Politics 10:42 13/11/2019 Armenia

Armenians fly from Istanbul to New York to participate in Turkish propaganda

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

It is amazing the lengths to which the Turkish government went to include Istanbul Armenian clergy and laymen in its propaganda campaign.

On November 5, 2019, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s Communications Office organized an exhibit in New York City featuring photos of the Armenian Holy Cross Cathedral located in Western Armenia, today’s eastern Turkey, near Van, on Aghtamar Island.

The opening of the exhibit was not only attended by Alper Aktas, Turkey’s Consul General in New York, but surprisingly, by several Armenian leaders as well as other Christian clergymen from Istanbul. Among the attendees were Istanbul Armenian Patriarchate’s Locum Tenens Bishop Sahak Mashalian; Shirvan Murzoyan, an Armenian priest from Istanbul; Yessayi Demir, Chairman of St. Kevork Church in Samatia, Istanbul; Mesut Ozdemir, Chairman of Dsnount Sourp Asdvadsadsni Church; Yetvart Ayvazian, Chairman of Sourp Krikor Lousavorich Church in Kouzgounjouk, Istanbul; Tamar Karasou, Director of the Turkish Branch of Sourp Krots Association; Aram Kouran from “Louys” biweekly; Chairman of the Board of Sourp Prgich Armenian Hospital in Istanbul, Bedros Shirinoglu and his wife; Turkish Minority Community Foundation Representative Moris Levi; Syriac Ancient Church Foundation President Sait Susin; American Greek Orthodox Church Archbishop Elpidophoros Lambriniadis; and members of the Turkish and Armenian communities. I am pleased that none of the clergy from the Armenian Church in the United States (Prelacy and Diocese) attended the opening of the exhibit in New York.

While it is understandable that given the tense relations between the United States and Turkey, the Turkish government would want to carry out a propaganda campaign in the US to improve its stained image, much less acceptable is the participation of the Armenian laymen and clergy as well as Syriac and Greek leaders. One can excuse the attendance of the Istanbul leaders given the fact that they are hostages in the hands of the oppressive Turkish regime. In the case of Bishop Mashalian, however, he may have come willingly, as he is one of the two candidates for the December election for the position of the Armenian Patriarch of Turkey. The Bishop knows well that any disobedience to the wishes of the Turkish government will cost him the seat of the Patriarchate.

Despite the strong desire of Erdogan’s government to carry out propaganda in the US, it failed to capitalize on this opportunity. Turkey spent a fortune to fly the 88 photographs of the Holy Cross Church to New York, pay for the rental of an exhibit hall in Manhattan, fly and accommodate over a dozen guests from Istanbul to New York City, and pay the expenses of making a film on the Holy Cross Cathedral, "The Hidden Monuments of Anatolia Coming to Light: Akdamar," shown at the exhibit. Yet, the highly-paid US lobbying firms hired by Turkey either were not asked or failed to disseminate the exhibit propaganda to the American media. Secondly, the Turkish government did not think of delaying the opening of the exhibit by one week so Pres. Erdogan, who will be in the US this week, could attend the official ribbon cutting ceremony. In September, Pres. Erdogan was present in New York at a similar opening of the exhibit of the photos of Ara Guler, a Turkish Armenian, which was also sponsored by the Turkish President’s Office.

Here are the reasons why I consider the Holy Cross Church photo exhibit a manifestation of Turkish propaganda:

1)  The Turkish government has designated Holy Cross as a museum, not a church, allowing Armenian liturgy to be performed only once a year by special permission. Much more important than organizing an exhibition in New York would have been the designation of the Holy Cross edifice as a church, not a museum. What are the Armenian and other clergymen doing celebrating the exhibit of a museum? If they had any guts, they would have refused to attend the exhibit until the museum is designated as a church which was completed in 921 AD, under the sponsorship of Armenian King Gagik Ardsruni. Visitors have even to pay a fee to enter “the museum.”

2)  After the Holy Cross Cathedral was repaired in 2007, the Turkish government did not allow a cross to be placed on the dome of the church, giving the excuse that the cross was too heavy for the dome. Finally, after much criticism, in 2010 the Turkish government allowed a cross to be placed atop the Holy Cross Cathedral.

3)  The Turkish government turkified the name of the island by changing it from Aghtamar to Akdamar (which means “White vein” in Turkish).

4)  In his remarks, Bishop Mashalian praised Pres. Erdogan for organizing the exhibit in New York: “Under the leadership of the president's vision, special attention and interest was shown in the Akdamar Church…. This is a cultural initiative to overcome the difficulties of communication between the Turkish and Armenian peoples, as well as a bridge to a better future and understanding based on goodwill."

5)  Chairman of the Board of Sourp Prgich Armenian Hospital in Istanbul Bedros Shirinoglu stated that “President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has made great efforts for minority communities…. We would like to express our gratitude to him for all his help and to the [President’s] Communications Office for this exhibition."

6)  American Greek Orthodox Church Archbishop Elpidophoros Lambriniadis reinforced the Turkish propaganda by underlining the significance of the photos at the exhibition in terms of showing the importance attached to the Christian minority in Turkey, saying: "Turkey is going in the right direction and it is good to tell the whole world about this."

7)  Pres. Erdogan proudly told the Turkish media last week that 17 representatives of Turkish minority groups are in New York at this time for the photo exhibit of the “Akdamar Church.”

If the Turkish government was truly sincere in promoting the Armenian Church in Aghtamar, why did it allow a group of Azeris recently to visit the church and claim it to be a Caucasian Albanian Christian church? This is the usual lie that the Azeri government uses to describe all historic Armenian churches in Azerbaijan. The Azeri visitors displayed inside the Holy Cross Church the Azeri and Turkish flags with an “Azeri priest” claiming to say prayers. In a statement made outside the front door of the church, an Azeri representative accused Armenians of invading Azerbaijan and committing vandalism. The Turkish government should apologize to Armenians for allowing the perpetration of such a gross lie!

Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Militant shelling kills around 30 civilians in Syria’s Aleppo
Illegal armed units continue to shell the Syrian city of Aleppo, where 28 civilians were killed in the past three days, the Russian Center for...
Two earthquakes recorded in Shirak province
An earthquake of 2,4 magnitude was registered 19 km south-east of Ashotsk village of Shirak province on Saturday at about 08:20 (GMT 04:20),...
PM receives astrophysicist Garik Israelian
Armenian PM Nikol Pashinyan received on Friday the founder and organizer of Starmus (Stars and Music) International festival, astrophysicist...
Some roads in Armenia are closed and difficult to pass
Some roads in Armenia are closed and difficult to pass as of January 17 at 6:55, the ministry of emergency situations (MES) reported....
KFOR Deputy Commander hails the high level of preparedness of Armenian peacekeepers in Kosovo
Deputy Commander of the NATO-led Kosovo Force (KFOR) Brigadier General Laurent Michaud visited the Armenian peacekeepers serving in Kosovo, the...
Alvina Gyulumyan elected Deputy President of the Constitutional Court
The judge of the Constitutional Court of Armenia Alvina Gyulumyan was elected on Friday Deputy President of the Constitutional Court during the...
European Figure Skating Championships to be held in Graz
The 2020 European Figure Skating Championships will be held in Graz, Austria, from 20–26 January 2020. As the National Olympic Committee...
Kutoyan’s body was found by wife – Artur Melikyan
The body of the former head of Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS) was found by his wife, the Head of Department of Investigation of...
Friday afternoon road conditions update
Some highways are closed or difficult to pass in the territory of Armenia as of Friday afternoon, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reported....
Ex-Armenian security chief found dead in Yerevan
Former Director of Armenia’s National Security Service Georgi Kutoyan was found dead with a gunshot wound in his apartment on...
US withdrawal from Open Skies Treaty to blow European security – Russian Foreign Ministry
Washington's withdrawal from the Treaty on Open Skies seriously "damages" European security and prompts Moscow to respond, the...
Three Turkish soldiers killed in car bomb attack in Syria
Three Turkish soldiers were killed in a car bomb attack while carrying out roadside checks on vehicles in northeast Syria on Thursday, Reuters...
EU ambassador to Armenia: You will have no human rights without rule of law
Political will is important in Armenia’s path to democracy, EU Ambassador to Armenia Andrea Wiktorin told reporters on Friday on the...
Pentagon: 11 US troops wounded in Iranian ballistic missile attack on Iraq bases
The Pentagon has revealed that 11 U.S. service members received treatment for concussions from an Iranian missile strike on Jan. 8, according...
Baku: Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs to hold new meeting by the end of January
Armenian and Azerbaijani Foreign Ministers Zohrab Mnatsakanyan and Elmar Mammadyarov will hold a new round of talks on the Nagorno-Karabakh...
Artistic director: ‘Tumanyan's Fairy Tales’ directed by Henrik Malyan can be included in Guinness World Records
2020 is a jubilee year for Henrik Malyan Theater of Cinema Artists, as it marks the 95th birthday anniversary of prominent Armenian filmmaker...
Khamenei: Iran gave U.S. 'slap on face', calls missile strikes 'day of God'
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said in a Friday sermon that Iran’s missile strikes on U.S. targets in Iraq this month delivered a...
Two seriously injured in house explosion in Armenian village
Two elderly people have been hospitalized with serious injuries after an explosion hit their house in the village of Zar in Armenia’s...
Ukraine PM submits resignation letter, president to consider it
Ukraine’s Prime Minister Oleksiy Honcharuk has submitted a letter of resignation and President Volodymur Zelenskiy will consider it, the...
Yerevan named most expensive city in South Caucasus
Yerevan, the capital of Armenia, appears to be the most expensive city in the South Caucasus, according to Cost of Living Index by City 2020...
Sepsis kills more people than cancer around the world
A new study finds that 1 in 5 deaths around the world is caused by sepsis, also known as blood poisoning, many more than previously estimated by...
A journey through history on Armenian Street in Singapore
An in-depth look at Singapore’s history reveals a history of civic and commercial involvement by Armenian merchants and entrepreneurs who...
Marine Le Pen announces bid for 2022 French presidential election
French far-right leader Marine Le Pen on Thursday announced she would run for president in the 2022 presidential election, Politico reported,...
Diplomat: Armenia values OSCE PA’s ‘balanced, tailor-made’ approach to various conflicts, crisis situations
Armenia’s Permanent Representative to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), Ambassador Armen Papikyan delivered...
VivaCell-MTS, Fuller Center for Housing hosted by Muradyans from Mayakovski village
Evaluating results is an important part of ensuring the continuity of any project. VivaCell-MTS and Fuller Center for Housing Armenia,...
Senate impeachment trial of Donald Trump officially begins
The third Senate impeachment trial of a US president in history convened on Thursday with the reading of the impeachment articles against...
Air temperature to go up by 3-4 degrees at night
Snow is predicted in separate regions in the daytime of January 19, at the night of 17, 20, Hydromet meteorological service at the ministry of...
FAAE asks The Semper Opera Ball for explanations over cancellation of Armenian soprano’s performance in Dresden
President of Forum of Armenian Associations of Europe Ashot Grigorian sent a letter to Artistic director of Semper Opera Ball Hans-Joachim Frey,...
Pashinyan congratulates Mishustin on his appointment as Prime Minister of Russia
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan congratulated Mikhail Mishustin on being appointed Prime Minister of the Russian Federation, the press...
VivaCell-MTS reports fourfold increase in LTE traffic during New Year period
The volume of Internet traffic in VivaCell-MTS mobile network on December 31, on New Year’s Eve before midnight, and on January 1, 2020,...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}