Politics 13:33 04/12/2019 World

Opinion: It would be impossible to imagine Germany being a part of NATO if it had not recognized Nazi crimes

Lithuanian political commentator, reporter Vladimiras Laučius has touched upon, among other things, Turkey’s policy of denial of the Armenian Genocide, its incompatibility with NATO membership and human rights abuses in the country in an article published on Delfi Lithuanian news portal.

Below is the full text of the English version of the article.

It would be impossible to imagine Germany being a part of NATO if it had not recognized Nazi crimes, including Holocaust. However, Turkey, which is not going to admit to having committed genocides against Christian nations - Armenians, Assyrians and Greeks - is a NATO member.  

The preamble to the North Atlantic Treaty states that the parties to the Treaty “are determined to safeguard the freedom, common heritage and civilization of their peoples, founded on the principles of democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law”.

Which of the above mentioned principles does Turkey preserve? Does it succeed? How it is possible to preserve the civilization to which it does not belong or to safeguard principles that are hardly followed in the country?

If all you need to be a NATO member is simply having a strong army, a semblance of democracy and some common interests with Western countries, then how come Russia is still not a part of NATO?

One may say, that Russia violates the principles of inviolability in South Ossetia and Ukraine. However, for the NATO countries, this seems to be no longer an insurmountable moral and legal issue after the 1974, when Turkish troops occupied Northern Cyprus.

Now Turkey is also occupying as much of Syria’s territory as possible a, amicably negotiating with Russia for patrol zones as well.

How about the issue of armament and military compatibility? After Turkey's purchase of the Russian S-400 missile systems and considering of buying Russian Su-57 fighter jets, it no longer seems to be a major obstacle to Russia's integration into NATO. It is obvious, that the indirect integration carried out through the armaments and the Turks is already underway.

Russian authorities do not recognize Soviet crimes and justify Stalin's atrocities? Turkey does absolutely the same not admitting for having planned and committed Armenian (Medz Yeghern), Assyrian (Seyfo) and Greek (Megali Catastrophi) genocides - mass killings, torture and desert exiles.

Moreover, Turkish law allows to prosecute people affirming the genocides executed by Turks claiming it insults Turkish people. This is very similar to Vladimir Putin's Russian law and ideological propaganda of the history of his country.

The genocide of the Christian nations in Turkey - in terms of cruelty, extent, torture and ideological justification - is very similar to the Jewish Holocaust committed by the Nazis.

For example, Mehmed Reshid, a doctor in the Ottoman Empire, was famous for treating Armenians as second-rate people compared to, in his opinion, more advanced Muslims.

He ordered to attach horseshoes to the feet of Armenian exiles to make it more entertaining to watch them go into exile after such an execution. He also liked to crucify them, given the Armenian religion. In 1978, in Turkey, a NATO member, an encyclopedia was published which describes Mehmed Reshid as a "great patriot."

Like their future Nazi colleagues, Turkish doctors conducted brutal experiments on the “second-rate” people. For example, they injected Armenians with blood of patients suffering from typhoid fever in search of a vaccine for the disease. A memorial museum was even built in Istanbul for the doctor famous for aforementioned experiments - he is considered the father of Turkish bacteriology.

Ali Saib, head of the Trapezund Department of Health, had diligently performed his professional duty by forcing pregnant Armenian women and children to drink poison. If they refused, they would be drowned in the sea.

Saib loved to inject a lethal dose of morphine to the Armenian exiles, who miraculously survived a disastrous journey through the wilderness. Also, he used to kill children in mobile hot steam baths.

Nowadays, streets and significant public sites in Turkey are titled after the organizers of the genocide - Talaat, Yemal, Enver. It would be the same if another NATO member - Germany - would name the streets, say, Himmler Straße.

The main problem of Turkey’s membership in NATO is not that it blocks Baltic defense plans, buys Russian S-400 refusing American armaments, supports ISIS and Jabhat al Nusra fighters, occupies Syrian territories, where along with its Arab allies, destroys remnants of Christian communities in Asia Minor.

The fundamental problem is not that Recep Tayyip Erdogan sees a demographically and culturally revitalized Ottoman Empire in Europe where high-fertility Turkish population will be able to impose their own rules.

The main problem of Turkey as a NATO member lies not in its actions, objectives, political and social realities or its attitude towards the West. This approach should not at all be surprising after centuries. The problem here is not the Turkish approach, but the Western one.

The genocides of Turkey’s Christians- Armenians (killed at least 1.5 million), Greeks (killed about 750,000) and Assyrians (approx. 300,000 victims) - have been officially recognized by the International Association for Genocide Scholars.

The Armenian genocide has also been recognized by the European Parliament, the Council of Europe and, most recently, the US House of Representatives. It has also been recognized by many NATO countries, including Lithuania.

In Switzerland, Slovakia, Greece and Cyprus one may be prosecuted for denying the Armenian genocide. Slovakia and Greece are members of NATO, just like Turkey, which stubbornly denies genocide. It is a sort of phantasmagoria. Do you still think aforementioned countries belong to common civilization, common heritage and common principles?

As for this situation, Turkey and its allies are not facing any particular problems yet. Many even rejoice and apparently take pride in having such an ally with a common (forgive me, Lord) heritage.

Well, it is true, that Turkey was an important counterweight to the USSR during the Cold War. It should be assumed, that Turkey has not yet entered the European Union not without a reason.

However, once there was hope that the situation in Turkey would improve. Instead, it got worse. And so, the farther it goes, the harder it becomes to explain and justify reconciling a deepening value gap.

Continuing a conciliatory approach would be even more hypocritical than hitherto the silence over the issue of genocide, selective amnesia, not talking about what could cause inconvenience to or is useless for Turkish comrades, and, to put it mildly, does not honor them.

Such an approach partly coincides with what Adolf Hitler said in 1939 as he shared his plans to exterminate the Poles: “Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?” In other words - nobody cares. And those, who defend the Western values, should they also not care about it?

Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Air temperature to drop by 2-3 degrees at night
no precipitation is predicted in the territory of Armenia on January 26-30, Hydromet meteorological service at the ministry of emergency...
45 cases of crime detected over the past day in Armenia
According to the operations reports of Police Armenia, 45 cases of crime were detected by officers of various police subdivisions in the...
Armenia’s bread production on the rise
Bread production volumes have increased in Armenia in January-November 2019 by 2.4 per cent, according to the latest figures released by the...
Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople objects public tender for Sanasaryan Han
Turkey’s Armenian Patriarchate said on Friday that Turkish authorities decision to hold a tender to rent the Sanasaryan Han was unjust as...
Iranian FM: Tehran still willing to negotiate with US
Iran is not ruling out negotiations with the United States even after an American drone strike that killed a top Iranian general, the...
Vardenyats pass closed for trucks
Armenia’s ministry of emergency situations (MES) reports that some roads are closed, difficult to pass in the territory of republic as of...
Anastasia Galustyan fails to overcome qualification round at the European Figure Skating Championships
Armenia’s representative Anastasia Galustyan failed to overcome the obstacle of the qualification round of the at the 2020 European Figure...
PM says Armenia’s external forex reserves stand at unprecedented level
Armenia's Foreign Exchange Reserves stood at 2.8 USD bln in 2019, which is more by 28 per cent to compare with the data of 2018, Prime...
Azerbaijan fired over 700 shots toward Armenian positions - Artsakh Defense Army
The Azerbaijani armed forces violated the ceasefire along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan Line of Contact over 130 times in the past week, the...
Death toll rises in eastern Turkey earthquake
At least 20 people were killed and more than 1,015 injured Friday after a deadly earthquake rattled eastern Turkey, according to authorities....
Armenia acquired unprecedented amount of weapons – PM
The budget allocations for the defense ministry will amount for 307 billion AMD (around 640 million USD) in 2020 which is an 28% increase to...
11 under watch in India over Coronavirus fears
Eleven people in four cities of India have been kept under observation after they returned from China and showed mild symptoms of the new...
PM Pashinyan sent congratulatory messages to leaders of China
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan sent congratulatory messages to the President Xi Jinping and Prime Minister Li Keqiang of the...
Armenian skaters reached the final at the 2020 European Figure Skating Championships
Armenian figure skaters Tina Karapetyan and Simon Senekal have reached the final in a pair event of the 2020 European Figure Skating...
At least 19 dead, more than 600 injured in Turkey earthquake
At least 19 people died and more than 600 were injured in eastern Turkey after an earthquake rattled the region on Friday evening, CNN reported....
Some roads closed, difficult to pass in Armenia
Armenia’s ministry of emergency situations (MES) reports that some roads are closed, difficult to pass in the territory of republic as of...
Diocese of Baltic States of the Armenian Apostolic Church established
On January 24, His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians issued a Kontag on establishing Diocese of the...
Vandals set fire to mosque in east Jerusalem
Israeli police said on Friday they are investigating after a “room was ignited” in a mosque on the outskirts of Jerusalem and Hebrew...
Viva-MTS: “+3GB” Internet package within “X”, “Y” and “Z” tariff plans
Now prepaid and postpaid subscribers of “X”, “Y” tariff plans, as well as prepaid subscribers of “Z” tariff...
Artak Kamalyan to be dismissed from post of deputy minister of economy
Armenia's deputy minister of economy Artak Kamalyan will be dismissed from office by the decree of the country’s Prime Minister Nikol...
Central Bank held its refinancing rate steady at 5.5 percent
The Board of Central Bank of Armenia (CBA) decided to leave the Refinancing Rate of CBA unchanged, at 5.5 percent. As the press department at...
Prince Charles visits Armenian church in Bethlehem
Prince Charles of the Great Britain on Friday visited the Armenian Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem, Chancellor of the Armenian Patriarchate...
Constitutional Court head says authorities seek to ‘get rid of' him as soon as possible
Constitutional Court Chairman Hrayr Tovmasyan reacted to the search conducted in his apartment by the Special Investigative Service on Friday....
WHO expects coronavirus cases to rise in China
Cases of the new coronavirus are likely to continue to rise in China and it is too soon to evaluate its severity, a spokesman for the World...
Lydian provides update on restructuring proceedings
Lydian International Limited (TSX:LYD) announced on Thursday that the company’s and its direct and indirect wholly owned subsidiaries,...
New Yerevan police chief named
Police Colonel Armen Gasparyan has been appointed new Yerevan police chief, the police press service reported. Before the appointment...
Soldier wounded in Artsakh undergoes surgery, in stable condition – Defense Ministry spox
One of the Armenian soldiers wounded in Artsakh under yet unclear circumstances has undergone surgery, Defense Ministry spokesman Artsrun...
Lawyer: Investigators ‘found nothing’ during search of Hrayr Tovmasyan’s home
Investigators have found nothing while searching the apartment of Constitutional Court Chairman Hrayr Tovmasyan, his lawyer Amram Makinyan told...
All flights from China's Wuhan to Moscow cancelled amid coronavirus outbreak
All flights from the Chinese city of Wuhan to Moscow have been cancelled over the coronavirus outbreak in China, Sputnik reported,...
Lawyer posts video from Armenian top court head's home being searched by SIS
Amram Makinyan, one of the lawyers of Constitutional Court Chairman Hrayr Tovmasyan, has posted a video on Facebook from the apartment of the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}