Society 10:58 15/06/2019 Armenia

Mikael Minasyan: The time to come out of trenches

Mikael Minasyan, Armenia's former ambassador to the Holy See of Vatican and the Republic of Malta, has published an article in 168.am.

Panorama.am presents the full text of the article below

Armenian women can curse, and they are really good at it. This discovery was perhaps the biggest surprise on social media this past year, and this refers to very real Armenian women living in Armenia and abroad. Of course, it’s the level of mutual intolerance that a shock delivers any public discourse impossible.

Clearly, this is a global phenomenon that did not occur overnight but has gradually gained momentum. In 2015, the Pew Institute conducted a survey to find out if people can write a public comment, if that comment might offend another group of people. Some 35% of those surveyed said they could. In other words, one out of three people believe it is normal to post something on a social media, knowing for sure it might offend someone. Taking into consideration the polarizing policy in the world and Armenia, it is no accident that the numbers of such people and the degree of aggression in comments have hiked since 2015.

On the one hand, a divided, polarized and hostile society is extremely predictable. On the other hand, it is extremely vulnerable. Societies have become internally hostile, clashed and weakened before suffering defeat from an external enemy. This has many precedents in history, starting from the Roman Empire and leading up to our days.

To understand the societies you are dealing with explore its urban legends. In this sense, Armenia operates on medieval morals:

- The purpose of the struggle between the government and the opposition is to eliminate each other politically and morally. If you don’t curse at or eliminate your opponent, you are neither a real government nor a real opposition.

- The foreign relations discourse does not go beyond unfeasable dreams or unrealistic notions, and the person who proposes an idea about advancing Armenia’s interests immediately becomes pro-Russian, a pro-Western or pro- something else.

- In regard to the Artsakh issue, Azerbaijan borders Artsakh, but we Armenians have dug the trenches among ourselves. Those trenches enclose the political parties of peace and war, patriots and traitors, patriots and bigger patriots, traitors and bigger traitors, as well as people who are ready to make concessions and concessions-over-my-dead-body attitudes.

The society is polarized, and the public evaluations are at extremes:

- In Armenia, people are either heroes or criminals.
- In Armenia, the government is either always right or always wrong.
- In Armenia, the opposition is either in prison or a cheap puppet.
- In Armenia, a beloved artist is either posthumous or lives abroad.
- In Armenia, a businessman is either a benefactor or an oligarch.

As for oligarchs, we Armenians declare our wealthy compatriots abroad as heroes, but refer to the local manufacturers and businessmen in Armenia as internal enemies or “nation’s leaches”. Instead of seeking more effective mechanisms for social justice, we proclaim that nobody should live well until everyone lives well.  It’s like the well-known joke when the widow of a participant of the October Revolution asks the Bolsheviks what the people are fighting for, the Bolsheviks say people are fighting to make sure there are no wealthy people. After that, the widow says her husband was fighting to make sure there are no poor people.

Examples are plenty and destructivism continues. It sure is one way to live —by hating, dividing, labeling and discrediting. After all, you can eliminate, align, remove, empty and desert everyone, but what happens after that? Does that make us happier? Based on the happiness index, it doesn’t! Armenia has always been in the list of the unhappy, holding the 116th place out of 157 countries in recent years.

They say the memory of mankind is fortunately limited. It must be true; otherwise the erosive and useless debates about the past, as well as hindsight stand-offs would be more far-reaching. Groping along the post-independence years we keep opposing one decade to another, one leader to another, clashing teams, destroying achievements gained by predecessors, and we do it with a very special cruelty and thoroughness.

What is, after all, the purpose? What is the purpose of the cursing on social media, feeding social frustrations, cleansing and judging, revolutions and reforms, governments and oppositions? What is all this for and what will happen? What will be the consequence of removing, splitting, labeling and discrediting? Does it improve people’s lives or will it?  If so, then everything is right. But clearly there are no paths leading these actions to those results, are they? However, people want to see their dreams come true. People want to live a good life, as they always did. People aspire for welfare and look up to a leader who can take them there. Do the recent or ongoing events serve the purpose of creative the good life or is it simply an end in itself?

We can go on and on. This way we are building a punitive and aggressive society in which everyone lives and works to get to a point when it’s their turn to punish and be punished. In fact, the society of the future has to be encouraging, multiplying a good model, accomplishing a good initiative, and developing good thinking. There is simply no other path to live the good life and live prosperously. It is impossible to keep a war of hating, humiliating and eliminating each other with rotating success and still claim the good life. World experience shows that only societies capable of reaching an agreement on how they can create a good future will have the opportunity to live the good life. The right to live the good life can only be gained in an environment of realizing common interest, solidarity, mutual trust and partnership.

We have a collective choice to make — to live in solidarity or fight and eliminate everyone and everything, or move forward by fixing the mistakes. Today we have all we need — the same mistakes that several generations have made along with the consequences. We have the chance to not make those mistakes again and the opportunity to avoid making new ones. We have citizens who are ready and a generation that is able. All we need to do is to stop, take a deep breath, draw a line and start from scratch, and this is possible.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:10
High Commissioner for Diaspora Affairs meets with members of Russian-Armenian Dialogue NGO
High Commissioner for Diaspora Affairs of Armenia Zareh Sinanyan who is paying a working trip to Russia, met on Saturday with representatives...
16:07
Azerbaijan fires over 900 shots in Artsakh direction last week
The Azerbaijani armed forces violated the ceasefire along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan Line of Contact over 95 times in the past week, the...
15:40
Trump says he's trying to bring rapper A$AP Rocky home
Urged on by the first lady and celebrities including Kanye West and Kim Kardashian West, President Donald Trump said Friday he is trying to help...
13:59
Zohrab Mnatsakanyan, Luis Almagro held talks in Washington
Armenian Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan who is on a working trip to Washington held on Friday meeting with the Secretary General of the...
13:55
Fires hit the area of medieval Ani ruins in Turkey
A strong fire broke in the territory of Ani ruins, medieval Armenian city in the territory of modern Turkey, that rapidly spread by gusts of...
12:51
France revises June temperature record up to 46 degrees
An area in southern France in June recorded the country's first ever 46 degree temperature, the French state weather service said on Friday,...
12:27
Today marks the 90th anniversary of renowned Armenian painter Minas
Today marks the 90th anniversary of the great of Minas Avetisyan, a renowned Armenian painter of the 20th century. Born in 1928 in...
11:30
Zelensky replaces Ukrainian Ambassador in Armenia
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has dismissed 11 ambassadors of Ukraine, including I Armenia. As Ukrinform news agency reports , the...
10:46
Michelle Obama beats out Angelina Jolie as most admired woman, poll says
Michelle Obama is now the most admired woman in the world, beating out former title holder Angelina Jolie, USA Today reported. According to...
18:39
Robert Hovhannisyan - the winner of Villa de Benasque tournament
Armenian Grandmaster Robert Hovhannisyan has won a major international chess tournament in Spain. As the Chess Federation reports, the Armenian...
17:37
Pyunik seal place in Europa League second qualifying round
Europa League first qualifying round second leg match between North Macedonian side FK Shkupi and FC Pyunik took place in Skopje on July 18. As...
17:03
The blast in Sisian was from an explosive device – Investigative Committee
The blast in one of the houses in Armenia’s Sisian town came from an explosive device, Armenia’s Investigative Committee reported....
16:34
Satik Seyranyan: The clashes in Ijevan revealed how frightened the authorities are
The recent clashes between the law enforcement and citizens in Ijevan revealed how frightened the authorities of Armenia are, Satik Seyranyan,...
15:52
Supreme Judicial Council elects new chairman
Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council, an oversight body tasked with monitoring the judiciary, elected on Friday its next chairman. As the...
15:28
One killed in an explosion in Southern Sisian town of Armenia
Armenia’s ministry of emergency situation said ina statement that an explosion rocked in Kamo Street in Armenia’s southern Sisian...
14:03
Rostransnadzor to conduct inspection after the incident in Sheremetyevo
Russian federal authority for transport oversight Rostransnadzor will conduct an unscheduled audit of the airline Nordwind after the incident...
12:58
Air temperature to reach +42°C in some parts of Armenia
The air temperature will reach +40+42°C in capital Yerevan, Ararat and Armavir provinces on July 21-23 due to hot tropical cyclone...
12:27
“Cilicia: The Land of Lions”: The grand premiere will take place in Armenia in the near future
The private premiere screening of a mood reel trilogy “Cilicia: The Land of Lions,” depicting the glorious history of the...
11:23
American warship destroys Iranian drone in Strait of Hormuz
A U.S. warship on Thursday destroyed an Iranian drone in the Strait of Hormuz after it threatened the ship, President Donald Trump said,...
11:23
Constitutional Court turns to Venice Commission, ECHR for opinion over ex-President Kocharyan case
The Constitutional Court of Armenia suspended the proceedings against the former President of the country Robert Kocharyan and turned to Venice...
10:15
A Yerevan-bound flight aborts takeoff at Moscow airport over cockpit smoke
A Boeing 737 plane belonging to Russia's Nordwind Airlines cancelled its takeoff from Moscow's Sheremetyevo International Airport after...
19:00
Turkey says Pentagon decision may ‘irreparably damage relations’ with US
Turkey is calling on the US to correct its mistake of removing the country from the F-35 fighter jet program, "which will irreparably...
18:38
“See you soon, Armenia!” - Nuno Gomes farewell message from Yerevan airport
Former Portugal player Nuno Gomes who was visiting Armenia for the U19 Euro championship, posted a farewell message on Instagram, summing up his...
18:22
15 migrants die in vehicle crash in Van
At least 15 people died and more than 20 were injured on Thursday when a vehicle carrying irregular migrants crashed in eastern Turkey, a local...
18:10
NSS chief arrives in Ijevan following clashes between law enforcement and residents
The Chief of Armenia’s National Security Service Artur Vanetsyan has arrived in Ijevan following the clashes on Wednesday evening between...
17:20
Suspect in Dink murder trial sentenced to 99 years in prison
Erhan Tuncel, one of the main suspects standing trial for allegedly playing a role in the 2007 murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink,...
16:15
13 citizens arrested over clashes with law enforcement in Ijevan
Armenia’s Investigative Committee has launched criminal investigation over the clashes between citizens and law enforcement in...
15:16
'You had the Nobel Prize?' Trump learns of Yazidi activist Murad
US President Donald Trump on Wednesday appeared unfamiliar with the work and cause of Nobel laureate Nadia Murad as she pleaded with him to help...
14:49
Mkhitaryan thanks Los Angeles fans for warm welcome at the first pre-season match
Asenal’s pre-season continued with an encouraging 2-1 victory over German champions Bayern Munich in Los Angeles. A late Eddie Nketiah...
14:14
Swiss responsAbility launches USD 175 m blended finance impact securitization transaction partnered with Ameriabank
Swiss responsAbility Investments AG, the international impact asset manager is launching a USD 175 m securitization of loans to SME-finance...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}