Politics 11:30 27/12/2023 Armenia

Court convicts Pashinyan critic after his death…

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

This week’s commentary is a lesson for all those who naively believe what they hear or read and then pass on unsubstantiated stories to others. By doing so, they are actually helping to spread fake news. When someone gives you a piece of ‘news’, you should always ask, ‘what is your source’? When the answer is: ‘I heard it from someone else,’ immediately dismiss what was said to you. It is critical to verify what you are told in order not to disseminate baseless rumors to others.

Those of us who are in the news business have a bigger responsibility to be vigilant because if we do not double-check what is being reported to us, then we become guilty of spreading fake news to thousands of readers or viewers.

Here is an example of a news item we just heard about. A 57-year-old entertainment producer, Armen Grigoryan, who had died in Armenia, was found guilty by a judge in Armenia last week, a year and five months after his death. Not having heard that a dead man can be tried and convicted, I wondered if such a thing really happened.

Since I have had long years of experience hearing all sorts of baseless reports, I immediately contacted the late defendant’s lawyer in Armenia, Ruben Melikian, who was kind enough to explain the circumstances of this strange story.

Armen Grigoryan, during a street protest against the authorities in Armenia in May 2022, shortly before the parliamentary elections, told a reporter that he stood by his earlier statement of April 2021 that half of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s supporters in certain parts of the country have Turkish blood. Naturally, this was a disparaging remark, but if a country is truly democratic, citizens have the right to use unpleasant, even offensive words. Nevertheless, Grigoryan had not said anything threatening, which would have been against the law.

In May 2022, Grigoryan, a vocal critic of the regime, was arrested and jailed for the statement he had made a year before his arrest. He was charged with “inciting ethnic hostility.” Those accused of such a charge in the past, had made offensive or degrading comments about other ethnic groups living in Armenia. However, no Armenian had been charged before with incitement after making such remarks about fellow Armenians. For example, Pashinyan supporters, who had made insulting comments against Artsakh Armenian refugees, have not been charged with incitement.

On July 15, 2022, two months after his arrest, Grigoryan was brought to court from jail to stand trial. Regrettably, in the midst of the trial, he collapsed and died in the courtroom from a brain aneurism or stroke.

In Armenia, when a defendant dies, his trial is discontinued. However, in this case, according to Armenian law, the defendant’s family has the right to ask that the trial be continued until a verdict is reached. Grigoryan’s lawyer explained that his family wanted to see that he is exonerated, even though, due to the presumption of innocence (innocent until proven guilty), he was merely charged, but not convicted prior to his death. The family insisted that Grigoryan’s name be cleared since they believe that he should have never been arrested, charged and jailed.

The attorney told me that during the trial, after Gregorian’s death, a government witness testified in court that he had not written the testimony that was submitted in his name to the court. This witness said that a government investigator had written the testimony and had told him to sign it.

Also, a government expert, who testified in court, admitted that Grigoryan’s words could not be considered an incitement to inter-ethnic hostility, which means targeting members of another ethnic group. Grigoryan had only used offensive words about his fellow Armenians, members of his own ethnic group.

Nevertheless, last week, a year and five months after Grigoryan’s death, the judge declared him guilty of the charge filed against him. His lawyer told me that after the verdict is received in writing, the family has one month to file an appeal, which they intend to do. If they lose in the court of appeal, they will then appeal to the Court of Cassation which is a Court that hears appeals against decisions of courts of appeal. If they fail there too, they will then go to the European Court of Human Rights.

Having investigated the circumstances of a court in Armenia holding a trial and finding a dead man guilty, I wanted to know if such trials had also taken place in other countries. Surprisingly, I found several cases in ancient and recent history when other countries held posthumous trials of defendants and found them guilty after their death.

Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Archbishop Bagrat meets with military personnel
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Tavush for the Homeland movement opposing the Armenian government’s unilateral territorial...
Senior cleric announces rally in Yerevan on May 26
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Tavush for the Homeland movement opposing the Armenian government’s unilateral territorial...
Archbishop Bagrat says no decision yet on his nomination for PM
No official decision has yet been taken on the nomination of Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan for Armenian prime minister. The Tavush for the...
Opposition MP reiterates support for movement led by Archbishop Bagrat
MP Hayk Mamijanyan, who heads the opposition Pativ Unem faction in the Armenian National Assembly, on Saturday reiterated his team’s...
Global study predicts increase in life expectancy by 2050
Global life expectancy is set to increase by almost five years by 2025, new research has found, but factors like obesity and high blood pressure...
Henrikh Mkhitaryan raises issue of Armenian prisoners held in Azerbaijan
Inter Milan midfielder Henrikh Mkhitaryan on Friday called the attention of the international community to the issue of Armenian prisoners held...
LIVE: Archbishop Bagrat meets with cultural figures
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Tavush for the Homeland movement against the Armenian government’s unilateral territorial...
Armenian MP urges Russia to review its priorities in South Caucasus
Armenian opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan calls on Russia to review its priorities in the South Caucasus and ensure the safe return of the...
Archbishop Bagrat reveals reason for meeting with parties
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of a protest movement against the Armenian government’s unilateral territorial concessions to...
Armenian minister meets with border villagers affected by land surrender
Armenian Minister of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures Gnel Sanosyan on Saturday travelled to the border village of Kirants in...
TV and film actor Dabney Coleman dies at 92
Dabney Coleman, best known for his portrayal of cantankerous characters in films such as Tootsie and 9 to 5, has died at age 92, BBC News...
Tavush movement activists released
Five activists of the Tavush for the Homeland protest movement were set free on Friday night, reported lawyer Varazdat Harutyunyan, a member of...
India awaits clear proposals from Armenia on Chabahar port use, envoy says
Regarding the use of Chabahar port, India is waiting for details from the Armenian side and will definitely consider them once clear proposals...
Snow to hit parts of Armenia
Snow and wet snow are expected in Armenia’s Gegharkunik Province and mountainous areas of Vayots Dzor and Syunik Provinces on Friday...
TikTok testing hour-long videos
It's known for its short, sharp content. But it appears that TikTok is taking a leaf out of YouTube's book with its latest test....
Opposition MP meets with detained Tavush protesters
MP Tigran Abrahamyan of the opposition Pativ Unem faction on Friday visited the Nubarashen Penitentiary to meet with four activists...
Armenian border villagers dissatisfied after meeting with Tavush governor
Governor of Tavush Province Hayk Ghalumyan on Friday travelled to the border village of Kirants to meet with local residents protesting against...
Four dead after powerful storms hit Texas
Thunderstorms have killed four people and knocked out power to nearly a million homes and businesses in south-east Texas, BBC News reports....
Diaspora strongly supports protest movement in Armenia, leader says
The Tavush for the Homeland protest movement against the Armenian government’s unilateral territorial concessions to Azerbaijan enjoys...
In pictures: Archbishop Bagrat delivers lecture at YSU courtyard
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Tavush for the Homeland movement against the Armenian government’s unilateral territorial...
Arman Tatoyan slams obstruction of reporters' work
Former Armenian Ombudsman Arman Tatoyan, who currently runs the Tatoyan Foundation, has denounced efforts to hinder journalistic activities and...
Bus carrying passengers gets stuck in rainwater in Yerevan
A bus carrying passengers was stuck in rainwater following downpours in Yerevan on Thursday, the Rescue Service of Armenia's Interior...
France says situation 'calmer' in New Caledonia after fourth night of troubles
Hundreds of extra military and police arrived in France's troubled Pacific territory of New Caledonia ahead of a fourth night of troubles...
LIVE: Archbishop Bagrat delivers lecture at YSU courtyard
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Tavush for the Homeland movement against the Armenian government’s unilateral...
International community urged to press for release of Ruben Vardanyan, other Armenian prisoners in Baku
Ruben Vardanyan’s family on Friday issued a statement calling on the international community to demand the unconditional release of...
Church in Artsakh's Aghavno at risk of destruction
The Holy Martyrs (Srbots Nahatakats) Church of Aghavno, a village in the Kashatagh region of Azerbaijani-occupied Artsakh, is at risk of...
Armenian, Azeri parliament speakers meet in Geneva
Armenian National Assembly Speaker Alen Simonyan met with Azerbaijan’s Milli Majlis Speaker Sahiba Gafarova in Geneva on Thursday 16 May....
Armenian wrestler Yeghishe Mosesyan crowned European champion
Freestyle wrestler Yeghishe Mosesyan has earned a gold medal at the U15 European Championships 2024 being held in Loutraki, Greece, from May...
UJA warns of increasing pressure on reporters in Armenia
The Union of Journalists of Armenia (UJA) on Thursday issued a statement warning of increasing pressure, violence and disrespect...
Georgia's central bank spends $60 mln to support lari amid rallies
Georgia's central bank said on Thursday it had spent $60 million in reserves to support the lari after a surge in demand for foreign...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}