Politics 10:44 03/03/2021 Armenia

Analysis: ‘Unexploded’ Russian missiles in Artsakh cause a political explosion in Armenia

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

Words have meanings and consequences as Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan found out when he told a journalist last week that the powerful Russian Iskander missiles, supposedly fired by Armenia during the Artsakh War last November, “did not explode or exploded 10%.” This surprising statement was in response to an interview by previous President Serzh Sargsyan in which he asked why Pashinyan had not ordered the use of the Iskander missiles during the early part of the Artsakh War.

Several days after the Prime Minister's highly controversial statement, his spokeswoman announced that Pashinyan "was not briefed correctly regarding the Russian missiles.” But it was too late. The damage was done.

No one could have predicted the chain of unexpected events that followed Pashinyan’s words questioning the merits of the Iskander missiles that Russia had exported exclusively to Armenia. A large number of Russian military experts and political leaders reacted very harshly to Pashinyan’s statement viewing it as disparaging of the prized missiles of Russia and the prestige of its defense industry.

However, the reaction within Armenia was no less devastating. When First Deputy Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces Tiran Khachatryan, a Lieutenant General, was asked to comment on Pashinyan’s statement about the Iskander missiles not exploding, he responded with a chuckle that it was not possible and not serious.

Upon hearing of this slight, Prime Minister Pashinyan immediately ordered the firing of the Deputy General Staff. His dismissal was endorsed by Pres. Armen Sarkissian, according to the process outlined in the constitution. The Prime Minister had surely overreacted to Khachatryan’s snub, particularly since Pashinyan himself had appointed him in June 2020 and awarded him the prestigious “National Hero” medal for his outstanding role during the Artsakh War.

In retaliation, dozens of top Armenian military leaders released a joint statement on Feb. 25, 2021, demanding the resignation of the Prime Minister and his government. The statement was signed by Onik Gasparyan, Chief of the General Staff and 40 other high-ranking military Officers, including 17 generals and Commanders of all five Army Corps. Later, several other military and police officials added their signatures.

The military’s statement expressed its “resolute protest” against the “short-sighted and baseless” dismissal of the First Deputy Chief of the General Staff “without taking into account the national and state interests of the Republic of Armenia, solely based on personal and pretentious sentiments.” The statement added that “in such difficult conditions for the country, such a decision is an anti-state and irresponsible step. The Prime Minister and his government are no longer able to make adequate decisions in this critical and fateful situation for the Armenian people. The Armed Forces, for a long time, patiently tolerated the ‘attacks’ by the incumbent authorities to discredit the Armed Forces, but everything has its limits…. The current authorities’ unproductive governing and the most serious errors exhibited in foreign policy have brought the country to the brink of collapse. Based on the created situation, the Armed Forces demand the resignation of the Prime Minister and the government….”

Pashinyan immediately announced on his Facebook page the firing of the Chief of the General Staff. The Prime Minister called the military’s statement “an attempted military coup,” urging his supporters to gather at the Republic Square where he joined them and marched in Yerevan streets holding a megaphone. This was a highly irresponsible act on the part of Pashinyan, venturing to the streets during what he described as an attempted military coup, which could have led to tragic consequences for the country had anyone harmed him.

After Pashinyan ordered the firing of Onig Gasparyan, Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces, Pres. Sarkissian, having consulting all sides of the political spectrum, refused to sign the Prime Minister’s order, calling it unconstitutional. The Prime Minister then submitted a second dismissal request to the President. Should the President refuse to sign the order for a second time, then the issue will be submitted to the constitutional court for its final decision. It is curious as to why the President endorsed the Prime Minister’s earlier order to sack the First Deputy of the General Staff but refused to sign the order to dismiss the Chief of the General Staff. After all, the First Deputy Chief of the General Staff’s wrongdoing was simply chuckling at the Prime Minister’s statement about the Russian missiles, whereas his boss, the Chief of the General Staff, demanded the Prime Minister’s resignation.

In the meantime, the Armenian military took no further steps beyond its call for the resignation of the Prime Minister which the Prime Minister wrongly described as an attempted coup. However, the statement could be viewed as interference in political affairs which violates the constitution. It is clear that the military’s intent is having the Prime Minister resign without taking any military actions.

Turning to the unconstitutionality of the military’s statement, there are counter points to this argument. The military stated that they could no longer remain quiet while the country is on the brink of collapse. The national interest of Armenia has to be of paramount importance. After all, the military is the guardian of the nation’s security. Furthermore, Pashinyan and his supporters cannot all of a sudden claim to be defenders of the constitution, when they have been violating many of its provisions in the past three years. The Prime Minister has repeatedly pressured the courts and has stacked the Constitutional Court with his allies to get verdicts desired by the government. Pashinyan and his supporters similarly pressured Pres. Sarkissian to force him to sign the Prime Minister’s order. Ironically, the democratic principles endorsed by Pashinyan when coming to power have dissipated turning the country into a one-man rule, a dictatorship. Given the Prime Minister’s partisans’ overwhelming majority in Parliament, other voices have been mostly muzzled. All suggestions to form a government of competent experts have been ignored, leaving Pashinyan with a mediocre and incompetent cadre of officials and advisors.

Pashinyan’s only important attribute is that he is not corrupt -- which is very positive, but that alone is not enough to lead the state through such turbulent waters. After all, Armenians are not looking for a saint, but a competent leader who can solve the country’s complex problems.

Furthermore, Pashinyan and his followers did not always practice what they are preaching now. Back in 2018, when there were widespread street protests by Pashinyan and his supporters, a large number of Armenian soldiers illegally left their barracks and marched with the demonstrators. Even though this was a violation of military rules and interference in politics, Pashinyan did not take any action against these soldiers. In a similar situation occurred in 1998, when Defense Minister Vazgen Sargsyan forced then President Levon Ter-Petrosyan to resign. No one complained that it was unconstitutional.

Shortly after this new crisis in Armenia, leaders in Azerbaijan and Turkey issued self-serving statements on the situation in Armenia. In my opinion, both of these countries, led by dictators, are in no position to comment on developments in Armenia, let alone give Armenians lectures about democracy. They should look at themselves in the mirror and keep their mouths shut.

Having suffered a devastating defeat at the hands of our enemies in the Artsakh War, Armenians cannot afford now to attack each other. We need to place the national interest above all else. Having lost most of Artsakh and thousands of soldiers, let’s not risk losing Armenia itself.

Pashinyan, the leader of the ‘Velvet Revolution,’ should not have told his followers last week that there will be no more ‘velvet’ which could be interpreted as a threat to anyone who disagrees with him. Should the military also adopt a no velvet approach, the outcome would be tragic for the entire Armenian nation. The best solution would be for the Prime Minister, having lost territories and thousands of soldiers, to resign by his own volition without facing any threats or protests. Otherwise, having demanded Pashinyan’s resignation, the military leaders may carry out their demand by force, to ensure that they themselves are not arrested. Such a group arrest would deprive Armenia of its entire military leadership. Months from now, under calmer conditions, new parliamentary elections should take place with a clean slate, hopefully excluding Pashinyan and the other former leaders. The people have the right to decide by a majority vote who their new leader should be.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

20:27
FM hopes the Minsk Group will not follow but lead the processes around Nagorno-Karabakh peace process
The last two statements issued by the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs reflect concerns raised by the Armenian side, Armenia's acting FM Ara...
20:03
Armenia’s Military Police celebrate 29th anniversary
May 5 is marked in the Armenian Armed Forces calendar as the Military Police Day.On the occasion of the day, a solemn event marking the Military...
19:11
We are ready to assume the responsibility to ensure the security of our country - Artur Sargsyan
"We are living through a decisive and major historical moment. 'Resurgent Armenia' party has committed to give a new birth to our...
18:00
Artsakh FM raises the with UN agencies the issue of forced evictions carried out by Azerbaijan in Shushi
Minister of Foreign Affairs of t Artsakh David Babayan sent letters on Wednesday to the UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and specialized...
17:05
Armenian servicemen killed as a result of a violation of arms handling rules
A serviceman of the Armenian Armed Forces was killed on Wednesday in the defence area of one of the military bases located in the southern...
16:30
Earthquake recorded near the Armenia-Nakhichevan border zone
An earthquake of 2.6 magnitude was registered 8km northwest of Elpin village in Vayots Dzor province near the the Armenia-Nakhijevan border on...
16:10
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin deplores Azerbaijani policy of cultural genocide
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin noted with sorrow that during the Artsakh second war and in the post-war period  Azerbaijan has not stopped...
15:31
US air base becomes focus of US-Turkey relations again
Turkey’s Incirlik Air Base is once again at the center of debates over Ankara-Washington relations, following US President Joe...
14:57
Farmer accidentally moves 200-year-old French border with Belgium
A farmer has - perhaps unwittingly - moved Belgium's border with France. The man moved an 150-kilogram stone so he could extend the...
14:46
Armenia’s ambassador meets with Iranian defense minister
Armenia’s Ambassador to Iran Artashes Toumanian held a meeting with Iranian Defense Minister Amir Hatami on May 2. The Armenian...
14:36
ALERT: Armenian cemetery in Azeri-held Mets Tagher village destroyed
An Armenian cemetery in the village of Mets Tagher in the Azerbaijani-held Hadrut region of Artsakh has recently been destroyed, Caucasus...
14:08
Former Azerbaijani political prisoner Bayram Mammadov found dead in Istanbul
On the night of May 5, the body of former Azerbaijani political prisoner Bayram Mammadov was removed from the water in Istanbul. The police...
14:01
‘We don’t want to live anywhere else’: People displaced from Hadrut hold rally outside Armenian Foreign Ministry
People displaced from the Hadrut region of Artsakh on Wednesday held a rally outside the building of the Armenian Foreign Ministry ahead of...
13:16
Artsakh reports 7 new COVID cases
Artsakh confirmed 7 new coronavirus infections in 24 hours, bringing the country total to 2,686, the Ministry of Health said on Wednesday....
13:05
UK government to offer over 50s third coronavirus vaccine shot in autumn
Everyone aged over 50 in the UK will be offered a third Covid-19 vaccination in the autumn in an attempt to eradicate the threat from the...
12:48
Ombudsman's representatives visit repatriated Armenian POWs
Representatives of Armenia’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan on Wednesday met with three Armenian prisoners of war (POWs)...
12:29
Biden considering LA Mayor Eric Garcetti as ambassador to India
U.S. President Joe Biden is reportedly considering Mayor Eric Garcetti for an ambassadorship, possibly to India, City News Service...
12:16
Aivazian, Lavrov to sum up their talks at joint news conference
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov will arrive in Armenia on a working visit on Wednesday, May 5. He is expected to meet with...
11:49
Minor quake hits near Armenian village of Yelpin
The Territorial Survey for Seismic Protection of Armenia’s Ministry of Emergency Situations detected a magnitude 2.3 earthquake in Armenia...
11:38
Armenia reports 493 new coronavirus cases, 13 more deaths on May 5
Armenia has confirmed 493 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 217,900 as of 11 a.m. Wednesday, May 5, the...
11:29
Rep. Schiff: Murder of 19 Armenian POWs further evidence of Azerbaijan’s grotesque disregard for international law
Congressman Adam Schiff renewed call for immediate action against Azerbaijan and end of U.S. military assistance to the regime in Baku following...
11:05
Andranik Iosifyan House-Museum to open in Artsakh’s Tsmakahogh village
The village of Tsmakahogh in Artsakh’s Martakert region is known to many as the birthplace of engineer, physicist and inventor Andranik...
10:44
1 killed, 6 injured in Israeli missile attack on northwest Syria
Israel fired missiles toward northwest Syria early Wednesday, killing one person and wounding six, AP reported, citing Syrian state media....
10:33
Armenian ombudsman: From now on, Azerbaijani president’s statements will be subject to special monitoring
Armenia’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan has sent official letters to the OSCE chief and the Minsk Group co-chairs,...
10:11
How can the Armenian Patriarch be as pro-Turkish as Erdogan?
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier The Armenian Patriarch of Turkey, Sahak Mashalian, once again issued a pro-Turkish...
21:01
Armenian court sentences two Syrian mercenaries to life in prison
A court in Armenia’s southern Syunik Province on Tuesday handed life sentences to two Syrian mercenaries who were captured while...
20:26
No incidents reported at Armenian-Azerbaijani border – Defense Ministry
The operational and tactical situation did not change along the entire length of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border on 3 and 4 May with no border...
20:17
Artsakh Foreign Ministry welcomes MEPs’ letter calling for release of Armenian POWs
The Artsakh Foreign Ministry on Tuesday welcomed the letter of over 120 members of the European Parliament (MEPs) urging European Commission...
19:54
MP Anna Kostanyan urges action to save Armenian cultural heritage of Artsakh
Under the guise of “restoration”, Azerbaijan is dismantling and destroying one of the most important Armenian cultural values, the...
19:16
Armenia’s caretaker FM holds phone call with Kyrgyz counterpart
Interim Foreign Minister of Armenia Ara Aivazian on Tuesday held a telephone conversation with his Kyrgyz counterpart Ruslan Kazakbaev....

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}