Politics 10:43 06/11/2019 Armenia

Genocide Resolution: A major victory, but facts should not be ignored

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

On October 29, 2019, Armenian Americans scored a major victory in the halls of US Congress. For the first time in 35 years, the US House of Representatives adopted Resolution 296 affirming the facts of the Armenian Genocide.

I used the term affirming because contrary to many Armenian and non-Armenian commentators, this was not the first time that the United States has recognized the Armenian Genocide. In fact, this was the fifth American governmental recognition. As I have reported dozens of times in past years, the United States Government first recognized the Armenian Genocide in 1951 when it sent an official document to the International Court of Justice (World Court) presenting the Armenian Genocide as an example of genocide. The US House of Representatives recognized the Armenian Genocide in two Resolutions adopted in 1975 and 1984, and Pres. Ronald Reagan issued a Presidential Proclamation on April 22, 1981 mentioning the Armenian Genocide.

Among the misrepresentations made by various commentators were statements like:

1.  “The October 29, 2019 recognition of the Armenian Genocide by the House of Representatives was the first time in a century that the United States has recognized the Armenian Genocide.” It was not! In fact, the text of Resolution 296 itself lists all the previous US recognitions of the Armenian Genocide and describes it as affirmation, not recognition.

2.  “Resolution 296 set a policy on the recognition of the Armenian Genocide by the US government.” It did no such thing. This Resolution, like the others before it, is a non-binding Resolution, expressing simply the sense of Congress. It is not a law and it has no legal consequences.

3.  “Resolution 296 obligates Pres. Trump to use the term genocide in his next April 24 statement.” It does not. The President can still use other euphemisms to describe the Armenian Genocide, if he wishes to, as he and other US Presidents have done since Pres. Reagan.

4.  “Resolution 296 will allow Armenians to file lawsuits in US courts against Turkey demanding restitution for damages suffered during the Genocide.” This is not true. As mentioned above, two similar Congressional Resolutions were adopted in 1975 and 1984 and neither one helped Armenians win a single lawsuit against Turkey in US courts.

5.  “After the passage of Resolution 296, if the US Senate adopts the counterpart Resolution (SRes.150), and if Pres. Trump signs it, then the Resolution becomes a law.” This is untrue, since both the House and Senate versions are “stand alone” Resolutions. Should the Senate version also be adopted, the Resolution will not go to Pres. Trump for his signature, since the House and Senate versions were not submitted as a “Joint Resolution.”

Nevertheless, none of the above clarifications are made to minimize the value of the adoption of Resolution 296 on October 29, 2019. Here are the reasons why this Resolution was a major victory for the Armenian Cause:

1.  After trying to pass a genocide resolution in the House for 35 years, it is a major accomplishment for the Armenian American community to be able to finally score such a victory. It is not possible to continue demanding that the Armenian public support a cause for decades without a concrete result from time to time. This victory will energize Armenian-Americans to continue their commitment to the Armenian Cause and work harder to attain greater accomplishments.

2.  While the passage of Resolution 296 does not obligate the President of the United States, it will increase the pressure on him to properly acknowledge the Armenian Genocide in his April 24 statement.

3.  Resolution 296 also makes it more difficult for the Turkish government to continue its denials of the Armenian Genocide.

4.  Paradoxically, the harsh reactions of the Turkish leaders to the adoption of Resolution 296 helped remind the Turkish people and others worldwide about the Armenian Genocide.

5.  Thousands of articles, TV reports, and social media posts on the adoption of Resolution 296 helped further publicize the Armenian Genocide around the world. Over 100 years after the Genocide, the cry for justice remains alive thanks to the activism of Armenians and their supporters.

6.  The passage of Resolution 296 is another step in Armenia’s struggle to pressure Turkey and the world community to take further steps to undo the damage caused by the Genocide, albeit delayed over a century!

7.  Beyond setting straight the historical record, the effort over the passage of the genocide resolution is a political battle between the Armenian American community and the Turkish government and its paid lobbyists as to which side has more political clout in Washington. The overwhelming victory (405 to 11 votes) is a clear indication of the smashing defeat of Turkey and the total victory of Armenians.

8.  The Turkish government has wasted tens of millions of dollars over the years hiring high-powered American lobbying firms in a failed attempt to block the approval of Armenian Genocide Resolutions by the US Congress. It is impossible to misrepresent genocide as a humane act no matter how many billions of dollars Turkey spends on lobbyists!

9.  Turkey’s defeat also sends a message to the Turkish public that the taxes they have paid are being squandered by their government to deny the undeniable.

10.  Some have made the excuse that Congress took advantage of the souring relations between Turkey and the United States to pass Resolution 296. While this is true, there are several counter-arguments:

          a) Congress is a political body; hence all its deliberations and decisions are of a political nature;
          b) If it weren’t for the diligent efforts of Armenian-American organizations and the Armenian community, there was no guarantee that this Resolution would have appeared on the agenda of the House of Representatives. Since the US Congress was unhappy with Turkey’s invasion of Northern Syria, the House of Representatives would have been satisfied by passing a Resolution on October 29, 2019, placing sanctions on Turkey for its barbaric attacks against Kurds. However, because of Armenian activism, the House also adopted on the same day the Resolution on the Armenian Genocide.
          c) We cannot be so naive as to expect that any government would defend the Armenian Cause if doing so would have been contrary to its own interests. It is perfectly reasonable that the condemnation of the Armenian Genocide happened to coincide with Congress’s anger at Turkey for other reasons. In fact, the more Armenians can find reasons to match their interests with those of other countries, the more successful they will be in their pursuit of the Armenian Cause.

For the next step, I hope the US Senate will shortly pass Senate Resolution 150. This is important, since the US Senate has never adopted a Resolution acknowledging the Armenian Genocide. And maybe next year, the Armenian Genocide Resolution could be reintroduced, but this time as a “Joint Resolution,” which would mean that should the Resolution pass both Houses of Congress and the President signs it, the Armenian Genocide would become US law, not just a “non-binding” Resolution. This would obligate all future American Presidents to use the term Armenian Genocide in their April 24 statements or on any other occasion.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

19:30
NATO pulling forces to Russian borders amid calls to deter Russia - Shoigu
NATO is consistently pulling its forces to Russian borders amid calls for military deterrence of Russia, Russia’s Defense Minister Sergei...
19:09
ALC announces new cases filed on “disappeared captives” and “unlawful killings” before the ECHR
The Armenian Legal Center for Justice & Human Rights (ALC) has announced the filing of 16 new cases of “enforced disappearances”...
18:39
Roadside bombing targets Taliban, kills Afghan civilians
A roadside bombing targeting a Taliban vehicle in eastern Afghanistan killed at least two civilians Saturday, including a child, Taliban and...
18:09
Armenian boxer takes silver at European Boxing Championships
Armenian boxer Elida Kocharyan won silver at EUBC Youth (M&W) European Boxing Championships in Budva 2021. As the Boxing Federation...
18:03
Grammy Award Winner Gil Shaham to perform in Yerevan
Gil Shaham, Grammy Award Winner and one of the prominent violinists of our time will perform in Yerevan on October 32. The concert will take...
17:45
MFA: Proposals for various meetings in different formats under discussion
No meeting between the Prime Minister of Armenia and the President of Azerbaijan is planned for the time being, the Spokesperson of the Armenian...
17:17
Pope Francis sends a personal message to Lionel Messi
Pope Francis has thanked Leo Messi for sending him a signed Paris Saint-Germain jersey. The 84-year-old sent a special message for the...
16:35
If we lack a strongly protected border, migration may periodically occur in Artsakh, lawmaker says
"We used to loudly declare that the state firmly stands behind the soldier, however, the condition of our servicemen standing on the border...
15:46
Kyrgyzstan will not host a US military base on its territory - President
Kyrgyzstan will not host a US military base on its territory as Russia's presence was "enough," Kyrgyz President Sadyr Japarov...
15:26
Air temperature to go down by 4-6 degrees in the coming days
No precipitation is predicted in the territory of Armenia in the daytime of October 23, on 24, at night of 25, in the daytime of 27 and on...
15:05
Kremlin reacts to reports of possible Russia-Armenia-Azerbaijan summit
If an agreement on holding a Russia-Armenia-Azerbaijan summit is reached, the Kremlin will report it in due time, its spokesman Dmitry Peskov...
14:47
Migrant detentions at US-Mexico border hit record high
The US says more than 1.7 million migrants were detained along its border with Mexico in the past 12 months - the highest number ever recorded....
14:38
Armenian woman dies from Covid-19 at 20th week of pregnancy – ministry
The mother of an Armenian fallen soldier has died from coronavirus at the 20th week of pregnancy, the Ministry of Health said on Friday....
13:46
Putin, Pashinyan and Aliyev may meet in Moscow in early November
A meeting of Russian President Vladimir Putin, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev may be held in...
13:23
Opposition MP Davit Sedrakyan quits
MP Davit Sedrakyan from the opposition Armenia faction stepped down on Friday, according to a statement released by the parliament. In...
12:56
Artsakh adds 46 fresh Covid cases on Oct. 23
Artsakh confirmed 46 new coronavirus cases in the past 24 hours, the Ministry of Health reported on Saturday, October 23. In total, 140...
12:50
Tigran Abrahamyan: Armenia’s security and defense chiefs have to explain how Azeri forces invaded Armenian territory unhindered
Opposition With Honor faction MP Tigran Abrahamyan says Armenia’s security and defense chiefs have to explain how Azerbaijani forces...
11:56
U.S. to release more records related to Kennedy assassination in December
The Biden administration said it will release more records related to the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in December, Bloomberg...
11:47
Armenia records 1,962 new Covid cases on Oct. 23
Armenia has confirmed 1,962 new cases of coronavirus in 24 hours, bringing the national tally to 293,014 as of 11 a.m. Saturday, October 23, the...
11:22
Arshile Gorky's new painting was hiding in plain sight
Among the works of great, exhaustively studied artists who have been dead for more than 70 years, true discoveries tend to be scarce. That...
11:10
Armenia and Azerbaijan set to sign two new documents in Moscow on Nov. 9, reporter says
Armenia and Azerbaijan are set to sign two new documents in Moscow on November 9, Aliq Media’s Tatul Hakobyan said on Friday, citing...
10:45
Alec Baldwin voices ‘shock and sadness’ over fatal film set shooting
Alec Baldwin has expressed his deep “shock and sadness” after he accidentally shot and killed his director of photography with an...
10:35
‘When I am Sad’ selected for CINANIMA Animated Film Festival of Portugal
“When I am Sad” animation directed by Lilit Altunyan has been selected for the official competition program of the world’s...
20:24
Azerbaijan conceals actual number of captured Armenians and places of their detention, FM says
Armenian FM Ararat Mirzoyan stated on Friday that the immediate repatriation of Armenian prisoners of war and captured civilians held in...
19:49
Around 20 flights cancelled or postponed at Moscow’s airports
Around 20 flights have been cancelled or postponed at Moscow’s Sheremetyevo, Domodedovo and Vnukovo airports as of midday October 22,...
19:25
The formation of national resistance should be at the centre of the opposition activity - Seyran Ohanyan
"Armenia and Artsakh are in a situation where the interests of global powers are continuously clashing in the region," the head of...
18:30
Ameriabank: 62.5% growth in taxes YOY
According to Q3 2021 data, Ameriabank is the largest taxpayer among Armenian banks.  Overall, the Bank paid AMD 7.13 billion in taxes (as...
18:07
Armenia to receive 620,400 doses of Moderna vaccine donated by Norway
A trilateral agreement has been signed between Armenia, the Kingdom of Norway, and Moderna inc, according to which Armenia will receive 620,400...
17:23
Viva-MTS: Native wild fruit trees were planted in Gnishik settlement
With the efforts of Viva-MTS and the Foundation for the Preservation of Wildlife and Cultural Assets, important and serious environmental...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}