Law 09:39 04/06/2015

Naming witness ‘significant step’ in MH17 investigation

The public identification of a witness to the MH17 crash is crucial not only for the investigation but also for the international PR war surrounding the issue, security analyst and former UK army officer Charles Shoebridge told RT.

Russia's investigative committee has released the name of a key witness into the downing of MH17 over East Ukraine last July. The witness is Evgeny Agapov, an aviation armaments mechanic in the Ukrainian Air Force and he is currently under Russian state protection.

Meanwhile on Tuesday a Russian missile manufacturer announced the results of its own probe. The BUK manfuactuer Almaz-Antey claims it knows what type of missile was responsible for the crash. The manufacturer says the damage caused to the aircraft is consistent with an outdated BUK M1 missile which has not been produced since 1999. The results of their analysis were passed on to international investigators.

RT: Let's focus on the witness accounts revealed by Russian investigators first. How are they going to affect the international investigation?

Charles Shoebridge: The naming of this person is a significant step for a number of reasons. First of all, of course, it bolsters his credibility enormously and not only for the investigation but also in terms of the international PR war that is going on online and elsewhere around this whole issue of who was responsible for MH17 and what capital can be gained from it in a political sense. So the fact that he has been identified shows the obvious point that he actually exists – this person hasn’t just been made up. But more importantly, it does give credibility to what he is saying because he was a person in a position to actually know what he is talking about. He is a person who has been working in the Ukrainian Air Force, who had direct experience and knowledge - if what he is saying is true, of the situation on the ground in respect to this particular Su-25 fighter aircraft.

However, it’s also the case that on some level it’s going to be quite easy to attack his evidence. We should also add of course that the significance of his evidence isn’t just… evidence that a plane went up, came back having fired off, it would appear, some cannon ammunition. That of course is also crucially consistent with what Russian investigators and the Russian state have put forward...

RT: On Tuesday, Russia's BUK missiles manufacturer said the plane may have been brought down by an old BUK missile. Meanwhile the official international probe is yet to reveal its results. How is this going to play out?

CS: …With regard to this mechanic, it must be said that his evidence must be attacked on a number of fronts, whether he is telling the truth or not he can be attacked on these fronts. First of all, of course, it can be obviously said that he is just simply lying, that he has a motive to lie and people can look at that and find the motives they want to. But also what is going to be crucially important is the degree to which this witness’s evidence matches the physical evidence that has been taken from the ground. Let’s not forget that the scene was secured by, shall we say, the pro-Russian rebels on the ground at the time. The Dutch investigators have recovered a certain amount of evidence which then plays into a very significant development [on Tuesday] where the manufacturer of the BUK missile, that’s alleged to have been responsible by many for the shooting down, actually came out and said from the shrapnel and from the trajectory of the weapon that they have worked out.

And they do this not from some way of studying videos; they are the manufacturers of this weapon, they are engineers, scientists, they know everything about this weapon. They have said quite conclusively [on Tuesday], and this is very important, that this weapon is only in the hands of Ukraine and not in the hands of Russia. So this will immediately debunk the idea that Russia supplied this weapon. Although it wouldn’t necessarily debunk the idea that this weapon was fired by pro-Russian rebels because they could have captured, or as a result of a defector, a Ukrainian missile passed to them. There are many options still open. But also let’s not forget that Russian manufacturer put forward a theory based on a scientific analysis of where the weapon came from and this alleged to come from an area that was said to be under the Ukrainian government not rebel-controlled. So this is highly significant evidence that the official inquiry will have to take into account…

Political analyst Aleksandar Pavic agrees that having an eyewitness in this investigation is a major development. He also suggests that Western mainstream media might try to marginalize this new witness and even discredit him.

“Whoever is after the truth about this whole tragic incident this will be very valuable information for them. But I just want to emphasize this is not new information, this is practically confirmation of testimony that appeared last July, just a few days after this incident. Namely, we had an OSCE monitor, a Canadian of Ukrainian origin, who testified before Canadian national television that he saw pockmarked debris of the downed airplane, which looked like machine gun fire which could have only come from a war plane that was nearby. We also had a Western aviation blog, called the Aviationist, only four days after the crash literally admitting that there were Ukrainian war planes in the vicinity of the passenger flight. Also, it’s known that the passenger plane diverted from the usual flight path that was taken by passenger planes just a day before on the same flight. This one was diverted directly over the war-time zone. So we have all these indicators that were available over a year now. We have a witness come forth – actually an eyewitness – to confirm all this is a very huge development.”

As for the official Dutch investigation, Pavic says it is taking too long, which makes everyone feel uncomfortable.

“We can safely bet that had anything been found to implicate Russia directly or so-called pro-Russian forces around Donetsk and Lugansk, I think the Commission would have come out with the truth by now, but they haven’t. So I think they don’t have anything to implicate Russia with and this is very uncomfortable news for them now. I think Western mainstream media is going to try very hard to marginalize this new proof and may even try to discredit this witness. But I think whoever is after the truth especially the families of the victims will have to listen very carefully to what this new witness said.” 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:00
Armenian, Azeri FMs to meet in Berlin in late February
The delegations led by Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov will meet in Berlin on February...
16:45
Lord Jacob Rothschild dies at 87
Financier, philanthropist, and head of the Rothschild family, Lord Jacob Rothschild, has died aged 87, The Independent reports. The...
16:36
MP Gevorg Papoyan steps down
Ruling Civil Contract faction MP Gevorg Papoyan has resigned his seat in the Armenian parliament.  The deputy submitted his...
16:15
Pro-government MP comments on Zelensky's possible visit to Armenia
MP Babken Tunyan, who represents Armenia’s ruling Civil Contract party, has reacted to reports of Ukrainian President Volodymyr...
15:35
Analyst names Pashinyan's main 'weapon' in possible snap elections
Political analyst Suren Surenyants believes outright anti-Russian policy and Armenia’s promised withdrawal from the CSTO will be Prime...
15:03
SJC dismisses judge Arshak Vardanyan
Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) has dismissed judge Arshak Vardanyan of the Criminal Court of Appeals at his own request, the...
14:35
Kremlin insists on clarity from Armenia over CSTO
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov says that there is no clarity yet on Armenia's position on its withdrawal from the Russian-led...
14:05
Fallen soldier's father to undergo heart surgery today
The health condition of Garik Galeyan, whose soldier son Mkhitar was killed in the 2020 Artsakh war, has stabilized and he is preparing for...
13:30
Armenian State Symphony Orchestra donates to UNICEF for Armenia refugee response
The Foundation for the Support of the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra announced today a donation of US$ 12,000 to UNICEF Armenia in support of...
13:14
Opposition MP blames Armenian authorities for failure to counter Azeri propaganda
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has blamed the Armenian authorities for failure to counter the false Azerbaijani propaganda narrative regarding...
12:33
Gisele Kapterian to run for Australian Parliament
The Armenian National Committee of Australia (ANC-AU) has welcomed the pre-selection of one of its valued board members, Gisele Kapterian, who...
12:15
Bayramov: Armenia, Azerbaijan to hold fresh talks soon
The delegations of Azerbaijan and Armenia will hold fresh peace talks in the near future, Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov has...
11:54
Tatul Altunyan Ensemble to tour France
Armenia’s Tatul Altunyan Dance and Song Ensemble will be touring France from February 28 to March 29, the Armenian Embassy in Paris...
11:30
Women to take part in Japan's 'naked festival' for first time
Women in Japan have been permitted to take part in an ancient ceremony, known as the naked festival, for the first time in the event’s...
11:15
Armenia outscore Albania at Basketball World Cup pre-qualifiers
Armenia outscored Albania 84-79 at the FIBA Basketball World Cup 2027 pre-qualifiers on Sunday. The game was held at the Karen...
11:00
Armenian FM to address UN Human Rights Council session
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan will travel to Geneva on February 26-27. Mirzoyan will deliver remarks during the...
18:15
Azerbaijani armed forces units discharged fire against Armenian combat positions near Verin Shorzha
The Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Armenia refutes the statement by the Ministry of Defence of Azerbaijan, which claimed that on...
18:11
Armenia Hires U.S. Law Firm in Amulsar Arbitration Case; Government Refuses to Reveal Contract Price
The United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) panel has begun hearing a U.S. investor’s treaty claim against Armenia...
17:05
Temperatures to drop further in Armenia
Rain and fog are predicted in Armenia during the weekend and on Monday, with snow set to hit the country’s mountainous areas. The...
16:45
UK court freezes Azerbaijani lawmaker's £39m properties
U.K. authorities have frozen 22 London properties that the Azerbaijani lawmaker Javanshir Feyziyev and his wife are suspected to have bought...
16:35
Gevorg Papoyan to be named Armenia's new economy minister
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s Civil Contract party has endorsed MP Gevorg Papoyan as new minister of economy. His candidacy was...
16:15
Analyst: Pashinyan's CSTO message addressed to the West
Relations between Armenia and the Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) have long been frozen, Yerevan-based political...
15:36
France plants flag in Russia’s backyard with Armenia arms deals – POLITICO
France wants Armenia to know it has its back — amid increased tensions with its neighbor Azerbaijan and strained ties with its historic...
15:05
Synergy chief expresses gratitude to IT and business community for their unity
Ashot Hovanesian, the founder and CEO of Synergy International Systems, issued a statement on Saturday expressing gratitude to the IT and...
14:32
King Charles overwhelmed by public support as 7,000 messages sent after cancer diagnosis
King Charles has been overwhelmed by messages of support from around 7,000 well-wishers worldwide since his cancer diagnosis, The Independent...
14:15
Fallen soldier's father hospitalized
Garik Galeyan, whose soldier son Mkhitar was killed in the 2020 Artsakh war, has been hospitalized after a suspected heart attack, his lawyer...
13:36
Moscow street named after Soviet spying legend Gevork Vartanian
A street in Moscow has been named after legendary Soviet Armenian spy Gevork Vartanian, who helped foil a Nazi plot to kill Allied leaders in...
13:15
Armenian Foreign Ministry reacts to reports about Zelenskyy's possible visit
The Armenian Foreign Ministry has commented on the news that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is reportedly planning to visit...
13:02
Political analyst: Armenia-CSTO relations in crisis
Relations between Armenia and the Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) are basically in crisis, claims political...
12:33
U.S. State Dept: Russia not concerned about Armenia’s interests
The U.S. Department of State has responded to an inquiry of the Voice of America’s Armenian Service regarding Prime Minister Nikol...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}