Politics 10:13 24/02/2021 Armenia

Analysis: Erdogan’s tightrope walk between East and West may soon collapse

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

Ever since Pres. Joe Biden’s election last November, hundreds of articles have been published around the world analyzing the problematic relations between Turkey and the United States. Pres. Biden has made no secret of his dislike, if not outright hostility, toward Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

The main points of contention between the United States and Turkey are as follows:

1) U.S. support for Kurdish allies in Syria which Turkey considers terrorists;

2) Turkey’s purchase of S-400 Russian missiles which could expose NATO’s military technology to Moscow. As a result, the United States cancelled the sale of advanced F-35 jets and imposed sanctions on Turkey;

3) U.S. refusal to extradite the Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen whom Turkey falsely accuses of inciting the coup d'état against Erdogan in 2016;

4) Turkey’s abysmal record on human rights with the jailing of thousands of innocent civilians, journalists and judges on trumped up charges which Pres. Biden finds unacceptable.

Pres. Erdogan is following the strategy practiced by the Ottoman Empire of manipulating rival European powers against each other, by switching sides and changing partners. For example, he has declared himself to be the defender of all Muslims and particularly Palestinians, while engaging in a military partnership with Israel until recently. Another example is Turkey’s membership in the Western military alliance of NATO, while purchasing billions of dollars of sophisticated Russian missiles which are incompatible with NATO and U.S. weapons. At the same time, Erdogan is cozying up to Russia while involved in a military conflict with Russia in Syria and Libya. Turkey and Russia, two normally antagonistic countries, have also managed to find a modus vivendi in the Artsakh conflict.

The souring of relations between the U.S. and Turkey dates back to the time of Obama’s presidency, during which Biden served as Vice President. Erdogan was annoyed with Obama after an initial friendship. However, the Turkish leader developed a privileged relationship with the United States after Donald Trump became President. It is still unclear what prompted such a warm personal affection between the two. Was it Trump’s financial interests in Turkey or his bizarre fondness for tyrants around the world? We may never know.

Nevertheless, Biden fired the first shot in a December 2019 interview with the New York Times in which he called Erdogan an ‘autocrat’ and stated that the United States should support Turkish opposition leaders “to be able to take on and defeat Erdogan. Not by a coup, but by the electoral process.”

The next awkward situation arose when Erdogan congratulated Biden a few days after the November election. Four months later, Biden has still not contacted Erdogan even though he has called many other world leaders. Erdogan must be deeply offended by this diplomatic snub.

The first indication of the Biden administration’s tough policy on Turkey became evident on January 19, 2021, during Secretary of State nominee Antony Blinken’s Senate Foreign Relations Committee confirmation hearing, when he pointedly called Turkey a “so-called strategic partner” and raised the possibility of imposing more sanctions on that country. “The idea that a strategic -- so-called strategic partner of ours -- would actually be in line with one of our biggest strategic competitors in Russia is not acceptable,” Blinken said. “I think we need to take a look to see the impact that the existing sanctions have had and then determine whether more needs to be done.”

Blinken’s critical comments on Turkey were later reaffirmed by US national security advisor Jake Sullivan who described Turkey as “an ally that in many ways... is not acting as an ally and this is a very, very significant challenge for us and we’re very clear-eyed about it.” Sullivan placed Turkey in the same category as China.

On Feb. 5, 2021, the Pentagon confirmed that the Biden administration has no intention to lift the sanctions on Turkey for purchasing the Russian missiles. Turkey’s “decision to purchase the S-400 is inconsistent with Turkey’s commitments as a U.S. and NATO ally,” Pentagon Press Secretary John Kirby said. “Our position has not changed…. We urge Turkey not to retain the S-400 system…. Turkey had multiple opportunities over the last decade to purchase the Patriot defense system from the United States and instead chose to purchase the S-400, which provides Russia revenue, access and influence,” Kirby said.

To make matters worse, Turkish Interior Minister Suleyman Soylu repeated in early February the baseless accusation that the United States was behind the abortive Turkish coup in 2016. State Department spokesman Ned Price issued a sharp rebuke, calling the allegations made by the Turkish Minister as “wholly false.” They “are inconsistent with Turkey’s status as a NATO ally and strategic partner of the United States,” added Price.

Another contentious issue is the in absentia Turkish trial of American professor Henri Barkey of Lehigh University on false charges of aiding the 2016 coup. The US State Department called the accusations against Prof. Barkey baseless.

On Feb. 10, 2021, the U.S. State Department called on Turkey to immediately release from jail Turkish philanthropist and human rights activist Osman Kavala who has been detained for more than three years without a conviction. Kavala was falsely accused of trying to overthrow the Turkish government with Prof. Barkey during the 2016 failed coup. The State Dept. urged Turkey to comply with a European Court of Human Rights ruling in late 2019 that Kavala be released.

On February 15, 2021, when Blinken finally called Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu, he urged Turkey not to retain the Russian S-400 surface-to-air missile system.

Last December, when the United States placed sanctions against Turkey for the purchase of the Russian missiles, the Turkish Foreign Ministry arrogantly warned: “Turkey will take the necessary steps against this decision, which will negatively affect our relations and will retaliate in a manner and timing it deems appropriate.”

Turkey is still attempting to find a way to circumvent the U.S. sanctions. On February 1, 2021, it hired Arnold & Porter, a major American lobbying firm in Washington, D.C., to resolve the dispute with the U.S. government over the Russian missiles. The contract was signed with the Ankara-based SSTEK Defense Industry Technologies, owned by the Presidency of Defense Industries (SSB), Ankara’s main defense industry authority. SSTEK agreed to pay Arnold & Porter $750,000 for the six months to give Turkey “strategic advice and outreach” to U.S. authorities.

It is highly doubtful that Turkey will be able to resolve the dispute regarding the Russian missiles through its hired lobbyist. Interestingly, the contract with SSTEK specified that Arnold & Porter “does not make any promises or guarantees” about the outcome. “If the matter does not reach a successful conclusion, for any reason, SSTEK shall still be responsible for all fees and disbursements charged by the firm under the terms of this agreement.” It is noteworthy that at a time when the Turkish economy is on the verge of collapse and the Turkish people are in dire financial straits, Pres. Erdogan is wasting $750,000 of Turkish taxpayers’ money on useless lobbying.

It remains to be seen if Turkey’s tightrope walking skills will succeed to maintain the Russian missiles and evade the U.S. sanctions. Should Turkey be forced to get rid of the missiles, it will have to face the consequences of a major disruption in its relations with Russia. Turkey will then have to choose either the East or the West. It will no longer be able to fool both sides. Biden and Blinken are too experienced to fall for Erdogan’s tricks.

The title of a recent article by journalist Nicholas Morgan describes best the state of U.S.-Turkish relations: "Is Turkey Biden's Ally from Hell?" We will find out shortly.



Source Panorama.am
Share |

Newsfeed

12:00
Texas governor issues disaster declaration as wildfires spread
"Devastating" wildfires in Texas have prompted a disaster declaration for dozens of counties and evacuation orders in parts of the...
11:35
U.S. continues to encourage Armenia, Azerbaijan to reach lasting agreement
The Unites States continues to encourage Armenia and Azerbaijan to try to reach a durable and lasting agreement, U.S. State Department spokesman...
11:16
Aliyev asks the Arab League and Turkey to pressure PACE to readmit Azerbaijan
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev repeatedly states: “I don’t...
11:01
Impunity of Baku's illegal use of force resulted in new territorial claims against Armenia, FM tells UN
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan delivered remarks at the High-level Segment of the 55th session of the Human Rights...
17:00
Temperatures to reach 16C in parts of Armenia
No precipitation is expected in Armenia in the next few days. Temperatures are set to gradually rise by 6-8C starting from Wednesday....
16:56
Opposition MP slams Pashinyan's foreign policy
Opposition MP Armen Rustamyan has denounced the “destructive” foreign policy pursued by Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and...
16:30
Armenian CEC members observe elections in Belarus
The deputy chair of Armenia’s Central Electoral Commission (CEC), Nune Hovhannisyan, and CEC member Silva Markosyan travelled to the...
16:05
Azerbaijan continues vandalizing and destroying Armenian monuments – Foreign Ministry
Azerbaijan continues the policy aimed at erasing the Armenian traces in the territories under its control, vandalizing and destroying Armenian...
15:33
Minister: One child wounded in Artsakh fuel depot blast continues treatment abroad
Most of the Armenians, who were wounded in a huge explosion at a fuel depot in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) in September 2023 and later moved...
15:02
Harry Potter first edition book sells for £11,000
A first-edition Harry Potter novel that was bought for 13p almost 30 years ago has sold at auction for £11,000, the BBC reports....
14:38
Parliament speaker rejects 'unacceptable' snap elections in Armenia
Speaker of the National Assembly Alen Simonyan claims snap elections in Armenia are "unacceptable". “The elections...
14:12
Azerbaijan destroys Alexander Myasnikyan statue in Stepanakert
Azerbaijan has destroyed the statue of prominent Soviet Armenian politician, academic and literary critic Alexander Myasnikyan located on...
13:33
Parliament speaker: I don't mind living in peace with Azerbaijan and Turkey
No information on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s visit to Armenia is currently available, Armenian National Assembly Speaker...
12:59
Hungarian parliament clears path for Sweden's Nato membership
Sweden has cleared its final obstacle to joining Nato after Hungary's parliament voted to ratify the bid, BBC News reported. The...
12:51
Armenian parliament to elect new top court judge at plenary session
The National Assembly of Armenia started a plenary session on Tuesday with 28 items on the agenda. Lawmakers are set to elect a new judge of...
12:26
Parents sue Armenian education minister over history textbook
Parents of school students have sued Armenian Minister of Education, Science, Culture and Sports Zhanna Andreasyan over the 7th grade history...
11:53
Pashinyan off to Greece with wife
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his spouse Anna Hakobyan have travelled to Greece on a working visit, the prime minister's...
11:32
Soprano Juliana Grigoryan wins Hildegard Behrens Prize
The Hildegard Behrens Foundation has announced that the 14th annual Hildegard Behrens Prize was awarded to Metropolitan Opera Lindemann Young...
11:15
Serzh Sargsyan meets with representatives of regional chess federations
A conference with representatives of regional federations, that was organized by the Armenian Chess Federation, took place at the Chess Academy...
11:00
Armenian FM meets with ICRC chief in Geneva
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan had a meeting with Mirjana Spoljaric Egger, President of the International Committee of Red...
17:00
Armenian, Azeri FMs to meet in Berlin in late February
The delegations led by Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov will meet in Berlin on February...
16:45
Lord Jacob Rothschild dies at 87
Financier, philanthropist, and head of the Rothschild family, Lord Jacob Rothschild, has died aged 87, The Independent reports. The...
16:36
MP Gevorg Papoyan steps down
Ruling Civil Contract faction MP Gevorg Papoyan has resigned his seat in the Armenian parliament.  The deputy submitted his...
16:15
Pro-government MP comments on Zelensky's possible visit to Armenia
MP Babken Tunyan, who represents Armenia’s ruling Civil Contract party, has reacted to reports of Ukrainian President Volodymyr...
15:35
Analyst names Pashinyan's main 'weapon' in possible snap elections
Political analyst Suren Surenyants believes outright anti-Russian policy and Armenia’s promised withdrawal from the CSTO will be Prime...
15:03
SJC dismisses judge Arshak Vardanyan
Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) has dismissed judge Arshak Vardanyan of the Criminal Court of Appeals at his own request, the...
14:35
Kremlin insists on clarity from Armenia over CSTO
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov says that there is no clarity yet on Armenia's position on its withdrawal from the Russian-led...
14:05
Fallen soldier's father to undergo heart surgery today
The health condition of Garik Galeyan, whose soldier son Mkhitar was killed in the 2020 Artsakh war, has stabilized and he is preparing for...
13:30
Armenian State Symphony Orchestra donates to UNICEF for Armenia refugee response
The Foundation for the Support of the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra announced today a donation of US$ 12,000 to UNICEF Armenia in support of...
13:14
Opposition MP blames Armenian authorities for failure to counter Azeri propaganda
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has blamed the Armenian authorities for failure to counter the false Azerbaijani propaganda narrative regarding...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}