Law 15:06 29/05/2020 Armenia

ECHR delivers advisory opinion on Robert Kocharyan’s case

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has delivered an advisory opinion on former Armenian President Robert Kocharyan’s case sought by the Constitutional Court of Armenia.

The court, delivering its second advisory opinion after Protocol 16 to the European Convention on Human Rights came into force in 2018, held that it could not answer the first two questions put by the Armenian top court.

The questions asked by the Constitutional Court were worded as follows:

1) Does the concept of ‘law’ under Article 7 of the Convention and referred to in other Articles of the Convention, for instance, in Articles 8-11, have the same degree of qualitative requirements (certainty, accessibility, foreseeability and stability)?

2) If not, what are the standards of delineation?

In particular, ECHR could not find any direct link between the questions and the ongoing domestic proceedings, which have been brought against former Kocharyan for allegedly attempting to overthrow the constitutional order in 2008.

The Constitutional Court’s third question was whether a provision which defined a crime and referred to a legal act with supreme legal force and a higher level of abstraction could meet the Convention requirements of certainty, accessibility, foreseeability and stability.

The court found that such a provision, using the “blanket reference” or “legislation by reference” technique in criminalizing acts or omissions, The referencing provision and the referenced provision, read together, had to enable individuals to foresee, if need be with the help of legal advice, what conduct would make them criminally liable.

Among other things, the most effective way of ensuringclarity and foreseeability was for the reference to be explicit and for the referencing provision to set out the constituent elements of the offence.

The Constitutional Court’s fourth question concerned the criteria under Article 7 (no punishment without law) of the European Convention for comparing two different versions of a legal act for their compatibility with the principle of the non-retroactivity of criminal law. The court found that such assessments had to take account of the specific circumstances of the case (the principle of concretisation) rather than be carried out in the abstract.

The full text of the advisory opinion can be accessed here



Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

19:05
Iraq cancels Turkish Defense minister visit, summons ambassador: statement
Iraq cancelled on Tuesday the Turkish defence minister’s visit to the country which was scheduled for Thursday, Iraq’s foreign...
18:58
Museums, libraries to reopen in Armenia as Covid-19 restrictions ease
Museums and libraries will reopen in Armenia as the government is gradually easing the Covid-19 restrictions imposed in March, Deputy Prime...
18:13
Avinyan: 57 coronavirus patients in critical condition in Armenia
A total of 258 coronavirus patients are in serious condition, while 57 others are in critical condition in Armenia, Deputy Prime Minister,...
17:52
Fallen soldier Sasha Galstyan would have turned 24 today
Today, August 12, marks the birthday anniversary of Sasha Galstyan, who heroically fell while defending the Artsakh borders during the 2016...
17:37
Analyst: Mediators have a lot of work to do to bring Azerbaijan back into political arena
The Turkish-Azerbaijani joint military exercises, which were initially scheduled for July 29-August 10, have in fact been extended. Tigran...
17:07
Twitter now lets users limit replies to their tweets
Twitter introduced a new feature that allows users to limit who can reply to their tweets, USA Today reported on Tuesday, citing a...
15:01
Trump says Americans will have to ‘learn Chinese’ if Biden wins
China would overtake the United States as the global superpower and force Americans to learn to speak Chinese if Joe Biden wins the election,...
14:53
Georgia reports 14 new COVID-19 cases
Georgia confirmed 14 new COVID-19 cases on Tuesday, bringing its total to 1,264, according to Xinhua. Two of the 14 new patients are...
14:46
Armenian PM’s assistant meets with angry protesters outside government building
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s assistant Nairi Sargsyan on Wednesday met with angry protesters in front of the government...
13:50
First batch of Russia's Covid-19 vaccine to be released in two weeks, health minister says
The first batch of the Russian vaccine against Covid-19 is expected to be released within two weeks, Health Minister Mikhail Murashko said on...
13:28
Armenia extends coronavirus state of emergency, removes some restrictions
The Armenian government extended the coronavirus state of emergency for another month at a special meeting on Wednesday. Presenting the...
12:49
Belarus post-election protests extend into third night
Hundreds of people took to the streets of Minsk and several other cities in Belarus on Tuesday evening, in a third straight night of protest...
12:28
Armenia reports 201 new COVID-19 cases on August 12
Armenia has confirmed 201 new coronavirus infections in a 24-hour period, bringing the national tally to 40,794 as of 11 a.m. Wednesday, August...
12:22
Around 100 Armenians return home from Lebanon
Nearly 100 Armenians have returned to their homeland from Lebanon by the three planes that delivered relief aid to Beirut after the massive...
11:53
Artsakh reports no new coronavirus cases for second day in a row
Artsakh has reported no new coronavirus infections on Wednesday for the second day in a row. The national virus tally stands at 251. A...
11:44
Quake hits near Turkish city, jolts felt in Armenia
A magnitude 4.3 earthquake struck near a city in eastern Turkey in the early hours of Wednesday. According to the European-Mediterranean...
11:17
Diaspora commissioner welcomes non-Armenian migrants to Armenia
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier On the top of all the other disputes among Armenians, a new controversy was added...
11:05
U.S. ban on TikTok could cut it off from app stores, advertisers – White House document
President Donald Trump’s executive order banning China’s TikTok could prevent U.S. app stores from offering the popular short-video...
19:13
Temperatures set to drop in Armenia by 4-5 degrees
Showers and thunderstorms are expected in separate regions of Armenia from August 11 to 16, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reports....
18:57
Beirut explosion death toll rises to 171
Lebanon's caretaker Health Minister Hamad Hassan announced on Tuesday that the death toll from the Beirut explosion has reached 171 while...
18:46
Treaty of Sevres has been and will remain a historical fact, Armenia tells Turkey
The Treaty of Sevres has been and will remain a historical fact, which cannot be edited or wiped away, Armenian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman...
18:14
Armenian government to hold special meeting on Wednesday
The Armenian government will hold an extraordinary meeting on Wednesday to discuss the extension of the coronavirus state of emergency....
17:55
Yerevan mayor takes two-week vacation
Yerevan Mayor Hayk Marutyan has taken a two-week vacation until August 25, his spokesperson Hakob Karapetyan wrote on Facebook. The mayor...
17:39
Turkey-Azerbaijan military drills not different from previous ones, says Armenian analyst
A preliminary analysis of the videos from the Turkey-Azerbaijan joint military exercises show that although they covered a large area, the...
17:19
EU relations with Belarus under review following election
The European Union’s relationship with Belarus is under review following the contested presidential election, the European Commission said...
17:01
Artsakh president hosts Armenian army chief
Artsakh President Arayik Harutyunyan on Tuesday received Chief of the General Staff of Armenian Armed Forces, Lieutenant-General Onik Gasparyan....
15:05
Court postpones hearing in case of Robert Kocharyan, three other former officials
The Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction, presided over by judge Anna Danibekyan, on Tuesday had to postpone another hearing in the case of...
14:41
WHO sees ‘green shoots of hope’ in coronavirus fight as global cases near 20 million
The World Health Organization said Monday there are glimmers of hope in the fight against the coronavirus, even as global cases from the virus...
14:28
Armenian FM highlights Francophonie family’s aid to Lebanon
Armenian Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan on Monday held a phone conversation with Secretary-General of the International Organisation of La...
13:58
Russia first to register coronavirus vaccine worldwide, Putin says
Russian President Vladimir Putin claimed Tuesday that Russia has developed the first coronavirus vaccine and said his daughter has taken it,...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}