Analysis 10:04 28/10/2014

Re-elected Dilma wins in a Brazil broken in two

By Pepe Escobar, RT

President Dilma Rousseff of the ruling Worker's Party (PT) was re-elected this Sunday in a tight run-off against opposition candidate Aecio Neves of the Social Democracy Party of Brazil (PSDB).

Sun, sex, samba, carnival and at least until the recent World Cup hammering by Germany, the “land of football.” And don’t forget “vibrant democracy.” Even as it enjoys one of the highest soft power quotients around the world, Brazil remains submerged by clichés.

“Vibrant democracy” certainly lived up to its billing in this hard-fought presidential election. Yet another cliché would rule this was the victory of “state-centric” policies against “structural reforms.” Or the victory of “high social spending” against a “pro-business” approach – which implies business as the privileged enemy of social equality.

Exit clichés. Enter a cherished national motto: ‘Brazil is not for beginners.’

Indeed. Brazil’s complexities boggle the mind. It starts with arguably the key, multi-layered message a divided country sent to winner Dilma Rousseff. We are part of a growing middle class. We are proud to be part of an increasingly less unequal nation. But we want social services to keep improving. We want more investment in education. We want inflation under control (at the moment, it's not). We support a very serious anti-corruption drive (here’s where Dilma’s Brazil meets Xi Jinping’s China). And we want to keep improving on the economic success of the past decade.

Rousseff seems to get the message. The question is how she will be able to deliver – in a continental-sized nation suffering from appalling education standards, with Brazilian manufacturing largely uncompetitive in global markets, and with corruption run amok.

Those ignorant, arrogant elites

Brazil is now mired in dismal GDP growth of 0.3 percent. Just blaming the global crisis doesn’t cut it; South American neighbors Peru at 3.6 percent, and Colombia with 4.8 percent are definitely going places in 2014.

And yet the numbers are not that shabby. Job creation is up. Unemployment is down to only 5.4 percent. Investment in social infrastructure is picking up. From 2002 to 2014, the minimum wage more than tripled. GDP per capita is up, reaching roughly $9,000 while the 2012 Gini coefficient of social inequality is down.

Industrial production is back to the same level before the 2008 financial crisis. Brazil paid all its debts to the IMF. The proportion of debt in relation to GDP is falling – reaching only 33.8 percent in 2013. Workers have more purchasing power – and even with rising inflation, that mirrors better income distribution.

Social programs have benefited 14 million families - roughly 50 million Brazilians. These policies may arguably be derided as too little, too late Keynesianism. But at least that’s a start – in a nation exploited by immensely ignorant, arrogant and rapacious elites for centuries.

Rousseff’s first stint as President may also be blamed for too many concessions to big extremely profitable banks in Brazil, powerful agribusiness interests and Big Capital. What happened, in a nutshell, is that the center-left Workers’ Party swung to the center – and was compelled to make unsavory oligarchic alliances. The result is that a significant section of its social base – the metropolitan working class, now heavily indebted to sustain its brand new consumer dream - ended up flirting with the right as a political alternative.

Add to it the PT’s not exactly brilliant management skills. True, the fight against poverty is a lofty ideal. But in such an unequal nation, that will take at least until 2030 for really serious results. Meanwhile, serious planning is in order - such as building a high-speed railway between the two megalopolises, Rio and Sao Paulo (the Chinese would do it in a few months). And seriously tackling Brazil’s oligopolies; banks, corporate media, construction/real estate conglomerates, the auto industry lobby.

And the loser is…neoliberalism

Unlike the US and Europe, neoliberalism in Brazil has been repeatedly knocked out at the ballot box since 2002, when Lula was first elected President. As for the “social democrat” opposition, there’s nothing social, and barely democratic, about it. The PSDB’s pet project is turbo-neoliberalism, pure and simple.

Team Neves had everything going for them. Their key constituency was in fact 60 million mostly angry Brazilian taxpayers - over 80 percent living and working in the wealthier southeastern seaboard. Life is tough if you are a Brazilian salaried professional or the owner of a small and medium enterprise (SME). The tax burden is on a par with the industrialized world – but you get virtually nothing in return.

No wonder these irate taxpayers are desperate for decently paved roads, urban security, better public hospitals, a public school system they can send their children to, and less red tape and bureaucracy – which add to the nefarious, universally known “Brazilian cost” (as in no value for money). These are not Workers’ Party voters – although some of them were. What they want is galaxies beyond the everyday tribulations of the new, large lower middle class created by the social programs first implemented by Lula.

Yet with a mediocre candidate like Neves – he even lost in his home state, where he was governor - neoliberalism does not need enemies.

Neves predictably billed himself as the dragon who would slay what Wall Street derides as “statism” - cutting government spending and “liberalizing” trade, code for privileging corporate US interests. At the same time Neves has never been able to capture the vote of an overburdened black woman in the favelas.

With Neves, Brazil’s future Finance Minister would have been Arminio Fraga, a slick operator who, among other things, ran high-risk funds in emerging markets for George Soros and is also a former president of Brazil’s Central Bank. Some of his shenanigans are detailed in More Money than God: Hedge Funds and the Making of a New Elite, by Sebastian Mallaby. Fraga would have been the point man of a Soros-inspired government.

Fraga is the proverbial Wall Street predator. With him at the Finance Ministry, think J.P. Morgan controlling Brazil’s macroeconomic policy. The road in fact was already paved by PSDB’s eminence, former president Fernando Henrique Cardoso, who met with key global investors – via J.P. Morgan - in New York last month.

Fraga was keen on destroying the Lula and Rousseff administrations’ “hyper-Keynesian bet on demand” and replace it with supply, via a new “capitalist shock.” Predictably, his prescription was amplified by the enormous echo chamber of conservative Brazilian media, and drowned everything else.

And as perception is reality, contamination ensued - pressuring public spending downwards, installing major confusion among private investors, and leading Western credit rating agencies to confirm the supposed lack of credibility of the Brazilian economy.

And it’s the US against the BRICS

Brazil is slowly but surely moving from the semi-periphery to being closer to the center of the action in international relations; because of its own regional geopolitical relevance and mostly because of its leading role among the BRICS. This is happening even as Washington could not give a damn about Brazil - or Latin America for that matter. US “think tank-land,” by the way, abhors BRICS.

Politically, a victory for the Cardoso/Neves neoliberals - a ghost of the social democracy they once practiced - would have thrown Brazilian foreign policy upside down; not only against the way the historical winds are blowing, but also against Brazil’s own national interests.

As Rousseff argued at the UN last month, Brazil is trying to fight a global crisis marked by increasing inequality without provoking unemployment and without sacrificing workers’ jobs and salaries. As ace economist Theotonio dos Santos stressed, the decadence of the West still exerting substantial influence over the Global South via their extensive network of collaborators, he also went one up; the key fight, as he sees it, is to control Brazilian oil.

Dos Santos is referring to Brazil’s top corporation, Petrobras, currently mired in a bribery scandal - which must be fully investigated – that obscures the Holy Grail: the future revenues from “pre-salt” oil – named after the billions of barrels of oil capped by a thick layer of salt lying several miles below the South Atlantic floor. Petrobras plans to invest $221 billion up to 2018 to unlock this treasure – and expects to make a profit even if oil trades around $45 to $50 a barrel.

Politically, in a nutshell, Rousseff’s narrow victory is crucial for the future of a progressive, integrated South America. It will reinvigorate Mercosur – the common market of the South – as well as Unasur – the union of South American nations. This goes way beyond free trade; it’s about close regional integration, in parallel to close Eurasia integration.

And starting in 2015, Brazil may be on the road to renewed economic expansion again – largely boosted by the fruits of “pre-salt” and compounded with accelerated building of roads, railways, ports and airports. That is bound to have a ripple effect across Brazil’s neighbors.

As for Washington/Wall Street, the Empire of Chaos is certainly not happy – and that’s a major euphemism, especially after betting on the wrong horse, Marina Silva, a sort of Amazon rainforest-born female counterpart to Obama’s “change we can believe in.” The fact is, as much as the Brazilian model of income distribution is against the interests of big business, Brazilian foreign policy is now diametrically opposed to Washington’s.

On a lighter note, at least some things will remain the same. Like “Dilma’s diary” – an apocryphal, satirical, ghost written take on the President’s busy schedule published by top Brazilian monthly Piaui, a somewhat local version of The New Yorker. Here’s a typical entry; “I watched a whole pirate copy of Homeland. Awesome! We stayed up late, me and Patriota [the former Minister of Foreign Affairs]. He found the whole thing extremely believable!”

 Who said a “vibrant democracy” can’t also be fun? 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:14
Strong winds, thunderstorms expected in Armenia
Rainless weather is expected across Armenia on Tuesday and in the next two days. Showers and thunderstorms coupled with strong winds...
16:59
Pierre d'Argent: What Aliyev calls its 'patriotic war' resulted in ethnic cleansing of Nagorno-Karabakh
International law professor Pierre d'Argent representing Armenian on Tuesday delivered remarks at public hearings in the case of Armenia v....
16:22
Lawyer calls Freedom House report on Armenia 'objective'
Lawyer Ara Ghazaryan says the assessments provided by the latest Freedom House report on Armenia are “objective”. "I...
15:35
Melanie Joly welcomes news of first Canadian expert joining EUMA
Canada’s Foreign Minister Mélanie Joly has welcomed the new of the first Canadian expert joining the EU Mission in...
15:04
Azerbaijan imposes hate speech against Armenians, agent tells ICJ
Armenia's Representative on International Legal Matters Yeghishe Kirakosyan on Tuesday delivered opening remarks at a hearing of...
14:35
Altercation erupts at Yerevan City Council
An altercation erupted between two female members of the Yerevan City Council on Tuesday. Speaking at a City Council meeting, Kristina...
14:05
Search reportedly underway at Wigmore Clinic in Yerevan
Officers of the Armenian Investigative Committee are currently raiding the Wigmore Clinic in Yerevan, News.am reports, citing its sources....
13:36
Arman Tatoyan slams MP's remark on 'verification' of Armenian Genocide victims
Former Armenian Ombudsman Arman Tatoyan has denounced as “absolutely unacceptable” a pro-government MP’s statement on the need...
13:14
Fire breaks out at Copenhagen's historic stock exchange
Denmark's historic old stock exchange building in the centre of Copenhagen has been engulfed by fire, BBC News reports. The 17th...
12:55
Raids conducted at Armenian Health Ministry, hospital
Law enforcement officials are raiding the buildings of the Armenian Health Ministry and a medical center, Investigative Committee spokesperson...
12:33
MP Tigran Abrahamyan meets with imprisoned opposition activists
Opposition Pativ Unem faction MP Tigran Abrahamyan on Monday visited the Armavir Penitentiary to meet with political prisoners Vazgen...
11:46
Ex-envoy urges end to 'vicious' Armenian Genocide discourse
Armenia’s former Ambassador-at-Large Edmon Marukyan has urged an end to the “vicious" discourse calling into question the...
11:15
GM Elina Danielian's team wins gold at Austrian Women's Bundesliga
The ASVÖ Pamhagen 1 team involving Armenian GM Elina Danielian won a gold medal at the Austrian Women's Bundesliga, the...
11:00
Lemkin Institute reacts to Azerbaijan's statement at ICJ
The Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention has reacted to Azerbaijan's statement at the International Court of Justice (ICJ)....
17:06
Opposition files lawsuits against Civil Contract
The opposition Mother Armenia faction in the Yerevan City Council has filed three lawsuits against the municipal faction of Prime Minister Nikol...
16:45
EU mission in Armenia welcomes first Canadian expert
The EU Mission in Armenia (EUMA) has welcomed the first Canadian expert. “Thrilled to welcome the first Canadian expert Alexander...
16:30
Temperatures to hit 28C in Yerevan this week
Showers and thunderstorms coupled with strong winds are expected in some parts of Armenia on Monday and later this week. Rainless weather is...
16:15
President: Kazakhstan ready to increase exports to Armenia up to $350 million
Kazakh President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev and Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan reaffirmed their strong commitment to enhancing...
15:36
Vardan Ghukasyan announces street protests in Yerevan
U.S.-based blogger Vardan Ghukasyan (better known as "Dog”), the founder of the Democracy, Law and Discipline party, has announced...
15:15
Opposition MP slams Brussels talks as 'disgraceful failure'
The Armenia-EU-US meeting held in Brussels on April 5 was a "disgraceful failure", Artur Khachatryan, an MP from the opposition...
14:33
UK’s Cameron urges Israel to use 'head as well as heart' after Iran attack
British Foreign Secretary David Cameron urged Israel not to retaliate after Iran's drone and missile attack, saying it should "think...
14:16
Armenian Foreign Ministry says no 'substantive' talks with UK over Rwanda deal
Armenia and the United Kingdom have had no “substantive” talks on a possible Rwanda deal, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Ani Badalyan...
13:36
Police in Yerevan seize flyers about 'missing' ombudsperson
Police officers on Monday seized flyers regarding Armenian Human Rights Defender Anahit Manasyan distributed by two employees of the...
13:05
Arsonist targeting Armenian cemetery in Fresno
Since the middle of January, the Fresno Ararat Armenian Cemetery has been targeted by an arsonist, FOX26 News reports. Six total...
12:35
New Middle East crisis will directly affect Armenia, MP warns
The escalation of tensions in the Middle East will have a direct impact on Armenia, warns opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan. His comments came...
11:57
UK targeting four countries, including Armenia, for Rwanda deal
Britain is targeting four more countries to replicate the Rwanda migrant deportation scheme, according to leaked documents. The UK has...
11:36
Kazakh president arrives in Armenia
President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev of Kazakhstan has arrived in Armenia on an official visit.  He was welcomed by Deputy Prime...
11:24
AntiFake employees detained in Yerevan
Two employees of the AntiFake media outlet were detained in Yerevan early on Monday, lawyer Ruben Melikyan revealed. Citing preliminary...
11:00
Armenia calls for dialogue in Middle East amid escalating tensions
Escalating tensions in the Middle East are a cause for grave concern, the Armenian Foreign Ministry said on Sunday following Iran's...
17:00
Temperatures to hit 27C in parts of Armenia
Rainless weather is expected in Armenia on Saturday, the met service reports. Showers are forecast for the country’s regions on Sunday...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}