Politics 11:34 20/09/2023 NKR

Opinion: War is returning to Nagorno-Karabakh because the world did nothing to stop it

By Hovhannes Nikoghosyan and Vahram Ter-Matevosyan

The the article was originally published on The Moscow Times.

Open conflict has once again broken out in Nagorno-Karabakh. On Tuesday, the Azerbaijani defense ministry announced the beginning of a new military campaign, indiscriminately shelling the capital Stepanakert and other settlements.

For the past few weeks, aerial images and videos have shown that Azerbaijan has been amassing troops along the borders of Nagorno-Karabakh and of Armenia itself. The upside-down letter “A” on Azerbaijani military vehicles — a copycat of the Russian military’s insignia in Ukraine — looks like a threat to cut through Southern Armenia and secure the land corridor into Nakhchivan and to Turkey, which President Ilham Aliyev has been demanding since the end of the 2020 war.

Many international organizations, including the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and foreign governments have condemned the dire humanitarian catastrophe in this breakaway region in the South Caucasus. Residents have been dying of malnutrition and shortages of medicine.

The ongoing blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh and its 120,000 inhabitants since December 2022, and regular ceasefire violations by Azerbaijan, prompted the former Prosecutor General of the International Criminal Court, Luis Moreno Ocampo, to call this a genocide under the UN’s 1948 Genocide Convention. 

A closer look into the situation on the ground makes it clear there is neither room for peace, nor preventing a new war.

Backed by Turkey, Pakistan and Israel, Azerbaijan launched and won an unprovoked war in fall 2020, reclaiming around 10,000 square kilometers of Armenian-controlled territories in and around Nagorno-Karabakh. Since November 2020, the remaining 2,200 square kilometers have been patrolled by local self-defense forces and Russian peacekeepers who lack a broad international mandate and rules of engagement.

Regular skirmishes both on the Line of Contact in Nagorno-Karabakh and along the international border between Armenia and Azerbaijan have become a new normal. Since May 2021, the Armenian government has reported about 150 square kilometers of its internationally-recognized sovereign territory under Azerbaijani occupation.

Incursions by Azerbaijan have barely been held back by unarmed European observers (since October 2022) or Russian peacekeepers.

Since November 2020, the Azerbaijani government and various state-sponsored activists have spoken more systematically about the state of Armenia representing “Western Azerbaijan.” Repatriating Azerbaijani inhabitants of Armenia and questioning the legitimacy of the country’s existence has unofficially been part of Baku’s agenda for some time.

Now Armenia is warned against criticizing Azerbaijan’s xenophobic statements, which it uses for internal propaganda, in order to avoid jeopardising the chances of a peace agreement. Meanwhile Aliyev, encouraged by this idleness of external players, has occupied swaths of Armenian highlands on the border and keeps lowland residents under fire, often literally.

Following Armenia’s snap parliamentary elections in 2021, which saw the election of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, the Armenian government started nurturing a new narrative about a “peace deal” with Azerbaijan. To meet one of Baku's key demands, Pashinyan has even publicly pronounced Nagorno-Karabakh part of Azerbaijan.

This backpedalling created an opportunity for both Russia, as well as the EU and U.S., to try to establish peace in the region. The Armenian leadership, most likely, acted under duress created by the threat of force by Azerbaijan.

The crux of the matter is that “sustainable peace” has become a euphemism for pushing a weakened Armenia to gradually denounce their national interests in the hope that Azerbaijan will stop its onslaught. Such calculus shows a lack of understanding of the historical grievances at play in the region. The global disorder of past years meant achieving peace was not a priority.

But there is more to it, often unspoken due to self-censorship and bothsidesism.

For 25 years following Azerbaijan’s defeat in 1994, first President Heydar Aliyev and then his son President Ilham Aliyev have placed anti-Armenian sentiment at the heart of their country’s national image. Children as young as kindergarten are being taught to see Armenians as the enemy. Despite this, the international community continues to court Baku.

Part of the reason why is that Aliyev has become adept at “caviar diplomacy”: an investigation by Organised Crime and Corruption Reporting project found he ran a slush-fund of $2.9 billion, with which he paid off hundreds of European, American and Russian politicians, media personalities and thought leaders.

This explains why Aliyev, being an experienced puppet-master, is ready to incur high risks and bear the costs of damage to his reputation. He knows he can get away with it.

Aliyev is trying to complete his nation-building project. Through policies and propaganda, him and his father created a vengeful nation for which the pain and suffering of Armenians is an article of faith.

Overinflating the sense of humiliation of the 1990s, the motivation for revenge has penetrated all aspects of social fabric. There are parallels with the myth of the humiliation of Russia by the West in the same decade.

Even if Nagorno-Karabakh is fully subordinated to Azerbaijan — a corrupt dictatorship — ethnic Armenians will most likely be persecuted as a result of decades-old and state-sponsored xenophobia against them. The Azerbaijani regime has no desire to overturn this policy, nor do the external players seem interested in using any leverage to end it.

Expecting Azerbaijan to back down because of diplomatic pressure is pointless. Even if the ICRC is successful in securing a durable commitment to the simultaneous opening of both the Lachin Corridor (which Azerbaijan blocked) and the road from Azerbaijan (to which Nagorno-Karabakh authorities object) — it will be yet another advance for Aliyev’s plan in subordinating Armenians.

Despite the world averting its eyes from the conflict between the two countries after November 2020, local residents and international observers know it never fully ended. Its dimensions and geography have merely been transformed.

Three years after that formal ceasefire, the Armenian military’s failure to regroup and resupply, and almost 18 months of Russia’s war in Ukraine, Azerbaijan is again looking to seize more of its maximalist demands. Most likely, these involve seizing control of a land passage through southern Armenia into its exclave of Nakhchivan and onward to its ally Turkey. 

Turkey will support its minor partner Azerbaijan as a bargaining chip in relations with Russia. There are four other players with the capacity that could prevent a new war. But none of them used any of it.

They are Iran, Europe, the United States and Russia.

Iran has long been the only power which has unequivocally claimed that the region’s borders cannot be altered. It seems following a recent visit to Tehran by the Turkish foreign minister some assurances to this end have been sought and received, which will put Iran at bay. 

The White House and State Department have put a lot of effort to bridge the divide between the parties diplomatically, but it seems Washington’s primary concern is geopolitical, not humanitarian: snatching Armenia from Russia’s embrace, without regard to the plight of Nagorno-Karabakh itself.

Europe has been divided on this matter. EU President Charles Michel has been trying, probably in his view, to pick the low-hanging fruit of securing a peace deal. But chronic misunderstanding of the regional dynamics and failure to adhere to any principled position have in fact further emboldened Aliyev.

This is not the result of Europe’sdependence on Azerbaijani gas. Europe’s unwillingness to engage meaningfully will lose it many supporters in Armenia.

At the end of the day, neither the EU nor the U.S. have skin in the game. The post-1990 arguments about the European and American rules-based order had given way to the global financial crisis and Covid. Furthermore, many politicians in both Brussels and Washington have strayed far from those ideals.

Russia remains the region’s traditional dealmaker — and dealbreaker. The Kremlin hasn’t stood idle in recent monthsdue to the distraction with Ukraine or the necessity to mobilize the economy in the face of Western sanctions. In fact, this inaction stems from competing interests and shattered decision-making mechanisms inside the Kremlin. For example, the commander of the Russian peacekeeping forces in Nagorno-Karabakh has been switched four times since 2020.

The Kremlin has only been reacting to Armenia's cozying up to the West . This has created a long list of grievances on both sides which prevents Moscow from being willing to stop a new war.

There are two ways to halt the humanitarian catastrophe in Nagorno-Karabakh and in Armenia and stifle the flames of the newly reignited conflict. Sadly, it is unlikely the international community will try either of them.

Firstly, the Azerbaijani economy and powerful individuals must be sanctioned for purported crimes both inside their country and against Armenians. Secondly, the international community should suspend the country’s membership of organizations like the Council of Europe and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, as happened to Yugoslavia in the 1990s.

Of course, this can be better achieved by more active Armenian diplomacy. But its sloppiness does not grant other players an excuse to stand by doing nothing. The only language dictators understand and respect is force. Very few become more aggressive in the face of credible consequences. Otherwise, for both Russia and the West, this is another appeasement of another dictator before a bigger war. 

Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:


Temperatures to reach 16C in parts of Armenia
No precipitation is expected in Armenia in the next few days. Temperatures are set to gradually rise by 6-8C starting from Wednesday....
Opposition MP slams Pashinyan's foreign policy
Opposition MP Armen Rustamyan has denounced the “destructive” foreign policy pursued by Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and...
Armenian CEC members observe elections in Belarus
The deputy chair of Armenia’s Central Electoral Commission (CEC), Nune Hovhannisyan, and CEC member Silva Markosyan travelled to the...
Azerbaijan continues vandalizing and destroying Armenian monuments – Foreign Ministry
Azerbaijan continues the policy aimed at erasing the Armenian traces in the territories under its control, vandalizing and destroying Armenian...
Minister: One child wounded in Artsakh fuel depot blast continues treatment abroad
Most of the Armenians, who were wounded in a huge explosion at a fuel depot in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) in September 2023 and later moved...
Harry Potter first edition book sells for £11,000
A first-edition Harry Potter novel that was bought for 13p almost 30 years ago has sold at auction for £11,000, the BBC reports....
Parliament speaker rejects 'unacceptable' snap elections in Armenia
Speaker of the National Assembly Alen Simonyan claims snap elections in Armenia are "unacceptable". “The elections...
Azerbaijan destroys Alexander Myasnikyan statue in Stepanakert
Azerbaijan has destroyed the statue of prominent Soviet Armenian politician, academic and literary critic Alexander Myasnikyan located on...
Parliament speaker: I don't mind living in peace with Azerbaijan and Turkey
No information on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s visit to Armenia is currently available, Armenian National Assembly Speaker...
Hungarian parliament clears path for Sweden's Nato membership
Sweden has cleared its final obstacle to joining Nato after Hungary's parliament voted to ratify the bid, BBC News reported. The...
Armenian parliament to elect new top court judge at plenary session
The National Assembly of Armenia started a plenary session on Tuesday with 28 items on the agenda. Lawmakers are set to elect a new judge of...
Parents sue Armenian education minister over history textbook
Parents of school students have sued Armenian Minister of Education, Science, Culture and Sports Zhanna Andreasyan over the 7th grade history...
Pashinyan off to Greece with wife
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his spouse Anna Hakobyan have travelled to Greece on a working visit, the prime minister's...
Soprano Juliana Grigoryan wins Hildegard Behrens Prize
The Hildegard Behrens Foundation has announced that the 14th annual Hildegard Behrens Prize was awarded to Metropolitan Opera Lindemann Young...
Serzh Sargsyan meets with representatives of regional chess federations
A conference with representatives of regional federations, that was organized by the Armenian Chess Federation, took place at the Chess Academy...
Armenian FM meets with ICRC chief in Geneva
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan had a meeting with Mirjana Spoljaric Egger, President of the International Committee of Red...
Armenian, Azeri FMs to meet in Berlin in late February
The delegations led by Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov will meet in Berlin on February...
Lord Jacob Rothschild dies at 87
Financier, philanthropist, and head of the Rothschild family, Lord Jacob Rothschild, has died aged 87, The Independent reports. The...
MP Gevorg Papoyan steps down
Ruling Civil Contract faction MP Gevorg Papoyan has resigned his seat in the Armenian parliament.  The deputy submitted his...
Pro-government MP comments on Zelensky's possible visit to Armenia
MP Babken Tunyan, who represents Armenia’s ruling Civil Contract party, has reacted to reports of Ukrainian President Volodymyr...
Analyst names Pashinyan's main 'weapon' in possible snap elections
Political analyst Suren Surenyants believes outright anti-Russian policy and Armenia’s promised withdrawal from the CSTO will be Prime...
SJC dismisses judge Arshak Vardanyan
Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) has dismissed judge Arshak Vardanyan of the Criminal Court of Appeals at his own request, the...
Kremlin insists on clarity from Armenia over CSTO
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov says that there is no clarity yet on Armenia's position on its withdrawal from the Russian-led...
Fallen soldier's father to undergo heart surgery today
The health condition of Garik Galeyan, whose soldier son Mkhitar was killed in the 2020 Artsakh war, has stabilized and he is preparing for...
Armenian State Symphony Orchestra donates to UNICEF for Armenia refugee response
The Foundation for the Support of the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra announced today a donation of US$ 12,000 to UNICEF Armenia in support of...
Opposition MP blames Armenian authorities for failure to counter Azeri propaganda
Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has blamed the Armenian authorities for failure to counter the false Azerbaijani propaganda narrative regarding...
Gisele Kapterian to run for Australian Parliament
The Armenian National Committee of Australia (ANC-AU) has welcomed the pre-selection of one of its valued board members, Gisele Kapterian, who...
Bayramov: Armenia, Azerbaijan to hold fresh talks soon
The delegations of Azerbaijan and Armenia will hold fresh peace talks in the near future, Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov has...
Tatul Altunyan Ensemble to tour France
Armenia’s Tatul Altunyan Dance and Song Ensemble will be touring France from February 28 to March 29, the Armenian Embassy in Paris...
Women to take part in Japan's 'naked festival' for first time
Women in Japan have been permitted to take part in an ancient ceremony, known as the naked festival, for the first time in the event’s...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}