Politics 12:33 10/07/2024 Armenia

Pashinyan criticized Armenia’s Constitution on Constitution Day

By Harut Sassounian


Only in Armenia does the leader of the country give a speech criticizing the Constitution on the Anniversary of the Constitution! This would be similar to the head of a country criticizing the independence of his country on Independence Day.

It would have been more appropriate if Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan had announced six years ago that he wanted to have parts of the Constitution amended. Many countries have amended their Constitutions to keep up with changes in their societies. Armenia’s Constitution was first adopted on July 5, 1995, amended on Nov. 27, 2005, and then amended again on Dec. 6, 2015. All three versions were approved by a public referendum.

Pashinyan had repeatedly criticized the Constitution before he became Prime Minister. However, as soon as he came to power, he changed his mind, saying: “let’s work with the Constitution we have. This is not something that we can change every day.” The reason for his reversal was that he was very pleased with the existing Constitution given the fact the parliamentary governmental system gave the Prime Minister almost limitless authority.

However, when Pres. Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan insisted that Armenia change its Constitution, Pashinyan immediately agreed, thus capitulating to the orders of Armenia’s enemy. Aliyev specifically demanded that Armenia remove from the Preamble of its Constitution the reference to the Declaration of Independence which mentioned Artsakh and the Armenian Genocide. Aliyev said that this was his pre-condition to sign a peace treaty with Armenia, which is something Pashinyan has been begging Azerbaijan for years. In fact, Pashinyan repeated Aliyev’s statement that it would be impossible to have peace with Azerbaijan as long as the Constitution’s Preamble included the reference that Aliyev rejected.

To complicate matters more, in line with his constant contradictions on all issues, Pashinyan initially said he disagreed with Aliyev’s request to remove that reference from the Constitution. He reasoned that the peace treaty’s provisions will take precedence over all domestic laws or even the Constitutions of both countries.

Furthermore, Armenia’s Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan also firmly rejected Aliyev’s demand to amend the Constitution, declaring that such a demand would be considered interference in the country’s internal affairs. One would think that after such firm rejections by the Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, this subject would have been closed.

Not if you are Pashinyan. He recently signed an order to form a commission that will prepare a whole new Constitution, not just amend it. By doing so, he annulled the two-year-long effort of the parliament’s existing commission to reform the Constitution. The other problem Pashinyan created is that he gave the commission the deadline of end 2026 to come up with a new Constitution which means that Aliyev will not sign a peace treaty with Armenia until two and a half years from now.

In his July 5 speech on Constitution Day, Pashinyan went into a lengthy diatribe against the existing Constitution, saying: “the citizen believes that the ruling elite created that text, announced about its adoption, and, in fact, introduced it in Armenia.” He further stated that: “And in the text of the [new] Constitution itself, the people express their idea of how they imagine that state, its governance, what it should be like in general, and what project we will all be working on to realize.” He thus falsely implied that, as opposed to the existing Constitution, the text of the new Constitution will be prepared by the citizens of the country. Regrettably, the new Constitution will probably be drafted by a group of Pashinyan’s party members who have no competence in jurisprudence. Rather than expressing the wishes of the citizens, it will reflect the self-serving political agenda of the ruling regime. Pashinyan and his circle hope that by preparing a new Constitution, they will be able to avoid being charged for their many violations under the existing Constitution.

In complying with Pres. Aliyev’s demand to change Armenia’s Constitution, Pashinyan failed to raise Armenia’s objections to certain parts of Azerbaijan’s Constitution. Why doesn’t Pashinyan demand that in return for changing Armenia’s Constitution, Aliyev change Azerbaijan’s Constitution? With Pashinyan, it is always a one-way street. When Aliyev demands territories from Armenia, why doesn’t Pashinyan demand the Armenian territories under Azerbaijan’s control? When Aliyev demands that Armenia give Azerbaijan a corridor through Armenia, why doesn’t Pashinyan demand that Azerbaijan give a similar corridor to Armenia through Azerbaijan? Once you start capitulating to a bully’s demands, there will be endless other demands. Aliyev will never be satisfied with Armenia’s concessions. On the contrary, he will be encouraged to demand many more concessions until nothing is left of Armenia.

Finally, Pashinyan did not say what would happen if and when the new Constitution is rejected by the citizens of Armenia in a referendum? Would Pashinyan use his favorite scare tactic warning that if the people don’t approve the Constitution, Aliyev will start a new war with Armenia?

The prospect of Pashinyan changing the Constitution at Aliyev’s demand adds one more important reason why Armenians should do everything possible to get rid of him at the earliest opportunity. Armenia does not need a new Constitution. It needs a new competent leader.

Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Reporter beaten up at Yerevan protest accuses Pashinyan of 'political immorality'
Famous journalist and political analyst Abraham Gasparyan, who was brutally beaten by police officers at a protest outside the Armenian...
Kim Kardashian opens up about son's rare skin condition
Kim Kardashian is opening up about a family health battle. "The Kardashians" star revealed that one of her and ex-husband Kanye...
Armenia expresses solidarity with Cyprus
Armenia expressed solidarity with Cyprus on Saturday as it marked 50 years of occupation. "This year marks the 50th anniversary of the...
Russian diplomat reveals secret meetings before Azeri attack on Artsakh
Retired Russian Foreign Ministry senior advisor Alexander Ananiev made some revelations about the developments in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) in...
CSI renews call to ban Azerbaijan from Paris Olympics
As the opening of the Paris Olympics approaches, Christian Solidarity International (CSI) is renewing its call to the International Olympic...
International Chess Day celebrated on July 20
International Chess Day is an annual chess celebration held on July 20. Players, clubs, and organizations from around the world create and...
Trump vows to end Ukraine war in call with Zelensky
US Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump said Friday he had spoken by telephone with Ukraine leader Volodymyr Zelensky, and pledged to...
Global media forum being held in Azeri-occupied Shushi
A global media forum on combating disinformation will be held in the Azerbaijani-occupied Artsakh town of Shushi on July 20-22....
Two policemen injured as foreigner fires shots at Armenian police station
A foreigner opened fire at a police station in Armenia’s Kotayk Province last night, injuring himself and two police officers. Police...
Biden vows to stay in race
US President Joe Biden is looking forward to "getting back on the campaign trail next week", fortifying his commitment to stick in the...
Azerbaijan erases Armenian heritage in Nagorno-Karabakh, report warns
The European Center for Law and Justice (ECLJ) warned of Azerbaijan’s systematic erasure of Armenian Christian heritage in...
Today marks Minas Avetisyan's birth anniversary
“There are very few painters like Minas Avetisyan in the world, believe me if I say that there are none at all. He is so powerful, so...
At least 11 killed as bridge collapses in China
Chinese authorities say at least 11 people have died in the partial collapse of a highway bridge in the northwest following heavy storms and...
Armenian church remembers St. Gregory the Illuminator's sons, grandsons
The Armenian Apostolic Church on Saturday commemorates St. Gregory the Illuminator’s sons and grandsons, Sts. Aristakes, Vrtanes, Housik,...
Yerevan bus driver to be dismissed after misconduct
A Yerevan bus driver will be sacked after misbehaving with a passenger, Yerevan mayoral spokesman Hayk Kostanyan said. A video...
White stork contamination reduces in Armenia
Research conducted by the branch of German Nature Protection Union (NABU) in Armenia shows that for the first time in 2020-2024, a reduction in...
Victims of Armenian military plane crash identified
The Armenian Defense Ministry has identified the two victims of a military aircraft crash. The Yak-52 aircraft crashed near the town of...
Microsoft says root cause of outage fixed
Microsoft said the “underlying cause” that caused the global outage “has been fixed,” adding that residual impact is...
Opera star Placido Domingo to perform in Armenia
The Armenian National Philharmonic Orchestra led by its chief conductor Eduard Topchyan will embark on a new concert season on September 12...
Iranian envoy: Next 3+3 meeting to be held in Turkey soon
The next meeting of foreign ministers in the 3+3 format, which includes Armenia, Azerbaijan, Iran, Russia, Turkey and Georgia, will be held in...
Armenian authorities probing military aircraft crash
Armenia’s law-enforcement authorities have launched a criminal investigation into the fatal military plane crash. The Interior...
Video shows Yerevan bus driver swearing at passenger, throwing bottle at him
A video of an incident involving a Yerevan bus driver has been circulating on social media. The footage shows the driver swearing at a male...
Opposition MP comments on failed Pashinyan-Aliyev talks in UK
Opposition lawmaker Tigran Abrahamyan claims that the breakdown of talks between Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and...
Microsoft IT outage hits users worldwide
A widespread Microsoft outage was disrupting flights, banks, media outlets and companies around the world on Friday, AP reported. ...
Armenian Defense Ministry says plane crashed during training exercise
The Armenian Defense Ministry reports that its military training plane was involved in a crash on Friday morning. The Interior Ministry said...
Two killed in small plane crash in Armenia
Two people were killed in a small airplane crash in Armenia on Friday, the Rescue Service of the country's Interior Ministry reported,...
Artists' strike threatens Paris Olympics opening ceremony
The opening ceremony for the Olympic Games is facing potential turmoil after a union of French performing artists issued a strike notice amid an...
Pashinyan, Macron discuss Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan met with French President Emmanuel Macron at Blenheim Palace in the UK on Thursday. The...
Ursula von der Leyen wins second term as European Commission chief
The European Parliament elected Ursula von der Leyen for another five years as European Commission president, choosing stability and continuity...
Maria Gabrielyan elected to Syrian parliament
Maria Gabrielyan, an ethnic Armenian from Aleppo, has been elected to the Syrian parliament, Kantsasar reports. According to the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}