Politics 11:27 05/06/2019 Region

Azerbaijan may be expelled from Council of Europe for violating court ruling

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

All members of the European Council had agreed to comply with judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). However, Azerbaijan has violated that commitment ever since 2014, according to the unanimous ruling of ECHR’s Grand Chamber of 17 judges, including the judge representing Azerbaijan, on May 29, 2019.

The case involves Azerbaijan’s imprisonment of political activist Ilgar Mammadov who was charged with criminal offenses and placed “in pre-trial detention in 2013 without there being any reasonable suspicion that he had committed an offense. [The European] Court considered the circumstances indicated the actual purpose of those measures was to silence or punish Mammadov for criticizing the Government [of Azerbaijan],” according to a press release by ECHR.

ECHR “found in particular that the Government [of Azerbaijan] had taken only limited steps to implement the judgment, which had not amounted to Azerbaijan acting in ‘good faith’ or in a manner which was in accordance with the ‘conclusions and spirit’ of its ruling in Mammadov’s case. It concluded that Azerbaijan had failed to fulfill its obligation under the Convention to abide by the judgment,” according to ECHR’s press release.

On December 5, 2017, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe, which is responsible for supervising the enforcement of the ECHR’s judgments, referred Azerbaijan’s violation back to European Court to determine whether that country had failed to abide by its 2014 judgment by not releasing Mammadov unconditionally.

After ECHR’s Grand Chamber ruled on May 29, 2019 that Azerbaijan had indeed violated its 2014 judgment, ECHR referred the case back to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe for consideration of further measures to be taken.

The Committee of Ministers stressed that there were fundamental flaws in the criminal proceedings against Mammadov and “called many times for Azerbaijan to release Mammadov as an essential step towards redressing the violations the [European] Court had found. However, he remained in detention for almost four years after the ECHR’s judgment had become final on 13 October 2014, until his conditional release on 13 August 2018, following the initiation of the infringement proceedings. In March 2019 [Azerbaijan’s] Supreme Court, after reducing his sentence, found he had served his time in full and set aside the probation order and other conditions on his release,” according to ECHR’s Grand Chamber.

Here is the background of Mammadov’s case as described by ECHR’s press release: He was born in 1970 and lives in Baku. He is a political blogger and activist who had also announced his intention to run as president of Azerbaijan in 2013. He was placed in pre-trial detention in February 2013 after writing on his blog about disturbances in Ismayilli. Mammadov said, among other things, that people there had been reacting to the “corruption and insolence” of public officials. He was subsequently charged with organizing or actively participating in actions causing a breach of public order, and later he was accused of stirring mass disorder and resistance to or violence against public officials, posing a threat to their life or health.

Mammadov applied to ECHR on February 25, 2013, alleging that he had been arrested and detained without a “reasonable suspicion” of a criminal offence; that his right to be presumed innocent had been breached; and that he had been prosecuted for his political views and the threat he had presented to the regime as a potential presidential candidate. In March 2014, Azerbaijan’s court convicted and sentenced him to seven years in prison.

In the Grand Chamber’s judgment of May 22, 2014 (the first Mammadov judgment) ECHR found violations of his right to liberty and security, right to judicial review of detention, presumption of innocence, and limitation on use of restrictions on rights. The ECHR also ordered the government of Azerbaijan to pay him 20,000 euros in compensation.

The Committee of Ministers first examined the case in December 2014. It took numerous decisions and interim resolutions, highlighting the State’s obligation under the Convention to adopt individual measures to put an end to any violations that had been established and to erase their consequences so as to put Mammadov in the position he would have been in if his rights had not been violated.

In October 2017, the Committee put Azerbaijan on formal notice that, in its view, it had failed to fulfill its obligation under the Convention, the first step in an infringement procedure. The Committee of Ministers in December 2017 also referred a question to ECHR on Azerbaijan’s fulfillment of its obligation.

Mammadov was freed on probation in August 2018. In March 2019, Azerbaijan’s Supreme Court reduced his sentence, found he had served his time in full and set aside the conditions on his release. In November 2017, ECHR found that Mammadov’s trial on the same criminal charges as those criticized in its 2014 judgment had also violated his rights (the second Mammadov judgment).

If Azerbaijan continues not to comply with ECHR’s judgments, it may eventually be expelled from the Council of Europe.

Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Tomorrow is the Eve of the Fast of the Holy Cross of Varague
Tomorrow is the Sunday preceding the week prior to the feast of the Appearance of the Holy Cross on the Mount Varague, lasting from Monday to...
Air temperature to go down by 8-10 degrees in the coming days
Rain with thunderstorm is predicted on September 22 in separate regions of Armenia, Hydromet meteorological center at the ministry of emergency...
Over 120 ceasefire violations reported at Artsakh borderline during the past week
The Azerbaijani armed forces violated the ceasefire along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan Line of Contact over 95 times in the past week, the...
Famous opera singer Anna Kasian, State Symphony Orchestra to perform joint concert in Yerevan
Famous  Armenia opera singer, soprano Anna Kasyan will perform in Yerevan, at Aram Khachatryan Concert Hall on September 23 accompanied by...
“Hero of Our Times” award ceremony held in Gyumri’s Black Fortress
Award ceremony entitled “Hero of Our Times” was held on Saturday in Gyumri Black Fortress as part of Armenia’s 28th...
PM congratulates Maltese counterpart on National holiday
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has sent a congratulatory message to Prime Minister Joseph Muscat of Malta on the country’s Independence...
Davit Babayan: Azerbaijani saboteurs’ return to Baku may have serious consequences
On July 17, 2014, 17-year-old Smbat Tsakalyan was buried in a cemetery at one of Karvachar villages next to his grandfather. Tsakalyan had been...
Ukraine boycotts upcoming PACE session
A Ukrainian parliamentary delegation to PACE will not attend the upcoming session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE),...
Putin, Trump send greetings on Armenia’s Independence Day
Russian President Vladimir Putin has sent greetings to President of Armenia Armen Sarkissian and the country’s Prime Minister Nikol...
“Yeva” drama receives special award at Venice film festival sidelines
Armenian-Iranian drama “Yeva” received a special award of  the International Art and Public Activity Biennale in the sidelines...
UN chief stresses negative impact of climate change on world peace
UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Friday highlighted the negative impact of climate change on world peace. At a ceremony to mark World...
Military parade underway in Berd border town
A festive event and military parade started at Berd dedicated to the 28th anniversary of Armenia’s Independence. A snippets from the event...
Gyumri hosting main celebrations of Independence Day
The main celebrations of the 28th anniversary of Armenia’s Independence is taking place in the country’s second largest city,...
Over 200 flights cancelled in Japan over Typhoon
Japanese airlines cancelled 204 flights in the southern and southwestern parts of the country over the approaching typhoon of Tapah, ...
Tbilisi billboards display messages with the theme of Armenia’s Independence
On the 28th anniversary of Armenia’s Independence, billboards across Georgia’s capital Tbilisi display messages on Intendance day...
Armenia’s highest leadership visited the Yerablur Pantheon
On the 28th anniversary of the Independence of the Republic of Armenia, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan joined President of the Republic of...
Armenia marks the 28th anniversary of Independence
The Republic of Armenia marks the 28th anniversary of Independence on September 21. The Declaration of Independence was adopted by the...
Aronian draws in the first game of quarterfinals at World Cup 2019
Armenian grandmaster Levon Aronian played draw on Friday with a Vietnamese chess player Lê Quang Liêm  in the first game of the...
Ara Guler photo exhibition to open in Japan
A selection of photos taken by legendary Turkish-Armenian photographer Ara Guler, who passed away last October, will be on display in New York...
Media reports: Russia considers termination of the railway operation contract in Armenia
Russia’s South Caucasus Railways company which is the rail operator of Armenia is considering  plans to terminate the contract with...
Dubai's Burj Khalifa to light up with Armenian flag on Independence Day
The President of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) Khalifa bin Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan, Vice President of UAE and ruler of the Emirate of Dubai...
Yerevan court rejects motion to release Robert Kocharyan on bail
The Yerevan court of general instance rejected on Friday the motion brought  by second President Robert Kocharyan’s defense team to...
all.me digital platform becomes WCIT 2019 Special Partner
The innovative digital platform all.me will join the ranks of official partners for the World Congress on Information Technology 2019, which...
Armenia’s U-17 football team loses friendly to Cyprus
An international friendly match between the U-17 national teams of Cyprus and Armenia took place at Amochostos stadium in Larnaca on September...
Armenian parliament adopts VAT debit return bill
The Armenian National Assembly passed in the first reading on Friday a government-drafted bill on making amendments and addenda to the...
Superstar French cellist Gautier Capuçon to perform in Armenia
Superstar French cellist Gautier Capuçon will perform a concert in Armenia on the sidelines of the 20th jubilee edition of the Yerevan...
Kocharyan’s lawyers appeal arrest ruling
The defense team of Armenia’s second President Robert Kocharyan has appealed the ruling of the Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction of...
Environmental lawyer insists fight against Amulsar mine operation aims to help government
Environmental lawyer Nazeli Vardanyan insists all the permits for the operation of the Amulsar gold mine have been issued in a gross violation...
Iran's Zarif questions U.S. coalition for 'peaceful resolution' in Middle East
Iran’s foreign minister on Friday questioned U.S. plans for a coalition for a “peaceful resolution” in the Middle East while...
Defense minister: Exchange of Armenian captives with Azerbaijani saboteurs not ruled out
Armenian Defense Minister David Tonoyan on Friday did not rule out the possible exchange of Armenian captives with Azerbaijani saboteurs. In...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}