Interviews 17:00 19/12/2013

French expert: Recognition of Nagorno-Karabakh Republic is the only solution that can ensure stability in region

Panorama.am presents an interview with Adrien Gévaudan, expert in geopolitics and geo-economics, founder of analytical website IntStrat, who has recently published an article titled “Geopolitics of the Greater Caucasus and Nagorno-Karabakh” (also published in French). 

- Mr. Gévaudan, you have recently been studying the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and you have written an article on it. From your point of view what is at the heart of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict?

- Historically speaking, the heart of the problem is the disappearance of the Soviet Union (the beginning of its breakup to be more precise) which set the region on fire.

But today I believe the most important problem is the growing imbalance of powers in the region. Nagorno-Karbakh is isolated and its resources are limited. It is obvious that the power balance between Armenia and Azerbaijan is strongly in favour of the latter (for well known reasons: autocratic system, growing military forces and huge royalties from the hydrocarbon industry). Internationally speaking, when you have a status quo in a situation where there is a balance of power between the states concerned, you can assume they won’t easily change the way they act against one another. However, if the power balance changes too much and too quickly, it is only a matter of time before one side decides to take advantage of its weaker adversary; strategically speaking, it is only logical. And even if right now Azerbaijan is not willing to wage war against Armenia, let’s not forget that they did lose the previous war and that they still claim sovereignty over Nagorno-Karabakh. If you add to his strong geopolitical powers, such as Iran, Russia or Israel, you have a powder keg ready to explode.

- In that case don’t the Madrid principles, particularly the point about the surrender of territories, actually propose even further shifting of the power balance in favour of the already-strong Azerbaijan? If this point is ever implemented won’t this increase the likelihood of a new war by Azerbaijan against Karabakh as opposed to long-term peace?

- Theoretically speaking if an imbalance is created, consequences will follow. This imbalance already exists in favour of Azerbaijan. So in order to counter that and to avoid war, you have to propose a resolution that solves this imbalance. But how will it be possible when it seems Azerbaijan has no interest in solving the issue? As for how the furthering of the imbalance can result in peace, this is the key problem – it is unlikely to result in peace. This is why I will not be very optimistic, mid-term speaking.

- From a purely geopolitical perspective what configuration do you think is more likely to ensure long-term stability in the region – the affirmation of the status quo and the recognition of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR) or a deal based on the implementation of Madrid principles?

- It is difficult to answer. The status quo is actually unlikely to last again because of the growing power imbalance, midterm speaking. For the same reasons, Madrid principles are not likely to be implemented right now; if this process did fail when the imbalance of powers was less vivid, why should it be successful now?
Therefore, the international recognition of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic is, in my opinion, the only solution to ensure the stability of the region. But let’s not get carried away: even if it happens, let’s not forget that war between internationally recognized countries can also (easily) occur…

- What do you think are the main reasons for the non-recognition of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR)? Do you think the NKR has the necessary attributes to “deserve” international recognition?

- The main reasons for the non-recognition are of course political!
As I have written in my paper, an entity can be recognized as an independent state when it meets the Montevideo criteria (1933) 1) stable territory; 2) permanent population; 3) political authority and 4) the capacity to build relations with other states. Let’s just say the NKR has the first three and the problem resides with the last one. But in order to build relations with other states you have to be recognized by them, which is quite a paradox.

This having said, we must at the same time acknowledge that international recognition has nothing to do with “deserving” it; recognition is an instrument of power and sovereign states are using it as such. Unfortunately states are not acting internationally driven by ethics but by interest. We can deplore it, and I personally do, but this is a fact. If the NKR wants to be recognized as an independent state, it has to give to strong geopolitical powers interest in doing so.

- And in what case can these powers have an interest in recognizing the NKR?

- As a matter of fact they already do have such interest given all the problems an open conflict would create if it were to explode in the South Caucasus. This especially should be a concern for the EU; this is why I think the EU should do more to promote the international recognition of the NKR. Nobody wants a new war right now (not even the Azerbaijanis); we should, we must take advantage of this while the consensus on peace is still existing.

- One final question: I wonder how you as a French researcher got interested in the topic of Nagorno-Karabakh and what motivated you to study it.

- I always have had a strong interest in protracted conflicts, especially those ignored by the dominant media. In general I dislike the way topics are chosen by mass media - on the one hand the media can create a “bubble” out of a trivial conflict and on the other hand it can completely censor a quite important and serious one. For this reason I got interested in the conflicts that are ignored by the media in the first place and in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict in particular, which I believe is a good example of the latter case. I can honestly say that if it hadn’t been for my contact with Save the Children NGO, I don’t think I would have ever heard about it. It is a pity that we have to depend on random, personal events to discover critical conflicts, especially this one.

- Mr Gévaudan, thank you very much for this interesting talk. 

Interview by Nvard Chalikyan

 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

20:30
U.S. donates $665,000 worth of medical equipment to Armenia’s expeditionary military medical unit
U.S. Ambassador to Armenia Lynne M. Tracy and U.S. Air Force Brigadier General Edward Vaughan, Deputy Director of Plans, Policy, Strategy and...
20:09
Mining companies in Armenia owe around 71 million drams to state – Prosecutor General's Office
Mining companies in Armenia owe around 71 million drams (approx. $148 thousand) to the state in mandatory payments, the Prosecutor General's...
19:36
Lawyer: Armen Charchyan's arrest proved illegal once again
The expertise carried out by an interdepartmental commission has proved that famous Armenian doctor and opposition MP Armen Charchyan was...
18:52
Author of Soghomon Tehlirian monument: ‘We should not be guided by the Turks' wish, should we?’
Recent media reports suggest that the monument to Armenian revolutionary and soldier Soghomon Tehlirian in the town of Maralik in...
17:45
Temperatures set to drop sharply in Armenia
Snow and fog are predicted in some regions of Armenia on January 20, with snowstorm expected to hit mountainous regions. No precipitation is...
17:30
Oil prices slip from 2014 highs
Oil slipped on Thursday on indications of rising U.S. stocks and as investors took profits after a recent price rally, but strong demand and...
17:16
Armenian security chief: There must not be any restrictions on Artsakh’s status
The signing of a peace treaty with Azerbaijan presupposes a number of conditions, Secretary of Armenia’s Security Council Armen Grigoryan...
16:37
Instagram testing paid subscriptions with small group of creators
Instagram rolled out a paid subscription feature with a small group of U.S. creators on Wednesday that will allow followers to pay for exclusive...
16:23
Armenian analyst: Meeting with US Congress members was just ‘photo op’ for Makunts
Political analyst Suren Sargsyan on Thursday weighed in on a meeting of the Armenian parliamentary delegation with U.S. House Speaker Nancy...
15:42
Toivo Klaar to visit Armenia, Azerbaijan
EU Special Representative for South Caucasus Toivo Klaar will visit Armenia and Azerbaijan, the politician said on Thursday. “Good to...
15:15
Argentina leave Messi out of squad for World Cup qualifiers
Argentina have left Lionel Messi out of their squad for World Cup qualifiers against Chile and Colombia as the Paris St Germain forward...
14:56
EBRD provides US$ 25 million to Ameriabank for private sector lending
The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) is providing a US$ 25 million financial support to Ameriabank in Armenia for...
14:41
Government's refusal to provide data on suspicious ZCMC deal is baseless and illegal, lawyer says
The Armenian Government has refused to provide the copy of donation agreement for transferring 15% of the shares of the Zangezur Copper...
14:04
Blinken seeks united front with European allies over Russia
US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken heads Thursday to Berlin for meetings with key European allies, as part of a whirlwind diplomatic tour to...
13:39
Parakar residents demand snap elections
Dozens of residents of Armenia's Parakar community have gathered outside the Armenian government building to protest what they call 'the...
12:46
Nancy Pelosi and Alen Simonyan agree the final settlement of the NK conflict can be reached under the auspice of the OSCE Minsk Group
Speaker of the Armenian parliament Alen Simonyan met on Wednesday with the Speaker of the U.S House of Representatives Nancy Pelosi, press...
12:34
Armenia reports 621 fresh Covid cases on Jan. 20
Armenia has confirmed 621  new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 349,329 as of 11 a.m. Thursday, January 20,...
12:05
Louvre threatens to sue Marine Le Pen for campaign film
The Louvre is threatening to sue Marine Le Pen, leader of the far-right National Rally, after she broadcast a presidential election campaign...
11:40
Artsakh Ombudsman urges not to give in to Azerbaijani manipulations
"In an interview with Azerbaijani media, the Azerbaijani leader expressed dissatisfaction with the fact that the Russian peacekeeping force...
10:58
Armenian church commemorates the King St. Theodos and Children of Ephesus
The Armenian Apostolic Church commemorates on January 20 King and distinguished Captain Theodos, who is called also Theodos the Great, is known...
10:33
Blizzard, snowstorms reported on number of roads in Armenia
It is snowing in Armavir, Baghramyan, Talin, Artik, Akhuryan, Ashotsk, Abovyan, Sevan, Noyemberyan, Gavar, Martuni, Tchambark, Vardenis, Spitak,...
20:30
No bodies found during search operations in Artsakh's Varanda
Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) search and rescue squads found no bodies during their operations in the Azerbaijani-occupied areas of Varanda region...
20:21
Blinken in Kyiv urges Russia to take peaceful path
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken has called on Russia to take a "diplomatic and peaceful path" as an estimated 100,000 Russian...
20:06
199 servicemen and 21 civilians still missing after the 44-day War
The Department of Investigation of Particularly Important Cases of General Military Investigative Department of the RA Investigative Committee...
19:11
Snowstorm reported on some roads in Armenia
Snow is reported in Talin, Ani, Artik, Akhuryan, Ashotsk, Hrazdan, Sevan, Sisian regions and Stepanavan turns,  "Road Department"...
18:51
FM: Conditions on formation of the commission on the border delimitation between Armenia and Azerbaijan under discussion
"No commission on the border delimitation and demarcation has been created yet, and the discussions now focus on the conditions based on...
18:07
The Armenian side passed a package of proposals to the Russian and Azerbaijani sides - Mirzoyan
The Armenian side has prepared and submitted a package of proposals on de-escalation of the situation on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border area,...
17:02
Baku’s anti-Armenian and genocidal policy has a clear chronology - Gegham Stepanyan
32 years ago, on January 13-19, 1990 a systematic and mass massacre of the Armenian population was carried out in Baku with apparent permission...
16:12
Turkey's “White Dove” - Today marks the anniversary of Hrant Dink's assassination
January 19 marks the 15th anniversary of the assassination of prominent Armenian-Turkish journalist, the editor-in-chief of Istanbul-based Agos...
15:08
World's oldest man dies at 112
The world’s oldest man, Saturnino de la Fuente García from León, Spain, has died at the age of 112 and 341 days, the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}