Politics 14:05 02/04/2020 World

‘Dictatorships often start in the face of a threat’, UN privacy chief warns amid coronavirus surveillance

Strict surveillance measures adopted to monitor citizens during coronavirus lockdowns could result in the long-lasting theft of personal freedoms, the United Nations’ privacy chief has warned.

“Dictatorships and authoritarian societies often start in the face of a threat,” Joseph Cannataci, the UN special rapporteur on the right to privacy told the Thomson Reuters Foundation, The Independent reported. 

“That is why it is important to be vigilant today and not give away all our freedoms.”

The coronavirus pandemic has led governments to declare themselves essentially on a war footing – with many politicians referencing an “invisible” enemy or attacker.

At the advice of health experts, even countries regarded as the world’s most liberal democracies have enforced quarantine measures thought unthinkable mere weeks ago.

As governments grapple with how to monitor and enforce such restrictions on movement, several have turned to more authoritarian technologies, such as facial recognition and phone tracking.

The danger is that measures brought in to protect citizens in exceptional circumstances – when most people accept they are needed – could outlast the current crisis, Mr Cannataci cautioned.

While it is difficult to properly assess each measure while the pandemic is ongoing, safeguards should be put in place to ensure responses are necessary and proportionate, according to Mr Cannataci.

Surveillance measures should be written in law and clearly limited in time, he told the foundation.

He warned that data obtained via phone tracking could be abused or stolen to vilify vulnerable ethnic, religious or sexual minorities, exposing them to the risk of violence and discrimination.

And while health data can be useful in assessing citizens' vulnerability to Covid-19, it could also be abused to identify HIV-positive people in countries where the condition is seen as an indicator of homosexuality and homophobia is rife, he added.

“We must be very careful how we use these tools,” Mr Cannataci said. “And citizens should use every means they have to influence both the policies and the laws that are made that affect them.”

China, which has long inflicted restrictive technologies upon its citizens, appears to have emerged from its first wave of domestically-transmitted infection after months of heavily policed quarantine measures in the most affected regions.

Israel’s counterterrorism unit will also use technologies like phone tracking – typically used on Palestinians – to track citizens, sending a text to their phone when they breach quarantine rules or may have come into contact with an infected person.

South Korea, which has been widely praised for its efforts to slow the outbreak’s spread, has employed web developers to build detailed maps of citizens’ movements using CCTV, phone-tracking and tracing bank transactions.

Singapore has also launched an open source contact-tracing smartphone app, which tells its opt-in users if they have possibly been exposed to coronavirus, while Taiwan has built an "electronic fence" using phone-tracking data to enforce quarantine measures.

The UN’s Mr Cannataci said governments should favour voluntary tools – such as phone-tracking apps requiring users’ consent – over broader surveillance powers, and urged countries to set up independent bodies to oversee such measures.

“Any form of data can be misapplied in incredibly bad ways,” he said. “If you have a leader who wants to abuse the system, the system is there.”

As reported earlier, the Armenian parliament also adoped a package of bills on making amendments and supplements to the laws on the state of emergency regime and electronic communication, allowing the authorities to use personal data from citizens’ mobile phones to fight the coronavirus outbreak. 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

10:06
England beat Czech Republic to top Euro 2020 Group D
Raheem Sterling's second goal of Euro 2020 saw England beat the Czech Republic to win Group D and set up a last-16 tie against France,...
20:28
Mona Lisa replica sells for €2.9 million at Christie's
A fake of Da Vinci's masterpiece known as the Hekking Mona Lisa was sold at Christie's Auction House in Paris on Friday. The painting...
20:16
Yerevan street renamed after benefactor Hrant Vardanyan
At its meeting on Tuesday, the Yerevan City Council approved a decision to rename Shahamiryans Street in Yerevan’s Shengavit...
19:30
Turkmenistan's capital tops list of most expensive cities for expats
The capital of Turkmenistan in Central Asia has been named as the world's most expensive city for foreign workers, BBC News reports....
19:20
Armen Sarkissian holds phone call with Robert Kocharyan
President Armen Sarkissian of Armenia on Tuesday held a telephone call with second President Robert Kocharyan, the leader of the Armenia...
18:47
ARF’s Ishkhan Saghatelyan slams 'fabricated' charges against famous doctor Armen Charchyan
ARF Supreme Council member Ishkhan Saghatelyan, one of the leaders of the Armenia bloc, on Tuesday slammed the charges against famous doctor,...
17:55
Spanish government pardons jailed Catalan separatist leaders
Spain's Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez on Tuesday pardoned all nine Catalan separatist leaders jailed for their role in a failed...
17:42
Armen Sarkissian holds phone call with Artur Vanetsyan
Armenian President Armen Sarkissian on Tuesday held a phone call with Artur Vanetsyan, the leader of the I’m Honored (Pativ Unem) bloc....
17:17
Robert Kocharyan: Factor of former authorities’ return affected election results in a sense
Armenia’s second President Robert Kocharyan, the leader of the Armenia bloc, says the outcome of Sunday’s snap parliamentary...
16:31
Over 65,719 vaccinations recorded in Armenia, health official says
More than 65,719 vaccinations have been recorded in Armenia thus far, comprising nearly 2% of the population, Gayane Sahakyan, Deputy Director...
15:36
Zakharova: Russia hopes for strengthening relations with Armenia after parliamentary elections
Russia hopes the results of Armenia’s early parliamentary elections will encourage the country’s development, promote stability and...
15:17
UK health minister says data looking good on easing lockdown
British Health Minister Matt Hancock said on Tuesday the COVID-19 data looks encouraging and currently suggests England's lockdown can fully...
14:58
The European Union committed to supporting a stable, democratic and prosperous future of Armenia
Spokesperson for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy of the European Union Nabila Massrali has issued a statement on the conduct of the early...
14:48
Russian Ambassador comments on possible deployment of Russian border guards on Armenian-Azerbaijani border
"The OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs plan to visit the region, however, I do not have information about the dates and other details,"...
14:31
Iran congratulates Armenia on successful parliamentary election
Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Saeed Khatibzadeh in a message congratulated Armenian people and representatives on the 2021 Armenian...
14:26
CEC publishes the signed voters' lists of snap parliamentary elections
Central Electoral Commission (CEC) of Armenia has published the signed lists of the voters who participated in the June 20 elections to the...
13:38
Robert Kocharyan: If the authorities continue their work-style, it may result in new snap elections
Armenia's ex-president Robert Kocharyan stated on Tuesday that the strategy of "Armenia" bloc in the parliament is under...
12:35
Armenia reports 77 new COVID-19 cases, 4 deaths on June 22
Armenia has confirmed 77 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 224,330 as of 11 a.m. Tuesday, June 22, the...
12:31
US State Department shares ODIHR’s concern regarding intense polarization and inflammatory rhetoric during the Armenian elections
"The United States congratulates the people of Armenia on their June 20 parliamentary elections. We welcome the overall positive assessment...
12:02
Robert Kocharyan: Proud to have such an electorate
Armenia's ex-President Robert Kocharyan expressed gratitude to all citizens who voted for 'Armenia' bloc during the Sunday's...
11:22
About 150 pilgrims and residents of Nagorno-Karabakh visited Amaras and Gandzasar Christian monasteries
As part of the implementation of the trilateral statement of the leaders of Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia of November 9, 2020, Russian...
10:39
A grenade thrown under the car of former MP Mihran Hakobyan
In the morning of June 21, unidentified people have thrown a grenade under the car of Mihran Hakobyan, political analyst Hrant...
10:24
Observers should not be rubber stamps for Pashinyan’s Civil Contract - 'Armenia' bloc
'Armenia' bloc led b ex-president Robert Kocharyan has issued a statement about the international observers' assessment on the early...
20:27
Stepanakert residents demand the resignation of Arayik Harutyunyan
Dozens of residents of the Artsakh capital city Stepanakert gathered on Monday at the central Revival square to demand the resignation of the...
20:18
Three more bodies found during search operations, Artsakh emergency service says
Three more bodies were found during the search operations in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) on Monday, June 21, the State Service of Emergency...
19:35
'I'm Honoured' bloc: The struggle will go on
"The June 20 elections in Armenia failed to become elections for the provision of security for Armenia and Artsakh, restoration of the...
19:05
Summer conscription kicks off in Armenia
The Summer 2021 military draft has launched in Armenia, the press service at the Ministry of Defense reported. According to the source, first...
18:44
Russian FM: Too early to speak about Armenian elections’ impacts on situation in Karabakh
It is too early to speak about any impacts of the parliamentary elections in Armenia that were held just on Sunday on the situation in...
18:39
Russia to discuss ‘pulling Ukraine into NATO’ with Turkey shortly — Lavrov
Russia plans to discuss the topic of pulling Ukraine into NATO during the upcoming contacts with Turkey, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov...
17:52
"Armenia" bloc to apply to the Constitutional Court to dispute the results of the early parliamentary elections
'Armenia' bloc, led by ex-president Robert Kocharyan, insists there are serious grounds to declare Sunday’s early parliamentary...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}