Politics 10:26 25/11/2020 World

Putin: Armenia not recognizing Artsakh was ‘a significant factor’

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

Pres. Vladimir Putin of Russia made several important comments in his response to journalists on Nov. 17, 2020, regarding the recent Artsakh War ceasefire that he brokered between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

The Russian leader started by providing the background of the Artsakh conflict: “It all started in the already remote year of 1988, when ethnic clashes took place in the Azerbaijani city of Sumgait. Armenian civilians fell victim to these events, and later it spread to Nagorno-Karabakh. And since Soviet Union’s leaders did not react duly to these events… let me say it again: these are sensitive issues, and I do not want to side with anyone or decide who was right or wrong. It is no longer possible to determine this now, but it was necessary to put things in order and protect civilians, and this was not done. At that point, the Armenians themselves took up arms, and this protracted conflict, a conflict building for many years broke out. Eventually, it led to a declaration of independence, sovereignty and self-reliance by Karabakh in 1991. The Bishkek agreements were signed in 1994 and this Bishkek memorandum stopped the hostilities at that time. What happened as a result? Karabakh declared independence, as I have said, and another seven adjacent regions came under the control of Armenians, that is, Armenia.”

In response to a journalist’s comment that “no one recognized Karabagh’s status,” Putin stated: “That is true: no one recognized it then or later. By the way, Armenia itself did not recognize it. …With regard to recognizing or not recognizing Karabakh as an independent state, there may be different approaches, but this undoubtedly was a significant factor, including in the course of the bloody conflict that I hope has ended. Because the very fact of the non-recognition of Karabakh, including by Armenia, has left a deep imprint on the course of events and the way it is perceived. To put it bluntly, after the former Georgian leaders’ undoubtedly criminal moves, I mean the attacks against our peacekeepers in South Ossetia, Russia recognized the independence of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. We recognized the expression of the will of the people living in Crimea to reunite with Russia as just, and we met the people halfway, we did so openly. Some people may like it, others may not like it, but we did it in the interests of the people who live there and in the interests of Russia, and we are not ashamed to speak about it openly. This did not happen with Karabakh, and this, of course, has significantly influenced the developments there.” Later in the interview, Putin added: “Armenia did not recognize the independence and sovereignty of Nagorno-Karabakh. In terms of international law, it meant that Nagorno-Karabakh and the adjoining districts were an inalienable part of the Republic of Azerbaijan.”

This is an important declaration by Pres. Putin. Armenia has been reluctant to recognize Artsakh’s independence out of a concern of a backlash from the international community. It was feared that such a move would have disrupted the peaceful negotiations and could have possibly resulted in war or at least rejection and sanctions against Armenia by the United Nations.

Armenia’s leaders, up until Putin’s above comments, had no idea that not recognizing Artsakh’s independence was viewed by the Russian leader as a mistake, negatively affecting Russia’s support. During the past decades of negotiations with the Minsk Group of mediators, including Russia, one wonders if any of Armenia’s leaders ever asked Putin or his predecessors for their reaction to Armenia’s possible recognition of Artsakh. If Armenia’s leaders did not raise this issue, it was a major mistake. Had Armenia known that Russia would have welcomed its recognition of Artsakh, the subsequent events, including the recent war, would have turned out much different. Some Armenians had suggested that if Artsakh had been united with Armenia, that would have compelled Russia to defend Artsakh from any foreign attacks based on the mutual defense treaty between Russia and Armenia. As I suggested previously, maybe at this late stage, Armenia would finally listen to Putin’s advice and recognize Artsakh’s independence or unify it with Armenia in order to have a bargaining chip in the negotiations with Azerbaijan.

In response to another question regarding the status of Artsakh, Putin stated: “Yes, there is this problem since Karabakh’s final status has not been settled. We have agreed to maintain the status quo. What happens next will be decided eventually by future leaders and future participants in this process. I think if proper conditions are created for normal life and relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan, between people in everyday life, especially in the conflict zone, are restored, it will create an environment for determining Karabakh’s status.” This response provides a ray of hope that with time, Artsakh may be able to attain its goal of securing an independent status. Interestingly, Pres. Putin left such a decision to “future leaders and future participants in this process.”

Another question was regarding the territories surrounding Artsakh and the status of Shushi prior to its occupation by Azerbaijan. Pres. Putin explained that the return of the territories surrounding Artsakh to Azerbaijan was first suggested by Russia in 2013 and supported by France and the United States. He said that this would have preserved Artsakh’s status quo “as an unrecognized state,” and its final status to be resolved in the future. Putin stated that there would have been no war if Armenia had agreed to the return of refugees of both sides to their previous homes.

Regarding the City of Shushi, Putin confirmed that its transfer to Azerbaijan was never raised. Putin recalled that 20 days before the end of the war, while Azerbaijan had only conquered “an insignificant part” of Artsakh, he had managed to convince Pres. Aliyev to end the hostilities on condition that Azeri refugees would be able to return to Shushi, under Armenian control in the presence of Russian peacekeepers. However, Prime Minister Pashinyan told Putin that this condition is unacceptable to Armenia and continued the fighting, resulting in the loss of Shushi. Pres. Putin added that there was no “treason” on the part of Pashinyan.

Pres. Putin also made several important deferential remarks regarding Turkey. The Russian leader acknowledged that “Azerbaijan is an independent sovereign state, and has every right to choose allies as it deems fit. Who can deny it this right? This is my first point. Second, as I have already mentioned, nobody has recognized Karabakh’s independence, [not] even Armenia. What does this mean in terms of international law? It means that Azerbaijan sought to recover territories which Azerbaijan and the entire international community view as Azerbaijani territory. In this context, it had the right to choose any ally who could assist it in this endeavor…. You can assess Turkey’s actions any way you want, but it can hardly be accused of violating international law.”

It is noteworthy that Putin did not mention Turkey’s violations of international law by recruiting terrorists from Northern Syria and transporting them to Azerbaijan to fight against Artsakh. Given Russia’s multiple interests in cooperating with Turkey, it is not surprising that he ignored Turkey’s crimes.

Pres. Putin gave an unexpected reason for blocking Turkish peacekeepers from joining Russians in Artsakh. He stated that it was because of “the bitter legacy of the past, the tragic and bloody events that took place during the First World War, the genocide. This is a factor that can be recognized or rejected; some people do and others don’t recognize it. This is not a problem for Russia; we have long recognized it. But why provoke the Armenian side by the presence of Turkish military personnel on the contact line? I believe that President Erdogan was and is fully aware of this.”

Finally, Pres. Putin justified Prime Minister Pashinyan’s agreement to cease the hostilities. He added that any rejection of the signed agreement would be “suicidal” for Armenia…. “It would be a huge mistake.” Putin also acknowledged that even though he had good relations with Armenia’s previous leaders, Russia’s relationship with Armenia did not change after Pashinyan came to power. This statement could be explained by the fact that since the Armenian opposition is critical of Pashinyan signing the ceasefire agreement, Putin is reluctant to criticize him because his opponents, should they come to power, would reject the agreement which could possibly restart the war with Azerbaijan.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

22:43
More than 49,000 refugees return to Nagorno-Karabakh - Russia’s MoD
Russian peacekeepers escorted another convoy of refugees who came back home in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) from Armenia, the Russian Defense...
22:40
World facing 'catastrophic moral failure' on vaccines, WHO chief says
The world is on the brink of a "catastrophic moral failure" if rich countries hog COVID-19 vaccine doses while the poorest suffer, the...
19:57
Armenian GM Levon Aronian to participate in the Grand Chess Tour
The Grand Chess Tour returns with five tournaments in summer 2021, after it has become clear that there won’t be a Chess Olympiad in 2021....
19:23
Traffic police: 16 vehicles taken to penalty areas over the past day
Traffic police of Armenia reports that about 16 vehicles were taken to the penalty area in the territory of Armenia  over the past day....
19:03
Lavrov: No reason to hinder the contacts of Armenian officials with Nagorno-Karabakh
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov believes there is no reason to hinder the contacts of Armenian officials with Nagorno-Karabakh. The...
18:50
Russia sends a new group of pyrotechnicians for demining works in Aghdam region
An IL-76 aircraft of the Russian Emergencies Ministry with pyrotechnicians on board flew to Ganja, the ministry reported on Monday. According to...
18:15
Arsen Torosyan appointed Chief of Staff at the Office of Prime Minister after being sacked as health minister
Armenia's Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed a decision on Monday, dismissing Eduard Aghajanyan from the post of the Chief of Staff at...
17:52
No incidents recorded across the Armenian-Azerbaijani line of contact - MoD
The operative situation across the entire contact line of the Armenian-Azerbaijan state border was stable on January 17 and in the morning of...
17:35
Russia’s FM says now not the best time to discuss Nagorno Karabakh status
The discussion of the status of Nagorno Karabakh will become possible in future, Russia’s foreign minister Sergey Lavrov said at a news...
16:05
Armenian ombudsman applies to Minsk Group co-chairs over return of POWs from Azerbaijan
Armenia’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan on Monday addressed an official letter to the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs and the...
15:46
Artsakh foreign minister meets with Armenian opposition figure
Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) Foreign Minister David Babayan on Monday received member of the opposition Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF,...
15:35
Trump baby blimp lands at Museum of London
A blimp depicting U.S. President Donald Trump as a snarling, nappy-wearing orange baby has found a home in one of London’s most popular...
15:23
More than 93,000 Artsakh people took temporary refuge in Armenia, official says
According to the latest data, more than 93,000 people of Artsakh took temporary refuge in Armenia during the recent war, chief advisor to the...
14:47
Artsakh reports 8 new coronavirus cases, tally reaches 2,234
Artsakh reported 8 new cases of COVID-19 on Monday, bringing the national tally to 2,234. The newly infected patients are from Noragyugh...
14:27
Arsen Torosyan to be sacked as Armenian health minister
Armenian President Armen Sarkissian has received a proposal of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan to dismiss Minister of Health Arsen Torosyan,...
14:12
You are getting worse’, opposition MP tells Armenian authorities
Back on November 14, the opposition Bright Armenia Party presented a road map on how to get Armenia out of the crisis, but all problems outlined...
13:26
Samsung's Lee sentenced to 30 months in prison in corruption retrial
Billionaire Samsung Electronics vice president Lee Jae-yong was sentenced to 2 1/2 years in prison for bribery and embezzlement on Monday at the...
13:20
Russian peacekeepers start demining outskirts of Artsakh’s Martakert
Specialists of the International Mine Action Center of the Russian Defense Ministry continue to work on demining the territory of Artsakh...
12:42
One of 3 fallen soldiers found on Sunday identified, Artsakh says
Three more bodies of fallen soldiers were found during the search operations in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) on Sunday, Hunan Tadevosyan, the head...
12:17
Around 50,000 refugees returned to Artsakh from Armenia
Russian peacekeepers escorted another convoy of refugees who came back home in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) from Armenia, the Russian Defense...
11:45
Biden fills out state department team with Obama administration veterans
U.S. President-elect Joe Biden is filling out his State Department team with a group of former career diplomats and veterans of the Obama...
11:36
Fallen soldier Vardan Amalyan would have turned 20 today
Today, January 18, marks the birthday anniversary of Armenian soldier Vardan Amalyan, who fell defending Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) in the...
11:13
Armenia’s coronavirus cases reach 164,676 on January 18
Armenia has confirmed 90 new cases of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) in a 24-hour period, bringing the national tally to 164,676 as of 11 a.m....
11:04
Armenian-American Jeff Marootian joins Joe Biden’s climate team
U.S. President-elect Joe Biden has named Armenian-American Jeff Marootian as his Special Assistant to the President for Climate and Science...
10:54
Stepantsminda-Larsi highway closed amid avalanche risk
Some roads are closed in Armenia as of Monday morning due to adverse weather conditions, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reports. In...
10:42
Azerbaijani president’s statements became slogans inspiring atrocities against Armenians in Artsakh war, ombudsman says
The statements of Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, along with other public officials and figures became slogans inspiring atrocities against...
10:16
Egypt announces major archaeological discoveries at Saqqara necropolis
Egypt has announced the discovery of a new trove of treasures at the Saqqara necropolis south of Cairo, including an ancient funerary temple,...
20:00
Service sector in Ukraine switched to official language from January 16
On January 16, the Ukrainian law on the functioning of Ukrainian as an official language came into effect, Ukrinform news agency reported....
19:30
Meetings with people in regions should be held more often, Vanetsyan says
The meeting of the representatives of the opposition Homeland Salvation Movement with residents of Vanadzor town in Armenia's Lori province...
19:00
Armenia sees decline in pastry, ice cream production
The pastry production volumes have dropped in Armenia in January-November 2020, the country's Statistical Committee reported in its updated...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}