Society 19:20 29/10/2013

Vadim Gomoz: At presentation of his book Kuznetsov admits being pro-Azerbaijani bias thus devaluating the book

Panorama.am had an exclusive interview with Vadim Gomoz, the editor of "Wikipedia".

- You've been at the presentation of Oleg Kuznetsov’s book in Moscow, "Truth about the "myths" of Karabakh conflict", which was initially considered as a response to the book of candidate of historical sciences Stanislav Tarasov called "Myths about Karabakh conflict." However, you publicly unveiled a lot of historical inaccuracies and fact juggling in the content of the book concerning the history of the Armenian people. Tell us more about it.

- The story of this book revealed an interesting problem. As far as I understood from the presentation most of the work was actually carried out by Azerbaijani historian Eldar Abbasov who spoke at the presentation. He, having investigated the archival documents, demonstrates incapacity of allegations of Stanislav Tarasov. According to Abbasov, a selective quoting and document reduction has been made during the publication. I am not going to judge who is right and who is wrong, for that I will have to get more familiar with these documents kept in the archives, however I liked Abbasov’s presentation, it was absolutely correct. Among the Azerbaijani representatives he was the only one who spoke to the point, and never made anti-Armenian attacks. Nevertheless, in the end the results of his works have been presented in Kuznetsov’s book, and are openly preceded by anti-Armenian propaganda, with all sorts of absurdities.

- Thus, it means that this product of Azerbaijani propaganda has caused exactly opposite effect?

- Any historian who will read this book will not be able to go on. If the author can allow himself to make racist attacks against Armenians, accompanied with unfounded allegations that contradict to everything we know about the history of the region, then where are the guarantees that by presenting the documents, the author will follow the criteria of scientific scrupulousness? Such passages, on the contrary, a priori persuade the third-party reader in Tarasov’s correctness, who is forced to argue with such opponents and on their background appears to be a pillar of academic correctness and integrity.

- It is known that Kuznetsov claims in his book about Stanislav Tarasov’s pro-Armenian disposition, at the same time he does not shun of cooperation with the Azerbaijani side.

- At some point Kuznetsov stated, "Yes, maybe I am not objective, but I unmasked Tarasov." From my point of view, just on the contrary, he did everything to avoid the opportunity to oppose Tarasov on the merits. Summarizing; they say the smart learns from others' mistakes, stupid - on its own. This case can serve an excellent lesson for all parties of the Karabakh conflict. As soon as the academic study gets surrounded with propaganda hullabaloo, together with xenophobic tinge, the credibility of that study tends to zero.
And this, from my point of view, is the main result of Oleg Kuznetsov’s book presentation.

There are normal researchers in both sides. The problem is in isolating them from aggressively ignorant crowds, because when there are ambassadors, Ph.D.s, distinguished writers all around you, and everyone is trying to dehumanize the opponent, even the mere silence seems to be a courageous deed. And if you try to argue, they may call you a "public enemy."



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

20:30
Armenian team record second straight victory at World Senior Team Championships 2019
The Armenian veteran chess team has won in the second round of the World Senior Team Championships 2019 underway in Greece. As the chess...
20:28
International community would be mindful to judge Nikol Pashinyan by his actions at home, not his speeches abroad – Robert Kocharyan
Armenian ex-president Robert Kocharyan, who is currently in custody charged with “overthrowing constitutional order of Armenia”...
20:24
VivaCell-MTS service centers operational on Good Friday
This year The Good Friday is celebrated on April 19. VivaCell-MTS informs that traditionally Good Friday is a non-working day in the Company,...
20:21
NSS brought charges against the Head of State Oversight Service Davit Sanasaryan
The Armenian National Security Service (NSS) has launched a criminal investigation against the head of the RA State Oversight Service Davit...
19:42
Garegin Baghramyan elected as Chairman of the RA Public Services Regulatory Commission
The National Assembly of Armenia approved Garegin Baghramyan’s candidacy to the post of the Chairman of the RA Public Services Regulatory...
19:19
More than19 million Russians living in poverty – Dmitry Medvedev
The head of the Russian Cabinet Dmitry Medvedev, has admitted in a speech at the State Duma that the life of most Russians is far from ideal and...
19:13
Current talks around Nagorno Karabakh being held on no concrete proposals - MFA spokeswoman
The current Nagorno Karabakh negotiations are not held around any concrete proposals and the discussions are mostly focused on familiarizing...
18:24
Turkish opposition candidate declared Istanbul mayor
The candidate from Turkey's main opposition party has been declared Istanbul's new mayor, despite a pending appeal from the ruling...
16:42
Cloud PBX solution by VivaCell-MTS: Cost-efficient services for companies
VivaCell-MTS has launched cloud Private Branch Exchange (PBX) solution for big companies, as well as small and medium enterprises. As the...
16:07
Armenia's Aronian to take part in Grenke Сhess Сlassic
Armenian GM Levon Aronian will take part in the Grenke Chess Classic 2019 to take place in Germany from 20 to 29 April, the Chess...
15:42
Iraq's religious leader calls on Turkey to apologize for Armenian Genocide
The chairman of Iraq’s National Religious Council Sheikh Yusif Al-Nasri said Turkey must apologize to Armenians “for their...
15:28
124 million drams to be allocated for Citizen’s Day celebrations in Armenia
A total of 124 million drams will be allocated to the Armenian government staff from the reserve fund for organizing celebrations on the...
15:05
Facebook says it ‘unintentionally uploaded’ 1.5 million users’ email contacts without permission
Social networking giant Facebook said on Wednesday evening it may have “unintentionally uploaded” the email contacts of up to 1.5...
14:56
Security agents raid house, office of wanted ex-Armenian official: report
Agents of the National Security Service on Thursday conducted a raid of the house and former office of Mihran Poghosyan, a former MP and chief...
14:10
Pope encourages Swedish campaigner Greta on environment
Pope Francis encouraged Swedish teenage environmental activist Greta Thunberg on Wednesday to continue her campaign to fight climate change,...
13:55
Lars road open only for passenger vehicles
Stepantsminda-Lars highway is open only for passenger vehicles as of 1pm Thursday, April 18, the Roads Department of Georgia’s Ministry of...
13:52
Armenia moves up 19 spots on World Press Freedom Index
Armenia has jumped 19 spots to 61st among 180 countries in the 2019 World Press Freedom Index compiled by the Reporters Without Borders (RSF)....
13:00
U.S. proposes to host next meeting of Armenian, Azeri FMs
The United States has proposed to host the next round of talks over the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) conflict between Armenian and Azerbaijani...
12:35
PM to represent France at Armenian Genocide commemoration ceremony on 24 April
Prime Minister Edouard Philippe will represent France at a ceremony commemorating the Armenia Genocide victims to be held at the Komitas...
11:58
Massachusetts honors Armenian Genocide victims in State House ceremony
Martyrs and survivors of the Armenian Genocide were honored under the golden dome of the Massachusetts State House last week during the 104th...
11:46
Armenian parliament votes down opposition motion to dismiss finance minister
The Armenia National Assembly voted down the opposition motion to have Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan consider dismissing Finance Minister Atom...
11:13
Armenian parliament adopts bill on new government structure
The Armenian National Assembly adopted in the first reading a bill setting a new structure of the government at a sitting on Thursday. A...
10:54
Michael Jackson co-executor says estate might sue 'Leaving Neverland' director
A co-executor of Michael Jackson's estate said that they are considering suing Leaving Neverland director Dan Reed over the allegations made...
10:42
Armenian Church observes Holy Thursday
The entire week leading up to Easter or Holy Resurrection is known as Holy Week (in Armenian Avak Shabat). During this period, the Armenian...
20:39
Turkish workshop discusses the safety at Armenian nuclear power plant
A workshop n the eastern province of Igdir started on Tuesday on the Armenian Metsamor nuclear power plant that is located close to the Turkish...
20:14
Artsakh president says ensuring the security of the country and people among crucial priorities of the state
Artsakh president Bako Sahakyan delivered his annual address in the National Assembly on Wednesday, introducing the performance of the Artsakh...
19:29
Armenian team starts with victory at World Senior Team Championships 2019
World Senior Team Championships 2019 kicked off in Greece on April 15 with Armenian team participating at the tournament. The Championship is an...
18:37
Cabinet does not consider changing school education system of 12 years, minister says
The Armenian government does not consider changing the 12-year education system in the schools, the Minister of Education and Sciences Arayik...
18:23
Russia sends integration proposals to Belarus, says premier
Belarus remains Russia’s closest partner, Moscow has sent proposals on further integration to Minsk, Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev said...
17:04
Yerevan and Baku interested the reached agreements will not remain on paper – Lavrov
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov deems the agreements reached between Armenian and Azerbaijani FMs in the recent meeting held in Moscow as...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}