Interviews 15:48 19/04/2014

American Professor: Nagorno-Karabakh is a case of remedial secession

Panorama.am presents an interview with Dr. William Slomanson, Professor of Law at Thomas Jefferson School of Law and visiting Professor at Pristina University. Dr. Slomanson argues that Nagorno-Karabakh qualifies as a case of remedial secession under the International Law.

- Dr. Slomanson, in one of your articles you argue that the cases of Ossetia, Abkhazia and Kosovo do not qualify as remedial secession, while in your article “Nagorno-Karabakh: An Alternative Legal Approach To Its Quest For Legitimacy” you argue that Nagorno-Karabakh presents such a case. How exactly does Nagorno-Karabakh qualify as a case of remedial secession and according to you what are the strongest points in NK’s argument of remedial secession?  

- The internationally accepted sources of International Law include – treaties, state practice and judicial decisions (as embedded in ICJ Statute, Article 38d). There is no treaty on secession, and there never will be, as that would be a political suicide for states. As for state practice, it has characterized three of the last four unilateral secessions as being unique (Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Kosovo—with no word yet on Crimea). There have otherwise been numerous conflicting state approaches to the status of Nagorno-Karabakh. The remaining recognized source on secession in the International Law is thus judicial decisions – those issued by national/international courts. 

In this regard the undisputed lead case is the Canadian Supreme Court Quebec Secession case, with its three prongs. According to the first prong there must be a “People,” for which Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians within Azerbaijan no doubt qualify. Second, there must be “gross human rights violations” against this people – these violations were in place starting in 1915, when NK emptied out most of its Armenian population because of Turkish regional policies. These policies continued through and including 1989 (the Armenian population declined considerably as a result of gross human rights violations over many decades). In 1989 the US Senate-House passed Resolution 178 that expressed a concern on the ongoing violence in Nagorno-Karabakh - “seeking (2) Soviet re-establishment of economic and supply routes”; (4) “urge[s] ... investigation of the violence against the people of Nagorno-Karabakh;” and (5) “express[es] the serious concern of the American people about the ongoing violence ... interfer[ing] with international relief efforts.”

The Quebec decision’s third prong is “no alternative but secession”. Given the fact that the status of Nagorno-Karabakh was altered for a number of times – in 1919 (when the United Kingdom forced NK authorities to conclude an interim agreement with Azerbaijan), in 1921 (when Moscow annexed NK to the Azerbaijan SSR), in 1988 (by war) and in 1991 (by the declaration of independence) as well as taking into account the 2004 Minsk Group statement that NK independence is not possible under the USSR statute of 03 April 1990 (all of which are addressed in my 2012 article) I do not see how one could logically suggest that there is an alternative to secession. 

- If Nagorno-Karabakh presents a strong case for remedial secession what implications can this have, given that the right to remedial secession is not a hard law?

- Given the non-existence of a secession treaty, multiple changes in sovereign status of Nagorno-Karabakh as well as national/international concerns (such as those expressed in the above US Congressional position), the above-mentioned recognized sources of International Law leave only one logical source for supporting Nagorno-Karabakh’s bid for legitimacy – a national (Canadian) Supreme Court decision on a matter of International Law. While not a primary source, such as State practice, it is a recognized source of International Law. If by “soft” law you mean enforceability, the arguable lack thereof is a discrete political point, while the Quebec elements are widely acclaimed and thus are more akin to hard law than soft law. 

- Azerbaijan has officially adopted a stance that unless the conflict is resolved by peaceful means Azerbaijan has the “right” to take back Nagorno-Karabakh by force, appealing to the right of self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter and referring to alleged “occupation” of its territory. Is this stance of Azerbaijan compatible with international law or not (considering its international obligations and the 1994 ceasefire agreement)?

- Citing the UN Charter Article 51 self-defense by Azerbaijan is illogical, given the comparative size of both the Azeri land mass and military strength. NK, for example, does not have the Israeli drones that the Azeris use for patrolling the border. As 2006 Russian-American Dartmouth Conference report indicates, no single document (i.e., the 1994 ceasefire agreement) will supplant the need for all necessary parties to come to the table to hammer out a peace accord. One result of that not happening is the Azeri threat to use its military force to shoot down any plane/helicopter attempting to make the trip between the Yerevan and NK airports. So it would be NK, not Azerbaijan, that would end up with a decent Art 51 defense argument in this context. 

Interview by Nvard Chalikyan
 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

21:51
The Co-chairs call upon the Parties to keep heavy military equipment, which had been moved earlier close to the LOC in it's present positions
The Co-Chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, Ambassadors Igor Popov of Russia, Stephane Visconti of France and Richard Hoagland of the United States...
13:57
NKR defense Army: Adversary applied cannons in Talish direction
The Azerbaijani forces continued intensively violating the ceasefire across the Line of Contact between Nagorno Karabakh and Azerbaijan...
20:19
Documentary “The Besieged” telling about human sufferings under Azerbaijani siege premiered in Yerevan
The Documentary “The Besieged” telling about the sufferings of the Stepanakert residents under Azerbaijani blockade in the winter...
19:32
NKR Defense Ministry unveils additional materials documenting the failed subversive operation of Azerbaijani forces
Defense Ministry of the Nagorno Karabakh Republic (NKR/Artsakh) has released two separate footages and an audio recording proving the...
18:15
Paul Pogba’s “Armenian speaking” video goes viral
Manchester United’s playmaker Paul Pogba has been captured speaking in Armenia in a footage that is garnering widespread reaction...
17:57
Armenia’s MFA accuses Baku for another blow to the efforts towards the peaceful settlement of the Karabakh conflict
“In defiance to the calls of the international community, the demands of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chair countries to strictly adhere to the...
17:32
RA Defense Ministry releases a footage proving Azerbaijani aggression
Defense Ministry of Armenia has released a footage proving the Azerbaijani aggression at the southeastern (Martuni) and eastern (Akna)...
16:52
“Ohanyan-Raffi-Oskanian” alliance holds a convention to address expectations ahead of parliamentary elections
The newly formed political alliance “Ohanyan-Raffi-Oskanyan” (ORO) named by the leaders of the Heritage party, Unity party as well...
15:42
Turkey ready to press deeper into Syria after Al-Bab victory – foreign minister
Turkey intends to continue its advance into Syria to drive Islamists out of their Raqqa stronghold after securing a strategic town in...
15:28
CEC publishes party lists ahead of parliamentary elections
The Central Electoral Commission (CEC) of Armenia has published on Saturday the proportional list of the parties and political blocs nominated...
15:03
China hotel fire leaves 10 killed, 14 injured
At least 10 people were killed and 14 others injured on Saturday when a major fire broke out at a multi-storey luxurious hotel in Nanchang,...
14:45
Representative of Iranian Supreme Leader issues two warnings to Azerbaijani ambassador
“There are some Azerbaijani officials who make anti-Iranian statements by Israel's instigation,” Representative of Iran’s...
14:02
Currently situation relatively calm in the frontline, Armenia’s MOD Spokesman says
“After some time a footage proving the Azerbaijani aggression will be released,” Spokesman of Armenia’s Ministry of Defense...
13:52
Armenia’s MFA informs OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairing countries about the Azerbaijani offensive attempt
Armenia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) has informed the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairing countries about the Azerbaijani offensive...
13:42
Attack on Syrian security forces in Homs kills dozens
A series of suicide attacks on military installations in Syria's government-held city of Homs have killed at least 20 people, including the...
13:26
Video, which has recently appeared on Internet, confirms Azerbaijani armed forces’ involvement in Khojaly tragedy
Azerbaijani journalist Chingiz Mustafayev known for his shooting of military action in the region of the Karabakh conflict was one of those, who...
13:21
Bodies of the Azerbaijani soldiers are in the neutral zone between the two opposing troops - Senor Hasratyan
Spokesman of the Defense Ministry of the Nagorno Karabakh Republic (NKR) Senor Hasratyan has made the following post on his Facebook page:...
13:07
Chingiz Mustafayev on Aghdam events: 10 Azerbaijanis were walking among corpses 600 meters away from our post
Azerbaijani journalist Chingiz Mustafayev known for his shooting of military action in the region of the Karabakh conflict was one of those, who...
12:57
Armenian Community exposes propaganda event of Azerbaijan’s embassy in Lithuania
Armenian Community of Lithuania screwed up another Azerbaijani propaganda event aimed at the distortion of historical facts. The information has...
12:48
NKR President Bako Sahakyan gives instructions to heads of regional administrations
On 25 February, Artsakh President Bako Sahakyan convoked a working consultation with the participation of the heads of regional administrations....
12:42
NKR Defense Ministry: The military-political leadership of Azerbaijan bears the entire responsibility of the consequences of escalating the frontline situation
“It is already for several days that the military-political leadership of Azerbaijan escalates the frontline situation and spreads...
12:20
How can the defending side leave casualties in the neutral zone? – NKR Defense Ministry addresses question to Azerbaijan
As usual, the adversary initiated an unsuccessful attempt to put the blame on the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) side for the offensive actions...
12:07
Number of Turkish restaurants, cafés increase in Akhaltsikhe, Georgia
Throughout only one year, the number of Turkish cafés and restaurants have significantly increased in Akhaltsikhe town, Georgia, which...
11:18
Aronian makes another draw in Sharjah Grand Prix
The game of Round 6 of FIDE Grand Prix underway in Sharjah took place. In this round, Armenian GM Levon Aronian played against Francisco Vallejo...
10:57
NKR Defense Ministry: Armenian forces detect advancement of the Azerbaijani forces on time, repel them causing losses
On the night of 25 February, at around 03:00 and 04:00, the Azerbaijani forces made attack attempts at the southeastern (Martuni) and eastern...
10:13
Fog descended over several highways in Armenia
Armenia’s Ministry of Transport, Communication and Information Technologies told Panorama.am that as of 09:30 February 25, Vardenyats Pass...
23:01
Presentation of book dedicated to Artsakh held in French Parliament
On February 22, at the initiative of the France-Artsakh Friendship Circle, presentation of the book “15 questions, 15 answers, to know...
20:20
Coffee imports volume increases in Armenia
In 2016 5 thousand 400 tons of coffee and coffee alternatives were imported to Armenia. As the State Revenue Committee of Armenia told...
20:07
Karvachar to have 24-hour drinking and irrigation water supply in coming future
Active works are underway on construction of water supply system in Karvachar city of Shahumyan region, NKR. In an interview with...
19:47
Women’s World Chess Championship: Players continue competing for the chess crown
The Semifinal matches of the Women’s World Chess Championship took place in Tehran, Iran. All the games ended in victories. Tan Zhongyi...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}