Analysis 10:42 19/03/2013

Will Pope Francis repeat Cardinal Bergoglio’s words on the Genocide?

Shortly after Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio became Pope Francis I, Armenian and Turkish media outlets rushed to inform their audiences that the Argentinean Archbishop had acknowledged the Armenian Genocide on a number of occasions. 

When Catholicos Karekin II visited Buenos Aires on April 23, 2004, Cardinal Bergoglio joined him in an ecumenical liturgy and spoke during the commemoration of the victims of the Armenian Genocide. The Cardinal stated: "We are united in grief over a genocide -- the first of the 20th century -- a genocide that powerful empires seek to silence and cover up by all means."

Last week, in his congratulatory letter to Pope Francis I, Karekin II "fondly remembered" their joint meetings and prayers in Argentina, and praised the Catholic Pontiff "as a courageous, wise, and righteous shepherd." The Catholicos recalled Cardinal Bergoglio’s "sincere affection toward the Armenian people," adding: "We gladly confirm that the historical relationship between our churches is marked by fraternal warmth. We greatly value the progress registered by our churches as a result of collaborative efforts undertaken during the pontificates of ourselves and our predecessors. This has been manifested during mutual visits and elaborated through a multitude of educational and charitable programs."

On April 22, 2006, during a program commemorating the 91st anniversary of the Armenian Genocide in Buenos Aires, Cardinal Bergoglio urged Turkey to unconditionally recognize the Armenian Genocide as the "gravest crime of Ottoman Turkey against the Armenian people and the entire humanity."

More recently, in 2011, after an Argentinean Federal Court found Turkey guilty of committing genocide against Armenians in response to a lawsuit filed by survivor Krikor Hairabedian, Cardinal Bergoglio issued a statement condemning "the abominable crime of genocide that the Turkish state committed against the Armenian people between 1915 and 1923."

Both Armenians and Turks are now wondering if in his new capacity Pope Francis I will repeat the words he uttered as Cardinal Bergoglio. Armenians are delighted that a close friend of their community in Argentina has been elected to lead the Catholic Church. Meanwhile, the Turkish press has expressed great concern that "the new Pope could be influenced by [Armenian] lobbying groups."

Now that he has ascended to the highest office of the Roman Church, no one really knows what position Pope Francis would take on Armenian issues. One must remember that the Pontiff has two distinct functions as head of the Catholic Church and the sovereign city-state of Vatican. In other words, he is both a spiritual leader and head of state. Hence, depending on the issue, he may not necessarily express the views he held as Cardinal Bergoglio. At times, he may assume positions on political matters that diverge from his personal views and coincide with Vatican’s more worldly interests. As head of the Vatican state, the Pope may be forced to act as any other politician, such as Pres. Obama, who said one thing before the election and changed his tune afterward. However, as the spiritual leader of the Catholic Church and a man of strong moral values, the Pope cannot simply ignore or contradict his deeply held convictions.

Realizing that all Popes are not alike, it may be useful to review recent papal pronouncements on the Armenian Genocide. Pope John Paul II, on two occasions, used the term Armenian Genocide -- on November 9, 2000 and September 27, 2001. However, unlike his predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI refrained from using that term, preferring to qualify the Genocide as "martyrdom" and "unspeakable suffering."

In the case of Pope Francis I, there is no need for Armenians to insist that he use the term Armenian Genocide; as the Vatican has twice acknowledged the Armenian Genocide. Thus, no purpose is served by demanding that every new Pope reaffirm the facts of the Armenian Genocide all over again. It is important, however, that Pope Francis I not retreat from his earlier position on the Armenian Genocide; substitutes and euphemisms would not be appropriate.

Given the Vatican’s positive record on the Armenian Genocide, it would be best to go beyond this issue and look for other areas in which the Pontiff could be supportive, such as pressing for the security of Armenians and other Christians in Syria. Efforts should also be made to strengthen the existing amicable ties between the Armenian Apostolic and Catholic churches, and friendly relations between the Vatican State and the Republic of Armenia.

Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:18
Russian forward Anton Kilin joins Urartu
Urartu FC has signed Russian forward Anton Kilin, the club said in a statement on Friday. 33-year-old footballer played in Russian...
17:07
Lawyer slams 'illegal' seizure of Artsakh president's state car
Lawyer Roman Yeritsyan denounced the “illegal” seizure of the Artsakh president’s official car during a raid on Friday....
16:33
Lavrov: Armenia’s withdrawal from CSTO not discussed at foreign ministerial meeting
Armenia's withdrawal from the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) was not discussed at the meeting of its foreign ministers on...
16:02
Special forces storm gates of Artsakh representative office in Yerevan
Armenian special forces on Friday breached the gates of Artsakh's representative office in Yerevan, the National Front reports....
15:36
Photo released to mark Prince William's birthday
A photograph of the Prince of Wales and his children has been released alongside a message reading "we all love you" to mark his 42nd...
15:15
Armenian MP urges int'l community to deter Azerbaijan
Even after the 2020 war, Azerbaijan has not backed down from the arms race and continues with its colossal arms purchases along with army...
14:34
U.S. senators press Biden to sharply boost aid to Artsakh refugees
Senate Armed Services Committee Chair Jack Reed (D-RI) and Senate Budget Committee Chair Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), along with some twenty of...
14:06
Israel summons Armenian envoy after its recognition of Palestine
Israel's foreign ministry summoned Armenia's ambassador to Israel after the country recognized the State of Palestine, AFP...
13:36
PLO welcomes Armenia's decision to recognize Palestine
Hussein Al-Sheikh, Secretary General of the Executive Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), welcomed Armenia's move...
13:16
Archbishop Bagrat visits border village
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Tavush for the Homeland protest movement, on Friday travelled to the border village of Kirants....
12:45
Azerbaijan hands over remains of two soldiers to Armenia
The Azerbaijani authorities have transferred the remains of two servicemen to Armenia, the National Security Service (NSS) reports....
12:34
Armenia recognizes Palestinian state
Armenia has officially recognized Palestine as a state, the Armenian Foreign Ministry said in a statement on Friday. "The catastrophic...
12:05
New book tells about Azerbaijani vandalism in Artsakh
With the blessing of Catholicos of all Armenians Karekin II and the order of Bishop Vrtanes Abrahamyan, Primate of the Artsakh Diocese, a book...
11:33
Armenia's Mirzoyan meets with Belarusian opposition leader
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan has met with Belarusian opposition leader Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya. In a post on X on Thursday,...
11:19
Euro 2024 fixtures for Friday
The UEFA Euro 2024 kicked off in Germany on 14 June and runs until 14 July 2024. The group stage concludes on 26 June, with the knockout stage...
11:00
Blinken urges Aliyev to release all those unjustly detained in Azerbaijan
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Thursday spoke with Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, the State Department reported. ...
17:07
Armenian culture ministry debunks Azerbaijan's lies
The Armenian Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports (MoESCS) has officially denied Azerbaijan’s false reports about attempts...
16:30
Harry and Meghan reportedly contacted Kate Middleton to make peace
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle had reached out to Kate Middleton before her defiant return to the spotlight at last week’s Trooping the...
16:14
Armenian government approves €15 million EU aid for Artsakh refugees
The Armenian government on Thursday approved an agreement on €15 million assistance from the European Union to respond to the needs of...
15:36
Armenia drop one spot in FIFA rankings
FIFA has today published the updated list of national teams' rankings. Armenia's national team has lost one spot to be placed 96th in...
15:23
Opposition MP: Armenian Foreign Ministry statement causes concern
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has expressed concern over the Armenian Foreign Ministry’s response to Baku’s strong criticism of...
14:36
Raya Nazaryan elected Bulgarian parliament speaker
UDF MP Raya Nazaryan was elected Bulgaria's National Assembly Chair on Thursday. She received 131 votes in favour, 66 MPs voted against, and...
14:08
Russia plans to open consulate general in Armenia's Kapan
Moscow expects to open a Russian consulate general in the Armenian city of Kapan shortly, State Secretary and Deputy Foreign Minister Yevgeny...
13:47
'Diplomatic failure': Expert reacts to Pashinyan-Erdogan phone call
Professor Ruben Melkonyan, dean of the YSU Faculty of Oriental Studies, has called the latest phone call between Armenian Prime Minister Nikol...
13:03
Yerevan Conservatory head replaced
Tsovinar Movsisyan was installed as caretaker rector of the Yerevan Komitas State Conservatory on 13 June pending the election of a new head,...
12:34
Iran condemns Canada's listing of IRGC as terror group
Tehran condemns Canada’s listing of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps as a terrorist organization as “an unwise and...
12:15
Russia reacts to Armenia's decision to skip CSTO meeting
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Mikhail Galuzin noted that Russia expects Yerevan to understand that the Collective Security Treaty Organization...
12:04
Ombudsperson: Protection of displaced Karabakh Armenians' rights crucial
In a message on World Refugee Day marked on June 20, Armenian Human Rights Defender Anahit Manasyan called attention to the forced displacement...
11:30
Armenian church marks Feast of the Holy Translators
The Armenian Apostolic Church on Thursday marks the Feast of the Holy Translators St. Sahak and St. Mesrop, Qahana.am reports. Catholicos...
11:15
West's agenda in South Caucasus doesn't always meet interests of regional states, Russia says
Agenda of the West in the South Caucasus region does not always meet the interests of regional nations, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Mikhail...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}