Politics 11:01 25/11/2020 Region

Armenia’s failure in Artsakh was determined by Pashinyan’s military and geopolitical incompetency – Greek City Times

By Paul Antonopoulos, Greek City Times

Artsakh, or more commonly known as Nagorno-Karabakh, experienced intense warfare in which thousands were killed and tens of thousands were driven out of their homes in only a month and a half of fighting that waged on until the Russian-brokered ceasefire two weeks ago. The conflict between indigenous Armenian forces and the Turkish-backed Azerbaijani military and their Syrian mercenary allies was described on October 1 as a “battle for survival” by Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.

Yet, despite the existential crisis in Artsakh, internationally recognized as a part of Azerbaijan but historically and demographically Armenian, Yerevan never fully committed to the war effort.

Colonel General Movses Hakobyan of the Military Supervision Service made a damning testimony on November 19 that revealed how the Armenian leadership made minimal efforts in what was supposed to be a “battle for survival.”

He revealed that by October 30, more than a month after the war began, that only 70% of Artsakh’s forces and 52% of reservists in Armenia had been mobilized. According to him, Armenia’s military doctrine determines that near full mobilization should be achieved within 48 hours of a war beginning. He also said that on the third day of the war Pashinyan had ordered the supply of regular Armenian reservist to Artsakh be halted and replaced with only volunteer detachments.

By downgrading mobilization to only volunteer detachments, a potential 200,000 reservists were not utilized. In fact, although government and military officials were calling for diaspora Armenians to fight in Artsakh, it has been revealed, at least in Greece, that volunteers were put on a list and would be deployed only if the situation demanded it. Hovik Kasapian, a leading member of the Armenian National Committee of Greece, also said that many ethnic Greeks had volunteered to fight in Artsakh but were rejected because Armenia did not want to put Athens in an awkward diplomatic situation, despite the fact that many of the Greek volunteers were highly trained ex-special forces. Pashinyan defended the necessity of the highly controversial ceasefire by claiming that Artsakh did not have enough manpower to defend against the Azerbaijani military, but Armenia had not even come close to using all the resources available.

The question begs though why Yerevan in a supposed “battle for survival” would be concerned about potentially creating diplomatic issues for Greece when Artsakh was completely abandoned by the West. In a so-called “battle for survival” it would be expected that Armenia would use any assistance offered, especially since Turkey had no qualms sending mercenaries. Instead, Armenian and foreign volunteers were only put on standby or rejected, Armenian and Artsakh forces were never fully mobilized, powerful Iskander missiles were used infrequently and the Armenian Air Force barely featured during the war.

What motivated Armenia’s non-commitment to the war effort is still unknown.

But for all the military mistakes of Pashinyan and his administration, the biggest miscalculation was his attempt to pivot Armenia towards the EU and even flirt with NATO. Pashinyan came to power off the back of the so-called Velvet Revolution in 2018. It was hoped with his accession to power that Soviet-era oligarchical rule and corruption would come to an end. However, as is often the case in post-Warsaw bloc countries, the belief is that replacing communist-era political and oligarchical structures can only be achieved by straining relations with Moscow and pivoting towards Western liberalism. Armenians of course have the right to demand an end to oligarchical corruption and domination, but this should only have been achieved without antagonizing traditional geopolitical alliances.

A report by EurAsia Daily documented Pashinyan’s appointments after coming to power, especially those associated with NGO’s funded by famous Russophobe billionaire George Soros. One appointment by Pashinyan was Armen Grigoryan to Head of the National Security Council. Grigoryan was the Election Program Coordinator of Soros Foundation-funded Transparency International, an NGO that sponsors so-called color revolutions. David Sanasaryan was appointed as Head of the State Audit Service but is known for throwing eggs at the Russian Embassy and demanding the withdrawal of Russian military base from Armenia. Babken Ter-Grigoryan was appointed as deputy minister for the Armenian Diaspora and formerly worked at Transparency International too. And these are just some among many.

Pashinyan effectively flooded his cabinet with Soros Foundation-funded or formerly funded members.

Although Eastern European countries may have opportunities to engage in dramatic social, cultural and economic changes towards Western liberalism with the direct support of the EU, the geography of Armenia dictates its realistic alliances. Armenia as a small, mountainous, landlocked and impoverished country of only 3 million people is wedged between Georgia, Azerbaijan, Iran and Turkey, and nearly 1200 km away from the closest EU member, Cyprus. Yerevan’s closeness and eventual accession into the EU is not a realistic prospect. Geography must determine Armenia’s foreign policy. Armenia relies on Iran for goods from the outside world, Turkey and Azerbaijan are hostile and maintain embargoes on Armenia, and Georgia has proven in action that they side with Armenia’s enemies by allowing Turkish planes to cross its airspace to land Syrian mercenaries in Azerbaijan.

A part of the EU system is peaceful coexistence among member states. This has actually been one of the few successes of the bloc after inheriting a continent plagued by millennia of war, genocide and devastation. The EU also operates because of open borders between member states that are contiguous with each other. Armenia is separated from EU member states Greece and Bulgaria as Turkey is located between them. Armenia will not have an opportunity to join the EU unless Turkey becomes a member state, which is a prospect certainly not foreseeable in the near future.

The geostrategic mistake was motivated by Pashinyan’s delusions of turning Armenia into a Western-styled liberal state despite being in a hostile region surrounded by enemies and far detached from the EU. This folly was exposed when the Turkish-sponsored invasion of Artsakh began and the West made no actions besides rhetorical sympathy.

In the end, with the failure to defend Artsakh militarily, it was Russia that had to intervene to bring an end to the conflict. This was despite the fact that Pashinyan had pivoted towards the West and stacked his administration with Russophobic Soros Foundation-funded members under the guise of supposedly fighting oligarchical rule and corruption that originates from Russia.

Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


US Ambassador and Attaché to Armenia hosted at the Ministry of Defense
Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Armenia, Colonel General Onik Gasparyan received on Friday US Ambassador to Armenia Lynne...
Baroness Caroline Cox: I have seen videos and photos of mutilations, torture and beheadings of Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh
Despite the ceasefire, reports continue of atrocities perpetrated by Azerbaijani forces on Armenian military and civilian prisoners, Baroness...
Parliament elected two members of Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council
Gagik Jhangiryan, former Military Prosecutor (1997 - 2006) and Deputy Prosecutor General of Armenia (2006-2008) was elected on Friday new member...
Lars road open for all types of vehicles
Some roads are closed in the territory of Armenia as of 16.30 on Friday, the Ministry of Emergency Situations reports.  In Aragatsotn...
Turkish firm opens drone factory in Ankara
A drone manufacturing plant started operations on Friday in Turkey's capital Ankara, the local sources reported.  As Anadolu news...
NATO calls on Russia to end its recognition of Abkhazia and South Ossetia
NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg received on Friday Georgian President Salome Zourabichvili at NATO Headquarters, according to NATO press...
My task is to present them the truth - Serge Avedikian
The new documentary "Return to Soloz" by French-Armenian director Serge Avedikian will be premiered in Armenia on Friday. Avedikian...
Air temperature to go 20 degrees below zero in some provinces of Armenia
No precipitation is predicted in the territory of Armenia in the daytime of January 22, on 23-27, Hydromet meteorological service reported on...
Georgia to lift ban on international flights on Feb. 1
Georgia will lift a ban on international flights, imposed last March as an anti-pandemic measure, in 10 days’ time, authorities said on...
Artak Beglaryan discussed a number of humanitarian programs with the Head of the ICRC mission
Chief of the Presidential Staff of the Artsakh Republic  Artak Beglaryan received on Friday the Head of the Stepanakert Office of the...
Armenian parliament restricts entry of media outlets and journalists – Media Advocate
The Armenian National Assembly (NA) restricts the entry of media outlets and journalists to the parliament, Media Advocate initiative said in a...
Artsakh reports 8 new COVID-19 cases
Artsakh reported 8 new coronavirus infections on Friday, bringing the national tally to 2,274. In total, 31 COVID-19 deaths have been...
Armenian ombudsman applies to European organizations’ heads over illegitimacy of border demarcation process
Armenia’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan on Friday applied to heads of a number of European organizations over the...
Rep. Schiff says Congress should recognize Artsakh
In an in-depth interview with Asbarez Editor Ara Khachatourian on Thursday, Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) said the Congress should recognize...
Foreign Ministry: Cessation of hostile actions against Armenia may create conditions for building trust in region
Armenian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Anna Naghdalyan has answered a question of PanARMENIAN.net news agency. The question and answer are below....
US ambassador: Political solution on Karabakh status essential for securing regional peace and stability
U.S. Ambassador to Armenia Lynne M. Tracy on Friday published an article entitled “Democracy is Precious”. The ambassador’s...
Protest held outside Armenian parliament
A group of activists on Friday gathered outside the Armenian National Assembly to protest against the possible election of Gagik Jhangiryan and...
European Parliament condemns Azeri war crimes in Artsakh, calls for accountability – Foreign Ministry
Armenian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Anna Naghdalyan on Friday reacted to the European Parliament’s annual report-resolutions on the...
European Parliament strongly condemns Turkey’s destabilizing role in Karabakh
In the resolution on the implementation of the Common Foreign and Security Policy – annual report 2020 adopted on Wednesday, January 20,...
US Secretary of State nominee Blinken voices support for Armenia and Artsakh
U.S. President Joe Biden’s nominee to serve as Secretary of State, Antony Blinken – in written responses submitted following...
Armenia’s COVID-19 cases reach 165,711 on January 22
Armenia has confirmed 183 new cases of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) in a 24-hour period, bringing the national tally to 165,711 as of 11...
1,900 doses of Moderna vaccine destroyed in US after cleaner accidentally unplugs freezer
Thousands of doses of Moderna's COVID-19 vaccine were destroyed after a cleaner in the US city of Boston accidentally unplugged the freezer...
Ombudsman: Propaganda of Armenophobia and hostility towards Armenian people has deep roots in Azerbaijan
Utterances recorded by the staff of Armenia’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Arman Tatoyan prove that the propaganda of Armenophobia...
More than 50,000 refugees returned to Artsakh from Armenia
Russian peacekeepers in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) escort convoys of local residents and refugees every day, the Russian Defense Ministry said...
Biden seeks extension of New START arms treaty with Russia
U.S. President Joe Biden will seek a five-year extension to the New START arms control treaty with Russia, the White House said on Thursday, in...
Magnitude 3.8 quake hits near Nakhichevan, jolts felt in Armenia
The Seismic Protection Service of Armenia’s Ministry of Emergency Situations detected a magnitude 3.8 earthquake in the...
U.S. ambassador to Armenia meets with think tank experts
U.S. Ambassador to Armenia Lynne Tracy on Thursday met with a group of think tank experts to discuss the commitment of the United States, as a...
Roads of Armenia’s Syunik difficult to pass
Some roads are closed or hardly passable in Armenia as of Thursday evening due to adverse weather conditions, the Ministry of Emergency...
Lawyer appeals against Alexey Navalny’s arrest
An appeal has been filed against blogger Alexey Navalny’s arrest, lawyer Vadim Kobzev told TASS. "We have filed an appeal against...
Lawyer. Search for Ruben Hayrapetyan stopped long ago
Former President of the Football Federation of Armenia Ruben Hayrapetyan's lawyer Amram Makinyan reacted to the statement released by the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}