Society 16:58 29/10/2013

Lessons of anti-Armenian presentation in Moscow; Consequences of passion for xenophobic rhetoric

Yesterday, at the "AIF" press center in Moscow the presentation of the book "Truth about the "myths" of Karabakh conflict" written by historian Oleg Kuznetsov was held. Initially, the book was considered as a response to candidate of historical sciences Stanislav Tarasov’s work "Myths about Karabakh conflict."

However, as Vadim Gomoz editor of "Wikipedia" revealed during the presentation of the book, that the latter was replete with historical inaccuracies, disinformation, and outright falsification of facts about Armenian people’s history, from the very first pages.

As it can be seen in the video on YouTube, Vadim Gomoz, in the presence of the author, guests and journalists, voices the absurdities of the book page by page. For example, Kuznetsov argues that the "real" history of the Armenian nation is a "closed book." "This means that, it can be assumed that the Armenians have misled the entire population of the earth, and the world leading experts in Armenian Studies, and there are many of them, do not understand what they are writing about," says Vadim Gomoz and notes that such passages turn the book into a kind of conspiracy theory and not a scientific work, because these statements are made by a person who has no scientific publications on the Armenian Studies, and does not even know Armenian language.

Evidence that Kuznetsov doesn’t know Armenian language may serve at least the fact of incorrect translation of terms. For example, on page 8 the term "Hay Dat", which is quite widespread term in the scientific and political area, is translated as "Armenian trace" while "Hay Dat" means "Armenian Cause" and refers to the Armenian Genocide issue in Ottoman Turkey.

In the frameworks of scientific controversy, Vadim Gomoz also notes Kuznetsov’s untenable assertion which says as if there are no reliable sources on the Armenian history. In front of the historian-author, Gomoz lists a number of scientific, academic works, of both foreign and Russian authors. Gomoz also turns to sources of Armenian authors of Middle Ages, refutation existence of which is, principally, meaningless.

Referring to the author's claim, that majority of sources on Armenian history have narrative, oral nature, Gomoz notes, "I probably will reveal a big secret, but most of the ancient sources are narrative, that is, they have oral nature like legends and myths; for example, the oldest Russian-source "Tale of Bygone Years", or ancient source for the history of the Jews – "The Bible." These are all narrative sources and it is unclear why such a claim is put in front of the Armenians."

Vadim Gomoz also highlights the strictly unscientific statements of the author claiming that only local Muslims began to call the "Armenians" "hay", in order to distinguish them, not only from Muslims, but from the rest of the Christian population existing in the region. "The Armenians were first mentioned in Behistun Inscription (VI century BC) by Darius. I specially Googled down: "An Armenian named Dadarshish, my servant, I sent into Armenia, and I said unto him: "Go, smite that host which is in revolt, and doth not acknowledge, me," Vadim Gomoz quotes.

Speaking of Kuznetsov’s statement which reads that, "The Armenian Apostolic Church has served merely a screen for the Armenians throughout its history, and the Armenians are trying to hide from the Muslims their primordial national paganism", Gomoz notes: "The Armenian Apostolic Church has been emerged in the 50s AD. At the beginning of the 4th century, the Armenian Apostolic Church has become the official church of Armenia. The Arabs brought Islam into Caucasus in 645 AD. We must assume that for about six centuries, while there was neither Islam, nor Prophet Mohammed, the Armenian Apostolic Church was getting ready for the Muslims to come to that region, and was conducting a big conspiracy," Gomoz said.

He also touched upon the author who as evidence of his rightness quoted not the Armenian historians, but the candidate of Geological Sciences Suren Ayvazyan, who has no serious scientific publications so far, in the same time the author ignores the falsification of the official Azerbaijani historians. "Scientists from different countries say that it is the Azerbaijani scientists that falsify the documents.
Buniatov published a book, and edit from there out the word "Armenians". This is proven. Put the original book next to the one published in Azerbaijan in modern times," notes Gomoz and reminds that Suren Ayvazyan is not taken seriously even in Armenia. Yagub Mahmudov, the director of the Institute of History of ANAS, for example, had stated that the Russian and Kazakh historians are falsifiers because they had published a book called "Turan on ancient maps", where "there is no description of 5000-year-old ancient Azerbaijan."

In his book Kuznetsov also makes such ridiculous statement, like, for example, the statement saying that "before the end of the 19th century, the Armenians not only had no historical experience of their own national statehood, but also were in the early stages of tribal development. "Is this about the Armenians who created literature, built churches, and created their own alphabet?" Gomoz asks.

Most of Kuznetsov’s book is devoted to the hints and direct accusation towards Tarasov, claiming that the latter works for the Armenians. Of course, this is not an argument in the scientific controversy, but as far as Kuznetsov finds him relevant, he should explain to the readers that there is a scandalous trail of provocative cooperation with the Azerbaijani media being pulled after him as well. It should be noted that recently, a correspondence of Oleg Kuznetsov with Bahram Batiev, employee of the Azerbaijani news agency “Vesti.az”, appeared in the network. There, Kuznetsov clearly speaks of the payment for his "services" rendered to the Azerbaijani propaganda, and shows interest in public reaction on his anti-Armenian opuses.

It looks like, the idea of answering Stanislav Tarasov’s theses in the form of a book, abounding with disinformation and Azerbaijani propaganda, cannot inspire with confidence the reader who is able to think and analyze. As, if on the first 30 pages of the book you can find such big number of blunders, the rest of the content cannot invoke trust as well. This means that the resources and money spent by the Azerbaijani side played against her own state propaganda once again.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

11:02
Militant shelling kills around 30 civilians in Syria’s Aleppo
Illegal armed units continue to shell the Syrian city of Aleppo, where 28 civilians were killed in the past three days, the Russian Center for...
10:36
Two earthquakes recorded in Shirak province
An earthquake of 2,4 magnitude was registered 19 km south-east of Ashotsk village of Shirak province on Saturday at about 08:20 (GMT 04:20),...
20:33
PM receives astrophysicist Garik Israelian
Armenian PM Nikol Pashinyan received on Friday the founder and organizer of Starmus (Stars and Music) International festival, astrophysicist...
20:15
Some roads in Armenia are closed and difficult to pass
Some roads in Armenia are closed and difficult to pass as of January 17 at 6:55, the ministry of emergency situations (MES) reported....
19:41
KFOR Deputy Commander hails the high level of preparedness of Armenian peacekeepers in Kosovo
Deputy Commander of the NATO-led Kosovo Force (KFOR) Brigadier General Laurent Michaud visited the Armenian peacekeepers serving in Kosovo, the...
18:39
Alvina Gyulumyan elected Deputy President of the Constitutional Court
The judge of the Constitutional Court of Armenia Alvina Gyulumyan was elected on Friday Deputy President of the Constitutional Court during the...
18:29
European Figure Skating Championships to be held in Graz
The 2020 European Figure Skating Championships will be held in Graz, Austria, from 20–26 January 2020. As the National Olympic Committee...
17:44
Kutoyan’s body was found by wife – Artur Melikyan
The body of the former head of Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS) was found by his wife, the Head of Department of Investigation of...
16:36
Friday afternoon road conditions update
Some highways are closed or difficult to pass in the territory of Armenia as of Friday afternoon, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reported....
16:24
Ex-Armenian security chief found dead in Yerevan
Former Director of Armenia’s National Security Service Georgi Kutoyan was found dead with a gunshot wound in his apartment on...
15:58
US withdrawal from Open Skies Treaty to blow European security – Russian Foreign Ministry
Washington's withdrawal from the Treaty on Open Skies seriously "damages" European security and prompts Moscow to respond, the...
15:39
Three Turkish soldiers killed in car bomb attack in Syria
Three Turkish soldiers were killed in a car bomb attack while carrying out roadside checks on vehicles in northeast Syria on Thursday, Reuters...
15:37
EU ambassador to Armenia: You will have no human rights without rule of law
Political will is important in Armenia’s path to democracy, EU Ambassador to Armenia Andrea Wiktorin told reporters on Friday on the...
14:27
Pentagon: 11 US troops wounded in Iranian ballistic missile attack on Iraq bases
The Pentagon has revealed that 11 U.S. service members received treatment for concussions from an Iranian missile strike on Jan. 8, according...
14:16
Baku: Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs to hold new meeting by the end of January
Armenian and Azerbaijani Foreign Ministers Zohrab Mnatsakanyan and Elmar Mammadyarov will hold a new round of talks on the Nagorno-Karabakh...
13:59
Artistic director: ‘Tumanyan's Fairy Tales’ directed by Henrik Malyan can be included in Guinness World Records
2020 is a jubilee year for Henrik Malyan Theater of Cinema Artists, as it marks the 95th birthday anniversary of prominent Armenian filmmaker...
13:19
Khamenei: Iran gave U.S. 'slap on face', calls missile strikes 'day of God'
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said in a Friday sermon that Iran’s missile strikes on U.S. targets in Iraq this month delivered a...
12:59
Two seriously injured in house explosion in Armenian village
Two elderly people have been hospitalized with serious injuries after an explosion hit their house in the village of Zar in Armenia’s...
12:38
Ukraine PM submits resignation letter, president to consider it
Ukraine’s Prime Minister Oleksiy Honcharuk has submitted a letter of resignation and President Volodymur Zelenskiy will consider it, the...
12:33
Yerevan named most expensive city in South Caucasus
Yerevan, the capital of Armenia, appears to be the most expensive city in the South Caucasus, according to Cost of Living Index by City 2020...
11:59
Sepsis kills more people than cancer around the world
A new study finds that 1 in 5 deaths around the world is caused by sepsis, also known as blood poisoning, many more than previously estimated by...
11:42
A journey through history on Armenian Street in Singapore
An in-depth look at Singapore’s history reveals a history of civic and commercial involvement by Armenian merchants and entrepreneurs who...
11:27
Marine Le Pen announces bid for 2022 French presidential election
French far-right leader Marine Le Pen on Thursday announced she would run for president in the 2022 presidential election, Politico reported,...
11:23
Diplomat: Armenia values OSCE PA’s ‘balanced, tailor-made’ approach to various conflicts, crisis situations
Armenia’s Permanent Representative to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), Ambassador Armen Papikyan delivered...
11:06
VivaCell-MTS, Fuller Center for Housing hosted by Muradyans from Mayakovski village
Evaluating results is an important part of ensuring the continuity of any project. VivaCell-MTS and Fuller Center for Housing Armenia,...
10:59
Senate impeachment trial of Donald Trump officially begins
The third Senate impeachment trial of a US president in history convened on Thursday with the reading of the impeachment articles against...
20:44
Air temperature to go up by 3-4 degrees at night
Snow is predicted in separate regions in the daytime of January 19, at the night of 17, 20, Hydromet meteorological service at the ministry of...
20:38
FAAE asks The Semper Opera Ball for explanations over cancellation of Armenian soprano’s performance in Dresden
President of Forum of Armenian Associations of Europe Ashot Grigorian sent a letter to Artistic director of Semper Opera Ball Hans-Joachim Frey,...
20:34
Pashinyan congratulates Mishustin on his appointment as Prime Minister of Russia
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan congratulated Mikhail Mishustin on being appointed Prime Minister of the Russian Federation, the press...
19:21
VivaCell-MTS reports fourfold increase in LTE traffic during New Year period
The volume of Internet traffic in VivaCell-MTS mobile network on December 31, on New Year’s Eve before midnight, and on January 1, 2020,...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}