Education 18:30 21/08/2019 Armenia

U.S. Armenians sue Turkey to visit their native land without a passport

A unique lawsuit, not based on the Armenian Genocide, was filed on May 29, 2019, by two Armenian-Americans against the Turkish government in the United States Federal Court, Central District of California.

The lawsuit was filed on behalf of Barkev Ghazarian, 88, and his son Garo Ghazarian claiming “statutory elder abuse, intentional affliction of emotional distress, violation of international law, breach of fiduciary duty, and intentional interference with expectation of inheritance,” according to a 44-page complaint filed by the law firm of Kerkonian Dajani LLC.

Plaintiff Barkev Ghazarian is a United States citizen born in Kaladouran, Turkey, on April 20, 1931. He currently resides in Glendale, California. His son, Garo, born in Beirut, Lebanon, is also a United States citizen who lives in Glendale.

The complaint alleges that the Plaintiffs suffered personal injury caused by tortuous acts or omissions of the Turkish government’s employees or agents in the United States.

In the 1930’s Kaladouran was a small Armenian village in the outskirts of Kessab, present day Syria. Barkev Ghazarian was baptized as an Armenian Christian “at a sacred ceremonial site in Ballum, Turkey, in 1931,” according to the lawsuit. Ballum or Barlum is the ancient site of Greco-Roman ruins, located at a short distance from Kaladouran. For centuries local Armenians, including Barkev’s family, went on pilgrimages to Ballum to perform their religious and cultural rites.

In 1939, Kaladouran was divided between Syria and Turkey, leaving Barkev’s home on the Syrian side, while his family’s fields and lands remained on the Turkish side. Since Ballum was also left under Turkish control, the Armenians of Kaladouran could no longer practice their rituals in that locality.

On October 11, 2017, Barkev decided to go to Turkey to visit Ballum. He submitted his visa application to the Turkish Embassy in Washington, D.C., indicating that his expected entry date would be December 23, 2017. In the visa application, under the category of “Type of passport,” he checked the box for “Other,” and under “please specify,” he wrote, Armenian Christian. Barkev also indicated that he was born in Kaladouran, Turkey, and was seeking entry “for religious pilgrimage” purposes. He intended “to pass native religious and cultural traditions to his son, Plaintiff Garo, and progeny,” according to the lawsuit.

Coincidentally, on October 8, 2017, Turkey suspended issuing visas to U.S. citizens in retaliation to a similar ban by the United States to Turkish citizens until December 28, 2017. Barkev did not possess a U.S. passport, but even if he did, Turkey would have refused to issue him an entry visa under the ban. The Turkish Embassy received Barkev’s visa application 71 days prior to his arrival in Turkey, whereas the Embassy required that such applications be submitted at least 30 days prior to his expected date of departure. Having received no response from the Turkish Embassy, Barkev sent a reminder on December 6, 2017, inquiring about the status of his visa application.

On December 11, 2017, an employee of the Turkish Embassy called the office of Barkev’s son Garo, indicating that the Embassy did not know what type of visa Barkev was requesting, even though it was clearly marked “short stay” on the visa application. In response, Barkev sent an email to the Embassy on December 18, 2017. Then on December 21, 2017, he sent a reminder to the Embassy by overnight mail. On December 22, 2017, on the same day that Barkev was supposed to fly to Turkey, the Embassy’s Consular Section sent an email to Barkev instructing him to reapply to the Turkish Consulate in Los Angeles with a passport. The complaint filed by Barkev’s attorneys stated that Turkey’s representatives “harassed, agitated, confused and thwarted Barkev, intending to devalue his identity as an Armenian Christian born in Turkey.”

The lawsuit also quoted Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of the Republic of Turkey in 1923, proclaiming: “Armenians have no rights at all in this prosperous country. The land is yours, the land belongs to the Turks. In history this land was Turkish, therefore it is Turkish and will remain Turkish forever. The land has finally been returned to its rightful owners. The Armenians and the others have no rights here at all. These blessed regions are the native lands of the true Turks.”

The lawsuit further stated that “by such proclamations, and then through a series of legislative, executive, administrative, and other official and/or unofficial acts, Defendant established the Targeted Policy at the very founding of the Republic of Turkey. The core purpose of the Targeted Policy was to strip native Armenian Christians of their rights and identities by dehumanizing, degrading, expropriating, alienating, disenfranchising, liquidating and otherwise severing Armenian Christians from their native lands and their native customs and religious practices on such lands. This Targeted Policy has been pursued, institutionalized, enhanced and adhered to by Defendant’s successive governments and agents.”

The lawsuit accused Turkey and its agents of violating the following international agreements by their mistreatment of Barkev:
— The United Nations Declaration of Human Rights;
— The United Nations Principles for Older Persons;
— The Treaty of Lausanne;
— The European Convention on Human Rights;
— International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights;
— Vienna International Plan of Action on Ageing;
— The Madrid International Plan on Ageing;
— United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

Unfortunately, Barkev’s health has deteriorated since his planned visit to Turkey in 2017 to the extent that he is no longer able to travel. This was the last chance Barkev had to visit his native land and practice his religious rites as a Christian Armenian. The Turkish government deprived Barkev of that opportunity by not granting him permission to enter Turkey.

On June 10, 2019, the U.S. Federal Court asked the Plaintiffs to show cause, in writing no later than June 28, 2019, as to why the case should not be dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. As requested by the Court, the Plaintiffs filed a 25-page memorandum on June 28, 2019, explaining that Turkey, as a foreign Sovereign, does not have the right to violate U.S. and international humanitarian laws, particularly on American soil.

On July 11, 2019, the Federal Court decided that it would “defer a determination about its jurisdiction until after Turkey has been served and had an opportunity to provide its views on the issue.”
This lawsuit provides a unique opportunity to affirm the rights of Armenians to visit without a passport their native lands now occupied by the Turkish government!

By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier 

Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


School subjects ‘The History of Armenian Church’ and ‘The History of Armenians’ unique for forming national identity, academician says
‘The History of Armenian Church” and “The History of Armenians” should be taught separately at public schools since they...
Armenia’s bread production on the decline
Bread production volumes kept dropping in Armenia over the past few months, according to the latest figures released by the National Statistical...
Turkish authorities proved their xenophobic attitude - Artsakh president
“Turkish authorities proved once again their denialist and xenophobic attitude toward civilizations through their latest decision on...
Artsakh reports more than 150 Azerbaijani ceasefire violations in the past week
Azerbaijani military breached the ceasefire along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan Line of Contact around 150 times in the past week, the Artsakh Defense...
5 dead in hostage situation at troubled South Africa church
Five people are dead and more than 40 have been arrested after an early-morning hostage situation at a long-troubled church near Johannesburg,...
The term of emergency situation in Artsakh prolonged till August 12
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan signed on Saturday a decree according to which the term of the emergency situation declared in the...
MES issues cyclone warning in the territory of Armenia
Intense rains with thunderstorms is expected in the territory of Armenia in On July 10-13 conditioned by cyclone penetration from the Black Sea....
Discussion on current trends in NK peace process held at Homeland party office
A discussion in the current trends of the Nagorno Karabakh (NK) conflict settlement was held on Saturday at the central office of Homeland...
Greece condemns Turkey's decision to convert Hagia Sophia into mosque
Greece condemned a decision by Turkey on Friday to convert Istanbul’s Hagia Sophia museum into a mosque, saying it would have...
Dr. Fauci: Coronavirus vaccine could be ready by 'end of the year'
The United States will know by the end of the year or the beginning of 2021 whether a coronavirus vaccine is safe and effective, Dr. Anthony...
Artsakh Defense Army refutes Azerbaijani reports about the ‘death’ of a soldier
The Nagorno-Karabakh Defense Army refuted on Saturday the report of Azerbaijani news portal, claiming that an Artsakh soldier had been...
Yvonne Chiu: WITSA is very proud to have bestowed upon Karen its highest and most prestigious award
The President of the World Information Technology & Services Alliance (WITSA) Yvonne Chiu has expressed condolences over the death of Karen...
Garo Paylan. The decision of turning Hagia Sophia into a mosque will make life difficult for Christians
Istanbul-Armenian MP Garo Paylan, representing the pro-Kurdish Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP), has reacted to the Turkish authorities...
16 people die from coronavirus in past 24 hours in Armenia - Coronavirus update on July 11
Armenia has confirmed 489 new coronavirus infections in a 24-hour period, bringing the national tally to 31,391 as of 11 a.m. Saturday, July 11,...
Candle lighting ceremony in memory of Karen Vardanyan to take place in Yerevan
A candle lighting ceremony will take place on Saturday in memory of CEO of the Union of Advanced Technology Enterprises (UATE) Karen Vardanyan....
Armenian church commemorates Christ’s twelve Apostles and thirteenth Apostle - St. Paul
The Armenian Apostolic Church marks on June 30 the commemoration of Christ’s twelve Apostles and thirteenth Apostle - St. Paul. As...
UNESCO 'deeply regrets' Turkey's conversion of Hagia Sophia into mosque
The UN's cultural agency UNESCO said it deeply regretted Turkey's decision to turn the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul from a museum into a...
Requiem mass in memory of Karen Vardanyan to take place on July 12
The requiem mass in memory of CEO of the Union of Advanced Technology Enterprises (UATE) Karen Vardanyan will take place on July 12 at 17:30 at...
Pashinyan: We position ourselves as supporters of the dialogue of civilizations in international relations
The Security Council of Armenia held a regular meeting on Friday in Yerevan, chaired by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan. As the government press...
Germany to send a medical team to Armenia
Emergency medical team of the International Search and Rescue Germany (ISAR) will send a medical team to Armenia to assist in the fight against...
Turkish court rules to revert the world-famous Hagia Sophia into a mosque
A top Turkish court on Friday struck down the 1934 Cabinet decree that turned Istanbul's Hagia Sophia into a museum, paving the way for its...
Artsakh president receives former defense minister of Armenia
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan received on Friday Artsakh and Armenian former Defense Minister Seyran Ohanyan. As the...
Fruit, vegetable prices up in Armenia
Prices for food and non-alcoholic beverages increased by 0.2% in Armenia in June from the same period of the previous month and 3.5% from May of...
UNESCO warns Turkey against Hagia Sophia mosque conversion
The UN's cultural agency UNESCO warned Turkey Friday against converting the Byzantine-era Hagia Sophia museum in Istanbul into a mosque,...
Robert Kocharyan held videoconference with supporters
Armenia’s former President Robert Kocharyan held on Thursday a videoconference with around 70 supporters from Armenia, Artsakh, Germany,...
University entrant confirmed with COVID-19 in Georgia
A university entrant, who was taking the united national examinations, has been confirmed with COVID-19, Georgian First Channel reported....
WHO advance team on way to China to set up probe into virus origin
An advance team from the World Health Organization (WHO) has left for China to organise an investigation into the origins of the novel...
Caucasus Nature Fund provides new grant to Armenia
Armenia’s Deputy Prime Minister Tigran Avinyan and Executive Director of the Caucasus Nature Fund George Giacomini have remotely...
Syrian-Armenian Bundestag employee attacked by Islamists in Berlin
Syrian-Armenian Kevork Almassian, an employee of Bundestag, was attacked by two Islamists in Berlin on 6 July, barely surviving the murder...
Explosion reported in west Tehran, denied by official
An explosion was heard in western Tehran on Friday, state broadcaster IRIB said, citing online reports that a senior official in that part of...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}