Politics 11:10 23/03/2022 Armenia

Only in Armenia: Nikol Pashinyan sued his own country in European Court

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

There might be heads of state who have sued their own governments after they were overthrown or their possessions confiscated, but, I am not aware of any leader in office who continued his pending lawsuit against his own country in a foreign court. We have the incredible case of not one, but two lawsuits filed years ago by Nikol Pashinyan against the Republic of Armenia in the European Court of Human Rights. These two lawsuits were still pending when he became Prime Minister. In addition, Alexander Arzumanyan had also a pending lawsuit against the Republic of Armenia in the European Court at the time of his appointment as Ambassador.

No one can fault citizen Pashinyan for filing the two lawsuits, long before he began serving as Prime Minister in 2018, in order to clear his name after he and his newspaper were found guilty of violating Armenian laws. However, after becoming Prime Minister, he should have withdrawn the lawsuits from the European Court and filed an appeal with Armenian courts which he has done now four years after assuming his current office. During his January 2022 “press conference,” Pashinyan admitted that he had thought about filing an appeal in Armenian courts, however, he said that he decided to wait until the European Court had made its decision. I believe it would have been more proper to withdraw the lawsuits from the European Court and file the appeal in Armenia.

Armenpress reported on Feb. 16, 2022 that “the Prosecutor-General of Armenia Artur Davtyan filed a motion in the Court of Appeal requesting to overturn the 2010 guilty verdict of Nikol Pashinyan and exonerate him. On January 19, 2010, the Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction had found Pashinyan guilty of ‘organizing mass disturbances’ during the March 1, 2008, demonstrations [which resulted in 10 deaths, burned cars and looted stores. After hiding from authorities for 16 months], Pashinyan was sentenced to seven years in prison but served a little less than two years and was released under a general amnesty. On January 18, 2022, the European Court of Human Rights issued a judgment in the case of Pashinyan vs. Armenia, which Pashinyan had filed when he was an opposition politician. The European Court recognized that Pashinyan’s right to freedom, personal immunity, as well as the right to freedom of peaceful assembly were violated.” The European Court did not award Pashinyan with any amount of money for damages or legal fees.

Interestingly, the Armenian government’s lawyer at the European Court did not present any evidence or objections to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) to defend the Armenian court’s 2010 verdict against Pashinyan. It is understandable that a government lawyer would be reluctant to present evidence of wrongdoing against his own country’s Prime Minister! The ECHR reaches all its decisions after weighing the plaintiff’s arguments against the evidence presented by the respective government. In this case, the government did not present its side of the story, since the plaintiff and the government were awkwardly on the same side. It is also important to note that the European Court only began to review Pashinyan’s lawsuit in 2019, after he became Prime Minister in 2018, which means that he had plenty of time to withdraw his petition from the European Court. Regrettably, Pashinyan’s lawsuit in the European Court against Armenia provided scandalous material to the Azeri press, publicizing it with the headline: "Pashinyan defeated Armenia in European Court."

Pashinyan’s second lawsuit in the European Court of Human Rights against the Republic of Armenia was filed by Dareskizb, the publishing company of his newspaper, Haykakan Jamanak. The newspaper had printed on October 14, 2010, an article under the headline: “Seven out of Eight are in the List,” accusing several high-ranking Armenian government officials of involvement in “drug and human trafficking and money laundering crimes.” Three of the accused officials filed a lawsuit in an Armenian court against Haykakan Jamanak for defamation. Pashinyan lost the lawsuit and the subsequent appeal.

The European Court decided in 2021 that the applicant’s rights were violated. The Government of Armenia was ordered to pay the publishing company of Pashinyan’s newspaper 9,000 euros in damages, in addition to taxes.

Alexander Arzumanyan had also filed a lawsuit against the Republic of Armenia in the European Court before being appointed Ambassador to Denmark and Norway in 2017, and additionally to Sweden in 2019. He challenged in the European Court of Human Rights his conviction by an Armenian court for his involvement in the 2008 protests following the presidential elections. He was the head of Levon Ter Petrosyan’s presidential campaign. Prior to that, Arzumanyan was Armenia’s Foreign Minister. In 2001, he became one of the founding members of the Turkish Armenian Reconciliation Commission. Following the 2008 protests, he was arrested and charged with “usurpation of State power.” On June 22, 2009, an Armenian court found him guilty of organizing mass disorder, sentenced him to five years in prison, and freed him immediately due to an amnesty. In 2009, Arzumanyan appealed to the European Court which ruled in 2021 that his rights to freedom of expression and freedom of peaceful assembly have been violated. Just like Pashinyan, Arzumanyan chose not to withdraw his lawsuit from the European Court of Human Rights after becoming an Ambassador. I don’t know why the Armenian government did not make his appointment in 2017 conditional on the withdrawal of his lawsuit. The ECHR ordered the Republic of Armenia to pay Amb. Arzumanyan 9,000 euros for damages and 2,600 euros for legal costs and expenses, in addition to taxes.

I wonder if there is any other country in the world whose Prime Minister and Ambassador had pending lawsuits against their own country in a foreign court at the time of assuming office, obliging the Republic of Armenia to pay them damages and legal fees from their own governmental budget!



Source Panorama.am
Share |

Newsfeed

17:00
Chairs of two Armenian commissions re-elected
The pro-government majority in the Armenian parliament on Thursday re-elected Garegin Baghramyan as chairman of the Public Services Regulatory...
16:31
Kazakh deputy FM reacts to Pashinyan's statement on CSTO
Kazakhstan’s Deputy Foreign Minister Roman Vassilenko has commented on Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's statement on the suspension of...
16:06
MTS Armenia donates 20% of its shares to Armenian government
The Armenian government formally accepted the donation of MTS Armenia’s shares on Thursday. At a weekly cabinet meeting, Prime...
15:33
Azerbaijan systematically destroys cultural heritage in Artsakh, expert warns
Azerbaijan systematically destroys the cultural heritage of occupied Artsakh at the state level, Cultural Ombudsman of Hayk Hovik Avanesov...
15:05
Armenian, Azeri FMs hold second round of talks in Berlin
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov started a second round of normalization talks in...
14:43
Нetq: ZCMC and GeoProMining Gold are considered assets of Russian company GeoProMining
The data available on Armenia’s State Register of Legal Entities confirms that the Russian company GeoProMining LLC owns neither Zangezur...
13:59
Mickey Mouse Funhouse to feature episode on Vardavar
Mickey Mouse Funhouse is set to feature an episode centered entirely on Vardavar, which will feature the Armenian language, the Armenian...
13:45
Freedom House: Seizure of Nagorno-Karabakh raised fears emboldened Azeri leadership could invade Armenia
Freedom in Eurasia experienced a stunning decline in 2023, largely due to the Azerbaijani regime's military conquest of Nagorno-Karabakh and...
13:16
Opposition MP slams boycott of CC judge election
Opposition Hayastan faction MP Artsvik Minasyan on Thursday attacked his pro-government colleagues for their decision to boycott the election of...
12:35
France issues stamps to honor Charles Aznavour and Missak Manouchian
French Philaposte on Tuesday issued a special collection of four stamps to pay tribute to legendary French-Armenian singer Charles Aznavour and...
12:11
Azerbaijani soldier arrested after illegally crossing into Armenia
The Azerbaijani serviceman, who illegally crossed the border into Armenia on Wednesday, has been placed under arrest. The soldier,...
11:50
ZCMC issues denial
Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine (ZCMC) issued the following statement on Thursday: "Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine Closed Joint...
11:35
US lawmakers reach tentative deal to avert government shutdown
Top US lawmakers have reached a tentative deal to avert a partial government shutdown ahead of a Friday deadline to approve funding, BBC...
11:16
European Parliament calls for sanctions against Azerbaijan
The European Parliament has adopted CFSP and CSDP reports, reiterating its principled stance on Armenia. The reports call for...
11:00
Wizz Air to launch flights between Yerevan, Budapest
From 17 June 2024 Wizz Air will start operating flights on the route Budapest-Yerevan-Budapest, the Armenia International Airports CJSC...
17:07
Russian diplomat deplores Armenian parliament speaker's 'unfriendly' comments
Russia views a remark by Armenian National Assembly Speaker Alen Simonyan who called for withdrawing Russian border guards from Zvartnots...
16:53
Armenian FM meets with German counterpart
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan has started a meeting with his German counterpart Annalena Baerbock in Berlin, the Foreign Ministry...
16:34
Mbappé meets with Macron and Qatar's emir in Paris
Kylian Mbappé (25) met with French President Emmanuel Macron and the Emir of Qatar, Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani, at a gala at the...
16:16
Armenian parliament fails to elect new top court member
The Armenian parliament failed to elect Davit Balayan as a member of the Constitution Court on Wednesday. All 32 out of 107 MPs, who took...
15:36
Alexei Navalny to be buried on Friday in Moscow
Russian opposition politician Alexei Navalny's funeral service and burial will take place in Moscow on Friday, Reuters reported, citing...
15:07
Armenia-CSTO relations remain unchanged, MP says
No progress has been made in relations between Armenia and the Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), pro-government MP...
14:34
Today marks Martiros Saryan's birth anniversary
February 28 marks the 144th birth anniversary of renowned Soviet Armenian painter Martiros Saryan, the founder of a modern Armenian...
14:00
Valuable additions to Yerevan's Matenadran continue
As part of the official visit of the Matenadaran delegation to Lebanon, they received valuable contributions to their collection. Reverend Nshan...
13:47
Meeting of Armenian, Azeri FMs kicks off in Berlin
The meeting between the delegations led by Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and Foreign Minister of Azerbaijan Jeyhun Bayramov...
13:36
Azeri soldier held after crossing into Armenia
Armenian troops neutralized an Azerbaijani serviceman who crossed the Armenian-Azerbaijani border in the area of the Tegh community in...
13:15
Former Soviet premier Nikolai Ryzhkov dies at 94
Former premier of the Soviet Union Nikolai Ryzhkov has died at the age of 94, Russia's Federation Council Speaker Valentina...
12:55
Russian company GeoProMining, which owns Armenian assets, hit by U.S. sanctions
The United States imposed fresh sanctions against Russia on February 23, targeting more than 500 individuals and entities to mark the second...
12:00
Texas governor issues disaster declaration as wildfires spread
"Devastating" wildfires in Texas have prompted a disaster declaration for dozens of counties and evacuation orders in parts of the...
11:35
U.S. continues to encourage Armenia, Azerbaijan to reach lasting agreement
The Unites States continues to encourage Armenia and Azerbaijan to try to reach a durable and lasting agreement, U.S. State Department spokesman...
11:16
Aliyev asks the Arab League and Turkey to pressure PACE to readmit Azerbaijan
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev repeatedly states: “I don’t...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}