Politics 12:24 06/12/2011

US court to rule on Turkish banks’ motion to dismiss Armenian lawsuits

Author By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier

 Two separate lawsuits were filed last year in US Federal Court in Los Angeles against the Republic of Turkey and two of its major banks demanding compensation for properties confiscated from Armenians after the 1915 Genocide.

The first is a class action lawsuit seeking what could amount to billions of dollars from the Turkish Republic, T.C. Ziraat Bankasi, and the Central Bank of Turkey for unjust enrichment from liquidation of properties belonging to Armenians deported and exterminated during the Genocide.

The second lawsuit, filed by three Armenian-Americans, seeks $64 million for their confiscated properties in Adana, Turkey, and millions more for accrued rent and interest paid by the U.S. government in the past 60 years for use of the strategic Incirlik Air Base, built on land taken from families of the Armenian plaintiffs.

When these lawsuits were initiated, the Turkish government and its two banks ridiculed the charges, claiming that US courts have no authority to judge the actions of other governments. In order to block the lawsuits, the Turkish entities refused to be served with the legal documents, which is the first step in filing a lawsuit. After lengthy cat and mouse games, Turkish officials finally received the court documents transmitted to them by the US Embassy in Ankara at the request of the State Department.

After grudgingly accepting the court papers, the Republic of Turkey refused to appear in US Federal Court, despite warnings from the State Department that it risked a default judgment. The Turkish banks, however, fearing a similar fate, rushed to the court and filed a motion to dismiss the pending lawsuits.

In their filings, the banks objected to the lawsuits, claiming that American courts lacked jurisdiction due to sovereign immunity. They argued that the lawsuits should not go forward because of the Ankara Agreement of 1934, the "political question doctrine," potential harm to U.S.-Turkish relations, lack of evidence that the plaintiffs are heirs of the owners of the confiscated properties, and the expiry of the statute of limitations.

Surprisingly, the Turkish banks conceded that even if the Republic of Turkey did confiscate Armenian properties, international law precluded the filing of such lawsuits, since Turkey had taken "the property of its own nationals."

The banks’ lawyers made the outrageous suggestion that the wills of Armenian Genocide victims be reviewed to determine the legal heirs of the confiscated properties. In case these victims did not have a will, the lawyers proposed that the relevant laws be examined to see who was really entitled to their properties!

The attorneys for the Armenian plaintiffs countered the Turkish objections and asked the court to deny the motion to dismiss. The plaintiffs asserted that the Ziraat bank branch in the United States is a private commercial bank and has no reason to enjoy sovereign immunity. Moreover, "genocide and the associated plunder of property is never deemed a legitimate act of the state. There is no application of a political question, as this case focuses on the return of unjust gains from the sale and/or rental of property held in trust. Finally, the statute of limitations does not apply because the properties were held in trust, and the failure to return them is a continuing injury." The attorneys further asserted that there are no statutes of limitations for War Crimes and Crimes against Humanity.

Contradicting the Banks’ claims, the lawyers for the class action lawsuit maintained that the Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act does not preclude the prosecution of foreign entities engaged in commercial activity in the United States which both the Republic of Turkey and the two banks have done for many years. The lawyers also asserted that the defendants falsely claimed that international law does not apply to foreign countries "for wrongs perpetrated against their own nationals." On the contrary, "international law prohibits states from expropriating property of nationals conducted during genocide and human rights abuses."

A hearing is scheduled in Federal Court on December 19 to determine the validity of the Turkish banks’ motion to dismiss the two lawsuits. Should the court reject the Turkish motion, and the Armenian plaintiffs end up winning their lawsuits during a subsequent trial, the court may order that the US assets of both Turkish banks be seized, up to the value of the claims, and turned over to the heirs of dispossessed Armenian victims as fair compensation.

Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Hero soldier Azat Asoyan would have turned 27 today
Today, July 26, is the birthday anniversary of Azat Asoyan, an Armenian soldier, who repulsed an Azerbaijani subversive attack on the...
Russia’s taekwondo fighter Khramtsov wins Olympic gold in men’s under-80kg event
Russia’s taekwondo fighter Maxim Khramtsov won gold on Monday of the 2020 Summer Olympic Games in Japan in the under-80 kilograms weight...
Ombudsman: Azerbaijani shootings close to Armenian villages violate residents' right to life, destroy their peaceful life
Azerbaijani shootings of 25-26 July in the immediate vicinity of Armenia's Verin Shorzha, Sotk and Yeraskh villages violate residents'...
Azerbaijani forces resume firing on Armenian positions near Yeraskh – Defense Ministry
The Azerbaijani troops resumed firing on the Armenian defense positions stationed near Yeraskh, a village in Armenia’s Ararat Province, at...
Artsakh villager taken captive after finding himself in Azerbaijani-held area, ombudsman says
The Office of Artsakh’s Human Rights Ombudsman Gegham Stepanyan has received an alarm about the capture of a resident of Machkalashen, a...
Ameriabank named largest taxpayer among Armenian banks according to results of second quarter of 2021
According to the data of the second quarter of year 2021, Ameriabank is the largest taxpayer among Armenian banks. It paid taxes to the...
Viva-MTS: New LED lighting system installed in borderline Voskevan community
Adhering its corporate social responsibility (CSR) culture Viva-MTS implements different social projects in Armenian regions for over 16 years....
Japanese Foreign Ministry summons Russian ambassador over Mishustin’s Iturup trip
The Japanese Foreign Ministry summoned Russian Ambassador Mikhail Galuzin to protest Russian Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin’s visit to...
Armenian school students win 5 medals at International Mathematical Olympiad
The Armenian team of school students won 5 medals at the 62nd International Mathematical Olympiad, the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture...
US to continue air strikes supporting Afghan troops fighting Taliban, general says
The United States will continue air strikes in support of Afghan forces fighting the Taliban, a top US general said Sunday, as the insurgents...
Expert: No information about two missing Armenian soldiers for 12 days already
The military-political leadership of Armenia has provided no information about the two Armenian soldiers, who went missing from the...
Armenia’s crisis management center handles 288 emergencies in one week
The National Center for Crisis Management of Armenia’s Ministry of Emergency Situations responded to a total of 614 calls from 19 to 25...
Azerbaijani forces open fire at Armenian positions in Gegharkunik and Ararat – Defense Ministry
The Azerbaijani troops have fired on the Armenian positions stationed in the Gegharkunik and Ararat Provinces, the Defense Ministry said in a...
Dutch ambassador to Armenia goes on a hike to Tavush with his kids
Ambassador of the Netherlands to Armenia Nico Schermers went on a hike to Tavush Province with his children on Sunday. “Sunday hike...
Heavy rains cause flooding in London
Heavy downpours and thunderstorms have caused severe flash flooding in parts of London, BBC News reports. There were reports of...
Sotk mine employees evacuated amid tensions on Armenian-Azerbaijani border at night
The situation was tense on the Sotk section of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border last night. As a result of the sporadic shootings,...
Japan's Abe siblings make Olympic history by winning gold on same day
Abe Hifumi has won Japan’s third judo gold medal at its home Olympics with an ippon victory over Georgia’s Vazha...
Armenia reports 112 new COVID-19 cases on July 26
Armenia has confirmed 112 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 228,910 as of 11 a.m. Monday, July 26, the...
Armenian wine festival draws hundreds in Burbank
Around 700 wine connoisseurs attended the third annual Armenian Wines and Spirits Festival at Castaway Restaurant in Burbank on Sunday, FOX...
Yerevan court to hear appeal against Kajaran head’s arrest on Monday
The Yerevan Court of Appeals will hear an appeal against the arrest of Kajaran community head Manvel Paramazyan on Monday. The court...
Stonehenge could follow Liverpool in losing its UNESCO world heritage status
Stonehenge could be the next historical UK site to lose its UNESCO World Heritage status. The UN’s heritage body has told ministers...
Artsakh reports one new COVID-19 case
Artsakh confirmed 1 new coronavirus case in the past 24 hours, bringing the country total to 2,936 on Saturday, July 24, the Ministry of Health...
‘A huge loss’: Armenians bid final farewell to legendary duduk player Jivan Gasparyan
Legendary duduk player Jivan Gasparyan’s death is a huge loss for the Armenian people, duduk payer Kamo Seyranyan told reporters on...
Lavrov urges to raise voice to shield Christians from persecution in Middle East
The world community should take steps to stop persecution of Christians in the Middle East and North Africa, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey...
Tokyo Olympics: Gymnast Artur Davtyan advances to final
Armenian artistic gymnast Artur Davtyan has advanced to the final after a successful start in the pole vault competition at the Tokyo Olympics....
Search for Artsakh war casualties continues in Varanda region
The search operations for remains of the 2020 Artsakh war casualties continue today in the Varanda (Fizuli) region. One search and rescue...
Russia reports nearly 24,000 new COVID-19 cases
Russia on Saturday reported nearly 24,000 new COVID-19 cases and a repeat all-time high in the number of daily deaths, at 799, but some...
Pianist Eva Gevorgyan to perform at 18th Chopin Competition
Russian-Armenian pianist Eva Gevorgyan will perform at the 18th Chopin Piano Competition, she said on Friday. “So happy to be selected...
Ukraine imposes sanctions on Wildberries, Russia’s wealthiest woman
Ukraine on Friday imposed sanctions on Russian online retailer Wildberries and its divisions in Ukraine, Belarus, Poland and other countries,...
Former MP Naira Zohrabyan sets up an NGO
Former Armenian MP Naira Zohrabyan has set up a non-governmental organization, she said in a Facebook post on Saturday. “As I have...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}