Economy 16:14 25/01/2023 Armenia

Corrupt deal of the year: Donation of ZCMC shares to Armenian government remains unclear

The issues concerning the transfer of the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine (ZCMC) shares to the Armenian government, one of the shadiest deals in the history of independent Armenia, remain up in the air.

It remains unclear how the government cut a deal with the mining giant, which is Armenia’s largest taxpayer, as its details have not been publicly disclosed.

It all started back on 30 September 2021, when it emerged that the Industrial Company JSC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Russian billionaire Roman Trotsenko’s GeoProMining Gold, acquired 60% of ZCMC and immediately donated a quarter of that stake to the Armenian government. Thus, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s government got hold of 15% of ZCMC’s stock.

Incidentally, the Industrial Company had never been listed among the shareholders of the mining company. It became a ZCMC shareholder on September 30, when 15% of its ZCMC stake were granted to the government.

Pashinyan's statement and changes in ZCMC

Campaigning for the June 2021 parliamentary elections, Nikol Pashinyan vowed to punish ZCMC’s “owners” for harassing its employees and make sure that their shares are “returned to the people” as parts of a “steel revolution” which he said would start from Syunik Province.

“Employees of the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine have been threatened with dismissal if they attend [Pashinyan’s] rallies. I promise you now that none of those threatening you will have worked at ZCMC by mid-July. It's enough that some bashibozouks remained in charge of the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine," Pashinyan said at an election campaign in the town of Kajaran on 15 June.

He also revealed some secrets. "I would like to reveal a secret; now negotiations are underway in this regard and I hope that some will take a constructive stance. Otherwise, the Armenian people shall get back their shares in the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine from those bashibozouks, even under the nationalization law."

The ZCMC deal was struck not long after his statements.

Here’s another striking circumstance. Decision No. 270-А of Armenia’s Competition Protection Commission dated 29 September 2021 reveals that the commission allowed the concurrence of the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine and the Industrial Company. It was based on a June 15 application submitted by the two companies, which said the Moscow-based Industrial Company sought to acquire around 60% of ZCMC’s stock.

Thus, the Competition Protection Commission received the application on the same day when Nikol Pashinyan told his supporters in Kajaran that "the Armenian people will regain their shares in the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine.”

Subsequently, the government handed over its 15% stake in ZCMC to the trust management of the Armenian National Interests Fund (ANIF). Strikingly, ANIF Board of Directors is led by Armenia’s former Deputy Prime Minister Tigran Avinyan.

A number of economists, politicians and media outlets sounded the alarm about this non-transparent deal. Moreover, the media asked the government to provide a copy of the donation agreement, however the latter rejected the request, citing “commercial issues” concerning the transfer.

CivilNet and the Transparency International Anti-Corruption Center next filed a lawsuit in the Administrative Court in December 2021, asking the court to oblige the government to publicize the deal.

Earlier in October, Varuzhan Hoktanyan, Project Director at the Transparency International Anti-Corruption Center, told Pastinfo that the deal to sell 60% of the ZCMC shares to Roman Trotsenko was not transparent and no further clarifications were provided.

"It’s unclear why GeoProMining was kind enough to donate 15% of its stake to the government. In turn, the government justified the deal claiming that its role in the distribution and use of the ZCMC profits, as well as in its further development will increase. Basically, it’s not a bad objective, but the question is whether those claims correspond to reality or not," Hoktanyan said.

He also called out the transfer of the shares to the prime minister’s office rather that the Ministry of Economy, which, Hoktanyan claimed, was a more competent agency.

"This is yet another evidence of the concentration of power, because it it’s clear why the stake was granted to the prime minister's office. Everything is concentrated in the hands of the prime minister's staff. If it continues like this, there will be no need for ministries, since they will emerge into departments of the prime minister's office," Hoktanyan stated.

Addressing the parliament on 6 October 2021, Pashinyan excitedly announced GeoProMining’s plans to build a copper smelter and a nuclear power plant in Armenia thriugh new investments, which essentially remained up in the air.

Incidentally, even Armenian politician Aram Sargsyan, who is a close ally of Nikol Pashinyan, called the deal reckless. "A Russian investor comes to Kajaran and says he will invest $3 billion there. However, a maximum of $800 million is needed to build a metal smelting plant," he stated.

Later on 24 August 2022, the Armenian government endorsed a draft decision to hand over 6.8% more stake in ZCMC to ANIF for management. Pashinyan revealed at a weekly cabinet meeting that the firm called AMP Holding secretly donated its 6.8% stake to the government in March. The premier said AMP asked the government at the time not to publicize the transfer due to “commercial issues.”

“Now they have no need for secrecy, and we are handing over that 6.8% stake to ANIF for management. Starting from March 24, the Armenian government holds a 21.875% stake [in ZCMC], which is a crucial development,” Pashinian said.

The decision said that Armenia would more effectively manage its shares in the company through ANIF which could create a long-term joint vision and opportunities between the state and the company's shareholders for business development and economic benefits for Armenia.

ANIF and transparency

Was ANIF transparent at work? The media can best answer this question, as their requests to ANIF were mostly ignored or they received vague answers after several warnings.

Panorama tried to obtain any information on the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine from the ANIF website. There were just two reports regarding ZCMC: The one revealed the transfer of the government’s stake in ZCMC to the fiduciary management of ANIF, while the other said ANIF “will no longer manage the shares owned by the government.” No other data was available.

Pastinfo also reported the issue, saying it could not reach the Italian and French members of the ANIF Board of Directors as well as Chairman of the ANIF Investment Committee Khaled Helioui to get answers to a number of controversial questions.

ANIF proposed the news outlet to send the requests to them, promising to forward them to the addressees. "We have not heard back from the addressees, thus we can assume that the questions have not been passed to them,” Pastinfo said.

It comes to show that ANIF’s foreign leaders are not authorized to provide any information on the management of the ZCMC shares. In other words, ANIF has adopted a policy of restricting and obstructing the media's right to access information, which is repeatedly reported by Pastinfo, GivilNet, and other media outlets.

It could not go without consequences

A few months after the government transferred its 21.8% stake in the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine to ANIF, it made another decision.

At a meeting on 22 December 2022, the government approved a decision to hand over its 21.9% stake in ZCMC to the State Property Management Committee, without giving any reason.

It only cited the need for a “more institutional approach” to its involvement in the corporate management of the company. No other details were available.

Referring to the matter, Pastinfo writes: "Serious discussions were held at ANIF, as some foreign members were concerned that their names were affected in the management of shares acquired through a highly suspicious corrupt transaction, which could negatively affect their ratings.”

It all comes under the government whose leader, Nikol Pashinyan, came to power on a promise to promote “transparency and openness”.



Source Panorama.am
Share |

Newsfeed

17:07
Lawyer accuses Armenian government of repression after search at GG office
Human rights lawyer Ruben Melikyan accused the Armenian government of repression following a search at the office of GG, an online taxi service...
16:45
Temperatures to rise further in Armenia
Showers and thunderstorms coupled with strong winds are expected in some regions of Armenia late on Saturday and in the next few days. Hail...
16:36
Kate Middleton makes first public appearance since cancer diagnosis
Kate Middleton waved to the crowd from Buckingham Palace's balcony, in her first public appearance since her cancer diagnosis earlier this...
16:14
Opposition MP: Pashinyan ready to sacrifice even his closest associates
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has brushed aside Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s statements on the Artsakh people and leaders, accusing...
15:36
Jennifer Lopez is 'over' trying to salvage doomed marriage to Ben Affleck
Jennifer Lopez is 'over' trying to make her marriage with Ben Affleck work, a source has told DailyMail.com. Amid furious rumors...
15:16
Protest movement in Armenia hasn't fizzled out, archbishop claims
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan claims the protest movement led by him aimed at ousting Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his government...
14:30
Armenian church commemorates discovery of St. Gregory the Illuminator's relics
The Armenian Apostolic Church commemorates the discovery of the relics of St. Gregory the Illuminator on Saturday 15 June. It is one of the...
14:07
LIVE: Authorities searching GG office in Yerevan
Armenia's Investigative Committee is searching the office of the taxi service GG in Yerevan. Lawyers have called the search...
13:36
Armenian authorities search office of GG taxi service
The Armenian Investigative Committee on Saturday raided the office of the online taxi service provider GG in Yerevan, lawyer Arsen Babayan...
13:04
Pashinyan congratulates Rishi Sunak on public holiday
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Saturday sent a congratulatory message to UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak on the occasion of the public...
12:46
WHO chief says many people in Gaza facing 'famine-like conditions'
The head of the World Health Organization (WHO) said on Friday that many people in Gaza were facing "catastrophic hunger and famine-like...
12:36
Human rights activist reports mass arrests in Armenia
Human rights activist Ruben Melikyan reports that Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s regime has ordered mass arrests in Armenia. ...
12:15
Political analyst: Pashinyan was ready to order tougher measures against protesters
Political analyst Hrant Melik-Shahnazaryan claims Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan was ready to order tougher measures against protesters outside...
11:35
Amnesty International: Violence during street protests in Yerevan must be investigated
Reacting to reports of violent clashes between protesters and police in Armenia’s capital Yerevan, which resulted in numerous injuries and...
11:15
Serzh Sargsyan follows games of Stepan Avagyan Memorial
Armenian Chess Federation President Serzh Sargsyan and First Vice-President Smbat Lputian on Friday came to the tournament venue to follow the...
11:00
Catholicos Aram I seeks support from Vatican for release of Armenian prisoners in Baku
During his meeting with Pope Francis at the Vatican, His Holiness Catholicos Aram I of the Great House of Cilicia expressed his deep gratitude...
19:10
EventHub.am is the official ticketing agent for the concert of the world renowned Black Eyed Peas in Tbilisi
EventHub․am platform has become the official ticketing agent in Armenia for the concert of the world-renowned Black Eyed Peas to be held in...
17:05
Reporter brutally beaten at Yerevan protest remains in hospital
Journalist and outspoken government critic Abraham Gasparyan, who was brutally beaten by special police officers while being detained at a...
16:45
Céline Dion vows to return to stage
Céline Dion has no intention of letting her health struggles get in the way of her career, HuffPost reports. The five-time...
16:33
Japanese violinist wins Khachaturian International Competition
Japanese violinist Tomotaka Seki has won the top prize at the 20th Khachaturian International Competition. Sergei Mkrtchian of Russia came...
16:05
Armenia sends protest note to Belarus
Armenia has issued a protest note to Belarus following the statements of its official, the Armenian Foreign Ministry reports. “A note...
15:53
Armenian contract soldier found dead
An Armenian contract soldier was found dead at his combat post early on Friday morning. The Defense Ministry reported that the...
15:36
Senior ARF members detained in Armenia
Senior members of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) were detained on Friday after the law-enforcement authorities searched its offices...
14:55
Armenian MP reacts to false Azeri accusations of border fire
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has reacted to Azerbaijan’s latest false claims that Armenian forces opened fire at its combat positions...
14:15
Donald Trump celebrates 78th birthday
Donald Trump turns 78 on Friday, a milestone that will remind voters that the two major-party candidates running for U.S. president this year...
13:52
Armenian health minister defends police actions against protesters
Armenian Health Minister Anahit Avanesyan has defended the police after bloody clashes with demonstrators outside the parliament on June...
13:05
Lawyer responds to U.S. Embassy statement on protests in Yerevan
Lawyer Gevorg Danielyan called out the U.S. Embassy in Armenia for failure to condemn the police crackdown on peaceful protesters in Yerevan on...
12:30
No one waits for Armenia to join EU, Russian official says
The West has no intentions of inviting Armenia to join the European Union (EU) and Ukraine should not expect it in the near future as well,...
12:15
Euro 2024 kicks off tonight
The 17th European Football Championship will begin on Friday night with Germany and Scotland's match at Munich's Allianz Arena. The...
11:50
Ruben Vardanyan tortured in Baku prison, lawyers claim
Today, the international legal team for Ruben Vardanyan, a political prisoner detained in Azerbaijan, filed an urgent appeal with the UN Special...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}