Politics 12:11 29/10/2010

“The February victims near Aghdam are a consequence of criminal actions of Azerbaijan’s political elite …”

“The February victims near Aghdam are a consequence of criminal inaction and, at the same time, no less criminal actions of Azerbaijan’s political elite …”
- Director of Information and PR Center Ara Saghatelyan argues.
Director of Information and PR Center Ara Saghatelyan during the presentation of documentary Maragha. 10 April 1992 in the beginning of October informed about the next in the Ordinary Genocide series, devoted to the so-called events in Khojali. xocali.net web-site, launched this spring, is regularly updated with proofs of multiple falsifications and juggling by Azeri propaganda in the issue of death of civilians near Azeri-controlled Khojali (at present - Ivanyan). Based on request from Golos Armenii, Ara Saghatelyan presented some of the new proofs, as well as details of the events from 18 years ago, which will be included into the new film.

- M-r Saghatelyan, how would you shape the key outcome of the work of the task force studying the events in Khojali, which make the cornerstone of Baku’s anti-Armenian propaganda?
- In the first place, the accumulated and systematized materials confirm the reality which is the following: the Azeri version of the so-called events in Khojali is now entirely exhausted. This has been proved yet not by three or five counter-arguments, but by dozens. Doubtlessly, the death of dozens of civilians gives us nothing but a sense of deep sorry. However, for those who studied this matter profoundly and objectively, one thing is clear: the events of the area completely in control of Azeri forces (this relates to both the village of Khojali and Aghdam vicinity) became the direct consequence of at least inaction and targeted policy of the authorities, and at the same time – coordinated actions of political elites of Azerbaijan of the time. The scope of arguments and facts available to the international community, which is now accessible by Armenians as well, is more than convincing to substantiate: official Baku’s version, which for long has made a speculative political asset of Azeri propaganda, is no longer capable of persuading anyone worldwide, with a possible exception of a part of Azeri public. The reason is trivial: excessiveness of falsifications and fictions, gathered in the so-called Khojali file of Azeri propaganda, resulted in rejection from Azeri version by all the experts and stakeholders, this or that way interested in identifying the truth of those events.

- Why do the Azeris persistently name the events “Khojali”, whereas it is known that execution of civilians occurred near Baku-controlled Aghdam?
- Bodies of those who died, the video and photo footage of whom has been voluntarily edited and re-shot later and which are attributed to now deceased cameraman Chingiz Mustafaev, were located close to Nakhichevanik village, and it’s a fact (with the exception of a couple of photos by journalist Viktoriya Ivleva, who pictured victims of fighting in Khojali streets). It is just as irrefutable that all of those areas were in full control of Azeris from Aghdam. Besides overall control over the area in general, immediately in Aghdam, according to the reports of Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry, 26 Azeri military units were located, who were dealing mainly with looting and marauding, of which we have written proofs: copies of reports to the military leadership of Azerbaijan, as well as reports of their General Staff. After all, we need to consider that it was Azeri “political” opposition that made use and took advantage of death of civilians in the first place. Thorough study of documents and circumstances of the situation, including direct confession in 2009 in the program of Liberty Radio (Azadlyg) by Ramiz Fataliev, who chaired Parliament’s commission investigating those events, leaves no doubt that Azeri authorities of the time were deliberately using the civilians as a live shield. And they were executed already in the territory controlled by military units which were subject to various political forces. There is a highly important thing I want to mention here: there was a considerable number of people in military uniform among the dead (the footage of this is contained in our archive as well as in Associated Press’ archive), which means that civilians who in the last hours were deviating from the route of the humanitarian corridor were used by military personnel to save their lives, hiding themselves behind the civilian population.
These are the facts confirmed by people acknowledged and brought in by Azerbaijanis as experts. Moreover, these facts are contained in the testimonies of Azeri political figures, noted in 1992 and, as I mentioned, in the interview of Fataliev. He acknowledged that there was a decision made at the level of Security Council of Azerbaijan: not to take people out of Khojali.

- Can you name such experts?
- Russian photo correspondent Viktorija Ivleva, whose photos were referred to by Azeris to prove their version, argues in an article published in Nezavisimaya Gazeta in 1992 that even after the operation to liberate Khojali the street fighting in the village was under way. This proves that Azeri military personnel were continuing armed resistance. Ivleva said that nearly 1,000 civilians were taken in an organized way and transported by Armenian side to Karabakh, and then returned to Azerbaijan. She also testifies that those people were treated well, and they were provided with food and clothing.
Another example. English expert Thom de Waal, who is pretty frequently cited by Azeris, in one of his latest interviews directly states that there had been no intention on the Armenians’ side, and that the death of the civilians was a consequence of military activities, which unfortunately happens during a war. The video recording of an interview with him is at our disposal and it will be incorporated into the documentary. And after all, the president of Azerbaijan of the time himself, who openly accused the opposition in organizing of a slaughter near Aghdam, in another interview that we have, bitterly confesses to the journalists that “there are people who do not care who to shoot” and that the opposition has various objectives.

- Are there any new proofs of existence of humanitarian corridor left by Karabakh military for the retreat of civilians?
- The corridor existed – that’s a fact. Generally speaking, during the military operation to break the blockade of Stepanakert, destroyed by regular shelling, in the Khojali direction all the norms of international humanitarian law were preserved. If there was no corridor, how could the former Khojali mayor Elman Mamedov leave the town and take his family with him? In 1992, in an interview to Moscow newspaper Megapolis Express (#17, 1992) Mamedov was saying: “We knew that the corridor was left for the civilians”. And then: “After we got the message about the operation to seize the town I asked Aghdam to send in choppers to move the elderly, children and women out of the town. We were told the blockade will be broken the next day, after the operation. But help never came…”
Today Mamedov is a deputy of Milli Majlis and of course he says completely different things. But recently his video interview was uploaded on YouTube, recorded in 1992 with Azeri reporter and cameraman Chingiz Mustafaev, where Mamedov directly accuses the authorities and the opposition of his country. His words confirm what the president of Azerbaijan Ajaz Mutalibov said in an interview with Czech journalist Dana Mazalova and what was published in the Moscow News: “I see the reason of our troubles in pointless and unreasonable fight for power! There has to be only one president in a republic… it is not clear who serves whom and who pursues what objectives. We do not know whom to blame in this tragedy. We do not know whether to put this on the record of those who was trying to dethrone the president, taking advantage of their rights granted by the president and who sent us under the bullets…”
There are many proofs of the existence of humanitarian corridor. For instance, that is the article of Arif Yunusov in Zerkalo newspaper (June 1992), where a map was published with arrows marking direction of the corridor. The map shows as well another route, which was taken by part of the civilians due to an unknown reason, in the direction of Nakhichevanik, which had been firmly controlled by Karabakh soldiers for a long time; this is also testified by the Azerbaijanis themselves. Suleiman Abbasov, who was retreating together with those who remained of defenders and part of Khojali villagers, said “We, together with part of the civilians, reached Nakhichevanik village, in a hope to find a shelter there; before, they told us by radio that the village had been liberated from Armenians. (Megapolis-Express, N17, 1992.)

- A key argument from Baku is the footage attributed to deceased cameramen Mustafaev. You mentioned there is a different footage as well. What is it about and what does that footage shed light on?
- As it is known, Chingiz Mustafaev died in unclear circumstances. Much speaks of his attempts to discover the underlying reasons of what happened in Khojali, which became the key motive for his murder. This is why it is really hard to identify the ownership of that footage. Still, in this specific case it is not the most important. What is much more important is that there is a shooting authored by an Austrian journalist Vera Frankl. The footage done by her is still preserved in the archive of Associated Press agency, AzTV; we also have that footage. The contents of her shootings explain much, in particular, the reason why the Azeri side never publicized that footage. The footage shows that among the dead bodies of those who supposedly died in Khojali there are many people in military uniform. The tape recorded the chopper coming in and picking up one specific dead body, leaving behind bodies of women and children. This shows, in the first place, attitude of Azeri authorities towards the died compatriots, and secondly, proves that someone was striving to exclude possibility of that specific body being caught by camera and aired in the future. Apparently, existence of that specific person among other dead people was extremely unwanted for the Azeri authorities due to certain reasons. Essentially, if it was not for the footage by Vera Frankl, appearance of people in military uniform among the dead bodies would have remained unknown. Meanwhile, this is just another proof that according to a decision made in Baku, the civilian population of Khojali was doomed to become the victims of Azeri internal political bickering.

- But in this case, who and why needed to desecrate the dead bodies?

- Falsifications by Azeris around the bodies of the dead near Aghdam and, as it is accepted to name now, “post-mortal raping of the corpses” is a topic of a separate project, implemented by Initiative against Xenophobia. A regularly updated web-site xocali.net has been created, which has been subject to multiple attacks from Azeri hackers. In a nut shell, we are dealing with numerous manipulations and staged shootings. The bodies were re-located many times, reshuffled and mutilated. And all that was happening on the territory controlled by Azeris. The footage shows the same body first dressed, then – undressed; first intact and then – scalped; first lying in one position then – in a different one. Plus to that a great amount of materials not having any link to Karabakh has been customized for Khojali events – there are photos from Afghanistan, Kosovo. The impression is that in their aspiration to gain favor some activists of the Azeri propaganda were using whatever they got handy. It is by no accident that after the web-site began functioning, certain sound media and experts in Azerbaijan noted some photos and proofs, not having any relation to Khojali.

- You were mentioning that in this disgusting political game various political powers were involved. Anti-Armenian objectives are obvious; it is also easy to understand the desire to get rid of Mutalibov. Who else had a stake in that kind of development?
- Various political forces relate to the Khojali events. Besides the People’s Front, which came to power, I have to mention Heydar Aliev, who at that time lived in Nakhijevan. It is a common knowledge that two days prior the Khojali libration operation the village’s mayor Elman Mamedov visited Nakhijevan and met with him. There is also a testimony of one of the organizers of Baku pogrom of Armenians Neymat Panakhov, who in January 2000 in an interview to Bylik Dunjasy agency argued that before the events in Khojali he applied to Aliev, who at that time was a member of Supreme Council of Azerbaijan and leader of Nakhijevan, with a request “to do something in order to prevent the tragedy.” The response was “blood-shed will be of benefit to us. We should not be interfering into the course of events”. Therefore, the death of civilians of Khojali became the consequence of actions and at the same time – inaction of Mutalibov with his Security Council, military leadership, who allowed an entire chaos in the military units, People’s Front, who were striving for power and who got it right after the events in Aghdam, and Heydar Aliev, who in all that was pursuing his own far-reaching objectives.

- When will the documentary be ready and what is its main objective?

- To give you an idea I want to inform that most likely there will be more than one movie. And we are not doing it for the Azeris – there is nothing we would like to prove to them. We will build a logical chain and display how everything started, what the developments were and who took advantage of them. The key objective is to sort out the piles of propaganda garbage, dumped upon the international agencies by our neighbors. With creation of this documentary the concept of Aghdam tragedy, replicated by Azeri propaganda for years, will be closed once and for all, as not a single sound person having received such quantity of irrefutable proofs will not be able to still believe the Azeri falsifications and concoctions.

Interview by Marina Grigoryan

Source Panorama.am
Share |


‘Criminalization of Armenian Genocide denial in Russia is in Armenia’s interests, regardless of initiative’s reason’
When trying to put pressure on Turkey, any country, including Russia, is making use of a number of factors, in particular, the Armenian Genocide...
Russian media speculate about Turkey government program, Armenian MFA should not react: expert
There is a misunderstanding in the information field, in particular reports of Russian mass media concerning the program of Turkey’s 64th...
PAP: Current Constitution gives no solutions to some important problems, hinders systemic changes
Members of the opposition Prosperous Armenia Party (PAP) met today with residents of Yerevan’s Shengavit administrative district during...
Macedonian army starts building fence on Greek border
The Macedonian army began erecting a metal fence on Saturday on the country's southern border with Greece at the point where migrants cross...
Georgia concerned about escalation of Russia-Turkey tensions
Georgia is concerned about consequences of the escalation in Russia-Turkey tensions, said Zurab Abashidze, Special Representative of Georgian...
Gomq community of Vayots Dzor region becomes tenth community to have been provided with street lighting
The Foundation for the Preservation of Wildlife and Cultural Assets (FPWC) and VivaCell-MTS presented the outcomes of already the 10th...
Wine fair& sampling opens in Yerevan
A wine fair& sampling opened in Northern Avenue of Yerevan today, on November 28. A wide range of wines made from grapes, pomegranates,...
NKR Defense Army: Azerbaijan violated ceasefire about 300 times in past week
From November 22 to 28, the Azerbaijani side violated the ceasefire about 300 times on the line of contact between the armed forces of Karabakh...
Girl can't get personalized Nutella jar because her name is Isis
As if being a little girl named “Isis” in this day and age isn't hard enough, now even Nutella has a problem with her name....
Alexander Markarov: 102nd Russian military base in Armenia unlikely to be used in Russia-Turkey standoff
An open confrontation between Russia and NATO can hardly be expected, such a scenario is unlikely, although nothing can be ruled out, political...
Representative of Armenian Community in Lithuania denies Azerbaijani media’s false information: Thank God, there are honest Lithuanians
Azerbaijan media ran false information about the participation of Marat Sargsyan, a film director and representative of the Armenian Community...
Disregarding problem of early marriages in Azerbaijan promotes paedophilia, expert says
The disregard of the problem of early marriages in Azerbaijan can be considered as promotion of paedophilia and undermining the health of the...
All motorways in Armenia passable
All the motorways in Armenia were passable as of 9:00 am today on November 28, according to the press service of Armenian Ministry of...
Zhamanak: Gang’s detention was planned for a later date
‘Zhamanak’ paper says citing its sources that the detention of the gang recently rendered harmless in Yerevan was planned for a...
Zhoghovurd: Party of Ara Abrahamyan to be called ‘National Unity’
President of the Union of Armenians of Russia Ara Abrahamyan already decided when he will call the constituent assembly of the new party he is...
Arthur Vardanyan and 20 members of criminal group set up by him arrested for 2 months
The general jurisdiction court of Kentton and Nork Marash administrative districts of Yerevan held a hearing on Friday, November 27. The court...
Colorado Springs: Three killed in shooting at Planned Parenthood clinic
A shooting at a family planning clinic in Colorado Springs has left two civilians and a police officer dead, with the suspected gunman under...
22 drown as minibus runs off road in Burkina Faso
Twenty-two people drowned after the minibus they were travelling in veered off a road in southwest Burkina Faso, the government in Ouagadougou...
Yes and No’ reality show: Situation in Armenia can also change without constitutional reform
The situation in Armenia could change for the better now too if there were the necessary preconditions, the head of the Public Opinion Research...
Yerevan-based Football Club Pyunik refuses to attend training session in Turkey in view of past week’s
Yerevan-based Football Club Pynuik has refused to participate in a training session in Turkey “in view of the past week’s...
Yerevan hosts session of CIS Council on Labor, Migration and Social Protection of Population
The 18th session of the Consultative Council on Labor, Migration and Social Protection of the Population of CIS member states started in Yerevan...
President of Artsakh visits military units
On 27 November Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan visited a number of Defense Army’s military units located in the northeastern part...
Paris attacks: France holds service two weeks after massacre
France has held a national memorial service for the 130 people who died in the Paris attacks two weeks ago, the BBC reported. Some 2,600...
NSS of Armenia to verify recently-arrested Yerevan criminal group leader’s involvement in ISIS
The criminal group arrested during an operation conducted by Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS) in Yerevan on November 25 is an...
Euphoria over Russian State Duma bill on Armenian Genocide denial criminalization inappropriate: Melkonyan
Director of the Institute of History of National Academy of Sciences (NAS) of Armenia Ashot Melkonyan urged everyone to stop euphoria over the...
Turkey has not changed in the last hundred years, Sharmazanov says at meeting with Naryshkin
Vice Speaker of the Armenian parliament Edward Sharmazanov met on November 26 with Chairman of Russia’s State Duma Sergey Naryshkin on the...
Criminal group arrested in Yerevan not related to political forces, NSS deputy chief says
The criminal group arrested on November 25 in Yerevan during an operation conducted by the National Security Service of Armenia has no relation...
President Sargsyan, prosecutor general discuss upcoming constitutional referendum in Armenia
Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan received today Prosecutor General of Armenia Gevorg Kostanyan who made a report on the competence of...
Azerbaijan: Nardaran settlement residents deny authorities’ accusations of revolution attempt
Azerbaijan police stepped up enhanced security measures after clashes took place in Nardaran settlement, Baku, local news agency Trend reports....
NSS of Armenia: Citizens, some branches of power were target of criminal group arrested in Yerevan
The criminal group detained during an operation conducted by units of Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS) in Yerevan on November 25...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}