Law 10:56 09/10/2019 Armenia

Jerusalem Armenian Patriarchate’s lawsuit advances through Turkish courts

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

While the lawsuit filed by the Catholicosate of Cilicia based in Antelias, Lebanon, for the recovery of its former headquarters in Sis, Turkey, has received wide publicity, another just as important lawsuit against Turkey, is hardly known by the Armenian and international community.

This relatively unknown lawsuit was filed by the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem seven years ago. During the last few years, the only news published by an Armenian newspaper in Istanbul has been about the various visits of Jerusalem Patriarch Nourhan Manougian to Turkey regarding claims filed for the Patriarchate’s properties in that country. There have been no announcements by the Jerusalem Patriarchate and no interviews published in any Armenian media on this important lawsuit.

The first major news was published by the Turkish newspaper Hurriyet on October 2, 2019 regarding the Jerusalem Patriarchate’s lawsuit in Turkey. Hurriyet reported that the Constitutional Court (the highest court in Turkey) ruled on September 12, 2019 that the lower Turkish court had violated the rights of the Armenian Patriarchate by denying proper access to the court to pursue its lawsuit (Article 36 of the Constitution). The Constitutional Court stated that the lower court had not sufficiently investigated the claims of the Armenian lawsuit.

The Armenian Apostolic See of St. James in Jerusalem had filed a lawsuit in an Ankara court on August 26, 2016, seeking the recovery of its properties in Turkey. The Turkish documents refer to the St. James Congregation of the Jerusalem Patriarchate as Mar Yakoub which is the Turkish translation of Saint James or Sourp Hagop. The two different names had caused confusion in the court as to the true identity of the ownership of these properties.

The Constitutional Court sent the lawsuit back to the Ankara court demanding that the lower court review the matter by conducting further investigations. If the lower court reconsiders its earlier rejection, it would open the door for the pursuit of the lawsuit through the Turkish court system.

I had the honor of speaking by telephone with Patriarch Nourhan Manougian last week regarding the status of the lawsuit. To my knowledge, this was the first interview that his Eminence has granted to a member of the media on this subject. He informed me that the Armenian Patriarchate in Jerusalem owned around 1,200 properties in Istanbul alone. The Patriarchate also owned dozens of other properties throughout Turkey which were confiscated by the government during the period of the Armenian Genocide in 1915. Patriarch Manougian mentioned that a very large and valuable property owned by the Jerusalem Patriarchate in Yalova, Turkey, was sold by a Turkish-Armenian in the 1950’s to a Turk and then fled to the United States. The Patriarch said he is interested in filing a lawsuit against the heirs of that Turkish-Armenian.

On August 7, 1973 the Turkish General Directorate of Foundations initially included the Jerusalem properties on its list. When the decision was made to exclude these properties from the General Directorate of Foundations, the Jerusalem Patriarchate filed a lawsuit on July, 19, 2012. However, the Turkish court dismissed the lawsuit. Even though the Patriarchate won the appeal, the court rejected the decision!

The Constitutional Court stated that at this point there was no need to examine the right of ownership of the properties claimed by the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem.

The Constitutional Court further ruled that “before the documents and records, particularly the administrative examinations of the legal matter are presented to the court, it should have been possible to clarify if there was a second Foundation or not. Without clarifying all these issues and without realizing all these necessary examinations, the rejection of the lawsuit has caused a great inconvenience to the applicant [the Patriarchate], and the interference in its right to apply to the court has been disproportionate. With this rejection, the 36th Article of the Constitutional Court is violated -- defending one’s rights through trial.”

This is a critical lawsuit not only for the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem but also for the entire Armenian nation. The sheer number of the 1,200 properties demanded by the lawsuit makes it highly valuable, particularly given their location in Istanbul, the most prominent Turkish city.

While it is too early to speculate about the final outcome of this lawsuit, it is probable that should the Patriarchate regain the possession of some, if not all, of the 1,200 properties, the Turkish government may not allow the sale of these properties and the taking of the income out of Turkey, permitting only the use of the properties or their lease to others. The generated income could then be used to support the Armenian schools and churches in Turkey.

However, should the lower court and the Constitutional Court rule against the Armenian Patriarchate, it can then file a lawsuit in the European Court of Human Rights.

The Catholicosate of Cilicia is in the process of following the same scheme, after its lawsuit with the European Court of Human Rights was rejected because it had gone directly to the Constitutional Court of Turkey, sidestepping the lower Turkish court. The Catholicosate is now refiling its lawsuit with the lower court in Turkey.

The decision of the Turkish courts on these two lawsuits, followed by the European Court of Human Rights, if necessary, will reshape the agenda of the legal pursuit of the Armenian demands from Turkey, beyond its simple recognition of the Armenian Genocide.

Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Armenian, Russian FMs discuss coronavirus pandemic over phone
At the initiative of the Armenian side, Foreign Minister of Armenia Zohrab Mnatsakanyan had a telephone conversation with his Russian...
US to block Iran's $5 billion virus loan request
The US plans to block Iran's requested $5 billion emergency loan from the International Monetary Fund for funding Tehran says it needs to...
Two new coronavirus cases registered in Ararat province
According to the latest update by Ararat Governor Garik Sargsyan, two new cases of novel coronavirus have been recorded in Ararat province,...
Disinfection activities were implemented in 527 public places
On April 6 and 7, departments of the Rescue Service implemented disinfection preventive activities in ten provinces of Armenia and in Yerevan...
Commandant says all state resources mobilized to make possible and impossible to secure the health of citizens
The state system makes utmost efforts in its work combating the spread of the pandemic. With full mobilization we are making all possible and...
Oil holds near $32 ahead of OPEC-led talks on output cuts
Oil steadied near $32 a barrel on Wednesday, supported by hopes that a meeting between OPEC members and allied producers on Thursday will...
Fire erupts at building site of palace in Berlin
A fire broke out on Wednesday at the royal palace that is being rebuilt at great expense in central Berlin, Reuters reported, citing the...
Kocharyan's lawyer comments on suit against Pashinyan
Armenia’s former President Robert Kocharyan again filed a defamation lawsuit against Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Tuesday. In the...
Iran's coronavirus death toll passes 4,000
Iran’s new coronavirus death toll has climbed to 4,003 with 121 more deaths in the past 24 hours, Reuters reported a Health Ministry...
Azerbaijan, Turkey submit joint application to UNESCO
The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) proclaimed Armenian duduk music a masterpiece of the oral and...
Turkey's death toll from coronavirus rises to 725
Turkey confirmed Tuesday that 76 more people died from the coronavirus in the country over the past 24 hours, bringing the death toll to...
Armenian PM sacks advisor
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has signed a decision to dismiss Hakob Chagharyan as his advisor. “Guided by Article 9, Part...
Russia’s coronavirus cases rise to 8,672
The number of novel coronavirus cases in Russia has risen by 1,175 over the past day, reaching 8,672 in 81 regions, the anti-coronavirus crisis...
Artsakh coronavirus patient in stable condition
The Artsakh citizen who has tested positive for the novel coronavirus is in a stable condition and has no complaints, the Artsakh Information...
Grammy-winning singer John Prine dies of coronavirus complications
Grammy-winning singer John Prine, who wrote his early songs in his head while delivering mail and later emerged from Chicago’s folk...
Armenia’s coronavirus cases rise to 881 as of April 8
Armenia has confirmed 28 new coronavirus infections, bringing the total number of cases to 881 in the country as of 11 a.m. Wednesday, April 8,...
93-year-old patient dies of coronavirus complications in Armenia
A 93-year-old person has died of coronavirus complications in Armenia, while eight patients are in a critical condition, Prime Minister Nikol...
Boris Johnson spends second night in intensive care
Boris Johnson has spent a second night in intensive care as he continues to receive treatment for coronavirus, BBC News reports. The PM is...
Artsakh presidential election runoff set for April 14
The Artsakh Central Electoral Commission (CEC) has set April 14 as the date for a runoff election to decide the country’s next president...
Armenian Church observes Holy Wednesday
The entire week leading up to Easter or Holy Resurrection is known as Holy Week (in Armenian Avak Shabat). During this period, the Armenian...
Vardenyats Pass closed for trailer trucks
Roads in Armenia are mostly open to traffic as of 8:20am Wednesday, April 8, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reported. The roadways...
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey pledges $1 billion for coronavirus relief
Jack Dorsey is devoting $1 billion of his stake in Square Inc., the payments firm he co-founded, to help fund the coronavirus relief...
US indicts Turkish Halkbank for illegal transfer of billions of dollars to Iran
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier Halkbank, whose majority shareholder is the Turkish government, pleaded not guilty...
Cold expected in the territory of Armenia on April 8-9
The air temperature will decrease on April 8-9 in Tavush, Syunik regions of Armenia and Artsakh foothills. On the night of 8-9 April cold by...
Another batch of Armenian citizens to arrive in Yerevan from Russia
The plane of Red wings airlines departed from Moscow Domodedovo airport with 200 Armenian citizens on board. As the Armenian Embassy in Russia...
Women rescuers of MES on duty
The women of the Rescue service of the Armenia’s ministry of emergency situations  (MES) continue to be faithful to their mission...
After signs of slowing, Spain sees rise in coronavirus deaths
The pace of coronavirus deaths in Spain ticked up slightly for the first time in five days on Tuesday, with 743 people succumbing overnight to...
Police charges 131 citizens in one day with violating movement restriction and quarantine rules
The Police of Armenia continues implementing the Commandant’s directive on the restriction on public movement to prevent the spread of...
Armenian brothers launch production of protective equipment in London amid the COVID-19 crisis
An A-level Armenian student and two former pupils have turned their school into a factory to produce protective equipment to help the NHS during...
Former president Kocharyan files defamation suit against PM Pashinyan
Armenia’s former President Robert Kocharyan has dropped a defamation lawsuit against Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Tuesday. In the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}