Politics 14:31 25/06/2013

Talaat killed the Ottoman Crown Prince for opposing the Armenian Genocide?

It is not often that I cover murder mysteries, but I am making an exception given the unusual circumstances of an Ottoman Crown Prince’s death in 1916 and its possible link to Talaat and the Armenian Genocide.

The first clue was an article I came across in the April 3, 1921 issue of The Pittsburgh Press, titled: "Patiently Tracked to His Hiding Place and Killed: How the Bloodthirsty Turkish Grand Vizier, Talaat Pasha, Who Planned the Murders of a Million Armenians Met His Fate." This news report was occasioned by Soghomon Tehlirian’s assassination of Talaat on March 15, 1921, in Berlin.

One paragraph, in particular, buried in the middle of the lengthy article, contained a shocking revelation: "Perhaps the strangest fact of all in connection with Talaat’s career is that he paved his way to this supreme office by murdering the heir to the throne, Crown Prince Youssouf Eddine, a nephew of the reigning Sultan. The young prince had protested strongly against Talaat’s announced policy of exterminating the Armenians. Talaat, seeing a prospect of serious opposition, shot the prince like a dog."

To ascertain the veracity of this surprising news item, I conducted a lengthy internet search and consulted publications in English, French, Turkish, Spanish, and Armenian, based on the different spellings of the Prince’s name: Youssouf Eddine, Yusuf Izzeddin, Yusuf Izzettin, etc.

While most of these sources agree that the Crown Prince died under suspicious circumstances, they present three distinct narratives on how he met his untimely death. There is even an entire Turkish book on this mystery, titled: ‘Shehzade Yusuf Izzedin olduruldu mu, intihar mi etti?’ [Crown Prince Yusuf Izzedin was killed or committed suicide?].

The first account is the one mentioned by The Pittsburgh Press claiming that the Crown Prince was killed by Talaat for opposing the extermination of the Armenian people.

The second explanation for the premature death of the Crown Prince is that he committed suicide by slashing his wrists. The Young Turk government issued the following official announcement on Feb. 3, 1916: "In consequence of the malady from which he suffered so long, His Highness the Heir to the throne committed suicide at half-past seven this morning in the bedroom of the harem pavilion of the summer-house at Zindjirly, by opening the veins of his left arm."

This formal statement was met with widespread skepticism, giving rise to a third explanation for the Crown Prince’s demise. French Minister of State Yves Guyot, in the preface to his book’s English edition, ‘The Causes and Consequences of the War,’ published in 1916, wrote that those who had read the official communiqué were convinced that the Young Turks "made the heir to the throne ‘commit suicide.’ Information from many quarters confirms that suspicion."

Guyot and other chroniclers asserted that War Minister Enver Pasha had Izzeddin killed for opposing the Ottoman alliance with Germany during World War I. "After the bombardment of Odessa by the Turkish fleet he [Izzeddin] indicated his disapproval in no uncertain manner. From that moment he was doomed," wrote the French Minister.

Guyot also described in detail a secret meeting in 1915 attended by Talaat, Enver and other Young Turk leaders, during which Enver advocated the elimination of the Crown Prince, who was "assassinated on the day before he was to start for Europe," according to Guyot.

Bishop Grigoris Balakian, a prominent survivor of the Armenian Genocide, affirms in his memoirs, ‘Armenian Golgotha,’ that the Crown Prince was "killed by Enver and Talaat’s criminal clique…. Enver himself killed Yusuf Izzedin at the imperial farm of Balmomji." Having witnessed the dead bodies of thousands of Turkish soldiers at the Battle of the Dardanelles, the Crown Prince protested to Enver that "the Dardanelles is the grave of the Turkish Army." He was murdered after threatening Enver with a pistol.

Those who think that the assassination of a Crown Prince is too far-fetched to be credible should realize that such palace intrigues were a common practice during the long history of the Ottoman Empire. All too often, Sultans would orchestrate the murder of scheming heirs, and rival siblings would kill each other to pave the way for their own accession to the throne. In fact, 15 of the 36 reigning Sultans either abdicated (3), were overthrown (7) or were murdered (5).

Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier 

Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Armenian, North Macedonian leaders discuss ways of promoting bilateral economic cooperation
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia on Saturday met with President Stevo Pendarovski of North Macedonia on the margins of the Munich...
Tokyo Olympics to proceed despite coronavirus fears
Tokyo Olympic organizers and the International Olympic Committee said Friday there is no “Plan B” for the 2020 Games, which open in...
Vayk Gold files lawsuit against Vayk-Invest
A regular public hearing was held in Azatek community of Armenia’s Vayots Dzor Province on possible exploitation of Azatek...
CoE secretary general to Armenian PM: There are some concerns
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia met with Council of Europe Secretary General Marija Pejčinović Burić on Saturday, his office reported....
Armenia sees increase in cases of acute intestinal infections, salmonellosis in two years
Cases of both acute intestinal infections and Salmonella infection (salmonellosis) increased in Armenia in 2016-2018, according to a study...
Zarif: Iran won't touch downed plane's black box without presence of all interested parties
Iran won't decipher the black box from in the plane of PS752 flight of Ukraine International Airlines (UIA) shot down near Tehran on January...
European Championships: Armenian wrestlers continue to clinch victories
Armenian freestyle wrestler Gevorg Mkheyan (70 kg) has captured a bronze medal at the 2020 European Championships underway in Rome, Italy....
Temperatures to rise by 6-8 degrees in Armenia
No precipitation is expected in Armenia on Sunday, 16 February, and from 18-20 February. Snow is expected in separate places on February 17,...
Earth just had hottest January since records began, data shows
Last month was the hottest January on record over the world’s land and ocean surfaces, with average temperatures exceeding anything in the...
Activist Narek Samsonyan charged over false crime reporting, Adekvad member says
Adekvad party member Lilit Tumanyan denounced the summoning of Chairman of the Civil Consciousness NGO, activist Narek Samsonyan to the Special...
Macron defends closer dialogue with Russia, sees no alternative
French President Emmanuel Macron said on Saturday that Europe’s policy of defiance towards Russia in recent years had failed and, as...
New Yerevan Circus building keeps being constructed
Yerevan, the capital of Armenia, has no circus for around nine years already. The old Yerevan Circus was demolished in 2012 after experts...
First coronavirus death confirmed in Europe
A Chinese tourist has died in France after contracting the new coronavirus - the first fatality from the disease outside Asia, BBC News...
Armenian PM, Azerbaijani president may hold meeting in Munich
The possibility of a bilateral meeting of Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham in Munich is being considered....
Artsakh reports around 120 Azerbaijani ceasefire violations in one week
Azerbaijani military breached the ceasefire along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan Line of Contact around 120 times in the past week. In the period...
Activist Narek Samsonyan summoned to Special Investigative Service as accused
Chairman of the Civil Consciousness NGO, activist Narek Samsonyan has been summoned to the Special Investigative Service (SIS) for questioning...
Armenian FM, OSCE chief discuss Karabakh peace
On the margins of the Munich Security Conference, Foreign Minister of Armenia Zohrab Mnatsakanyan met on Friday with OSCE Secretary General...
Criminal case launched into soldier’s death in Artsakh
The Investigative Committee of Armenia is probing the death of a contract soldier of the Artsakh Defense Army. Lieutenant Hayk Asryan, 23,...
European Championships: Armenian wrestler Mihran Jaburyan advances to semifinals
Armenian freestyle wrestler Mihran Jaburyan (57 kg) has made it to the semifinals of the 2020 European Championships underway in Rome, Italy....
Armenian PM congratulates Serbian counterpart on national holiday
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has sent a congratulatory message to Prime Minister of Serbia Ana Brnabić on the country’s...
Egypt confirms coronavirus case, first in Africa
Egypt has confirmed its first case of a deadly coronavirus that emerged in central China at the end of last year and has since spread to more...
Fallen hero Grigor Harutyunyan would have turned 23 today
Today, February 15, marks the birthday anniversary of Grigor Harutyunyan, an Armenian soldier who died a hero’s death during the 2016...
Coronavirus death toll in China passes 1,500
The death toll from China's new coronavirus epidemic surged past 1,500 on Saturday after 143 more people died in the country, AFP said...
Contract soldier dies in Artsakh
A contract soldier of the Artsakh Defense Army was fatally wounded at the military post of an eastern military unit under yet unclear...
Armenia’s Hover State Chamber Choir to present choral arrangements of popular songs
Armenia’s Hover State Chamber Choir will perform a unique concert at Komitas Chamber Music Hall in Yerevan on February 15, at 7pm. The...
Russian man freezes himself in icy heart for bizarre Valentine's Day stunt to impress wife
A Russian man declared his undying love to his wife on Valentine's Day by laying in a coffin of ice for 13 minutes. The bizarre stunt...
Stepantsminda-Larsi highway open to all vehicles
Some roads in Armenia are closed or difficult to pass as of 9:25am Saturday, February 15, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reported. The...
EU-Armenia investment forum to be held in Luxembourg; Nikol Pashinyan meets with Johannes Hahn
On the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia met with EU Commissioner for Budget and...
Armenian Church pays tribute to Pontiff St. Sahak Partev
The Armenian Apostolic Church commemorates on Saturday, February 15, Pontiff St. Sahak Partev, Qahana.am reports. St. Sahak Partev was the...
Recordings of the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra available in IDAGIO App
Recordings of the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra are now available on IDAGIO App - a streaming mobile service for classical music. As the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}