Politics 10:13 21/04/2021 Armenia

Catholicosate of Cilicia refiles lawsuit against Turkey

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

In 2015 the Catholicosate of Cilicia (headquartered in Antelias, Lebanon) filed a lawsuit against the government of Turkey seeking the return of its historic seat in Sis, Turkey (present-day Kozan district of the Adana Province), which was confiscated in 1921.

The Catholicosate had initially filed its lawsuit directly with the Constitutional Court of Turkey because the claim raised issues of historical property rights that lower courts would not have jurisdiction over. At the urging of the Justice Ministry, the Constitutional Court referred the lawsuit to a lower court. The Catholicosate then appealed the ruling to the European Court of Human Rights in 2016. The European Court rejected the Catholicosate’s 900-page lawsuit in 2017, finding it inadmissible because it had not first exhausted all local legal remedies, such as the lower courts in Turkey.

Therefore, the Catholicosate refiled its lawsuit in 2019, this time with a lower Turkish court in Kozan (Sis). After two postponements due to the coronavirus pandemic, a pre-trial hearing finally took place on March 30, 2021 in the Kozan Civil Litigation Court to decide whether a viable cause of action existed to proceed to trial.

The Catholicosate’s lawsuit against the Municipality of Kozan and the Turkish government’s Treasury Department is being defended by a group of international law experts, as well as Turkish lawyer Jem Sofouoghlu and Turkish Armenian lawyer Setrag Davouthan, who is serving as a consultant.

The Istanbul-based Jamanak Armenian newspaper reported that according to attorney Sofouoghlu the March 30 hearing was intended to clarify the applicant’s qualifications and authorizations and the possibility of the expiration of the statute of limitations. The Municipality of Kozan and the Treasury Department presented their counter-evidence claiming that the applicant does not have standing -- is not a legal entity -- and is a foreign litigant.

The defendants also stated that, before the hearing could proceed, the applicant as a foreign entity must provide a letter of guarantee corresponding to 15% of the demand’s value, as required by the Turkish legal system. Sofouoghlu was quoted by Jamanak telling the Judge that the Catholicosate had already submitted the required documents to the court. The Judge agreed to go ahead and consider the substance of the lawsuit, meaning that the court rejected the objections raised by the Municipality and Treasury Department, and ruled that the lawsuit could definitively proceed. The next hearing is scheduled for May 6, 2021. Sofouoghlu said that he considers this a very positive development.

Now the trial will go through several presumable phases. Sofouoghlu anticipates that the court will first assemble the evidence presented by the Catholicosate of Cilicia. For this purpose, the corresponding work will be carried out through the official archives and property registers at governmental bodies. The investigative-exploratory phase then follows the collection of evidence. According to Sofouoghlu, the court, most probably later on, will reach the conclusion that it will be necessary to appoint an expert to carry out this task. Such experts are usually academics from one of the universities in the Adana region. Even though the courts always have the authority to carry out this work on their own, they prefer to appoint an expert.

At the end, should the Catholicosate’s lawsuit be rejected, as expected, by the lower Turkish Court, it will then be appealed to the Constitutional Court of Turkey and after its probable rejection there, a new, and this time proper, appeal could be filed in the European Court of Human Rights which hopefully will not dismiss it because of a technicality.

Even though this lawsuit is filed by the Catholicosate of Cilicia to recover its historic seat, it is in fact much more significant than this particular case. The lawsuit is related to the Armenian nation’s larger efforts to pursue its legal demands for the return of all properties and assets confiscated by the Turkish government during the Armenian Genocide of 1915-1923. As Catholicos Aram I has rightly pointed out: “This is the time that we move from the stage of [Genocide] recognition to reparation.” He told the New York Times in May 2015: “After 100 years, I thought it was time that we put the emphasis on reparation. … This is the first legal step. This will be followed by our claim to return all the churches, the monasteries, the church-related properties and, finally, the individual properties.”

Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


National Assembly dissolved after failing to elect a prime minister twice
Armenia's National Assembly failed on Monday to elect a prime minister in accordance with a political agreement for the second time. The...
Armenian acting FM, UN Secretary General discussed post-war situation in Nagorno-Karabakh
On May 10, acting Foreign Minister of Armenia Ara Aivazian held a phone conversation with the UN Secretary General António Guterres. As...
Court accepts UNM leader Melia’s release after EU posts bail
Tbilisi City Court has accepted the release of the head of the United National Movement Nika Melia after the European Union posted Melia’s...
10,727 citizens have been vaccinated in Armenia as of May 9
Since the launch of vaccination campaign till May 9, 10,727 citizens have been vaccinated in Armenia, the country's Ministry of Health...
Putin, Aliyev talked on phone
Russian President Vladimir Putin and his Azerbaijani counterpart, Ilham Aliyev, have confirmed a mutual disposition to building up cooperation...
Works of Alexander Spendiaryan and Yervand Yerkanyan to be performed in Yerevan
Within the 12th edition of the Armenian Composers' Art Festival, the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra will host a concert on  May 17...
Armenian swimmers to take part in the 2020 European Aquatics Championships
The  European Aquatics Championships will open today in Budapest. As the Armenian National Olympic Committee reported, the event will be...
Artur Danielyan: Propaganda aimed at 'disintegrating Syunik' will start soon in Armenia
The Founder of Adekvat Union Artur Danielyan writes on Facebook:  "The Saudi import to Turkey fell by 93.7% this year to compare with...
Erdogan calls Israel 'terror State' over clashes
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Saturday called Israel a "terror state " after Israeli police clashed with Palestinian...
Artur Vanetsyan: We have just four and a half years to reinforce our army
During one of his regional visits, former Director of Armenia’s National Security Service, Chairman of the Homeland Party Artur Vanetsyan...
MP Edmon Marukyan urges former authorities to withdraw from electoral processes
Opposition lawmaker Edmon Marukyan, the leader of the Bright Armenia Party, reiterated his call for Armenia’s former authorities to...
Car escorting Nikol Pashinyan involved in traffic crash in Yerevan
A major road traffic crash involving a car escorting Nikol Pashinyan occurred near the Foreign Ministry building in central Yerevan on Monday....
Poll shows 60% of Japanese want Tokyo Olympics cancelled
Nearly 60% of people in Japan want the Tokyo Olympics to be cancelled, an opinion poll showed on Monday, less than three months before the Games...
Pashinyan formally nominated as PM candidate for second time
The Armenian National Assembly on Monday kicked off a special session, with the issue of electing a new prime minister on the agenda. The...
Armenian military expert: We must voice our complaints to all international organizations ‘day and night’
Armenian military expert, Turkologist Karen Hovhannisyan calls for efforts to bring Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev to account for the war...
Martuni stadium shelled by Azerbaijani forces during Artsakh war reopens
Avagyan Arena stadium in the town of Martuni in Artsakh, which was shelled by the Azerbaijani armed forces during last year’s 44-day war,...
US government declares emergency after fuel pipeline cyber-attack
The US government declared a regional emergency Sunday as the largest fuel pipeline system in the United States remained largely shut down, two...
Armenia reports 83 fresh coronavirus cases on May 10
Armenia has confirmed 83 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 219,353 as of 11 a.m. Monday, May 10, the Ministry...
UN Security Council to discuss situation in East Jerusalem on Monday
The United Nations Security Council will on Monday privately discuss rising tensions in East Jerusalem around al Aqsa, Islam's third-holiest...
Past.am: Around 33,000 people took part in Sunday’s rally at Yerevan square
Armenia’s second President Robert Kocharyan, the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF, Dashnaktsutyun) and Reviving Armenia parties,...
Public TV hardly covers Armenian ombudsman’s statements, Tatoyan reaffirms
Armenia’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan reaffirmed his position on Public TV Company that the TV station hardly covers...
Basketball legend Michael Jordan's North Carolina jersey sells for record £1m
A game-worn jersey belonging to Michael Jordan from his second season at the University of North Carolina sold for a record $1.38m (£1m)...
Roadway leading to Lake Kari difficult to pass
Armenia’s Ministry of Emergency Situations provided updates on road conditions on Monday morning. In particular, the roadway leading...
Air temperature to drop by 5-7 degrees on May 10-11
No precipitation is predicted in the territory of Armenia in the daytime of May 8, on 11-12, at night of 13, Hydromet meteorological service...
The construction of 30 block-modular camps for Russian peacekeepers completed in Nagorno-Karabakh
The specialists of the Russian Ministry of Defense have completed the construction of 30 block-modular camps for servicemen of the peacekeeping...
Putin sends Victory Day greetings to CIS leaders, people of Ukraine and Georgia
Russian President Vladimir Putin has sent Victory Day greetings to the leaders of Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) countries, Abkhazia...
Prices of essential goods increase in Armenia
The prices for food and non-alcoholic beverage prose 8.3% in April 2021 to compare with April last year and by 2.6% against March of the ongoing...
Pope Francis backs Biden call to waive Covid vaccine patents
Pope Francis on Saturday came out in favor of a waiver on intellectual property rights for coronavirus vaccines, echoing comments made by the US...
US Paratroopers make large-scale drop in Estonia as part of joint drills
Over 700 US paratroopers participated in a large-scale overnight jump over central Estonia as part of the joint Swift Response exercise, the...
Armenia’s consumer market sees 6.2% inflation in 12 months
In April 2021, 6.2% inflation was registered in Armenia’s consumer market to compare with April of the past year, while 1.3% inflation is...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}