Law 12:25 05/04/2019 Armenia

Sevak Torosyan: "There is no guarantee that Robert Kocharyan's trial will be conducted in accordance with the principles of a fair trial"

Sevak Torosyan, French advocate for political and financial international criminal cases, joins the team of advocates in the case of Robert Kocharyan, the Second President of the Republic of Armenia. The court session will take place during the upcoming weeks.

-Why have you agreed to defend ex-president Robert Kocharyan who is being accused of "overthrowing of the constitutional order"?

-I was born and have grown up in a country that has 200 years of history of post-revolutionary status. The situation with Robert Kocharyan worries me. All revolutions take place through the same procedure: the stage of euphoria of the society is followed by the stage of cleaning. The revolution always needs an accused for the remission of sins, who bears the punishment for 30 years of tension, injustice and hatred. It is not accidental that one of the Presidents having acted since the independence has been chosen; it is necessary that the person is unique, exceptional to fully bear the responsibility for the consequences of the tension. I have rarely witnessed such atmosphere of hostility during criminal procedure. I realise very well that the events of March 1 are reasons for pain for the whole Armenian nation. Its emotional impact is very big. This may lead to uncertainty between emotional and legal approaches. The procedure will start soon. The President's case will be examined by a judge sitting alone, without collegial examination and without special jurisdiction such as examination by the supreme judicial instance of the Republic. And this all in the atmosphere of unusual hostility. The executive authorities do not cease publicly presenting their position with regard to a judicial case not having completed yet. This is unbelievable. In previous July, the members of the executive body ordered the examining judge to detain the ex-president "irrespective of his will". There is no guarantee, even in case of meeting all the conditions, that the Kocharyan's case will be examined in accordance with a fair trial.

-What importance does the examination of this case have?

-The examination of this case regards Robert Kocharyan to the extent it is a testing of fair trial in Armenia. It is the most important judicial case for independent Armenia. The pressure of a judge sitting alone is huge. Dozens of European institutions will discuss the course, arguments and evidence of the procedure. It will be a great testing of fair trial which will reflect the real democracy of the country or will classify it among virtual democracies. In case of a fair trial, the result may disappoint people some time later. But the justice prevails. Soon, historians will collect the archives, speeches, the positions of both parties, the charges, cases of fraud. Politicians will present their comments, and this will be the legacy left by us. The mentioned has taken place several times in the Western countries. Unfair judges and political leaders are considered to be traitors in history.

-Is Robert Kocharyan subject to criminal liability in your opinion?

-If the President of the Republic of Armenia is subject to criminal liability, then the leaders of all states in the world may be deprived of their liberty. For several months, the movement of the Yellow Jackets has invaded the streets of Paris and the large cities of France. They have all been repeating during months "Macron, leave!". The damages suffered as a result of their actions reach the amount of EUR 300 million. We are not able to walk through Champs-Élysées on Saturdays, where concrete barricades have been installed along the avenue. What should President Macron do? Thousands of Police forces are being mobilised. There are continuously injured people. At present, negotiations are being held around the engagement of troops. How long can the country survive in this situation? How long can a country like Armenia survive in this situation? I have read the charges against President Kocharyan. From the legal point of view, I do not accept the arguments submitted within the scope of the content of Article 300.1 of the Criminal Code and the charges. Frankly speaking, I have never understood the meaning of the term "overthrowing of the constitutional order". Every crime must be defined clearly. Let's be honest, this is a crime of not a criminal but concealed political nature. Crimes of political nature have been prohibited in Europe since 19th century. They are still up-to-date in some African dictatorships. The danger of such uncertain concept is that if it is applied by the court, it will later be a ground for deprivation of liberty of the political opposition, journalists or ordinary citizens acting against the authorities.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

19:07
Azerbaijani Armed Forces attempting offensive operations in uniforms of Armenian forces, Artsakh Ombudsman says
The Human Rights Defender of Artsakh Artak Beglaryan reports that number of credible reports have been received, indicating that the Azerbaijani...
18:58
Azerbaijan has lost 6,614 soldiers since September 27 - Defense Army
Since the last update the new losses of Azerbaijan are: 11 UAVs, 2 TOS, 12 armored vehicles, 75 casualties, the Armenian Unified Infocenter...
18:23
Armenians block a major interstate highway connecting France with Spain
Armenians have blocked on Saturday  an interstate highway connecting France with Spain. The protesters demand Spain to Recognize Artsakh as...
17:53
Video: Defense Army destroys Azeri TOS-1A heavy flamethrower system
The Artsakh Defense Army has destroyed TOS-1 heavy flamethrower system of the Azerbaijani forces. The video of the destruction has been shared...
17:48
Defense minister visited wounded soldiers
The Minister of Defense of Armenia visited Saturday the soldiers who sustained wounds during the successful operation of the Defense army on...
17:47
More than 15 militants killed and injured in a missile strike in Syria
More than 15 militants from the Turkish-controlled Syrian armed opposition were killed and injured in a missile strike by an unknown military...
16:13
Wedding ceremony in Shushi Cathedral is a message to the entire civilized world - Arayik Harutyunyan
"Along with the war, life in Artsakh continues," Artsakh President Arayik Harutyunyan wrote on Facebook, sharing photos from the...
15:51
An Azerbaijani soldier captured by Defense Army successfully operated on - Armenian MoD
An Azerbaijani soldier who was captured on Friday as a result of successful operation of the Defense Army in southern direction of the front was...
15:16
Wedding ceremony held at Ghazanchetsots Cathedral of Shushi
A wedding ceremony has taken place at the Ghazanchetsots (Holy Savior) Cathedral in the Artsakh town of Shushi on Saturday amid Azerbaijani...
14:51
Armenian ombudsman formally labels Azerbaijan’s execution of two POWs as ‘undeniable war crime’
Armenia's Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan has formally labelled Azerbaijan's execution of two Armenian prisoners of war...
14:40
Photos show aftermath of latest Azerbaijani attack on Artsakh capital
The Artsakh State Service of Emergency Situations on Saturday released photos showing the aftermath of the Azerbaijani bombardment of...
14:22
Turkey reportedly sends 1,200 mountain commando forces to Azerbaijan to fight against Artsakh
Turkey has sent 1,200 mountain special forces to Azerbaijan to fight against Armenians in Artsakh, WarGonzo’s founder Semon Pegov said in...
13:52
Armenian FM: Azerbaijan should bear appropriate international responsibility for crimes against Artsakh people
Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan of Armenia on Friday held a phone conversation with the head of the Swiss Federal Department of Foreign...
13:43
40 Armenian civilians killed in Azerbaijani attacks: infographics
The Armenian Unified Infocenter has today provided updates on civilian casualties and losses of the Armenian side as a result of Azerbaijani...
13:18
Armenia’s Mnatsaknayan holds online meeting with Nancy Pelosi
In the framework of the working visit to the United States, Foreign Minister of Armenia Zohrab Mnatsaknayan on Friday held an online meeting...
13:10
Canadian-Armenians hold protest, call for recognition of Artsakh’s independence
Armenians in Canada are holding protests in different parts of the country against the ongoing Turkey-backed Azerbaijani aggression aganst...
12:56
Azerbaijani POW: I knew almost none of my squad members
An Azerbaijani prisoner of war (POW) captured by the Artsakh military said that most of the soldiers in his squad were not Azerbaijanis. In...
12:20
Sossi Tatikyan to UN: What happened to your objectives?
Independent Armenian consultant for public, foreign and security policy and administration, Sossi Tatikyan, has expressed strong dissatisfaction...
11:59
New footage shows destruction of Azerbaijan’s manpower, fortifications
The Artsakh Defense Army on Friday released a new video showing the destruction of the Azerbaijani manpower and fortifications.
11:50
Alexis Ohanian: What’s happening in Artsakh is a tragedy
“What’s happening in Artsakh is a tragedy. Without a real ceasefire, a lot of suffering will continue,” Reddit co-founder...
11:41
Armenia reports 2,213 new coronavirus cases on October 24
Armenia has confirmed 2,213 new cases of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) in a 24-hour period, bringing the national tally to 75,523 as of 11...
11:30
Armenian FM: Nearly 90,000 people displaced, lost property in Artsakh amid Azeri aggression
Around 90,000 people have been displaced in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) as a result of the Azerbaijani military aggression, Armenian Foreign...
10:59
Polish President Andrzej Duda tests positive for coronavirus
Polish President Andrzej Duda has tested positive for coronavirus but is feeling good, Reuters reported on Saturday, citing presidential...
10:30
Adam Schiff formally calls for U.S. recognition of Republic of Artsakh
Congressman Adam Schiff on Friday formally called on the United States to recognize the Republic of Artsakh. “For more than a month,...
10:18
Local battles underway in all directions of frontline, Artsakh military says
The situation in the Artsakh-Azerbaijan conflict zone was relatively stable, but tense overnight. Artillery battles and firefights continued in...
10:06
Armenian foreign minister meets with US national security advisor
Within the framework of the working visit to the United States, Foreign Minister of Armenia Zohrab Mnatsakanyan on Friday met with US National...
21:43
Defense Army eliminated a large formation of Azerbaijani special forces
"A large formation of Azerbaijani special forces was eliminated as a result of a successfully executed Armenian operation in the southern...
21:35
Trump says 'a really good progress is being made' in Nagorno-Karabakh talks
US President Donald Trump insists that 'a really good progress is being made' in the talks around ceasing military actions in Nagorno...
21:17
Parliament of Catalonia condemns the Azerbaijani-Turkish aggression against Artsakh
Parliament of Catalonia adopted a statement condemning Azerbaijani-Turkish attack against the Republic of Artsakh, the Artsakh Foreign Ministry...
20:26
FM Mnatsakanyan held meeting with US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo
Meeting of Foreign Minister of Armenia Zohrab Mnatsakanyan and US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo was held, Spokeswoman at the Foreign Ministry...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}