Politics 18:49 15/06/2019 Armenia

Turkey unable to deny the fact of the Armenian Genocide, no matter Ottoman archives are open or closed

“Statements about opening the Ottoman archives are not new. For years, especially since 1987-88 Turkey has constantly been stating about readiness to open the archives to show what they call facts proving their stance,” expert in Turkish studies Anush Hovhannisyan told Panorama.am when asked to comment on the rationale behind the recent call by Turkish FM Mevlut Cavusoglu to open the archives.

To remind, Cavusoglu stated days ago that if Armenia was confident [in its approach] then could accept the proposal on setting up a joint working group to involve also France, Russia. USA. In the ministers’ words, Armenia could even suggest any party to join the working group and open the archives.

Hovhannisyan first questioned the FM’s statement. “What does it mean to open the archives? Turkish archives have been filtered before they are open. There are numerous evidences proving that with many scientists and researchers who had worked in those archives and voiced certain documents were missing. I myself had a chance to visit the Ottoman archives of the Prime Minister. It contained rich materials about the number of population, the economic situation. However, the documents related to the Armenian Genocide are not there. They will never open military archives, including the archives of secret services,” said our interlocutor.

The expert recalled the fact that Talat Pasha and the officers under his command had burned all documentation of the general directives regarding the Armenian Genocide before leaving the Ottoman Empire  and took some materials to unknown directions.

“That is to say the statements of the Turkish side  are aimed at certain circles who are not quite familiar with the issue. Those statements are populist in nature,” said the turkologyst, adding, the archive of Armenia however, is open for Turkish colleagues.  

“I am engaged with the issue of confiscation of the Armenian property in Turkey and quite interested in Turkish land registry and cadaster archives. It is known that in 2005 the digitization of the documents in that archive started and the archive director wrote letter to the head of Turkey’s state security council which dealt and coordinated all activities regarding the issues of the Armenian Genocide. When informed about the existence of those documents the response letter suggested to close the archive and ban access to it to ‘not make a fuss and combat ungrounded claims about the Genocide’. However, the materials leaked to the press with some documents published in media in 2007-20008. That is to say whatever relates to the Armenian Genocide is a taboo in Turkey.”

Hovhannisyan argued that Turkish archives may not contain materials that would deny the fact of the Armenian Genocide. “All archival documents available in the world - whether in German, Armenian and to some extent in Turkish archives come to unequivocally prove there was an intention, action and a Genocide. Thus, Turkey has no chance to deny the fact no matter its archives are open or closed,” explained Anush Hovhannisyan.

As to the idea of setting up a commissions, the expert noted the move is aimed at prolonging the discussions and using them as a pretext  to silence the topic whenever the issues is raised in other parliaments. “That was something Turkey practiced during the Armenian-Turkish rapprochement urging all countries to not interfere as the both parties are discussing the issue. The primary aim of the suggested commission is to prevent resolutions against Turkey,” concluded Hovhannisyan.

Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Robert Hovhannisyan - the winner of Villa de Benasque tournament
Armenian Grandmaster Robert Hovhannisyan has won a major international chess tournament in Spain. As the Chess Federation reports, the Armenian...
Pyunik seal place in Europa League second qualifying round
Europa League first qualifying round second leg match between North Macedonian side FK Shkupi and FC Pyunik took place in Skopje on July 18. As...
The blast in Sisian was from an explosive device – Investigative Committee
The blast in one of the houses in Armenia’s Sisian town came from an explosive device, Armenia’s Investigative Committee reported....
Satik Seyranyan: The clashes in Ijevan revealed how frightened the authorities are
The recent clashes between the law enforcement and citizens in Ijevan revealed how frightened the authorities of Armenia are, Satik Seyranyan,...
Supreme Judicial Council elects new chairman
Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council, an oversight body tasked with monitoring the judiciary, elected on Friday its next chairman. As the...
One killed in an explosion in Southern Sisian town of Armenia
Armenia’s ministry of emergency situation said ina statement that an explosion rocked in Kamo Street in Armenia’s southern Sisian...
Rostransnadzor to conduct inspection after the incident in Sheremetyevo
Russian federal authority for transport oversight Rostransnadzor will conduct an unscheduled audit of the airline Nordwind after the incident...
Air temperature to reach +42°C in some parts of Armenia
The air temperature will reach +40+42°C in capital Yerevan, Ararat and Armavir provinces on July 21-23 due to hot tropical cyclone...
“Cilicia: The Land of Lions”: The grand premiere will take place in Armenia in the near future
The private premiere screening of a mood reel trilogy “Cilicia: The Land of Lions,” depicting the glorious history of the...
American warship destroys Iranian drone in Strait of Hormuz
A U.S. warship on Thursday destroyed an Iranian drone in the Strait of Hormuz after it threatened the ship, President Donald Trump said,...
Constitutional Court turns to Venice Commission, ECHR for opinion over ex-President Kocharyan case
The Constitutional Court of Armenia suspended the proceedings against the former President of the country Robert Kocharyan and turned to Venice...
A Yerevan-bound flight aborts takeoff at Moscow airport over cockpit smoke
A Boeing 737 plane belonging to Russia's Nordwind Airlines cancelled its takeoff from Moscow's Sheremetyevo International Airport after...
Turkey says Pentagon decision may ‘irreparably damage relations’ with US
Turkey is calling on the US to correct its mistake of removing the country from the F-35 fighter jet program, "which will irreparably...
“See you soon, Armenia!” - Nuno Gomes farewell message from Yerevan airport
Former Portugal player Nuno Gomes who was visiting Armenia for the U19 Euro championship, posted a farewell message on Instagram, summing up his...
15 migrants die in vehicle crash in Van
At least 15 people died and more than 20 were injured on Thursday when a vehicle carrying irregular migrants crashed in eastern Turkey, a local...
NSS chief arrives in Ijevan following clashes between law enforcement and residents
The Chief of Armenia’s National Security Service Artur Vanetsyan has arrived in Ijevan following the clashes on Wednesday evening between...
Suspect in Dink murder trial sentenced to 99 years in prison
Erhan Tuncel, one of the main suspects standing trial for allegedly playing a role in the 2007 murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink,...
13 citizens arrested over clashes with law enforcement in Ijevan
Armenia’s Investigative Committee has launched criminal investigation over the clashes between citizens and law enforcement in...
'You had the Nobel Prize?' Trump learns of Yazidi activist Murad
US President Donald Trump on Wednesday appeared unfamiliar with the work and cause of Nobel laureate Nadia Murad as she pleaded with him to help...
Mkhitaryan thanks Los Angeles fans for warm welcome at the first pre-season match
Asenal’s pre-season continued with an encouraging 2-1 victory over German champions Bayern Munich in Los Angeles. A late Eddie Nketiah...
Swiss responsAbility launches USD 175 m blended finance impact securitization transaction partnered with Ameriabank
Swiss responsAbility Investments AG, the international impact asset manager is launching a USD 175 m securitization of loans to SME-finance...
Ex-president Kocharyan’s office sees political motivations behind the search of the judge office
The office of Armenia’s ex-President Robert Kocharyan’s insists the searches held in the office of Judge Davit Grigoryan who had...
Atlantic Council: For Armenia’s Pashinyan, Poroshenko’s presidency should serve as a cautionary tale
The Atlantic Council has published an article about Armenia’s ongoing political developments and drawing parallels with the Ukrainian...
Police officers injured in clashes with protesters in Ijevan released from hospitals
Police officers injured in clashes with protester in Ijevan released from hospitals The health condition of police officers injured in...
Canoeists preparing for World Championship
The Armenian canoe team will take part in the Canoe Sprint World Championship in Hungarian Szeged from August 21 to 25. Executive Secretary...
Turkish President Erdogan to pay compensation for calling statue symbolising peace a 'freak'
The Constitutional Court of Turkey ruled that the demolition of the "Monument of Humanity" violated sculptor Mehmet Aksoy's...
Artsakh president receives Secretary of Armenia's National Security council
Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan received on July 17 the Secretary of Armenia's National Security Council Armen Grigoryan. As...
PM Nikol Pashinyan extends birthday greetings to German Chancellor Angela Merkel
“Germany’s continued progress and strengthening during your tenure is the vivid evidence of your high qualities as a leader. Highly...
Blueberry festival to be held in Armenia
The Delegation of the European Union to Armenia and Aregak Universal Credit Organization support Armenia Tree Project in organising a Blueberry...
Ararat Mirzoyan, Nancy Pelosi discussed issues on Armenian-American relations
The Speaker of Armenia’s National Assembly Ararat Mirzoyan met on Wednesday with the Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives Nancy...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}