Politics 10:37 01/04/2020 Region

Turkey ignores its highest court’s verdict on Armenian Patriarch’s election

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

Forum 18 News Service of Oslo, Norway, published a lengthy article by Dr. Mine Yildirim on March 25, 2020, explaining the Turkish government’s interference in the election of the Armenian Patriarch of Turkey, despite the ruling of the Constitutional Court that the government’s interference “was not prescribed by law and not necessary in a democratic society.”

Two Armenians of Istanbul, Levon Berj Kuzukoglu and Ohannes Garbis Balmumciyan, had initially filed a lawsuit with the Administrative Court on March 27, 2012. The Court rejected the lawsuit, stating that the Patriarchal election can only take place after the death or resignation of the Patriarch who was in a coma, even though the 1863 Ottoman-era regulations stated that the Armenian Patriarch’s election can take place in the case of “the death of the Patriarch, resignation and other." The applicants appealed this decision, but the Court of Cassation rejected it on November 23, 2015.

The two Armenians then appealed to the Constitutional Court claiming that the state’s refusal of their request for the election of a new Patriarch violated their right to freedom of religion. The Court made its judgment in favor of the Armenians five years later in May 2019. However, the Turkish leaders ignored the Court’s decision. “While the judgment includes important findings related to the state's unjustified interference in the internal affairs of the Armenian community, it also raises questions about whether the Constitutional Court is an effective domestic remedy or an actor that conveniently blocks applications to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, thus closing the door to international supervision,” Dr. Yildirim wrote. “The state had prevented the Armenian community from electing its religious leader between 2009, when the then Patriarch Mesrob Mutafyan could no longer perform his duties due to illness, and 2019, when the community finally elected Bishop Sahak Mashalyan as the new Patriarch.”

It is more than a coincidence that the Constitutional Court gave its verdict on May 22, 2019, following the state’s approval of the Patriarchal election after the March 8, 2019, passing away of Patriarch Mutafyan. The timing of the decision was intended to give the impression that the state was not interfering in the election of a new Patriarch and the Court was not telling the government what to do.

In its ruling, the Constitutional Court referred “to the 1863 Regulation for the Armenian Millet (ethno-religious community) and international legal provisions, including the European Court on Human Rights (ECHR) and the 1923 Lausanne Peace Treaty's provisions on the protection of non-Muslims in Turkey,” according to Dr. Yildirim.

Throughout the existence of the Republic of Turkey, the government made some arbitrary changes during the 1950, 1961, 1990, 1998 and 2019 Patriarchal elections. “The election Directives were based on the Cabinet Decree of 18 September 1961 which had been issued only for that year's Patriarchal election and which included no provisions for future elections. Despite this, the Interior Ministry has continued to use this Decree,” Dr. Yildirim wrote. The Interior Ministry's submission to the Constitutional Court stated that the measures taken by the authorities derive from "the state's positive obligation to organize the religious field.”

The Constitutional Court countered that argument by ruling that its verdict is based on Article 24 of the Turkish Constitution which protected religious freedom, Article 38 of the Lausanne Treaty which referred to the practice of religion, as well as the various rulings of the European Court of Human Rights. Furthermore, the Constitutional Court ruled that “the appointment of a Patriarchal Vicar-General (in 2010) occurred not as a result of a process that took place within the competing civilian and spiritual initiatives in the Armenian community, but as a result of ‘state pressure that was unconstitutional,’” according to Dr. Yildirim. “In conclusion, the Constitutional Court found that the state has not been able to demonstrate a pressing social need that overrides the ‘spirit of Armenian traditions’ and the ‘Armenian community's will.’ Therefore the interference in the applicants' right to freedom of religion or belief by way of refusing the request to hold Patriarchal elections cannot be considered compatible with the requirements of a democratic society, and Article 24 of the Constitution had thus been violated.”

However, even after the ruling of the Constitutional court, the state continued to interfere in the Patriarchal election. The Turkish Interior Ministry came up with a new restriction, ruling that only those Turkish Armenian bishops who were serving in Turkey at the time could be candidates for the Patriarchal election, thus reducing the number of eligible candidates to two. “This is 100% in contradiction to the Constitutional Court’s judgment,” said Sebu Aslangil, the lawyer in the case. Nevertheless, the Armenian Steering Committee for the Patriarchal election decided not to contest the Interior Ministry’s ruling in order not to further delay the election of a new Patriarch.

Dr. Yildirim concluded: “The judgment raised the profile of the Constitutional Court as a high court delivering a judgment in line with ECHR jurisprudence. Yet, due to its timing, the judgment had no impact on rectifying the injustice that the Armenian community experienced. It also closed the door for an application to be made to the ECHR in Strasbourg, thus blocking international supervision of the implementation of the judgment.”

In effect, as the legal axiom states, “Justice delayed is justice denied.”



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

20:27
440 patients in severe, 50 - in critical condition - coronavirus updates from the minister of health
Health Minister Arsen Torosyan says his predictions according to which the coronavirus case in Armenia will reach 10,000 came true. The...
20:07
8923 beneficiaries received a total of 1.7 billion drams within the government 18th anti-crisis measure
Within the 18th measure aimed at easing the economic impacts of the coronavirus, 12 227 taxpayers have been considered as the program’s...
19:14
Artsakh President received newly-appointed Secretary of the Security Council Samvel Babayan
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan received today the newly-appointed secretary of the Artsakh Republic Security Council Samvel...
18:28
50 letters, 50 smiles. Children of Kotayk and Tavush children's villages will receive tablets
Children are one of the most vulnerable groups in society and demand daily attention, love and protection, especially in these difficult times...
18:06
FIDE Top 100 players feature five Armenian grandmasters
Armenian grandmaster Levon Aronian maintained the seventh spot on the latest World Chess Federation (FIDE) ratings, the National Olympic...
17:48
Armenian Armed Forces only respond to provocations by the adversary - defense ministry
A footage and reports circulated online suggest the Armed Forces of Armenia have destroyed an Azerbaijani military equipment in Nakhijevan...
17:11
19 violinists to participate in the 16th Khachaturian International Competition
19 violinists have overcome the pre-selection auditions and will take part in the 16th Khachaturian International Competition. As...
16:21
Artsakh president tests negative for coronavirus
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan has tested negative for the novel coronavirus based on the results of a PCR test, Head of the...
16:05
Armenian woman beats coronavirus after 44 days in intensive care
A 47-year-old Armenian woman with coronavirus has recovered and discharged from St. Gregory the Illuminator Medical Center in Yerevan after 44...
15:43
Iran says coronavirus cases jump nearly 3,000 in a day, a 2-month high
Iran on Monday announced almost 3,000 new coronavirus infections, its highest daily count in two months, as it warned of another "dangerous...
15:35
Why is number of daily coronavirus tests dropping in Armenia?
The number of daily coronavirus tests has recently dropped in Armenia. According to the official data, 1,124 tests were performed on May 26,...
15:00
Notre Dame forecourt reopens to public after long cleanup delayed by coronavirus
Notre Dame Cathedral's forecourt opened up to the public for the first time since the devastating fire of April 15 last year, Euronews...
14:54
Mikhail Mishustin extends birthday greetings to Nikol Pashinyan
Russian Premier Mikhail Mishustin has extended birthday greetings to Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.  “Dear Nikol...
14:40
Armenian MP: Response to Azerbaijan’s aggression to be more than adequate and strong
Azerbaijani Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov has made a threatening statement in which he, in fact, acknowledged that the 2016 April War has been...
13:56
Artsakh president appoints new ministers
Artsakh Republic President Arayik Harutyunyan signed a range of decrees to appoint new ministers on Monday, June 1. In particular, Levon...
13:47
Today is International Children's Day
The World Conference for the Well-being of Children in Geneva, Switzerland, proclaimed June 1 to be International Children's Day in 1925. It...
13:40
No mass coronavirus testing of Armenian government members planned, says PM’s spox
No mass coronavirus testing of the Armenian government members and the prime minister’s staff is planned, PM Nikol Pashinyan's...
13:19
Russia reports 9,035 new coronavirus infections
Russia has confirmed 9,035 new COVID-19 cases in the past 24 hours, raising its total to 414,878, its coronavirus response center said in a...
13:13
75% of Armenians dissatisfied with government’s coronavirus response, survey shows
Some 75% of Armenians are dissatisfied with the government’s coronavirus containment measures, a new online survey shows. The survey...
12:14
Putin sends birthday greetings to Pashinyan
Russian President Vladimir Putin has sent birthday greetings to Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan. The congratulatory message, published...
11:55
Armenia’s coronavirus tally climbs to 9,492 on June 1
Armenia has confirmed 210 new coronavirus infections, bringing the national tally to 9,492 as of 11 a.m. Monday, June 1, the Ministry of Health...
11:41
Outrage as Israeli police kill autistic Palestinian man
Israeli police in Jerusalem shot and killed an autistic Palestinian who they mistakenly thought was armed with a gun, provoking furious...
11:36
Artsakh reports three new coronavirus cases
Artsakh has reported three new cases of COVID-19 on Monday, bringing the national tally to 43. The infected people are Artsakh citizens who...
11:12
Former Armenian Cadaster Committee head’s mother dies from coronavirus
The mother of Sarhat Petrosyan, the former head of Armenia’s State Committee of Real Estate Cadaster, has died from the coronavirus...
10:44
NYC mayor's daughter arrested at Manhattan protest
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio’s daughter was arrested at a Manhattan protest on Saturday night, law enforcement sources told...
10:37
Armenian PM, family members test positive for coronavirus
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his family members have tested positive for COVID-19, the PM said in a Facebook live on Monday....
10:01
Poll: Biden widens lead over Trump to 10 points
Former U.S. Vice President Joe Biden, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee, has built a double-digit lead over President Trump in his...
20:00
Elijah’s fast to begin on Monday
The Armenian Church will celebrate the Feast of Pentecost on Monday, June 1. The Feast of Pentecost is the commemoration of the descent of the...
19:46
Defense ministry spokesperson reacts to Azerbaijani minister’s threats
“Azerbaijani Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov held a consultation today and came up with new threats, admitting, in fact, that the initiator...
19:30
Puppet theatre organizes an open-air performance in Yerevan
The Yerevan State Puppet theatre is organizing an amusing concert-performance on June 1 to mark the International Day for Protection of...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}