Law 09:15 29/11/2013

Sexual abuse in US Army: erasing extensive powers of military officers the only way to ensure justice - US Attorney

One of the more controversial issues concerning this year’s national defense authorization act concerns an amendment introduced by New York Democratic Senator Kirsten Gillibrand called the Military Justice Improvement Act. While the amendment would affect how many crimes are prosecuted it was conceived mostly as a way of dealing with the recent epidemic of sexual assaults in the military. To find out more about this issue, the Voice of Russia spoke to Susan Burke, an Attorney who has represented victims of sexual assault in the military and she is a major proponent of Gillibrand’s amendment. In her interview Burke said that the issue at the center of all this is the broad powers military commanding officers enjoy over the military criminal justice system, and that erasing those powers are the only way to ensure justice for violent crimes, including sexual assault.

- Can you tell us what the Military Justice Improvement Act, which is Kirsten Gillibrand’s amendment, is?

- Certainly. Right now we have 2 Federal systems that operate in the courts in our country, one is the regular federal courts that most folks are familiar with, and then in addition we have a whole other separate judicial system that is operated by the military, for the military. And that is governed by what is called the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Now what that current code allows is that it allows for people who are not lawyers, who are not trained in evidence collection or in court proceedings, it allows the chain of command to be making decisions as to whether or not a reported crime will be investigated and prosecuted.

So, what Senator Gillibrand bill does is making a very logical and much overdue change to that and it simply says for the investigation and prosecution of crimes the military judicial system once take the lead, will be in charge of that. Civil lawyers and the prosecutors and the investigators will be making the judgment calls as to whether a report of rape should be investigated and prosecuted rather than these untrained chain of command people.

- To make it clear, this amendment would affect a lot of different kinds of violent crime, not just sexual assault, right?

- That is correct, it would apply to essentially all felonies, anything where there is potential jail time over 1 year.

- But it was designed specifically to deal with sexual assault. Does the same problem exist for murder or assault or anything like that?

- The same problem does exist for all crimes and the reason is that in all instances when the chain command is involved, they are not impartial, it rather they have their own career that are intertwined with their decision making and they also know, both the victims and the perpetrators for all crimes. What this does is says “wait a minute, we as Americans know that the best justice is blind justice, impartial justice and we are going to make sure that the service members, the men and women who are willing to put their lives on the line to protect us don’t have some kind of second class justice but they have the same blind impartial justice that the rest of us enjoy.”

- You’ve been very involved in the fight to bring justice to victims of military sexual assault, there is a documentary called the invisible war which you are featured in. Can you tell us about your work and how you got involved in this?

- I was first contacted few years ago by a woman who had been raped by a soldier that she knew. It was actually a friend of her husband. Her husband was also a soldier. And so she contacted me and told me what had happened, where it had gone to court-martial but the prosecution had lost the evidence and there was one mishap after the other. So, based on that initial really contact out of the blue from someone I began to study the issue and I began to talk with people who had not obtained justice and they were very upset with the way that no one was obtaining justice. So, I began to network, spread the word that I would be willing to help these folks and we filed a series of law suits in Federal civilian court saying “this is so poorly handled that you are actually violating these people’s constitutional rights.”

- How have these lawsuits worked out?

- Right now all of them, the Federal judges that have heard them, although they have expressed their concern about the way that the military is handling things, they done what is called abstention, they have abstained from exercising jurisdiction based on Supreme Court case. So, essentially the case has not been heard.

- And what has to happen in order for your case to be heard?

- I think there is two different possibilities, one is that Federal Judge will decide to hear it, because abstention is really a prudential doctrine, it is in the judge’s discretion. So, we are going to continue to keep filing them and maybe judge does decide that the facts here are so egregious that they are not going to defer to the military. Obviously the second and what we hope more likely outcome is that Senator Gillibrand bill gets through and the structural problems are eliminated and the military judicial system begins to function more effectively. As a practical matter, right now although the military itself estimates that they have 26.000 rapes and sexual assaults per year, they only manage to convict and incarcerate a couple hundred people. So, you’ve got a very low conviction rate and that is why we are seeing all these problems because they are just not doing a good job of prosecuting and convicting folks.

- Even the rate of reports is very low. It is something like 90% don’t get reported, is that correct?

- It is correct. If you think about it, it is very logical. If a judicial system doesn’t function well and it is corrupted because the people who are holding the power have their own interests at play, what happens over time if you don’t trust that system, you don’t report and if you look around the globe, in fact if you look at the state department human rights report, they tend to look at judicial systems around the globe and say this country has one that is not impartial, it is corrupted by people knowing each other, and what happens there is if you don’t trust the judicial system, you don’t report crimes. So, that is why this is really a critical national issue, we need to make sure that there is an impartial judicial system that is trusted so that service members who are crime victims are comfortable reporting.

- There is a lot of pushback to Gillibrand amendment and to the idea of taking commanders out of the military judicial system, and one of those is that the commanders will be held accountable if they are responsible of how the system works and if it works independently of them, then the accountability is a problem. What is your reaction to that?

- It is not true because if they were going to be held accountable for how the system failed to work, they would already be held accountable. It’s been broken for several decades now.


Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


440 patients in severe, 50 - in critical condition - coronavirus updates from the minister of health
Health Minister Arsen Torosyan says his predictions according to which the coronavirus case in Armenia will reach 10,000 came true. The...
8923 beneficiaries received a total of 1.7 billion drams within the government 18th anti-crisis measure
Within the 18th measure aimed at easing the economic impacts of the coronavirus, 12 227 taxpayers have been considered as the program’s...
Artsakh President received newly-appointed Secretary of the Security Council Samvel Babayan
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan received today the newly-appointed secretary of the Artsakh Republic Security Council Samvel...
50 letters, 50 smiles. Children of Kotayk and Tavush children's villages will receive tablets
Children are one of the most vulnerable groups in society and demand daily attention, love and protection, especially in these difficult times...
FIDE Top 100 players feature five Armenian grandmasters
Armenian grandmaster Levon Aronian maintained the seventh spot on the latest World Chess Federation (FIDE) ratings, the National Olympic...
Armenian Armed Forces only respond to provocations by the adversary - defense ministry
A footage and reports circulated online suggest the Armed Forces of Armenia have destroyed an Azerbaijani military equipment in Nakhijevan...
19 violinists to participate in the 16th Khachaturian International Competition
19 violinists have overcome the pre-selection auditions and will take part in the 16th Khachaturian International Competition. As...
Artsakh president tests negative for coronavirus
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan has tested negative for the novel coronavirus based on the results of a PCR test, Head of the...
Armenian woman beats coronavirus after 44 days in intensive care
A 47-year-old Armenian woman with coronavirus has recovered and discharged from St. Gregory the Illuminator Medical Center in Yerevan after 44...
Iran says coronavirus cases jump nearly 3,000 in a day, a 2-month high
Iran on Monday announced almost 3,000 new coronavirus infections, its highest daily count in two months, as it warned of another "dangerous...
Why is number of daily coronavirus tests dropping in Armenia?
The number of daily coronavirus tests has recently dropped in Armenia. According to the official data, 1,124 tests were performed on May 26,...
Notre Dame forecourt reopens to public after long cleanup delayed by coronavirus
Notre Dame Cathedral's forecourt opened up to the public for the first time since the devastating fire of April 15 last year, Euronews...
Mikhail Mishustin extends birthday greetings to Nikol Pashinyan
Russian Premier Mikhail Mishustin has extended birthday greetings to Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.  “Dear Nikol...
Armenian MP: Response to Azerbaijan’s aggression to be more than adequate and strong
Azerbaijani Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov has made a threatening statement in which he, in fact, acknowledged that the 2016 April War has been...
Artsakh president appoints new ministers
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan signed a range of decrees to appoint new ministers on Monday, June 1. In particular, Levon...
Today is International Children's Day
The World Conference for the Well-being of Children in Geneva, Switzerland, proclaimed June 1 to be International Children's Day in 1925. It...
No mass coronavirus testing of Armenian government members planned, says PM’s spox
No mass coronavirus testing of the Armenian government members and the prime minister’s staff is planned, PM Nikol Pashinyan's...
Russia reports 9,035 new coronavirus infections
Russia has confirmed 9,035 new COVID-19 cases in the past 24 hours, raising its total to 414,878, its coronavirus response center said in a...
75% of Armenians dissatisfied with government’s coronavirus response, survey shows
Some 75% of Armenians are dissatisfied with the government’s coronavirus containment measures, a new online survey shows. The survey...
Putin sends birthday greetings to Pashinyan
Russian President Vladimir Putin has sent birthday greetings to Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan. The congratulatory message, published...
Armenia’s coronavirus tally climbs to 9,492 on June 1
Armenia has confirmed 210 new coronavirus infections, bringing the national tally to 9,492 as of 11 a.m. Monday, June 1, the Ministry of Health...
Outrage as Israeli police kill autistic Palestinian man
Israeli police in Jerusalem shot and killed an autistic Palestinian who they mistakenly thought was armed with a gun, provoking furious...
Artsakh reports three new coronavirus cases
Artsakh has reported three new cases of COVID-19 on Monday, bringing the national tally to 43. The infected people are Artsakh citizens who...
Former Armenian Cadaster Committee head’s mother dies from coronavirus
The mother of Sarhat Petrosyan, the former head of Armenia’s State Committee of Real Estate Cadaster, has died from the coronavirus...
NYC mayor's daughter arrested at Manhattan protest
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio’s daughter was arrested at a Manhattan protest on Saturday night, law enforcement sources told...
Armenian PM, family members test positive for coronavirus
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his family members have tested positive for COVID-19, the PM said in a Facebook live on Monday....
Poll: Biden widens lead over Trump to 10 points
Former U.S. Vice President Joe Biden, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee, has built a double-digit lead over President Trump in his...
Elijah’s fast to begin on Monday
The Armenian Church will celebrate the Feast of Pentecost on Monday, June 1. The Feast of Pentecost is the commemoration of the descent of the...
Defense ministry spokesperson reacts to Azerbaijani minister’s threats
“Azerbaijani Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov held a consultation today and came up with new threats, admitting, in fact, that the initiator...
Puppet theatre organizes an open-air performance in Yerevan
The Yerevan State Puppet theatre is organizing an amusing concert-performance on June 1 to mark the International Day for Protection of...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}