Politics 11:34 07/12/2022 Armenia

Armenia should bring back skulls of five Genocide victims from museum in France

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

The New York Times published on November 28, 2022, a shocking article by reporter Constant Méheut, titled: “A Paris Museum Has 18,000 Skulls. It’s Reluctant to Say Whose.”

The article reveals that the Musée de l’Homme (Museum of Mankind) in Paris, France, holds a “vast collection of human remains.” Stored in the basement of that museum are “18,000 skulls that include the remains of African tribal chiefs, Cambodian rebels and Indigenous people from Oceania. Many were gathered in France’s former colonies, and the collection also includes the skulls of more than 200 Native Americans, including from the Sioux and Navajo tribes. The remains, kept in cardboard boxes stored in metal racks, form one of the world’s largest human skull collections, spanning centuries and covering every corner of the earth.” Five of the skulls belong to Armenian Genocide victims. The museum has not made public the information about the identities of the 18,000 skulls, fearing restitution lawsuits.

I read the December 15, 2021 report of a French Senate Committee on its discussion of a proposed law about the fate of the remains at the museum. During that meeting, Sen. Catherine Morin-Desailly, co-author of the proposed law, stated: “amazingly, we find in our collections skulls dating from the Armenian Genocide.” Sen. Pierre Ouzoulias, another co-author of the proposed law, added: “I was overwhelmed learning that five Armenian skulls of victims of the Armenian Genocide, which were recovered in Deir-ez Zor [Syria], are still in the collections of the Museum of Mankind.”

Since New York Times reporter Méheut mentioned in his article that he had obtained confidential documents about the human remains in the museum, I wrote to him asking if these documents contained any details about the skulls of the five Armenian Genocide victims. He informed me that they were female skulls which were collected by Emmanuel Passemard, a French prehistory specialist, during his explorations in Syria in 1925-1926. The Bulletin of the French Prehistoric Society reported that Passemard gave a lecture at the Sorbonne University in Paris on February 16, 1927, during which he described his trip to the banks of the Euphrates River in Syria.

Méheut wrote in his article that “while France has led the way in Europe in investigating and returning colonial-era collections of artifacts -- cultural objects, made by human hands -- it has lagged behind its neighbors when it comes to remains.” The claimant of the remains has to prove an ancestral connection. However, “French legislation has made any return a cumbersome and time-consuming process.”

Méheut added: “As with other 19th-century museums, the Museum of Mankind was initially a repository for items gathered from around the world. The skulls were collected during archaeological digs and colonial campaigns, sometimes by soldiers who beheaded resistance fighters. Prized by researchers working in the now-debunked field of race science, the remains then fell into relative oblivion. In 1989, Philippe Mennecier, the curator [of the museum], put together the first electronic database of the collection. It enabled him to identify hundreds of what he called ‘potentially litigious’ skulls -- remains of anticolonial fighters and Indigenous people, collected as war trophies or plundered by explorers -- that could be claimed by people wishing to honor their ancestors.”

Christine Lefèvre, a top official at the Museum of Natural History, which oversees the Museum of Mankind, and Martin Friess, who is responsible for the museum’s modern anthropology collections, told Méheut the information was withheld because of privacy concerns, fear of controversy and because of uncertainties around some remains’ identities. “But several scholars and lawmakers said the museum’s stance stemmed from a greater concern: that transparency could open the floodgates for restitution claims,” Méheut wrote. “Over the past two decades, France has returned only about 50 sets of remains, including to South Africa, New Zealand and Algeria.”

Méheut explained that “to make matters more complicated, objects in public museum collections are the property of the French state and cannot change ownership unless the return is voted into law -- a cumbersome process that has sometimes led France to lend remains instead of ceding possession. A representative for France’s culture ministry said officials were working on a sweeping law to regulate future returns of human remains.” The French government has yet to accept “a bill passed by the Senate in January that would remove the need for Parliament to approve every restitution.”

During the French Senate committee hearing, referring to the skulls of victims of the Armenian Genocide, Sen. Ouzoulias told his colleagues: “This is intolerable. We risk a major diplomatic conflict with certain countries when they become aware of the content of our collections. It is time to stop this. We can no longer live with corpses in our closets.”

Now that Armenians have learned about the storage of the skulls of five Armenian Genocide victims in a French museum, I suggest that the Armenian government, through its embassy in Paris, make an immediate request for the return of these skulls to Armenia to be buried near the Armenian Genocide Memorial complex in Yerevan. These victims deserve a respectful burial after being stored in a box in the basement of a French museum for a century.

Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Snow to persist across Armenia
Snow and fog will persist across Armenia throughout this week, the national weather service said. Strong winds of up to 20 m/s are predicted...
Will Smith and Martin Lawrence announce fourth 'Bad Boys' sequel
The “Bad Boys” are officially returning, with Will Smith and Martin Lawrence announcing that they’ll reunite for a fourth film...
Armenia’s ski resorts open up winter wonderland: TTN
The spa town of Tsaghkadzor in Armenia is becoming one of the top skiing destinations in the world with its majestic mountains and wide array of...
Armenian expert: Iran's efforts moving Turkey-Syria settlement to Astana format
Iran’s active diplomatic efforts are pushing the Turkey-Syria settlement to the Astana format, Armenian orientalist Armen Petrosyan said...
Iranian actions and statements helped to stop a further deterioration of that situation, deputy FM tells Al-Monitor
Armenia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Vahan Kostanyan has said that Iran’s actions and statements helped to stop larger Azerbaijani...
Ukrainian authorities search house of ex-interior minister Arsen Avakov
Former Ukrainian interior minister Arsen Avakov said his home was searched by security officials on Wednesday as part of an investigation into a...
Protesters in Yerevan urge EU action to end Azerbaijan's Artsakh blockade
A group of Armenian women on Wednesday staged a protest outside the EU Office in Yerevan, urging European Commission President Ursula von der...
Dangerous ice storm sweeps parts of US
Nearly 40 million people are under a winter weather alert in south-central parts of the US, spreading from Tennessee to Texas. A mix of...
Opposition MP dismisses authorities' 'dangerous' claims about Russia's responsibility for Lachin corridor
MP Gegham Manukyan of the opposition Hayastan bloc dismissed the Armenian authorities’ “dangerous” claims that Russia is...
Drivers warned over snow and ice in parts of Armenia
Some roads are closed or difficult to pass in Armenia as of Wednesday afternoon, the Rescue Service reports. In particular, the roads...
CoE resolution condemns Azerbaijan's destruction policy of Armenian cultural heritage in Artsakh
The European Parliament has adopted a resolution “On the implementation of the New European Agenda for Culture and the EU Strategy for...
Turin hands over keys of Eurovision to Liverpool
The official keys of the Eurovision Song Contest have been handed from the previous host city Turin to Liverpool in a grand ceremony, the...
Armenian MP: Azerbaijan obviously pushing Artsakh into a trap
Armenian MP Tigran Abrahamyan of the opposition Pativ Unem faction says Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) has two main approaches on possible...
Rep. Katie Porter condemns Azerbaijan's Artsakh blockade
U.S. Congresswoman Katie Porter has condemned Azerbaijan’s blockade of the Lachin corridor, the sole road linking Artsakh...
Russian, Azeri FMs discuss situation around Lachin corridor
Ways of settling the situation around the Lachin corridor were the focus of a telephone conversation between Russian and Azerbaijani Foreign...
Iran vows retaliation over drone attack on Isfahan
Iran will not let the attack on the Defense Ministry's facility in Isfahan go unanswered, Mahmoud Abbaszadeh Meshkini, the spokesman for the...
Israeli TV spews repulsive Azeri propaganda against Armenia & Iran
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier On January 27, Israel’s international TV station, i24NEWS, aired a half-hour...
Temperatures set to drop in Armenia
Snow and fog will persist in Armenia throughout this week, the national weather service said. Strong winds of up to 20 m/s are predicted in...
Samsung profits sink to 8-year low
Samsung’s quarterly profits have plunged to their lowest level in eight years as customers snapped up fewer cell phones and...
Armenian church in Texas named US Building of the Year 2022
Saint Sarkis Armenian Church, located in the north Dallas suburb of Carrollton, has received the most votes in our poll for US Building of the...
Court hearing in Kocharyan's case again postponed
The Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction on Tuesday again postponed the hearing in the case of second Armenian President Robert Kocharyan and...
Mel Gibson visits Armenian church in Glendale
Oscar-winning American actor and director Mel Gibson has visited St. Kevork Armenian Church in Glendale. Members of the Armenian community...
Death toll in Pakistan mosque blast rises to 93
The death toll from a suicide bombing at a mosque in northwest Pakistan has risen to 93, a provincial government official said Tuesday, a day...
Armenian health minister, WHO chief discuss situation in Artsakh
Armenian Health Minister Anahit Avanesyan on Tuesday held a phone conversation with World Health Organization (WHO) Director-General Tedros...
Three dead, two injured in single-car crash in Armenia
Three people were killed, while two others were injured in a tragic single-car crash in Armenia last night. The crash took place on the...
Armenia's Central Bank leaves refinancing rate unchanged
At its meeting on Tuesday, the Board of the Central Bank of Armenia decided to leave the refinancing rate unchanged at 10.75%. The Lombard...
Armenian soldiers injured in military barracks fire in moderate condition
The three Armenian servicemen injured in a military barracks fire on 19 January are in moderate condition, a spokeswoman for the Health...
Armenian army officer charged with treason
The National Security Service (NSS) of Armenia has uncovered another case of high treason involving an Armenian army officer. In a statement...
Armenia to celebrate St. Sarkis Day on Feb. 4
St. Sarkis Day will be celebrated in Armenia on February 4 this year. The day has been designated a youth holiday by Catholicos of All Armenians...
Schools reopen in Artsakh
Classes resumed in all pre-schools, primary and secondary schools in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) on Monday following a 10-day hiatus amid the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}