Politics 11:47 24/03/2021 Armenia

Why did the Superior Court reject Governor’s denial of Sassounian’s pardon

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

Last month, California Superior Court Judge William C. Ryan rejected Gov. Gavin Newsom’s refusal to accept the Parole Board’s decision to release Hampig Sassounian from jail. I was under the wrong impression that the Governor’s decision on pardons was final and not subject to a review or reversal by the courts. It turns out that the law requires the Governor to consider “all relevant, reliable information available” and his parole decisions must not be arbitrary or capricious. This article is based on a copy of the Judge’s 19-page ruling.

Hampig Sassounian, not related to this writer, was convicted on June 29, 1984 of first degree murder and sentenced to life without the possibility of parole, but was resentenced to a term of 25 years to life in 2002, making him eligible for parole. Sassounian assassinated Turkish Consul General Kemal Arikan in Los Angeles on January 28, 1982 when he was 19 years old. He is now 58.

On December 27, 2019, the Board of Parole Hearings, found Sassounian suitable for release on parole. However, on May 25, 2020, Gov. Newsom rejected the Board’s decision based on the prisoner’s crime, “outsized political import,” and that his insight was “relatively new.”

On August 14, 2020, Sassounian filed a petition to the Superior Court challenging the Governor’s reversal of the Parole Board’s decision. He argued that the Governor’s decision is not supported by evidence that he posed an unreasonable danger to society, if released. Sassounian also contended that the “Governor imposed an unlawfully heightened standard of parole suitability illegally founded upon the circumstances of Sassounian’s life crime.” He contended that there is no evidence that he lacked “insight” and “the Governor’s conclusion that Sassounian has not demonstrated insight ‘for a sufficiently long period’ is an illegal reason to deny parole.”

On October 7, 2020, the court issued an Order to Show Cause. The Governor’s office filed its response on January 11, 2021, repeating the reasons why he refused parole for the prisoner. Sassounian then submitted his response on January 26, 2021 rejecting the Governor’s claims against him.

Judge Ryan ruled that Sassounian’s record does not contain any evidence to support the Governor’s contention that he is not suitable for release on parole. In addition, the Judge found that the Governor used an improper standard when considering both the “import” of Sassounian’s offense and the notoriety of his victim, as well as the recency of his insight. Therefore, the Judge ordered the release of Sassounian from jail.

Judge Ryan, in his verdict, mentioned Sassounian’s description of his background “as an Armenian born and raised until the age of 13 in Lebanon. During this time, they lived in an ‘active war zone and would routinely see dead bodies,’ including those of women and children. His father was an alcoholic who was often gone for weeks at a time, though Petitioner [Sassounian] had a good, loving relationship with his mother. He lived with his many siblings and extended family members, including his grandparents who were victims of the ‘Armenian Genocide.’ His grandmother often told Petitioner of how she lost her entire family to the genocide and that she only narrowly escaped death herself.”

The Judge continued: “At 13, his [Sassounian’s] family immigrated to the United States to escape the violence in Lebanon, but the family dynamic remained challenging. They moved to Pasadena where there was a large Armenian population. He joined the Armenian Boy Scouts and the Armenian Youth Federation. This is where he met his crime partner, Krikor ‘Koko’ Saliba. They became friendly a year or two before the crime and would discuss politics and the history between Armenia and Turkey, including the genocide. They also noted and discussed that there were ‘a lot of political assassinations going on’ at the time. That is, ‘Armenians were assassinating Turkish diplomats in Europe mostly because they were angry that … after the genocide Turkey would deny the genocide…. Young Armenians were upset about this and -- they thought that -- Turkey should step up and acknowledge the genocide…and get into dialogue with the Armenian people or make peace with them.’ Because this was not happening, ‘young Armenians decided to resort to violence….[They had] given up that… peaceful dialogue with Turkey was… going to happen.’ During this time Petitioner [Sassounian] and his crime partner, who was a few years older than Petitioner, discussed going to Europe to carry out an assassination like they had been seeing take place. At some point, Arikan, however, made a public address calling all Armenians ‘liars’ and declared there was no Armenian genocide. Saliba showed Petitioner an article regarding Arikan’s statement. ‘Being the grandsons of survivors of the Armenian genocide, we took that to be very insulting. And we took very deep offense about that.’”

Judge Ryan decided that “there is no evidence in the record to support the Governor’s finding of lack of insight, such the commitment offense of nearly 40 years is still probative of Petitioner’s current dangerousness.”

The Judge challenged the Governor’s contention that Sassounian’s insight into his crime was “very recent.” Judge Ryan stated that “the case law establishes there is no predetermined amount of time an inmate must demonstrate or possess insight such that it is sufficient for the purposes of suitability.” The Judge ruled that “the insight standard the Governor used to guide his decision was incorrect… and held Sassounian to a different ‘arbitrary’ standard.”

Regarding the issue of Sassounian being a danger to society, “the court notes that the psychologist found Petitioner to represent a low risk of violence upon release,” wrote the Judge. “Petitioner wrote a victim apology letter to Mr. Arikan’s family, friends, and colleagues, as well as one to the ‘Nation of Turkey, the Turkish government, and Turkish Communities of the World,’” stated Judge Ryan. “The court finds the Governor’s decision was both arbitrary and procedurally flawed,” ruled the Judge. He also noted that Sassounian “has comprehensive release plans for both the United States and Armenia.” This is in reference to Sassounian’s statement that he may relocate to Armenia after his release from prison.

At the end, the Judge pronounced that Sassounian “committed a murder for which he has been appropriately punished…. The Governor’s reversal is vacated, the Board’s grant of parole from December 27, 2019, is hereby reinstated. The Board is directed ‘to proceed in accordance with its usual procedures for release of an inmate on parole unless within 30 days of the finality of this decision the Board determines in good faith that cause for rescission of parole may exist and initiates appropriate proceedings to determine that question.’” Gov. Newsom decided not to appeal the Judge’s ruling, allowing the pardon go into effect which would set Sassounian free shortly.

In my opinion, violence is never justified regardless of the reason. Consul General Arikan was not guilty of committing genocide against the Armenian people. He was not even born during the genocide. Armenians have demands from the Government of Turkey, not individual Turks. Sassounian committed a crime for which he was punished by serving almost 40 years in jail. The complaints by the Turkish government about Sassounian’s release are not credible. The Turkish government pressured the Federal Government to urge Gov. Newsom in 2020 and previously Gov. Brown in 2017 to reject the Parole Board’s decisions to release Sassounian. Even less credible, not to say completely shameful, are the protests of the Azerbaijani government against Sassounian’s release. Azerbaijan awarded Azeri axe murderer Ramil Safarov the title of national hero for butchering an Armenian soldier while he was sleeping. Safarov served not a single day in jail in Azerbaijan after his extradition from Hungary.

Finally, it is completely unacceptable that the Turkish Government would demand excessive punishment for an Armenian who murdered a Turk, while Turkey itself continues to deny the mass murder of 1.5 million innocent Armenians. Only after the Turkish government acknowledges the Armenian Genocide and makes appropriate amends for it, Armenians can consider apologizing for the murder of a single Turk!



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

14:58
The European Union committed to supporting a stable, democratic and prosperous future of Armenia
Spokesperson for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy of the European Union Nabila Massrali has issued a statement on the conduct of the early...
14:48
Russian Ambassador comments on possible deployment of Russian border guards on Armenian-Azerbaijani border
"The OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs plan to visit the region, however, I do not have information about the dates and other details,"...
14:31
Iran congratulates Armenia on successful parliamentary election
Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Saeed Khatibzadeh in a message congratulated Armenian people and representatives on the 2021 Armenian...
14:26
CEC publishes the signed voters' lists of snap parliamentary elections
Central Electoral Commission (CEC) of Armenia has published the signed lists of the voters who participated in the June 20 elections to the...
13:38
Robert Kocharyan: If the authorities continue their work-style, it may result in new snap elections
Armenia's ex-president Robert Kocharyan stated on Tuesday that the strategy of "Armenia" bloc in the parliament is under...
12:35
Armenia reports 77 new COVID-19 cases, 4 deaths on June 22
Armenia has confirmed 77 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 224,330 as of 11 a.m. Tuesday, June 22, the...
12:31
US State Department shares ODIHR’s concern regarding intense polarization and inflammatory rhetoric during the Armenian elections
"The United States congratulates the people of Armenia on their June 20 parliamentary elections. We welcome the overall positive assessment...
12:02
Robert Kocharyan: Proud to have such an electorate
Armenia's ex-President Robert Kocharyan expressed gratitude to all citizens who voted for 'Armenia' bloc during the Sunday's...
11:22
About 150 pilgrims and residents of Nagorno-Karabakh visited Amaras and Gandzasar Christian monasteries
As part of the implementation of the trilateral statement of the leaders of Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia of November 9, 2020, Russian...
10:39
A grenade thrown under the car of former MP Mihran Hakobyan
In the morning of June 21, unidentified people have thrown a grenade under the car of Mihran Hakobyan, political analyst Hrant...
10:24
Observers should not be rubber stamps for Pashinyan’s Civil Contract - 'Armenia' bloc
'Armenia' bloc led b ex-president Robert Kocharyan has issued a statement about the international observers' assessment on the early...
20:27
Stepanakert residents demand the resignation of Arayik Harutyunyan
Dozens of residents of the Artsakh capital city Stepanakert gathered on Monday at the central Revival square to demand the resignation of the...
20:18
Three more bodies found during search operations, Artsakh emergency service says
Three more bodies were found during the search operations in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) on Monday, June 21, the State Service of Emergency...
19:35
'I'm Honoured' bloc: The struggle will go on
"The June 20 elections in Armenia failed to become elections for the provision of security for Armenia and Artsakh, restoration of the...
19:05
Summer conscription kicks off in Armenia
The Summer 2021 military draft has launched in Armenia, the press service at the Ministry of Defense reported. According to the source, first...
18:44
Russian FM: Too early to speak about Armenian elections’ impacts on situation in Karabakh
It is too early to speak about any impacts of the parliamentary elections in Armenia that were held just on Sunday on the situation in...
18:39
Russia to discuss ‘pulling Ukraine into NATO’ with Turkey shortly — Lavrov
Russia plans to discuss the topic of pulling Ukraine into NATO during the upcoming contacts with Turkey, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov...
17:52
"Armenia" bloc to apply to the Constitutional Court to dispute the results of the early parliamentary elections
'Armenia' bloc, led by ex-president Robert Kocharyan, insists there are serious grounds to declare Sunday’s early parliamentary...
17:28
Armenia’s early parliamentary elections were polarized and marred by aggressive rhetoric, international observers say
Armenia’s early parliamentary elections were competitive and well-managed within a short time frame. However, they were characterized by...
15:50
Air temperature to reach +40°C in Yerevan
Due to the penetration of the tropical warm air wave from the Arabian Desert, on 21-24 June high thermal background is expected throughout the...
14:59
Up to 10,000 Japanese fans to be permitted at Tokyo Olympic venues
Up to 10,000 Japanese fans will be permitted at Tokyo 2020 Olympic venues, despite warnings from health bosses, BBC Sport reports. ...
14:44
Republic Party issues statement after Sunday’s snap elections
The Council of Aram Sargsyan’s Republic (Hanrapetutyun) Party, which gained 3.04% of the vote in Sunday’s snap parliamentary...
14:11
EU extends sanctions against Crimea by one year
The EU has renewed the sanctions against Crimea within the strategy approved in 2014, which does not recognize the peninsula’s...
13:57
Armenia’s Investigative Committee prepares 87 materials on apparent hindrance to exercise of voting rights in Sunday's elections
As of 9am Monday, 87 materials on apparent hindrance to the exercise of voting rights during Sunday’s snap parliamentary elections...
13:31
Search for Artsakh war casualties continues in Varanda region
Search operations for casualties of the 2020 Artsakh war continue today in the Varanda (Fizuli) region under Azerbaijan’s control. One...
13:06
Tigran Urikhanyan: We have a ‘lot of work to do’ despite not being elected to parliament
Tigran Urikhanyan, the leader of the Our Home is Armenia Party, which garnered 0.95% of the vote in Sunday’s snap parliamentary elections...
12:49
UK mulls removing self-isolation for double-vaccinated
Britain is piloting a plan to ditch the self-isolation requirement for people who have received two doses of COVID-19 vaccine if they are...
12:36
CIS observers: Sunday’s elections held in accordance with Armenian legislation
Sunday’s snap parliamentary elections in Armenia were fully in line with the country’s electoral legislation and the Constitution....
12:00
Armenia adds 26 new COVID-19 cases on June 21
Armenia has confirmed 26 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 224,253 as of 11 a.m. Monday, June 21, the...
11:52
CEC chief sums up early results of Sunday’s snap elections in Armenia
Chairman of the Central Electoral Commission (CEC) Tigran Mukuchyan on Monday summed up the preliminary results of Sunday’s snap...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}