Law 09:39 04/06/2015

Naming witness ‘significant step’ in MH17 investigation

The public identification of a witness to the MH17 crash is crucial not only for the investigation but also for the international PR war surrounding the issue, security analyst and former UK army officer Charles Shoebridge told RT.

Russia's investigative committee has released the name of a key witness into the downing of MH17 over East Ukraine last July. The witness is Evgeny Agapov, an aviation armaments mechanic in the Ukrainian Air Force and he is currently under Russian state protection.

Meanwhile on Tuesday a Russian missile manufacturer announced the results of its own probe. The BUK manfuactuer Almaz-Antey claims it knows what type of missile was responsible for the crash. The manufacturer says the damage caused to the aircraft is consistent with an outdated BUK M1 missile which has not been produced since 1999. The results of their analysis were passed on to international investigators.

RT: Let's focus on the witness accounts revealed by Russian investigators first. How are they going to affect the international investigation?

Charles Shoebridge: The naming of this person is a significant step for a number of reasons. First of all, of course, it bolsters his credibility enormously and not only for the investigation but also in terms of the international PR war that is going on online and elsewhere around this whole issue of who was responsible for MH17 and what capital can be gained from it in a political sense. So the fact that he has been identified shows the obvious point that he actually exists – this person hasn’t just been made up. But more importantly, it does give credibility to what he is saying because he was a person in a position to actually know what he is talking about. He is a person who has been working in the Ukrainian Air Force, who had direct experience and knowledge - if what he is saying is true, of the situation on the ground in respect to this particular Su-25 fighter aircraft.

However, it’s also the case that on some level it’s going to be quite easy to attack his evidence. We should also add of course that the significance of his evidence isn’t just… evidence that a plane went up, came back having fired off, it would appear, some cannon ammunition. That of course is also crucially consistent with what Russian investigators and the Russian state have put forward...

RT: On Tuesday, Russia's BUK missiles manufacturer said the plane may have been brought down by an old BUK missile. Meanwhile the official international probe is yet to reveal its results. How is this going to play out?

CS: …With regard to this mechanic, it must be said that his evidence must be attacked on a number of fronts, whether he is telling the truth or not he can be attacked on these fronts. First of all, of course, it can be obviously said that he is just simply lying, that he has a motive to lie and people can look at that and find the motives they want to. But also what is going to be crucially important is the degree to which this witness’s evidence matches the physical evidence that has been taken from the ground. Let’s not forget that the scene was secured by, shall we say, the pro-Russian rebels on the ground at the time. The Dutch investigators have recovered a certain amount of evidence which then plays into a very significant development [on Tuesday] where the manufacturer of the BUK missile, that’s alleged to have been responsible by many for the shooting down, actually came out and said from the shrapnel and from the trajectory of the weapon that they have worked out.

And they do this not from some way of studying videos; they are the manufacturers of this weapon, they are engineers, scientists, they know everything about this weapon. They have said quite conclusively [on Tuesday], and this is very important, that this weapon is only in the hands of Ukraine and not in the hands of Russia. So this will immediately debunk the idea that Russia supplied this weapon. Although it wouldn’t necessarily debunk the idea that this weapon was fired by pro-Russian rebels because they could have captured, or as a result of a defector, a Ukrainian missile passed to them. There are many options still open. But also let’s not forget that Russian manufacturer put forward a theory based on a scientific analysis of where the weapon came from and this alleged to come from an area that was said to be under the Ukrainian government not rebel-controlled. So this is highly significant evidence that the official inquiry will have to take into account…

Political analyst Aleksandar Pavic agrees that having an eyewitness in this investigation is a major development. He also suggests that Western mainstream media might try to marginalize this new witness and even discredit him.

“Whoever is after the truth about this whole tragic incident this will be very valuable information for them. But I just want to emphasize this is not new information, this is practically confirmation of testimony that appeared last July, just a few days after this incident. Namely, we had an OSCE monitor, a Canadian of Ukrainian origin, who testified before Canadian national television that he saw pockmarked debris of the downed airplane, which looked like machine gun fire which could have only come from a war plane that was nearby. We also had a Western aviation blog, called the Aviationist, only four days after the crash literally admitting that there were Ukrainian war planes in the vicinity of the passenger flight. Also, it’s known that the passenger plane diverted from the usual flight path that was taken by passenger planes just a day before on the same flight. This one was diverted directly over the war-time zone. So we have all these indicators that were available over a year now. We have a witness come forth – actually an eyewitness – to confirm all this is a very huge development.”

As for the official Dutch investigation, Pavic says it is taking too long, which makes everyone feel uncomfortable.

“We can safely bet that had anything been found to implicate Russia directly or so-called pro-Russian forces around Donetsk and Lugansk, I think the Commission would have come out with the truth by now, but they haven’t. So I think they don’t have anything to implicate Russia with and this is very uncomfortable news for them now. I think Western mainstream media is going to try very hard to marginalize this new proof and may even try to discredit this witness. But I think whoever is after the truth especially the families of the victims will have to listen very carefully to what this new witness said.” 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

16:31
Armenian U16 team defeats Bosnia and Herzegovina
The Armenian U16 football team defeated Bosnia and Herzegovina on April 26 in Sarajevo. As the Football Federation reports, the match was...
15:04
Turkey orders detention of 210 military personnel over links to Gulen
Istanbul prosecutors ordered the detention of 210 military personnel over suspected links to the network blamed by Ankara for orchestrating a...
14:51
Armenian president appoints new ambassador to Spain
Armenian President Armen Sarkissian has signed a decree to appoint Vladimir Karmirshalyan Ambassador of Armenia to Spain, the presidential...
14:14
Congressman Frank Pallone slams Erdogan’s April 24 speech as ‘disgusting denial’
U.S. Congressman Frank Pallone has slammed the April 24 remarks of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan as "a disgusting denial of...
13:57
Paylan on Erdogan’s April 24 remarks: 104 years have passed, but Turkey’s mentality remains unchanged
Garo Paylan, an Armenian member of the Turkey’s parliament representing the People’s Democratic Party (HDP), took to Twitter on...
13:13
Border situation stable, says Armenia’s defense chief
The situation is stable on the border, Armenian Defense Minister Davit Tonoyan told reporters on Friday. “The situation remains...
12:48
Armenian PM appoints new deputy health minister
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia has signed a decision to appoint Hovhannes Harutyunyan as new Deputy Health Minister of Armenia....
12:41
Macron says Schengen Area should be restructured, some states may be excluded
The Schengen Area should be reviewed, and a number of countries should possibly be excluded from it, French President Emmanuel Macron said...
12:25
‘Seems from fantasy genre, but is real’: Armenian PM presents details on over 50,000 new jobs
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan took to Facebook live on Friday to clarify his statements on the creation of over 50,000 new jobs in the...
11:25
Russian pranksters claim they tricked France's Macron in fake call with Ukraine's new leader
Russian pranksters posing as Ukrainian president-elect Volodymyr Zelenskiy claim to have tricked French President Emmanuel Macron into a hoax...
11:10
President hails successful performance of Artsakh athletes at European Sambo Championship
Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan on Thursday met with Artsakh champions and prize-winners of the European Sambo Championship among Youth...
10:59
Pashinyan: France's Armenian Genocide move highlights special relations between two countries
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia on Thursday received First Deputy Mayor of Lyon Georges Kepenekian. The meeting was attended by...
10:44
Trump says China's Xi will soon come to White House
U.S. President Donald Trump said on Thursday he would soon host Chinese leader Xi Jinping at the White House, setting the stage for a possible...
20:25
Government approves Armenia’s Business Environment Improvement Process for 2019
The government approved on Thursday the 2019 action plan aimed at improving Armenia’s business environment. The document outlines a set of...
19:55
US election 2020: Joe Biden launches presidential bid
Former US Vice-President Joe Biden has declared a presidential bid, putting an end to months of speculation, BBC reported. In a video...
19:25
Air temperature to increase by 5-6 degrees on April 25-28
In the daytime of April 28 in separate regions, on 29-30 in most regions short-term rain and thunderstorm is predicted. On 26-27 no...
18:52
Artsakh refutes Azerbaijani media reports on targeting civilians
The Artsakh defense ministry reacted on Thursday to Azerbaijani reports suggesting the Armenian Armed Forces had opened fire at the Chiragli...
18:17
IS conflict: Coalition strikes on Raqqa 'killed 1,600 civilians'
More than 1,600 civilians were killed in US-led coalition air and artillery strikes during the offensive to oust the Islamic State group from...
17:26
EU and Council of Europe to allocate €2,3 million for Partnership for Good Governance programme
The representatives of the European Union and the Council of Europe presented today the launch of the second phase of Partnership for Good...
16:03
Artsakh president holds working consultation
Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan on Thursday convened in Askeran town a working consultation devoted to the process of implementation...
15:58
Armenia violated Levon Ter-Petrosyan’s rights, European court rules
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) on Thursday delivered a judgement in the Levon Ter-Petrosyan v. Armenia case, unanimously...
15:21
Pashinyan: Armenia proposes a peace agenda to Azerbaijan, not a war agenda
Armenia proposes a peace agenda, not a war agenda to Azerbaijan in the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) settlement, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan...
14:17
More than 100 Indonesian election workers, police die of exhaustion
The death from exhaustion of more than 100 Indonesian election workers and police officers during the world’s largest one-day vote has...
13:59
Moscow church hosts candlelight vigil in honor of Armenian Genocide victims
A wreath and flower-laying ceremony took place on Wednesday at the memorial to the Armenian Genocide victims in the Armenian church complex of...
13:31
Armenia performs first-ever liver transplantation
First-ever liver transplantation with a living donor has been performed in Armenia, Minister of Health Arsen Torosyan told a Cabinet meeting on...
13:02
Macron on Armenian Genocide anniv: Man is capable of the worst
We commemorate the Armenian Genocide to make sure that the history does not repeat itself, French President Emmanuel Macron said in a tweet on...
12:25
GRENKE Chess Classic: Aronian draws with Lagrave in fifth round
Armenian GM Levon Aronian drew his game against French Maxime Vachier-Lagrave in Round 5 of the GRENKE Chess Classic 2019 taking place in...
11:58
Colorado recognizes Artsakh, commemorates Armenian Genocide
Colorado’s State Senate unanimously voted on Wednesday to designate April 24 as “Colorado Day of the Remembrance of the Armenian...
11:45
No room for Trump at Buckingham Palace during UK visit
Donald Trump and his wife Melania will not be able to stay at Buckingham Palace – because building work is being carried out, Daily Mail...
11:30
German MP of Turkish descent calls for including Armenian Genocide issue in textbooks
German MP of Turkish origin Cem Ozdemir made a post on Facebook on the 104th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide marked on Wednesday,...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}