Society 10:10 18/07/2014

'What is the price of a little inconvenience when it comes to protecting our privacy?'

Both typewriter and strong encryption is going to slow down communication, but upholding a basic democratic right of privacy seems to be more important, former MI5 agent Annie Machon told RT.

Amid the American-German espionage scandal, German politicians are considering going back to old-fashioned manual typewriters for confidential documents in order to protect national secrets from American NSA surveillance.

RT: Why would Germany think of using typewriters as a security measure?

Annie Machon: What I find interesting is that we have a situation where even our democratically elected representatives have to think deeply and seriously about how to protect the privacy of their communications, particularly when the investigation of the very subject of invasion of the privacy of the citizens, which is what the Bundestag at the moment is doing in Germany, trying to hold hearings to work out what exactly the NSA has been doing, which might be contravening the constitution of Germany. It is very difficult now but it is still possible to protect your electronic communications, but I think this announcement, this sort of statement by the Bundestag representative about going back to typewriters is interesting. It just makes a very strong point that we all need to be aware of the fact that we can be spied on at any time.

RT: Do you think everyone would follow Germany’s example?

AM: I think more and more people are concerned about their privacy because of the Edward Snowden disclosures. He has done the world a huge service with great personal cost, exposing the predations of the US Intelligence agencies and the NSA particularly, as well as a number of European agencies. In the past all countries spied on each other because they wanted to gain advantage over other countries, not necessarily their enemies, just an advantage economically or politically. However, what we are seeing at the moment is the result of what was the perfect storm for the USA in the 1990s, it was a perfect opportunity for them, because at that point the Cold War had ended, they were the sole remaining superpower on the planet, and precisely at that moment we had the evolution of the internet, a huge tech explosion of communications. They saw the opportunity and they went for it. Of course they did because that meant that they could embed whatever they wanted into the infrastructure that the whole world now uses for communication. Of course they were not going to turn this opportunity down, and they haven’t. That is what Edward Snowden disclosed.

So we have the situation now when everything can conceivably be hoovered up by the NSA and its vassal states in Europe, everything can conceivably be stored for ever and be used against citizens in the future if the laws change. And everything can conceivably be known amongst the private deliberations of our parliament’s democratically elected representatives. It’s worse than Orwellian.

It would be naïve to think that the US would not take up this opportunity, but of course they did, and these are the results we are living in. It would be lovely to think that we could go back to the era of having privacy in our lives that our governments would have power to ensure we had it, but in this globalized world it is very difficult to ensure that. One of the things that is little known out of all Snowden’s disclosures is the fact that it is not just what we send over the internet, it is also hardware, the computers, the technology we actually use that can already be compromised by the NSA. This is one of the things that came out just after Christmas last year. So we are living in a very complex world but there are very simple steps we can take, both the governments and the citizens, to protect our democratic and our basic right to privacy.

RT: Wouldn’t using typewriters slow things down in terms of communication? Why not use other, more modern ways of protecting communication? 

AM: Either going back to using pen paper or typewriter or using very strong encryption is going to slow down one’s communication, there is no doubt about it. The point is though, what is more important, is it access to the latest celebrity gossip on the internet or is it actually upholding a basic democratic right of privacy. Because if we don’t have privacy, then we lose our freedom to communicate easily and in private, we lose our freedom to ingest information via video, audio or from reading, we cannot plan, we cannot conduct private personal relationships over the internet. So what is the price of a little bit of inconvenience when it comes to protecting our basic rights? I think that however light-heartedly the German politician mentioned using typewriters, when it comes to proper security issues within government, he is probably absolutely right. Last year there was a report as well, saying that some of the Russian security operators were now using typewriters too. We will all have to think about that, and it’s just a jolting wake up call to make us all think about that by stating that the German government is now going back to typewriters for certain things.

RT: What kind of solution do you see? Should people rely on their governments for protection of their privacy?

AM: There is a danger that people and the government will become very paranoid about trying to protect against the predations of the NSA and its vassals in Europe. However, I’m not sure as we as citizens can rely on governments to protect our privacy because all governments would want to know what is going on on the internet for legitimate reasons as well, to try to track down the illegitimate criminals and terrorists. But it can be easy for them to hoover up all the personal information and we, as citizens, need that have that guarantee of privacy. So one of the things we can do as citizens is to take responsibility in our own hands. We can indeed source all technologies, source computers pre-2008 that have not built-in hardware backdoors. We can use decent PGP encryption, we can use Tor to hide what we are looking at in the internet, we can use other encryption methodologies to protect our privacy, and we need to. I think it’s a very interesting crossroads in our history, both as civilizations, as democracy and as individuals, but also how we view the technology, how we use it, how we can better use it to protect our life, so that is going it be an ongoing debate. I’m very pleased to see this in Germany particularly. The politicians seem to be waking up around these issues and wanting debate these issues because the USA has got away with it for long enough across the West. 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

08:00
Geghasar housewives, tractors and idlers
Stories of four women from Geghasar village of northern Armenia Armine “I am the housewife and this is my husband, Armen, my...
20:00
Mineral water production grows in Armenia
Armenia saw an increase in mineral water production over the first three months of 2019, according to the latest figures released by the...
19:35
Magnitude 2.2 quake recorded near Spitak town
The Seismic Protection Service of Armenia’s ministry of emergency situations registered a magnitude 2.2 earthquake in the territory of...
19:30
Azerbaijan insists safety of Arsenal's Henrikh Mkhitaryan
The Azerbaijan FA has insisted that there is “no issue” over the safety and security of Arsenal attacker Henrikh Mkhitaryan, who is...
19:11
Air temperature to drop by 4-5 degrees
On May 19, on 22 in separate regions, in the afternoon of 20-21 in most regions rain and thunderstorm is predicted, in separate regions hail is...
17:32
Artsakh reports over 80 Azerbaijani ceasefire violations over past week
The Azerbaijani armed forces violated the ceasefire along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan Line of Contact over 80 times in the past week. In the...
17:30
Prosecutors to appeal release of general ex-President Kocharyan
Armenia’s Prosecutor General’s Office will appeal the ruling of the Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction releasing former president...
16:25
Ex-President Robert Kocharyan released from pre-trial detention
The Yerevan Court, under presiding judge Davit Grigoryan, ruled today to release Armenia’s second President Robert Kocharyan from...
15:00
Kocharyan’s lawyer issues message to PM
The member of the ex-President Robert Kocharyan’s defense team Hayk Alumyan has issued a message to Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan,...
12:57
Museum Night: Entrance to more than100 Armenian and Artsakh museums free of charge on May 18
The Museum Night event will be held in Armenia today on May 18. The event is organized by the International Council of Museum (ICOM) within the...
12:23
MP from the ruling party urges citizens to exert pressure on Judge over ex-President Kocharyan’s case
Member of the ruling My Step fraction at the Armenian National Assembly Hayk Sargsyan has called on citizens to exert pressure on the judge...
12:19
Tigran Kirakosyan wins gold at the European Sambo Championship
Armenian athlete Tigran Kirakosyan was named champion at the European Sambo championship in Spanish Gijon on May 17, the Armenian National...
11:18
Aronian loses at the opening game of the FIDE Grand Prix
Armenian grandmaster Levon Aronian lost the game to Yan Nepomniachtchi at the opening game of the first leg of the 2019 FIDE Grand Prix series...
20:29
Pashinyan confirms upcoming meeting with Putin
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has confirmed he will meet with Russian president Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of St. Petersburg...
20:27
Lawyer calls the charge brought against the owner of the Fifth Channel as political persecution
The charge brought against Armen Tavadyan, the owner of the Fifth TV Channel is a political persecution, lawyer Narek Aloyan stated on Friday....
19:44
Statistics reveal poor building conditions in Armenian schools, lacking heating system, water and even sanitation
The Armenian National Statistical Service published a report about the condition of school buildings of 1409 schools operating throughout the...
18:35
Armenian athletes win two medals at European Sambo Championship
Three representatives of the Armenian team in the sports sambo succeeded in the European Sambo Championships which kicked off in Spanish Gijon...
18:04
FIDE Grand Prix to kick off in Moscow
The first leg of the 2019 FIDE Grand Prix series will be officially opened on Thursday in Moscow and the first round is on Friday. 16 players...
18:02
PM meets with representatives of leading Russian mass media outlets
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan met with representatives of a number of leading Russian media outlets in the Office of Government. As...
16:50
Council of Europe restores Russia’s voting rights
The Council of Europe adopted a declaration Friday that allows Russia to start voting again at the continent’s main human rights body...
15:52
Ex-king of Belgium faces fine or love child DNA paternity test
Albert II, the former king of Belgium, will be fined €5,000 per day until he accepts to undergo a DNA test, the Brussels appeals court...
15:45
Kocharyan’s lawyer names biggest omission in ex-president’s trial
The trial of Armenia’s second President Robert Kocharyan proceeded smoothly in general, despite several serious omissions, his lawyer Aram...
14:56
Yerevan Metro chief resigns
Director of the Yerevan Metro Paylak Yayloyan has been dismissed upon his own resignation, Metro spokesperson Tatev Khachatryan told...
14:11
President: The 21st century is the century of Armenians
On a working visit to Kazakhstan, President Armen Sarkissian of Armenia attended a penal discussion on the risks of the collapse of the global...
13:14
Practical steps needed to save Iran nuclear deal, FM Zarif says
The remaining signatories of Iran’s nuclear deal should act to save the accord as “supportive statements” are not enough,...
13:08
Armenian parliamentary delegation to attend CSTO PA session in Bishkek
A delegation of the Armenian National Assembly led by Speaker Ararat Mirzoyan is leaving for Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan on Sunday to take part in a...
12:44
Armenian FM: Human rights not selective, cannot have ‘gray zones’
“The Council of Europe is for protecting rights of 830 million people of Europe. Human rights are not selective, cannot have grey zones....
12:06
Istanbul-Armenian writer Sevan Nisanyan grated Armenian citizenship
Istanbul-Armenian writer, linguist, reporter and columnist Sevan Nisanyan, who escaped prison and fled Turkey in 2017, has been granted Armenian...
11:40
Zelensky to dissolve Ukrainian parliament, says aide
Ukrainian President-Elect Vladimir Zelensky will initiate the dissolution of the Verkhovna Rada (Ukrainian parliament), his aide Dmitry Razumkov...
11:31
Arsenal expect Mkhitaryan to miss Europa League final over safety fears
Arsenal are expecting to leave Armenian midfielder Henrikh Mkhitaryan at home for the Europa League final against Chelsea in Baku on May 29 for...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}