Society 11:17 12/08/2020 Armenia

Diaspora commissioner welcomes non-Armenian migrants to Armenia

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

On the top of all the other disputes among Armenians, a new controversy was added last week by Zareh Sinanyan, the Armenian Republic’s High Commissioner for Diaspora Affairs.

A few days before Sinanyan’s visit to Lebanon over the weekend, accompanying a plane-load of humanitarian aid from Armenia, he spoke on a teleconference with a group of Armenian officials and others and made some unexpected statements. Here are excerpts from Sinanyan’s statement:

“…We should create such a reality in Armenia that not in the distant future we can think about not only the repatriation of Armenians, but also making Armenia the homeland of, how do I say this, for nationalities like us. I am talking about Christian Arabs, Assyrians, those nationalities that do not represent a national security danger to Armenia and can be easily integrated in Armenia. Because in such an intelligent, thoughtful and civilized manner, we can change the demographic situation in Armenia. We should not be embarrassed by that. That is a correct step. That will be a success. Imagine that we can make Armenia a country that is attractive also to non-Armenians….”

Sinanyan’s above statement created a major controversy in Armenian circles worldwide. The vast majority of Armenian comments on Facebook pages were highly critical, turning this issue, like many others, into a partisan political dispute.

I also watched another one of Sinanyan’s interviews with the Civilnet website prior to his visit to Lebanon. In that interview, Sinanyan again spoke about Christian Arabs, Assyrians and other nationalities immigrating to Armenia. However, this time, Sinanyan stated that the idea came from Shahan Kandaharian, the editor of Aztag newspaper in Lebanon, the official organ of the local Armenian Revolutionary Party (ARF). Sinanyan implied that the ARF supported this idea, repeating twice that Kandaharian is an ARF member. In fact, the ARF leaders have publicly announced that they prefer Lebanese Armenians not abandon the well-established community of that country. Naturally, no one can constrain any Lebanese Armenian from immigrating to Armenia, which is much more preferable than immigrating to other foreign lands. Kandaharian’s words were somewhat misconstrued by Sinanyan. In the video, Kandaharian was speaking about the immigration to Armenia of Lebanese who had Armenian roots, not Christian Arabs nor Assyrians. Sinanyan also alleged that those who criticized him on Facebook are ARF members and an "army of fakes." While there may be a few fakes, but it is clear that the overwhelming majority of the critics are Armenians who do not wish non-Armenians to immigrate to Armenia.

Nevertheless, there are several important issues that need to be raised:

First of all, the immigration of non-Armenians to Armenia is a very sensitive issue for most Armenians with serious national consequences which go far beyond Sinanyan’s authority and responsibilities. The genocide of 1915 which decimated 1.5 million Armenians makes all Armenians extra protective of the remnants of their people and the diminished homeland.

Furthermore, while Sinanyan is responsible for implementing the Armenian government’s policy of repatriating Diaspora Armenians, the immigration of non-Armenians to Armenia has nothing to do with the office of the High Commissioner of Diaspora Affairs.

The immigration of non-Armenians is a matter of governmental policy. Since independence, there has been a small number of non-Armenians who have settled in Armenia as businessmen or family members of Armenian citizens. There have been also some refugees who have asked for asylum in Armenia. Anyway, it is doubtful that a large number of non-Armenians would be interested in moving permanently to Armenia in the near future.

To be clear, we are not talking about the various minority nationalities that live in Armenia, such as Yezidis, Assyrians, Greeks and Russians. These minorities have been residing in Armenia for centuries. There is no question about their continued residence in Armenia.

In terms of changing the demographics of Armenia and increasing its population, the first thing the Armenian government has to do is to establish policies that would discourage the native population of Armenia from leaving the homeland. This would mean creating jobs and providing housing. After that, the Armenian government should try to attract Diaspora Armenians, particularly those in the near abroad, such as the recent emigrants to Russia, to return to Armenia. To do that, Armenia needs to facilitate their move to Armenia by having a simple procedure for their resettlement, and providing them housing and employment. Otherwise, the Russian Armenians either will not return to Armenia or will turn around and go back after a short stay. This is exactly what happened to Syrian-Armenians who moved to Armenia, fleeing from the civil war in Syria. Many of them left for Western Europe, Canada or the United States due to lack of jobs and housing in Armenia.

The priority right now for Sinanyan’s office is to attract Armenians from the Diaspora to move to Armenia. If by a miracle, a large number of Diaspora Armenians resettle in Armenia, only then the Armenian government can raise the issue of allowing a large number of other nationalities to immigrate to Armenia. There needs to be a major national consensus for allowing a large number of non-Armenians moving to Armenia. This is not a one man’s or one group’s decision.

Share |


An 18-year-old soldier managed to destroy 9 armored vehicles of the adversary - Arayik Harutyunyan
"There has been no considerable changes of the military positions, and the fighting continued in the same areas - in Omar and Mrav mountain...
Azerbaijan suffers 130 more casualties – Armenian MoD
Azerbaijan suffered 130 losses in manpower during heavy fighting on the Artsakh-Azerbaijan line of contact in the past 24 hours, Armenian...
Artsakh’s Martakert after Azerbaijani air strikes
Azerbaijan once again targeted civilian objects in the Artsakh town of Martakert on Wednesday. As reported earlier, three civilians –...
Alexis Ohanian: International community must stand together against dictatorships like Turkey, Azerbaijan
Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian urges the international community to stand together against dictatorships like Turkey and Azerbaijan....
Armenia refutes Azerbaijani reports of Tochka-U missile system use
The Defense Ministry of Armenia officially announces that the information actively disseminated by the Azerbaijani media that on Wednesday the...
Footage of Artsakh forces taking over Azerbaijani military post released
Armenian Defense Ministry spokeswoman Shushan Stepanyan has today posted a video on Facebook showing how the Artsakh army is capturing an...
Turkey takes over Azerbaijan’s air offensive operations against Artsakh, says Armenian infocenter
The Republic of Azerbaijan has handed over the air command of its offensive operations against the Artsakh Republic to the Turkish Air Force,...
Azerbaijani forces lose Smerch, Uragan rocket launchers, tanks – Artsakh MoD
During the day fighting has continued in all directions of the Artsakh-Azerbaijan line of contact, the Artsakh Ministry of Defense (MoD)...
Armenian women ready to head to frontline
Hundreds of Armenian women have volunteered for going to the Artsakh frontline to take part in the military operations, A total of 250 women...
Artsakh ombudsman strongly condemns deliberate targeting of civilians by Azerbaijan
On September 30, Artak Beglaryan, Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) of the Republic of Artsakh, was informed that 3 civilians, 2 women and a...
Ombudsman: International community must react immediately to reports on using mercenaries against Armenians
The international community and especially human rights organizations must react immediately to the reports on Turkey’s recruitment and...
Pashinyan briefs Rouhani on Turkey's involvement in hostilities
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan keeps holding telephone conversations with the leaders of foreign states and international...
Soldiers fighting in northeast of Artsakh crew has visited military positions located in the northeastern direction of the Artsakh-Azerbaijan line of contact. The website...
Azerbaijanis use mobile phones of Armenians acquired during hostilities to make calls, Artsakh NSS warns
The National Security Service (NSS) of the Republic of Artsakh warns that during the military hostilities unleashed by Azerbaijan against...
Artsakh Defense Army keeps repelling Azerbaijani attacks in all directions, president says
The Artsakh Defense Army continues confidently fulfilling its combat tasks, successfully repelling the attacks of the Azerbaijani military in...
Human Rights Watch: Attacks targeting civilians are serious violations of international humanitarian law
All armed forces fighting over Nagorno-Karabakh must at all times distinguish between combatants and civilians under international humanitarian...
Three more Artsakh civilians killed as Azerbaijan bombards Martakert town
Three more civilians have been killed in the Artsakh town of Martakert as a result of the Azerbaijani air attack, Artsakh presidential spokesman...
ECHR decides to apply interim measure against Azerbaijan based on Armenia’s request
With regard to the request of the Armenian government to apply interim measures under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, the European Court of Human...
Artsakh army has significant achievements in several directions – Defense Ministry
The Azerbaijani troops on Wednesday employed Turkish F-16 multifunctional aircrafts in the northeastern and then southern directions of the...
Photos of wreckage of the Armenian SU-25 downed by Turkish F-16 released
The Armenian Unified Infocenter shared the images of the SU-15 jet shot down by F-16 fighter jet of Turkey's army forces. The source...
Defense Army destroys Azeri TOS-1A heavy flamethrower system
"The subdivisions of the Artsakh Defense Army are carrying out punitive counter retaliatory actions in specific areas," Artsakh...
Macron criticizes Turkey's "warlike" rhetoric on Nagorno Karabakh
French President Emmanuel Macron said on Wednesday Turkey’s “warlike” rhetoric was encouraging Azerbaijan to reconquer...
Armenia demands immediate withdrawal of Turkish armed forces from Karabakh conflict zone
"Armenia strongly condemns Turkey’s provocative actions and demand the immediate withdrawal of the Turkish armed forces, including...
PM: Armenia considers recognizing Nagorno Karabakh
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said on Wednesday that his government is considering to formally recognize the Republic of Artsakh following the...
Number of COVID-19 cases tops 50,000 mark in Armenia on September 30
Armenia has confirmed 458 new cases of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) in a 24-hour period, bringing the national tally to 50,359 as of 11 a.m....
Artsakh Foreign Ministry: Turkey should be excluded from the OSCE Minsk Group
Turkey has long and actively been trying to use the Azerbaijan-Karabakh conflict to advance its destructive foreign policy agenda in the South...
Azerbaijan applies air-to-surface long-range missiles
The Azerbaijani Air Force conducted aerial bombing carried out with mixed battle order in the northern direction of the Artsakh Defense Army,...
Armenia has no intention to apply to CSTO for now - Pashinyan
Armenia has no intention to apply to the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) with regard to the situation occurred in Nagorno...
UN Security Council condemns the use of force in Karabakh
The UN Security Council on Tuesday called on Azerbaijani and Armenian forces to "immediately stop fighting" over the breakaway region...
Artsakh Defense Ministry: Azerbaijan continues suffering losses
The Defense Ministry of the Artsakh Republic has shared a new video, showing the losses of manpower of the Azerbaijani Armed Forces. The video...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}