Short news (12)

15:25 24/11/2009 » Politics

Armenia submits protocols to Constitutional Court: What's Next?

Pres. Serzh Sargsyan quietly submitted the Armenia-Turkey Protocols to the Constitutional Court on November 19, without a public announcement.

Under Armenian law, all international agreements have to be submitted to the Constitutional Court, prior to their consideration by Parliament for ratification. The Protocols were signed by the Armenian and Turkish Foreign Ministers on October 10, after both sides publicly committed on August 31 to "make their best efforts" to ratify the Protocols in a "timely" manner.

Given the fact that Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu had already introduced the Protocols to the Turkish Parliament on October 21, the timing of Pres. Sargsyan's submission to the Court may have been prompted by his wish to avoid accusations of foot-dragging by Prime Minister Recep Erdogan during his Washington visit on December 6. Indeed, over the weekend, a Turkish official accused Armenia of not taking any steps to ratify the Protocols.. Hurriyet newspaper quoted a Senior Turkish Diplomat as stating: "I do not think that one could press Turkey at this moment when Armenia has still not submitted them to Parliament."

Forwarding the Protocols to the Constitutional Court, however, does not necessarily mean that Armenian officials intend to ratify them quickly, since they had announced that they are going to wait for Turkey to ratify them first. Moreover, Turkish leaders have repeatedly linked the ratification of the Protocols to the resolution of the Karabagh (Artsakh) conflict, thus making it questionable if the Protocols would be ratified at all.

The Armenian Constitutional Court's website indicates that after submission of a case to the Court, the first step is assigning one of its judges to conduct a preliminary review within 15 days, which could be extended by 10 days. In all, the Court has 90 days from date of submission to announcing its decision. The Constitutional Court's mandate specifies that its decision will not be based on whether the Protocols are in compliance with the Constitution, but on whether the obligations deriving from such an international agreement are in conformity with the Constitution.

Given the lack of public trust in Armenia's courts in general, most Armenians, especially those who oppose the Protocols, are highly skeptical that the Constitutional Court would not rubber stamp the government's position on these Protocols. Some members of the press questioned the appropriateness of Gagik Harutyunyan, the Constitutional Court's Chair, accompanying Pres. Sargsyan on his recent overseas "consulting tour," trying to convince Diaspora Armenians that the Protocols were in Armenia's best interest.

Given the critical nature of the proposed Protocols and their long-term impact on Armenia's national interest, it is expected that the Constitutional Court would approach this case with the utmost seriousness and responsibility. While most Armenians would prefer that the Court disapprove the Protocols, it is more likely that it would approve them after adding several clarifications and interpretations that would be part and parcel of the agreement prior to submission to Parliament. Such clarifications would hopefully minimize the detrimental effects of the Protocols and not allow Turkey to misinterpret the agreement, particularly references to international treaties that may preclude future Armenian claims, and formation of a historical sub-commission that could question the facts of the Armenian Genocide.

Another important issue that the Constitutional Court may consider is adding a provision that would give the Armenian government the right to unilaterally abrogate this agreement, should Turkey violate any of its provisions after ratification.

During Pres. Sargsyan's meeting with over 60  Armenian community leaders in Los Angeles on October 4, I suggested that the Armenian government add a formal reservation to the Protocols, giving itself the right to consider the agreement null and void, should Turkey, after ratification, not open the border with Armenia within the stipulated 60-day timeframe or if it closed the border after opening it. Significantly, Pres. Sargsyan publicly agreed with my suggestion and committed himself to adding such a provision.Since it appears that the Armenian government is intent on going through with these Protocols despite all objections, the Constitutional Court and the Armenian Parliament should attempt to minimize the damage they are sure to cause to the country's national interests by adding specific reservations and clarifications prior to their eventual ratification.

By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier

Source: Panorama.am

Share |

Print version

In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the editor by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.

↓ Latest news

17:55 06/02/2012 » Society

H. Tamrazyan: Opening of restored old building of Matenadaran to surprise everyone

The reconstruction of Armenian repository of manuscripts - Matenadaran named after Mesrop Mashtots, which kicked off yet in previous year, will finish in May. Before the reconstruction is terminated, the road leading to Matenadaran will be ready in April. Arthur Meschian is the architect and designer of the project. Panorama.am reporter, accompanied by chief engineer Hunan Kostanyan, walked through the old building. He said they were tasked to create fresh architectural innovations ...

17:24 06/02/2012 » Politics

Saribekyan wonders what ‘defenders of reforms are being defeated’ expression means

 “Oxford Analytica” paper referred to reforms being implemented in the Armed Forces of Armenia noting that casualties and murders recorded in peace conditions obstruct advancement recorded in the Armenian Armed Forces in the recent phase. The paper also mentions that defenders of reforms in Armenian army are being defeated. Panorama.am asked Karen Saribekyan, member of NA Standing Committee on Defense, national security and interior affairs, to remark on the analytic ...

15:44 06/02/2012 » Politics

Romanian Government to resign

 The Romanian Prime Minister Emil Boc announced on Monday he and his government were going to immediately resign, “Reuters” news agency reported. “It’s time for vital political decisions. In this respect, I’ve decided to resign from my mandate,” Boc said. In January, Romanians staged weeks of protests against President Traian Basescu and PM Emil Boc. They protested low living standards, widespread corruption, and the passage of some laws ...

15:23 06/02/2012 » Society

ICRC representatives visit Azerbaijani POW in NKR

 Representatives of International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) have visited Azerbaijani prisoner of war kept in Nagorno-Karabakh Mammadbagir Akhundzade, ICRC Baku Office Spokesperson Shahla Gahramanova told Trend. The POW has been delivered a letter from parents and handed in a letter to ICRC representatives. Junior sergeant of Azerbaijani Armed Forces Mammadbagir Akhundzade was captivated near the Yukhary Chayli village on the contact line. Azerbaijan’s Defense ...

15:13 06/02/2012 » Culture

Hasmik Poghosyan: Armenia must take part in Eurovision 2012

 Minister of Culture Hasmik Poghosyan says she thinks Armenia must take part in “Eurovision 2012” international song contest to be held in Baku, Azerbaijan. “Yes, I think that Armenia must take part in Eurovision 2012,” said the minister and continued that it would do but favor to Armenia, even if defeated. Asked who would the minister prefer to see on the stage, H. Poghosyan said she hasn’t though over it “though I like “Dorians” ...

Continue
Interviews
Comments
Videos

14:05 06/02/2012

Hayk Gevorgyan released


17:49 04/02/2012

17:36
04/02/2012

Serzh Sargsyan attended the celebration in "Lovers” Park


Calendar