a misstep when it privileges Turkey’s denialism (a country with one of the worst records on intellectual freedom and human rights over the past decades) as a “heated debate.” As the IAGS has written in an Open Letter on denialism and the Armenian genocide (October, 2006), “scholars who deny the facts of genocide in the face of the overwhelming scholarly evidence are not engaging in historical debate, but have another agenda. In the case of the Armenian Genocide, the agenda is to absolve Turkey of responsibility for the planned extermination of the Armenians—an agenda consistent with every Turkish ruling party since the time of the Genocide in 1915. Scholars who dispute that what happened to the Armenians in the Ottoman Empire in 1915 constitutes genocide blatantly ignore the overwhelming historical and scholarly evidence.”

As noted genocide scholar Deborah Lipstadt has written: “Denial of genocide whether that of the Turks against the Armenians, or the Nazis against the Jews is not an act of historical reinterpretation . . . . The deniers aim at convincing innocent third parties that there is another side of the story . . . when there is no other side.” We believe that the Court’s decision and reasoning contributes to denialism and this has a corrosive impact on efforts for truth and reconciliation, and ethics.

We believe it important that the government of Switzerland request a reexamination of the Court’s judgment in this case.


Taner Akçam, Kaloosdian/Mugar Professor, Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies, Clark University

Margaret Lavinia Anderson; Professor of the Graduate School (Current); Professor of History emerita; University of California – Berkley

Joyce Apsel, Master Teacher of Humanities, New York University; Past President, International Association of Genocide Scholars

Yair Auron, head, Department of Sociology, Political Science and Communication, The Open University of Israel

Peter Balakian, Donald M. and Constance H. Rebar Professor of the Humanities, Colgate University

Annette Becker, Professor of History, University of Paris, Ouest Nanterre La Defense; senior member, Institut Universitaire de France

Matthias Bjornlund, archival historian; Danish Institute for Study Abroad (DIS), Copenhagen

Donald Bloxham, Professor of Modern History, University of Edinburgh

Hamit Bozarslan, Director, EHESS, Paris

Cathy Caruth, Frank H. T. Rhodes Professor of Humane Letters, Cornell University

Frank Chalk, Professor of History; Director, Montreal Institute for Genocide and Human Rights Studies

Israel Charny, Past President International Association of Genocide Scholars; Director, Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide, Jerusalem

Deborah Dwork, Rose Professor of History; Director of the Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies, Clark University

Helen Fein, Independent Scholar; former executive director of Institute for the Study of Genocide (New York)

Marcelo Flores, Professor of Comparative History; director, The European Master in Human Rights and Genocide Studies, University of Siena

Donna-Lee Frieze, Prins Senior Fellow, Center For Jewish History, New York City; Visiting Fellow, Alfred Deakin Research Institute, Deakin University, Melbourne.

Wolfgang Gust, Independent Scholar, Director armenocide.com.de Hamburg

Herbert Hirsch, Professor of Political Science, Virginia Commonwealth University; co-editor, Genocide Studies International

Marianne Hirsch, William Peterfield Trent Professor of English and Comparative Literature at Professor in the Institute for Research on Women, Gender, and Sexuality; Columbia University

Tessa Hofmann, Prof. h.c. Dr. phil, Frie Universitat Berlin, Institute for East European Studies

Richard Hovanissian, Professor Emeritus, Armenian and Near Eastern History at the University of California, Los Angeles; Distinguished Visiting Scholar at Chapman University and the University of California, Irvine

Raymond Kevorkian, Historian, University of Paris-VIII-Saint Denis

Hans-Lukas Kieser, Professor of Modern History, University of Zurich

Mark Levene, Reader in Comparative History, University of Southampton, UK

Robert Jay Lifton, MD; Distinguished Professor Emeritus, The City University of New York

Deborah Lipstadt, Dorot Professor of Modern Jewish History and Holocaust Studies, Emory University

Wendy Lower, John K. Roth Professor of History, Claremont McKenna College

Robert Melson, Professor Emeritus, Purdue University; Past President, International Association of Genocide Scholars

Donald E. Miller, Professor of Religion; Director, Center for Religion and Civic Culture, University of Southern California

A. Dirk Moses, Professor of Global and Colonial History, European University Institute, Florence and Senior Editor, Journal of Genocide Research.

James R. Russell, Mashtots Professor of Armenian Studies, Harvard University

Roger W. Smith, Professor Emeritus of Government, College of William and Mary; Past President, International Association of Genocide Scholars

Leo Spitzer, K.T. Vernon Professor of History Emeritus, Dartmouth College

Gregory Stanton, Research Professor in Genocide Studies and Prevention, George Mason University; Past President, International Association of Genocide Scholars

Yves Ternon, Historian of modern genocide, independent scholar, France

Henry C. Theriault, Professor of Philosophy, Worcester State University; Co-Editor-in-Chief, Genocide Studies and Prevention

Eric D. Weitz, Dean of Humanities and Arts and Professor of History, The City College of New York/Graduate Center

Source Panorama.am
Share |


Expert reveals way Armenian delegation can use to bloc Karabakh-related reports of Walter, Markovic in PACE
The worsening of relations between Europe and Azerbaijan should be used for the good of Armenia, political scientist Hrant Melik-Shahnazaryan...
Armenian PM, Serbian defense minister discuss expansion of bilateral relations
Official visits and meeting in recent years have significantly promoted the political dialog between Armenia and Serbia and contributed to...
Expert: Draft report on Sarsang reservoir approved by PACE Committee is result of Armenian delegation’s inactivity
Approval of the draft report on the Sarsang reservoir in Nagorno Karabakh by the PACE Committee on Social Affairs, Health and Sustainable...
Constitution currently in force gives oppositionists no chance to work, they can only criticize: Hrayr Tovmasyan
The proposed amendments to the Constitution of Armenia restrict the presidential powers: the president can no longer participate in political...
Deputy FM of Armenia: Draft report on Sarsang reservoir only plays into Azerbaijani propaganda’s hands
Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia Shavarsh Kocharyan discussed - in an interview with News.am - the draft report on the Sarsang reservoir in...
Putin: Russian SU-24 fighter jet was shot down by Turkish air force over Syrian territory
The Russian fighter jet Su-24 did not pose any threat to Turkey, but was attacked and shot down by air-to-air missile from Turkish F-16 fighter...
Amateur rapid chess tournament held in Armenia on Bank Employee Day
The 8th Amateur Rapid Chess Tournament took place in Yerevan’s Tigran Petrosyan Chess House on the occasion of Bank Employee Day. The...
Turkish F-16 shoots down Russian fighter jet near Syria border
NATO has called an emergency meeting in Brussels on Tuesday after two Turkish F-16 fighter jets shot down a Russian warplane near Turkey's...
Military chronicler of Russian Empire testifies how greedy Khan of Erivan robbed Etchmiadzin Cathedral
The peaceful life, which commenced in Karabakh after the Persians’ defeat in the first Russo-Persian war, contributed to the increase of...
Actress Varduhi Varderesyan dies
Famous Armenian actress Varduhi Varderesyan died aged 87, Panorama.am learned from Armenian Culture Ministry. A government commission will...
Bako Sahakyan signs decree on conferring honorary titles on cultural workers of Karabakh
On 24 November President Bako Sahakyan signed a decree on conferring the honorary title of Honored Culture Worker of the Nagorno Karabagh...
Seyran Ohanyan: Armenia to keep participation volume in NATO peacekeeping mission in Afghanistan
A delegation led by Armenian Defense Minister Seyran Ohanyan was on a working visit to Berlin yesterday, on November 23, according to the press...
Armenian parliament speaker to pay working visit to Saint Petersburg
Speaker of the National Assembly of Armenia Galust Sahakyan will be on a working visit to Saint Petersburg on November 25-27, the press service...
Why Azerbaijan needs made-to-order, non-binding reports of PACE on Nagorno Karabakh? Interview with D. Babayan
The spokesman for President of Nagorno Karabakh Republic David Babayan spoke about PACE rapporteur Milica Markovic’s report on Sarsang...
Borderland villages of Gnishik and Mozrov, Vayots Dzor region provided with street lighting
The Foundation for the Preservation of Wildlife and Cultural Assets (FPWC) and VivaCell-MTS presented the outcomes of yet another initiative...
Two bombs explode at hotel housing election judges in Egypt, one killed
Two bombs exploded outside a hotel in Egypt housing election judges on Tuesday, killing at least one person, state television reported. The...
Hraparak: Presidents Sargsyan and Aliyev to meet on December 1
‘Hraparak’ paper learned that a meeting of Presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan will take place in Paris on December 1. About two...
Zhoghovurd: Air Armenia declared bankrupt
‘Zhoghovurd’ paper says that the tragic situation in Armenia’s aviation sector is a known reality. “Following the...
Hraparak: Arthur Baghdasaryan tries to get rid of inglorious pages of the past
The founder of Armenian Revival alliance Arthur Baghdasaryan intends to turn it into a political party in the hope that it would be the best way...
Deputy chief of GS of Armenian forces M. Hakobyan on possibility of Stepanakert airport use by Russia
Deputy Chief of the General Staff of the Armenian Armed Forces Movses Hakobyan declined to comment on reports of some Russian media outlets to...
Foreign Ministry: Armenian missions in Belgium operate normally
The Armenian embassy in Belgium, the country’s diplomatic mission to Brussels and the missions to the European Union and the NATO are...
G. Yeghiazaryan: ‘Yes and No’ reality show ahead of referendum introduced new political culture in Armenia
'Yes and No’ reality show launched as part of the campaign ahead of the constitutional referendum in Armenia is a welcome initiative:...
PACE Committee to discuss M. Markovic’s scandalous report on Sarsang reservoir in NKR
The PACE Committee on Social Affairs, Health and Sustainable Development will hold a meeting in Paris today to discuss the report...
Union of Employers of Information and Communication Technologies established in Armenia
Upon the initiative of a number of ICT companies, Union of Employers of Information and Communication Technologies has been established in...
Azerbaijani religious leader Allahshukur Pashazadeh’s Sweden visit turns out failure
Allahshukur Pashazadeh, the chairman of the Caucasus Muslim Board, failed to meet any high-ranking official of Sweden during his visit to that...
Physical-Mathematical School after Shahinyan awarded ‘Gratitude’ Medal
On 23 November President of Artsakh Bako Sahakyan signed a decree, according to which the Physical-Mathematical Specialized School after...
Alexandra Soumm, Alexander Romanovsky and Youth Orchestra perform in memory of Sviatoslav Richter
On November 21 the concert of Khachaturian International Festival was dedicated to the 100th anniversary of the renowned Russian pianist...
Zaruhi Postanjyan urges civil disobedience in her speech at extraordinary sitting of Armenian parliament
At the extraordinary sitting today the Armenian parliament began debating the Protocol on Some Issues Related to the Import and Turnover of...
Braille guides developed for blind voters ahead of constitutional referendum in Armenia
"We attach importance to awareness of each citizen, each voter of the voting procedure. As before, the issue of providing handicapped...
Hayastan All-Armenian Fund’s 2015 Phoneathon raises over 1.3 million euros
The annual Pan-European Phoneathon of the Hayastan All-Armenian Fund, headed by the Fund’s French affiliate and held during November...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}