13:55 20/12/2016

ESI report on “Caviar diplomacy”: Azerbaijan involves European politicians in corrupt schemes

European Stability Initiative issued the second part of the report about Azerbaijan named “Caviar diplomacy: the European Swamp,” in which it describes blatant facts of corrupt schemes organized by the Azerbaijani authorities with the involvement of high-ranking European politicians. 

It is noted that in recent years, the leaders of Azerbaijan, a small autocracy in the Caucasus, have shown how easy it is to undermine core human rights standards and bend a formerly proud institution to its will. They have done so in close cooperation with politicians from across Europe, who were members of the Council of Europe.

Azerbaijan’s actions have been met with almost complete silence from European parliaments, governments and political parties.

According to the authors of the report, in 2012 ESI published “Caviar Diplomacy – How Azerbaijan silenced the Council of Europe” to sound an alarm. The official reaction was disappointing. The report was covered by international media and the term “caviar diplomacy” began to be widely used. Some concerned officials in the Council of Europe reached out to the authors to confirm that things were, indeed, as bad as we had described them. But there things stopped, and it added to their sense of impunity of the Azerbaijani authorities.

Azerbaijan’s lobbyists were busy preparing for their biggest coup – to combine Baku’s chairmanship of the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers in 2014 with the imprisonment of their most prominent domestic critics. Caviar diplomacy went into overdrive.

Expensive carpets worth thousands of euros were given away as gifts; so many that one Azerbaijani embassy had its own room for them. Luxury Vertu smart phones, handmade in the UK, were presented to supporters. Expensive watches and jewellery, silver sets and MacBookswere handed over to politicians, officials, even secretaries. Business contracts and paid holidays were part of the benefits. And then there was money: large sums, given incash or transferred via anonymous companies. And while the campaign was in full swing, Azerbaijani politicians attacked anyone who drew attention to their activities.

It is highlighted that the Council of Europe failed to speak out about the imprisonment of Azerbaijani journalists, dissidents and youth activists, most leaders of European governments felt that it was not a matter of deep concern. Its consequences can be seen in the growing confidence of autocrats, the increasing ruthlessness of their methods and the widespread retreat of liberal politics.

In this part of the report, the Azerbaijani authorities’ relationship with the Italian parliamentarian Luca Volonteis described. Only one month before the ESI report was published, he had travelled on a private trip to Baku to negotiate with the regime what services he could offer. On 10 April 2012, he arrived in Baku to meet with ElkhanSuleymanov, a fellow member of PACE. In Baku, Volonte presented his ideas how to boost Azerbaijan’s image in advance of its presidency of the Council’s Committee of Ministers in May 2014.This was not Volonte’s first trip to Baku. His cosy relationship with the regime began duringan earlier trip in July 2011, when the Italian parliamentarian wrote a letter to Suleymanov after his visit to Baku and thanked him for generous presents. 

As a whole, Luca Volontereceived around 3 million euros from Azerbaijan at different times for his “dirty lobbying services.”

It is emphasized in the report that the money Luca Volonte received were also intended for the bribery of several MPs from other European countries, who voted against resolutions and reports in the CoE condemning human right violations in Azerbaijan. Tracks also lead to the head of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), Pedro Agramunt.

Volonte knew that Pedro Agramunt was a crucial player. Few PACE members had travelled to Azerbaijan as often as Agramunt, who went there as PACE election observer in 2003, 2005, 2010 and 2013 and consistently defended Baku’s human rights record.

Volonte collaborated with other European politicians for lobbying Azerbaijan’s interests. All of these “friends” had long been central to Baku’s advocacy efforts. Italian EPP member Luigi Vitali was a former state secretary at the ministry of justice. Tadeusz Iwinski was a former Polish communist and member of PACE since 1992, who had travelled to Azerbaijan many times. In January 2011, he had presented to PACE an implausibly positive report on the 2010 parliamentary elections in Azerbaijan. Robert Walter was a British Conservative from North Dorset and leader of the European Conservative Group in PACE, another regular defender of Baku’s record. Jordi Xucla was a Spanish MP who later became chairperson of the ALDE group, and who repeatedly voted with Azerbaijan, as well as British politician Michael Hancock, who always praised “democracy development in Azerbaijan.”

It is reminded that when in 2013 German MP Christoph Strässer presented a report about political prisoners in Azerbaijan, Pedro Agramuntcame out strongly against him, arguing that there simply was no problem with political prisoners in Azerbaijan. As a result, the report was vetoed during the voting.
For the Azerbaijani regime, the January 2013 vote was a triumph. For human rights activists in Baku, it was a disaster. Encouraged by this outcome and keen to get rid of prominent human rights defenders and dissidents, the regime began to arrest even more people on bogus charges, sentencing them to ever harsher prison terms. Three among hundreds stand out, also because of their connections with the Council of Europe. The most prominent victims of the country’s authoritarian regime are Republican alternative leader IlgarMammadov, leader of an independent election monitoringorganisation AnarMammadli, and journalist Khadija Ismayilova.

Summing up, the authors of the report note that in 2017, systematic human rights violations in Azerbaijan should be on the agenda in PACE, and all the cases of corruption and bribery with the involvement of European parliamentarians should be investigated in detail.

In 2012, the European Stability Initiative issued the first part of the report named “Caviar Diplomacy - How Azerbaijan silenced the Council of Europe,” in which the chronology and mechanisms of bribing the members of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe by the Azerbaijani ruling regime were described in detail.

It was particularly noted in the report that giving generous presents was a part of the Azerbaijani tradition, like the expectation that the generosity would ever be repaid. This is the logic of the politics, which the Azerbaijani officials call “Caviar diplomacy” in private discussions.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:00
Egypt's world-famous antiquities could be lost to climate change, experts warn
Egypt’s world-famous antiquities, including the Sphinx and the Great Pyramids of Giza, could be lost to climate change by the end of the...
16:56
Security chief: Normalization of Armenia's relations with Turkey, Azerbaijan separate processes
The Armenia-Turkey and Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization processes are separate, Secretary of the Security Council Armen Grigoryan insisted on...
16:32
Celine Dion diagnosed with rare neurological disorder
Celine Dion announced Thursday morning that she’s been diagnosed with stiff person syndrome and will be postponing or canceling her...
16:15
Minister comments on decision to withdraw benefits for displaced Artsakh Armenians
Any program concerning the Artsakh people is implemented as a result of discussions with Artsakh's leadership, Armenian Labor and Social...
15:35
Armenian, Russian and Azeri chief prosecutors meet in Moscow
A trilateral meeting between Russian Prosecutor General Igor Krasnov, Armenian Prosecutor General Anna Vardapetyan and Prosecutor General of...
14:58
Four opposition members take up parliament seats
Four members of the opposition Hayastan alliance have agreed to take up the vacant parliament seats. At a special meeting on Thursday,...
14:32
'A hiker's dream': National Geographic reveals Armenia's wonders
A 500-plus mile hiking path reveals the wonders of Armenia, “a country at the crossroads of the world”, American travel writer Mark...
14:05
Armenia's Mariam Mkrtchyan named sole winner of youth chess tournament
Armenian chess player Mariam Mkrtchyan has emerged as the sole winner of the girls’ competition at "The Game has begun!", a...
13:35
First coins featuring King Charles enter circulation in UK
Millions of 50p coins bearing the image of King Charles III will enter circulation in the UK from Thursday via post offices across the country,...
13:22
Armenian opposition votes against draft state budget for 2023
The pro-government majority in the Armenian National Assembly approved the draft state budget for 2023 at a session on Thursday. All 66 MPs...
12:58
Cargo flights between Armenia, Turkey 'to start soon'
The second phase of normalization of ties between Turkey and Armenia has started, with the Turkish and Armenian officials discussing the start...
12:35
Armenian MP: Azerbaijan engaged in systematic provocations against Artsakh
Azerbaijan has launched a systematic provocation campaign against Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh), Armenian security expert Tigran Abrahamyan, an MP...
11:53
Magnitude 5․6 quake hits near Russian city; tremors felt in Armenia
A magnitude 5․6 earthquake struck Russia’s Dagestan region early on Thursday. The quake was 99 km southwest of the city of Makhachkala...
11:25
EU special envoy visiting Armenia
Toivo Klaar, the European Union's special representative for the South Caucasus and the crisis in Georgia, has started a visit to Armenia,...
11:15
Uzbekistan rejects Russian 'gas union' plan
Uzbekistan’s energy minister on Wednesday poured cold water on a Russian proposal for a “gas union” including the Central...
11:00
Armenian defense minister off to Russia
A delegation led by Armenian Defense Minister Suren Papikyan left for Russia on a working visit on Thursday, the Defense Ministry reported....
17:00
World Cup 2022: Quarterfinal fixtures set
The FIFA World Cup 2022 has reached the quarterfinal stage in Qatar. Confirmed World Cup quarterfinal fixtures Friday December 9...
16:54
No precipitation in sight for Armenia in next few days
Light snow is expected in some parts of Armenia on Wednesday, while no precipitation is forecast for the next few days. Fog is in sight...
16:36
Artsakh refutes Azerbaijan's claims of ceasefire violation
The Artsakh Defense Ministry has denied Azerbaijan’s fresh claims of a ceasefire breach by its forces as disinformation. “The...
16:18
Parliament speaker: Armenia opposes setup of Azeri checkpoint on road to Artsakh
Armenia opposes the possible setup of an Azerbaijani checkpoint on the Lachin corridor connecting Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) to Armenia, the...
15:45
Russia ready to facilitate meeting of Armenian, Azeri leaders – Kremlin
Russia is ready to facilitate a meeting between Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, RIA Novosti...
15:30
UK Embassy joins Armenian people to commemorate devastating quake victims
The British Embassy in Yerevan joins the Armenian people to commemorate the victims of the devastating earthquake in 1988 on its 34th...
15:05
Russian peacekeepers in Artsakh deny entry to Azeri reporters
The Russian peacekeeping troops have barred a group of Azerbaijani journalists from entering Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh). The reporters...
14:46
Armenian government's military attestation plan risky, opposition leader says
The certification scheme in the Armenian military offered by the government contains risks, MP Seyran Ohanyan, the head of the largest...
14:05
Artsakh parliament speaker pays tribute to devastating Armenia quake victims
Speaker of the Artsakh National Assembly Artur Tovmasyan on Wednesday visited the Stepanakert Memorial to pay homage to the victims of the...
13:45
Armenian parliament passes bills on universal income declaration, minimum wage rise
The Armenian National Assembly passed all bills on the agenda in the first or second readings at a regular session on Wednesday. MPs from...
13:15
Train crash leaves 155 injured in Spain
Two trains collided near Barcelona early Wednesday, injuring 155 people but none seriously, AP reported, citing Spanish officials....
13:00
Opposition MP: Azerbaijan increasing pressure on Artsakh amid 'tacit consent' of Armenian leaders
MP Tigran Abrahamyan of the opposition Pativ Unem faction blamed the Armenian leadership for silence amid increasing pressure on Artsakh...
12:36
French FM confirms need to extend EU mission mandate in Armenia
French Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs Catherine Colonna has confirmed the need to extend the mandate of the EU observation mission...
12:15
Armenian ruling party's candidate elected as SJC member
The Armenian parliament held a minute's silence to pay tribute to the catastrophic Spitak earthquake victims on its 34th anniversary at the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}