Society 13:11 14/11/2013

Europe, Azerbaijan, and the caviar: Azerbaijan in the center of attention of Italian press

The Italian “Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso” online resource issued an extensive publication concerning the European – Azerbaijani problems. We present to you the article written by Luka Zanoni, titled “Europe, Azerbaijan, and the caviar.”

The recent presidential elections in Azerbaijan for the OSCE were probably among the worst ever seen in the history of this institution, on the other hand for the MEPs led by Italian Pino Arlacchi they were free and transparent.

It's called caviar diplomacy. Caviar has always been a symbol of luxury due to its given high cost (about 1,500 euro per kg), and for quite some time it has enabled some countries to “make it clear “their own reasons to others. Azerbaijan is historically recognized as one of the producers of the best caviar in the world and also one of the countries that in recent years has been distinguished in this very special diplomatic activity.

In May 2012 the research center European Stability Initiative (ESI) has published "Diplomacy of caviar- Azerbaijan has silenced the Council of Europe." The report traces the stages of a process that was supposed to bring Azerbaijan close to the values and European democratic standards but instead it is likely to bring Europe to rest on the strong limitations to fundamental rights and the absence of free and fair elections in that country in exchange for their " caviar " . Of course, the ESI makes the point, “not all of those who have defended Azerbaijan in PACE [Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe] have done it for material benefits. There were other factors in the game including geopolitical considerations. But there are several indications that corruption played a big role in diverting the PACE from its responsibilities. "

"Caviar diplomacy - writes the ESI - began in 2001, not long ago after Azerbaijan joined the Council of Europe. It was strengthened after Ilham Aliyev became president of Azerbaijan in 2003. Once the Baku- Tbilisi -Ceyhan pipeline was constructed in 2005 and the state coffers flooded with Azeri oil revenues the ‘’ politics of caviar’’ has entered a higher gear. "

The CoE changes opinion about Azerbaijan

The extra gear is inserted in the elections of November 2005 which are decisive for the permanence of Azerbaijan in the assembly of the CoE. Indeed, the standard to be met to be part of the oldest international organization that deals with human rights and democracy inevitably appears the criterion of “free and fair elections.”

But despite the report of the OSCE / ODIHR Election 2005 were negative, as well as the CoE rapporteur by Andreas Gross, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) decided not to sanction Azerbaijan. The rapporteurs on Azerbaijan were repeatedly attacked by the majority of members of the Assembly of the CoE for their critical positions of the Azerbaijani elections.

On the eve of the presidential election of 2008 the Azerbaijani debate was a hot topic again and the British Michael Hancock and The Estonian Kristiina Ojuland who were pro-Azerbaijiani disagreed with the position of the former rapporteur Andres Herkel. The focus of the debate finally shifted to the role of the OSCE / ODIHR and the alleged unreliability of the expert mission.

"Until the nineties Azerbaijan was considered a state of no importance. With the boom of hydrocarbons it has acquired great importance and as soon as it understood how to take advantage of the European side, Azerbaijan created a very effective and determined lobby, "says an official at OBC in Brussels.

Illuminating are the words of Lise Christoffersen relating to an affair of 2009 when the Norwegian deputy was close to be named the PACE co-rapporteur on Azerbaijan.

“A mostly hidden network which was gradually becoming visible was mobilized to prevent my designation ... There was the strong reluctance of Azerbaijan to the appointment of the Norwegian rapporteur and the reason was obvious. During our countries’ official visits Norway always raises the issue of human rights violations in Azerbaijan. "

The parliamentary elections were held in Azerbaijan in 2010 which were defined by ESI as “the most fraudulent that has ever been monitored in a member state of the CoE." The mission of ODIHR then led by Audrey Glover collided with the mission of PACE in the short term and the other two field missions, the EP and the Parliamentary Assembly of the OSCE the outcome of election observation. The result was some trade-offs to draft a joint document which, however, was followed by four different embarrassing statements to the press.

Debates, reports followed and even a petition signed by 19 Azerbaijani civil society organizations addressed to the PACE and the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly. At the end of Audrey Glover said resignedly: " There is so much distrust that it renders the question: is there any value in the continuous monitoring of these countries?”

The Elections of 2013

Azerbaijan presidential elections were held on October 9, 2013. With the constitutional amendment of 2009 confirmed by a referendum which abolishes the limit of two consecutive presidential terms, Ilham Aliyev had a chance to reapply and get the 84 .5 % of preferences on the third five-year term for the presidency of the Republic. Recall that the above mentioned amendment has been a subject of series of complaints by the CoE and the Venice Commission for its dubious democratic value.

The mission of long-term (3 months ) of the OSCE / ODIHR led by Tana de Zulueta concluded in the very detailed report of October 10 that " the elections of October 9 have been compromised by restrictions on freedom of expression, assembly and association, which did not ensure a level playing field for candidates . " This position is still in stark contrast with that expressed in the joint statement of the mission of PACE and the official of the European Parliament led by the Socialist deputy Pino Arlacchi . The joint statement of missions and short-term (4 days) of PACE and the EP on 10 October, in essence states that " on the whole, on the Election Day we observed the electoral process which was ‘’free, fair and transparent." Scandal, for the first time the two missions do not find a compromise and make two completely different press releases.

On 11 October in a statement on the Azerbaijani presidential elections Catherine Ashton, High Representative of the EU for Foreign Affairs and Commissioner Štefan Füle didn’t seem to take into account the mission of the EP. In the joint statement they included the results of the OSCE/ ODIHR with just a quick mention of EP and PACE of the monitoring missions.
An Embarrassing mission

A week after the election in Azerbaijan scandal rises. The Foreign Affairs Committee of the European Parliament discussed the report of the mission led by Arlacchi . The greens reacted harshly and forwarded a statement to the press criticizing the official report of the EP mission. “The Greens / EFA Group does not endorse the statements made by the EP delegation and requests a meeting with the Head of Mission of the OSCE / ODIHR Tana de Zulueta," says Ulrike Lunacek , Foreign Affairs spokesman of the group. Another green spokesman Werner Schulz made even tougher statement: "The European Parliament loses credibility with statements that ignore the reality of the situation in the country. A group of MPs is damaging the reputation of the European Parliament in the struggle for human rights, democracy and the rule of law."

Arlacchi confidently reiterated his position in an exclusive interview with the Azerbaijani APA agency. When asked by the journalist Victoria Dementyeva: " How do you explain the big difference in assessments of the European Parliament, PACE and ODIHR?” Arlacchi replies: "It's very simple. We were 66 MPs belonging to 3 different assemblies - CoE, OSCE and PE. We have all observed the elections freely and we had a positive opinion about them. The ODIHR is formed by a group of so-called experts without political responsibility that have not been elected by anyone. So it is easy to manipulate. Our assessment was done with a great sense of responsibility; we also know that parliamentary elections much better than the experts who just want to be sure to get work at the next opportunity. "

Meanwhile, the president of the Socialist Group in the European Parliament, Hannes Swoboda said: “The group of Socialists in the European Parliament has distanced itself from the words of the observer mission EP / PACE on the recent elections in Azerbaijan. The group believes that the differences between the findings of the delegation of parliamentarians and the OSCE are so far away that it cannot be supported at all."

Business list

The scandal did not stop. The case of Members of Parliament was revealed: they went unofficially in Azerbaijan during the elections on 9 October. In an article in the influential European Voice with the significant title "MEPs must explain trips to Azerbaijan," published on October 17, the matter was brought to the surface with very clear words. “A crass stupidity or a petty venality seem to be the only plausible explanations for a member of the European Parliament choosing to go to Baku as an unofficial observer of Azerbaijan’s sham presidential election in Azerbaijan last week ." The newspaper reports the list (probably incomplete) with the names of deputies who “who appears to have indulged in electoral tourism ". That was the comment made by the newspaper founded by the Economist Group -adds: " Ivo Vajgl (Slovenia), Alexandra Thein (Germany) and Hannu Takkula (Finland) , all of the liberal ALDE group , they traveled at the expense of the German Association , the Society for the promotion of German - Azerbaijani relations , which appears to be a thinly disguised front organization for Azerbaijani government interests . [...] liberal Estonian MEP Kristiina Ojuland was quoted by the Azerbaijani media praising the government but refuses to say who paid the trip. "

“No wonder. It is known that various members of the EP are on the ' Azerbaijani business list '. That is to say, gifts, travel, luxury hotels, etc. " The above mentioned statement was made by an anonymous sources within the EP was made to OBC. The same source does not hide that luxurious Christmas baskets, including caviar safely reach the Brussels offices.

The European Parliament reacts and Azerbaijan leaves Euronest

The crisis of monitoring missions in Azerbaijan flares up just seven months before the elections for the European Parliament. The image of an important pillar of the European Union is likely to be in doubt. At this point the European Parliament reacts indirectly discrediting the conclusions of his own mission.

In its resolution on Neighborhood Policy adopted on 23 October by the European Parliament passes a note that angers the Azerbaijani government a lot. In paragraph 32 of the resolution it is stated that the European Parliament " regrets the fact that according to the findings of long-term mission of ODIHR, the recent presidential election held on October 9, 2013 didn’t meet the OSCE standards imposing restrictions on freedom of assembly and expression; calls, in view of this, on the Azerbaijani authorities to address and swiftly implement all the recommendations included in the current and past ODIHR / OSCE reports.’’

The Azerbaijani reaction was immediate. The next day in a letter addressed to the President of the European Parliament Martin Schulz, the MP Elkhan Suleymanov - close to President Ilham Aliyev and driving the Azerbaijani delegation to Euronest (assembly was founded by the EP in 2009 which in addition to MEP members also includes members of so-called Eastern partners: Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine) replied angrily to the note contained in the EP resolution.

Suleymanov accuses the European Parliament saying that " The EP want to create unrest and sabotage in Azerbaijan ," adding that perhaps the EP is not fully succeeded in his ’’ campaign of sabotage’’ which is to "transform Azerbaijan in Libya or in Syria ", since the elections were " free and fair ". For this reason the “the Azerbaijani delegation is obliged to suspend all activities within the Euronest Assembly." This position was confirmed on 6 November in Kiev during the Euronest meeting.

Baku and the crisis of the missions

Finally, on November 7 a meeting was held in Brussels with the head of the monitoring mission to OSCE / ODIHR Election in Azerbaijan in the presence of the Democracy Support and Election Coordination Group (DEG) and spokesman of the Foreign Affairs Committee of the groups, i.e. practically all parliamentary political groups. The meeting was attended by all participants but in the end they didn’t reach any conclusion. The second round will be held on 12 December.

Many EP members talked about the recent developments in Azerbaijan, especially the liberal Alexander Graf Lambsdorff who stated "I am thrilled about how a small non-governmental organization based in Germany which is in charge of relations with Azerbaijan has been able to pay for the trip in business class and first class hotels for 120 people across Europe including parliamentarians.” A truly remarkable number which if confirmed makes the idea of size and capacity of the so-called “caviar diplomacy.”

What about the ESI, study center based in Berlin. Their latest report released a few days ago is unequivocally entitled ‘’disgraced Azerbaijan and the end of election monitoring as we know it’’. Seven pages are dedicated to several parliamentary relations with Azerbaijan and the lobbying work of some organizations very similar to the one indicated by Lambsdorff. ESI also puts in doubt the value of monitoring missions’ short-term election as a tool to promote democracy.

In fact, what happened in Baku last month marked a kind of watershed in monitoring missions. The striking difference between the OSCE / ODIHR and the short-term missions has affected the credibility of some of the most respected institutions. The EU and its parliament have shown that they are able to react. It could be necessary if those important institutions could clarify this incredible story and to question, as soon as possible, about the meaning of the international election observation missions.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:03
National Geographic: How to plan a wine-tasting tour of Armenia
As Armenia prepares to host the 8th UN Tourism Global Conference on Wine Tourism between 11-13 September 2024, National Geographic rounds up the...
16:32
U,S. Embassy rejects arrested activist Narek Samsonyan's letter
The U.S. Embassy in Yerevan on Friday refused to accept an open letter from arrested opposition activist and Imnemnimi podcast co-host Narek...
16:09
Reporter accuses Armenian authorities of crackdown on dissent
Chairman of the Civic Consciousness NGO, founder of AntiFake.am media outlet, political prisoner Narek Samsonyan wrote an open letter-inquiry to...
15:30
Varsen Aghabekian named Palestine's state minister
Armenian Varsen Aghabekian has been appointed Palestine's Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and Expatriates, WAFA reported....
14:54
Ameriabank named Best Bank in Armenia for 2024 by Global Finance
Ameriabank has been named the Best Bank in Armenia by Global Finance magazine in its 31st annual awards for the World’s Best Banks....
14:35
MP Tigran Abrahamyan blasts Pashinyan for threatening Artsakh leaders
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has decried Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s statements in which he slammed Artsakh’s...
13:59
Queen Camilla says Kate is 'thrilled by all the kind wishes and support'
Princess Kate is "thrilled by all the kind wishes and support" after sharing her cancer news, Queen Camilla has said. The...
13:35
MP Levon Kocharyan warns of false statements
Opposition Hayastan faction MP Levon Kocharyan has warned his supporters over false and misleading statements being disseminated on his...
13:08
Armenian expert warns against land handover to Azerbaijan
Political scientist Suren Petrosyan warns that the handover of four border villages in Tavush Province to Azerbaijan would pave the way for the...
12:43
Yerevan Bus head resigns
Yerevan Bus CJSC Director Hovhannes Manukyan has stepped down. "I've submitted resignation today," he said in a social...
12:23
Police raiding homes of Armenian opposition group members
The Armenian authorities are searching the homes of members and supporters of the opposition group National Democratic Pole as well as its...
11:47
Armenian leadership seeking rupture of ties with Russia, Lavrov says
The Armenian leadership is messing up relations with Moscow for no good reason, TASS quoted Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov as...
11:30
Today marks Good Friday
The week leading up to Easter or Holy Resurrection is called Holy Week (in Armenian Avak Shabat). During this period, the Armenian Apostolic...
11:15
Political prisoner Narek Samsonyan addresses open letter-inquiry to U.S. ambassador
Chairman of Civic Consciousness NGO, founder of AntiFake.am media outlet, political prisoner Narek Samsonyan wrote an open letter-inquiry to...
11:00
ARF calls for consolidation to save Armenian statehood
The Armenian Revolutionary Federation-Dashnaktsutyun (ARF-D) Bureau issued the following statement on Thursday: "In recent weeks, Nikol...
17:12
She said yes: Marriage proposal at Hayat Project concert in Gyumri
A young man proposed to his beloved at a Hayat Project concert in Gyumri, Armenia’s second largest city. In a video posted online, the...
16:45
Opposition MP slams Pashinyan's Artsakh statements
Opposition Hayastan faction MP Ishkhan Saghatelyan has expressed support to the Artsakh government in exile following Armenian Prime Minister...
16:04
MP Aghvan Vardanyan visits arrested activists
MP Aghvan Vardanyan, who represents the opposition Hayastan faction, on Thursday visited the Armavir Penitentiary where activists Vazgen...
15:36
Armenian opposition MP visits border villages
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has visited the villages of Voskepar and Baghanis in Tavush Province adjacent to the border areas demanded by...
15:04
Ex-Yerevan mayor setting up new party
Former Yerevan Mayor Hayk Marutyan is setting up a new party in the near future, his team has confirmed to RFE/RL’s Armenian Service....
14:36
Armenia to send 29.94 tons of humanitarian aid to Gaza
Armenia will deliver 29.94 tons of humanitarian aid to Gaza ravaged by the conflict with Israel. The decision was approved at a cabinet...
14:07
Expert: Pashinyan decided to terrorize Artsakh leaders
Political analyst Suren Surenyants has criticized Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s statements on Artsakh leaders at a cabinet meeting on...
13:35
Analyst: The West doesn't care about Armenia
The West wants Armenia and Azerbaijan to sign a peace treaty as soon as possible and Armenia's territorial losses do not matter to it,...
13:06
Moscow concerned over anti-Russian bias of Armenia-EU-US meeting
The Armenia-EU-US meeting scheduled for April 5 is causing Moscow’s concern as Washington and Brussels are openly discussing its...
12:37
Pashinyan: Some circles displaced from Karabakh take actions threatening Armenia's security
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan warns that the actions taken by “some circles” forcibly displaced from Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh)...
12:04
Artsakh dissolution decree was 'the only way' to save people, president says
President Samvel Shahramanyan claims his decree ordering the dissolution of the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) Republic was the “only...
11:30
Japanese supplement products recalled after two deaths and over 100 people hospitalized
Health supplement products believed to have caused two deaths and sickened more than 100 people have been ordered to be taken off store shelves...
11:15
Today is Holy Thursday
The week leading up to Easter or Holy Resurrection is called Holy Week (in Armenian Avak Shabat). During this period, the Armenian Apostolic...
11:00
Upcoming Armenia-US-EU meeting not directed against any third party – Foreign Ministry
The high-level meeting scheduled for April 5 in Brussels is aimed at strengthening Armenia-EU-US cooperation and is not directed against...
17:00
Azerbaijan's team opts out of Sambo World Cup in Yerevan
Azerbaijan's national team will not participate in the Sambo World Cup to be held in Yerevan, Armenia, Azerbaijani Sambo Federation official...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}