Law 12:25 05/04/2019 Armenia

Sevak Torosyan: "There is no guarantee that Robert Kocharyan's trial will be conducted in accordance with the principles of a fair trial"

Sevak Torosyan, French advocate for political and financial international criminal cases, joins the team of advocates in the case of Robert Kocharyan, the Second President of the Republic of Armenia. The court session will take place during the upcoming weeks.

-Why have you agreed to defend ex-president Robert Kocharyan who is being accused of "overthrowing of the constitutional order"?

-I was born and have grown up in a country that has 200 years of history of post-revolutionary status. The situation with Robert Kocharyan worries me. All revolutions take place through the same procedure: the stage of euphoria of the society is followed by the stage of cleaning. The revolution always needs an accused for the remission of sins, who bears the punishment for 30 years of tension, injustice and hatred. It is not accidental that one of the Presidents having acted since the independence has been chosen; it is necessary that the person is unique, exceptional to fully bear the responsibility for the consequences of the tension. I have rarely witnessed such atmosphere of hostility during criminal procedure. I realise very well that the events of March 1 are reasons for pain for the whole Armenian nation. Its emotional impact is very big. This may lead to uncertainty between emotional and legal approaches. The procedure will start soon. The President's case will be examined by a judge sitting alone, without collegial examination and without special jurisdiction such as examination by the supreme judicial instance of the Republic. And this all in the atmosphere of unusual hostility. The executive authorities do not cease publicly presenting their position with regard to a judicial case not having completed yet. This is unbelievable. In previous July, the members of the executive body ordered the examining judge to detain the ex-president "irrespective of his will". There is no guarantee, even in case of meeting all the conditions, that the Kocharyan's case will be examined in accordance with a fair trial.

-What importance does the examination of this case have?

-The examination of this case regards Robert Kocharyan to the extent it is a testing of fair trial in Armenia. It is the most important judicial case for independent Armenia. The pressure of a judge sitting alone is huge. Dozens of European institutions will discuss the course, arguments and evidence of the procedure. It will be a great testing of fair trial which will reflect the real democracy of the country or will classify it among virtual democracies. In case of a fair trial, the result may disappoint people some time later. But the justice prevails. Soon, historians will collect the archives, speeches, the positions of both parties, the charges, cases of fraud. Politicians will present their comments, and this will be the legacy left by us. The mentioned has taken place several times in the Western countries. Unfair judges and political leaders are considered to be traitors in history.

-Is Robert Kocharyan subject to criminal liability in your opinion?

-If the President of the Republic of Armenia is subject to criminal liability, then the leaders of all states in the world may be deprived of their liberty. For several months, the movement of the Yellow Jackets has invaded the streets of Paris and the large cities of France. They have all been repeating during months "Macron, leave!". The damages suffered as a result of their actions reach the amount of EUR 300 million. We are not able to walk through Champs-Élysées on Saturdays, where concrete barricades have been installed along the avenue. What should President Macron do? Thousands of Police forces are being mobilised. There are continuously injured people. At present, negotiations are being held around the engagement of troops. How long can the country survive in this situation? How long can a country like Armenia survive in this situation? I have read the charges against President Kocharyan. From the legal point of view, I do not accept the arguments submitted within the scope of the content of Article 300.1 of the Criminal Code and the charges. Frankly speaking, I have never understood the meaning of the term "overthrowing of the constitutional order". Every crime must be defined clearly. Let's be honest, this is a crime of not a criminal but concealed political nature. Crimes of political nature have been prohibited in Europe since 19th century. They are still up-to-date in some African dictatorships. The danger of such uncertain concept is that if it is applied by the court, it will later be a ground for deprivation of liberty of the political opposition, journalists or ordinary citizens acting against the authorities.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

00:32
CEC summing up preliminary results of the snap parliamentary elections
The Central Electoral Commission (CEC) of Armenia is summing up the preliminary results of the parliamentary elections. The results are updated...
22:41
CSTO observers released final conclusion about Armenian parliamentary elections
"The snap parliamentary elections in Armenia were held in accordance with the legislation of the Republic," the mission of observers...
22:21
Parliamentary elections in Armenia: the ballot count is underway
The vote count is underway in the polling stations of Armenia after the elections ended at 20.00. Panorama.am photographer has captured photos...
22:20
Turnout in Armenia’s snap elections stands at 49.4%
The voter turnout in Sunday’s snap parliamentary elections in Armenia stood at 49.4%, at the end of voting, according to updated data...
21:36
Armenia’s police received 87 calls to its hotline as of 8:30pm
As of 8:30pm, Armenia’s police received 87 calls to its hotline, the police said in a statement, adding no reports were received from CIS...
20:52
From hero to traitor: Armenia’s Pashinyan fighting for political survival – France 24
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan was celebrated as a national hero when he swept to power in a peaceful revolution in 2018, but now he is...
20:38
Polls close in Armenian snap elections
Voting in Armenia’s snap parliamentary elections ended at 8pm, followed by the vote court. As of 5pm, the voter turnout stood at...
20:19
Armenian authorities are in ‘agony’, says ARF’s Ishkhan Saghatelyan
One of the ARF leaders, Ishkhan Saghatelyan, an Armenia bloc candidate, said he has voted for a strong, secure, stable, prosperous and...
19:49
Artur Vanetsyan: Justice always wins
Homeland Party leader Artur Vanetsyan, the candidate for prime minister of the I’m Honored bloc, has praised the release of the bloc's...
19:26
Unlawful actions against opposition will give no result, Aram Vardevanyan says
The official representative of "Armenia" pre-election bloc Aram Vardevanyan has issued a statement. "Since early morning we...
18:45
Voter turnout exceeds 40% in Yerevan, Syunik, Vayots Dzor and Tavush as of 5pm
The voter turnout in the ongoing snap parliamentary elections in Armenia stood at 38.17% as of 5pm Sunday, according to updated data released by...
18:23
Actions by the authorities aimed at disrupting the opposition activity on the voting day - Davit Harutyunyan
Number of employees of "I'm Honored" pre-election bloc offices were arrested on Friday, including Gor Sedrakyan, a candidate for...
17:25
Investigative Committee prepared 15 materials on apparent electoral crimes as of 15:00
As of 15:00 of the voting day of the snap parliamentary elections 15 materials on apparent hindrance to implementation of the right to elect...
17:12
No one may influence the decision of Goris residents - Arush Arushanyan
Member of "Armenia" bloc, the head of Goris community in southern Syunik province Arush Arushanyan has voted for a just and strong...
16:47
Sovereign Armenia Party candidate Narine Martirosyan wrongfully detained
Narine Martirosyan, a candidate of MP from the Sovereign Armenia Party, was wrongfully detained as she left the 6/31 polling station in Yerevan...
16:22
Ter-Petrosyan refuses to answer reporters’ questions after casting ballot in snap elections
The fingerprint scanner recognized the fingerprint of first Armenian President Levon Ter-Petrosyan, the leader of the Armenian National Congress...
15:59
Voter turnout in Armenia’s snap elections stands at 26.82% as of 2pm, CEC says
The voter turnout in the ongoing snap parliamentary elections in Armenia stood at 26.82% as of 2pm Sunday, according to updated data released by...
15:42
Rights of Armenians of Artsakh have not yet been restored – Armenian Foreign Ministry
The Armenian Foreign Ministry issued a statement on the World Refugee Day marked on June 20. The full text of the statement is provided below....
15:26
Catholicos Karekin II casts ballot in snap elections
His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians, on Sunday cast his ballot in the snap parliamentary elections in...
14:58
OSCE chief to meet with Lavrov, other high-level officials in Moscow
OSCE Secretary General Helga Maria Schmid will visit Moscow for meetings with the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation Sergey...
14:51
Serzh Sargsyan says he voted for a strong Armenian army, inviolability of country's borders
Third President of Armenia Serzh Sargsyan, who leads the Republican Party of Armenia (RPA), highlighted the need to unite the divided Armenian...
14:05
In Armenia, a bitter election in the shadow of a lost war – Euronews
Polling stations in Armenia have opened on Sunday morning for early elections called by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, and against the backdrop...
13:49
Civil Contract will suffer a crushing defeat in Syunik – Vahe Hakobyan
Chairman of the Reviving Armenia Party Vahe Hakobyan, a candidate of MP from the Armenia bloc, cast his vote at the 4/53 polling station in...
13:46
The Committee for the Control of Elections reports over 100 irregularities at parliamentary elections
The Committee for the Control of Elections announced that  more than 100 reports of voting irregularities have been received as of 12։00am....
13:09
We vote for the national solidarity - Edmon Marukyan
The leader of "Bright Armenia" party Edmon Marukyan cast his vote at 1/20 polling station. "We are voting for unity, for...
12:53
Turnout in early parliamentary polls in Armenia stands at 12.2% as of 11am— CEC
The voter turnout at June 20 snap parliamentary elections in Armenia is 12.2%, the deputy chairman of Armenia’s Central Electoral...
12:27
1,996 polling stations opened across the republic, 12 will open later - CEC representative
1,996 polling stations opened across Armenia  on June 20 for the snap parliamentary elections, the member of Central Electoral Commission...
12:19
Armenia reports 60 fresh COVID-19 cases on June 20
Armenia has confirmed 60 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 224,227 as of 11 a.m. Sunday, June 20, the...
12:15
Artur Vanetsyan: I vote for a safe Armenia, for Artsakh and Armenia's future
"I am casting my vote for decent, civil and safe Armenia, for our large motherland, for Artsakh and Armenia's future," the...
11:46
Yerevan Court granted lawyers' petition to release Professor Armen Charchyan
The Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction has granted the petition filed by Professor Armen Charchyan's lawyers about the legality of...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}