Politics 11:44 07/04/2021 Armenia

Opinion: Saudi Arabia should sue Turkey for stealing Prophet Muhammad's relics

By Harut Sassounian

Publisher, The California Courier

The Arab News published on March 28 an article titled, “Book by Saudi author unravels Ottoman atrocities in Madinah.” The book was written by Saudi historian Muhammad Al-Saeed who exposed Ottoman atrocities against the Muslim population of the holy city of Madinah in Saudi Arabia in 1918 when it was part of the Ottoman Empire.

Al-Saeed, in his book, “Seferberlik: A Century on from the Ottoman crime in Madinah,” tells the seldom-known story of the deportation and killings of the population of Madinah by Ottoman General Fakhri Pasha. The city was pillaged and its holy relics looted by the Ottoman army.

The journalist of the Arab News article, Mohammed Al-Sulami, explained that even though some historians use the Turkish/Arabic word ‘Seferberlik -- meaning mobilization or collective deportation -- when referring to the Armenian Genocide, this term is also used to refer to the mass displacement of the population from Madinah.

Fakhri Pasha laid siege to Madinah when the city was under attack by the British-backed Arab fighters of Hussein bin Ali, the Sharif of Makkah. Fakhri Pasha deported 40,000 people from Madinah by trains to present-day Syria, Turkey, and Iraq, abandoning them to their fate. Only 140 residents remained in Madinah who suffered from famine.

Furthermore, the Ottoman army removed the valuable personal effects of Prophet Muhammad from his sacred chamber and smuggled them to Constantinople (Istanbul). Fakhri Pasha converted the Prophet’s mosque into a weapons depot, thus endangering the tomb of the Prophet. Fakhri Pasha also demolished many buildings, starved the remaining population of Madinah and confiscated their possessions, such as farms and crops, reserving the food for his soldiers.

“The stolen treasures arrived in Constantinople, the Ottoman Empire’s capital, and have been on display for many years at the Topkapi Museum,” author Al-Saeed said. The Arab News article explained that the stolen holy relics included “old copies of the Quran, jewelry, golden candlesticks and swords. Besides the 390 artifacts, visitors to the [Topkapi] museum can see the following possessions of Prophet Muhammad: the Blessed Mantle, the Holy Banner, his sword and bow, a jar, a piece of his tooth and a hair from his beard.”

Al-Saeed also revealed that “Fakhri Pasha even attempted to have the body of Prophet Muhammad exhumed and shipped to Constantinople. An Egyptian engineer, who was summoned to Madinah to modify the minarets of the Prophet’s Mosque to support the weight of Ottoman artillery, claimed he was ordered to open the tomb, but he refused. Fakhri Pasha asked for his help to exhume the body of the prophet and move it to Constantinople, according to the historical documents written by the French representative in Cairo and sent to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The French representative vouched for the account of the Egyptian engineer, who fled the city and did not carry out the crime, thus confirming that the grave in question did indeed house the prophet’s body and the goal was to move the body to Constantinople.”

Al-Saeed told the Arab News that “Madinah reached the point of famine, forcing its citizens and orphaned children to eat cats, dogs and what remained on the farms and in the streets.”

Importantly, Al-Saeed said he wrote about the Ottoman Empire’s atrocities in Madinah “because he believes modern Turkey is trying to whitewash its imperial past. He plans to translate his book into several languages to raise awareness of this little-known chapter of Ottoman history.”

Al-Saeed further said: “I wrote an article in 2015 about the passage of 100 years since this crime and provided details that few people knew about. Reactions to the article varied between people shocked at the information and those who could not believe it, given the Turkish publicity ahead of its publication which attempted to whitewash the Ottoman Empire’s ugliness and its heinous crimes against Arabs. The public was oblivious to the Ottoman crimes. Following the article, the idea of documenting the event was established, so that history would not forget it like other events in Arab history, particularly since the few historical sources that documented Seferberlik are in the Ottoman, English and French archives. Moreover, the sources of information are very limited and the grandchildren of those who were in Madinah at the time do not have many documents. A lot of the city’s inhabitants were displaced. Many of them did not return.”

In a second publication, Saudi Arabia’s ‘Okaz’ newspaper, Saudi journalist Khaled Abbas Tashkandy, wrote in a 2017 article that “his own grandfather was one of the victims of the mass and forced displacement crimes of the people and sons of Madinah by the orders of the military governor Fakhri Pasha during the Seferberlik and how the Turkish soldiers broke into his family’s house and kidnapped him from his mother’s arms and deported him to Astana.” The Saudi journalist confirmed the details of the persecution of the people of  Madinah by Fakhri Pasha and the looting of Prophet Muhammad’s personal effects.

In a third publication, The NewArab published an article by Kemal Afzali on March 11, titled: “Saudis claim last Ottoman governor planned to ‘steal Prophet Muhammad’s body.’” This article “provoked uproar among Saudi social media users, many of whom believe it to be characteristic evidence of alleged Turkish animosity towards the Kingdom’s holy cities.” The Arabic hashtag #desecration_ of_the_prophets_grave has appeared in over 7,500 posts on Twitter and Facebook as of early March. Many Saudis have decried “the historic act of ‘Turkish blasphemy.’” Some have drawn parallels between Fakhri Pasha’s barbaric actions and Pres. Erdogan’s “contemporary support for ‘insurgent activity against Arab states.’” One social media post read: “Turks are a nation of thieves. They are bandits and criminals.”

It is incomprehensible to me that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, after more than a Century, has not demanded that the Turkish government return the looted sacred relics of Prophet Muhammad. While Turkey brazenly demands that museums in other countries return antiques that were taken out of Turkey, even though many of these items are of Greek or Armenian origin, the Turkish government has not returned the stolen Saudi artifacts. Should Turkey refuse to do so, Saudi Arabia should file a lawsuit against Turkey in the World Court and publicize the Turkish theft worldwide.

In the past, Turkey and Saudi Arabia enjoyed normal or friendly relations, but that is not the case now. Due to Pres. Erdogan’s dictatorial and military actions in some parts of the world, Turkey and Saudi Arabia are on the opposite sides of various disputes. As a result, Saudi Arabia has blocked the transmission of Turkish programs from its TV stations and has banned the import of Turkish products. This is the right time for Saudi Arabia to act more decisively against Turkey and demand the return of the sacred religious items belonging to the Kingdom. The display of Prophet Muhammad’s personal effects in a Turkish museum is an insult to all Arabs and all Muslims worldwide. These sacred items belong to Saudi Arabia.



Source Panorama.am
Share |

Newsfeed

15:33
Armenian border troops attend CIS meeting in Baku
Baku is today hosting the 86th meeting of the Council of Commanders of Border Troops of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)....
15:02
Armenia, several other countries help Russia evade sanctions, U.S. claims
Exports of key microchips and electronics that Russia needs for its war machine are back to pre-war levels, as Russia has gotten better at...
14:36
Azerbaijan postpones Washington talks with Armenia
Azerbaijan has postponed the talks with Armenia set to take place in Washington next week, the Armenian Foreign Ministry reported. “At...
14:15
Pope awake and joking after surgery, doctor says
Pope Francis was said to be awake and cheerful Wednesday after undergoing a three-hour hernia operation which has revived concerns over the...
13:58
Artsakh president meets with Ruben Vardanyan
President Arayik Harutyunyan of the Artsakh Republic on Wednesday met with the members of the Council of the Front of Security and...
13:30
ICRC officials visit two Armenian soldiers held in Baku
Representatives of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) have visited two Armenian servicemen held in Azerbaijan. “ICRC...
12:58
Blinken, new Turkish FM discuss Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Thursday held a phone call with new Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan. Fidan and Blinken...
12:31
Direct dialogue between Yerevan, Baku key to durable and dignified peace, U.S. insists
The United States continues to believe that direct dialogue between Armenia and Azerbaijan is key towards reaching a durable and dignified...
12:05
Foreign literature confirms Armenian origin of Dadivank
The inscriptions preserved on the walls of the monastery and ancient khachkars on the territory of the monastery testify to the antiquity and...
11:36
Artsakh reports fresh ceasefire violation by Azerbaijani forces
Artsakh’s military authorities reported a fresh ceasefire breach by Azerbaijani forces last night. "On June 8, between 2:25 a.m....
11:15
Mike Pence launches 2024 presidential bid
Former vice president Mike Pence on Wednesday announced that he is entering the running for the 2024 presidential election, setting up a heated...
11:00
Azeri forces fire at Armenian border positions
Armenian army positions near the village of Khoznavar came under fire from Azerbaijani forces late on Wednesday, the Defense Ministry of Armenia...
17:00
Temperatures to rise in Armenia from Thursday
Showers and thunderstorms will persist in Armenia throughout the week. Hail is possible in some parts of the country, the weather service...
16:36
Messi reportedly ready to play for Barcelona 'for free'
Barcelona are doing what they can in order to bring Lionel Messi back to the club, but pessimism has grown amongst the local press that a deal...
16:26
EU mission plans to open three additional operational hubs in Armenia
The EU Mission in Armenia (EUMA) plans to open three additional operational hubs in Kapan, Ijevan and Yeghegnadzor in the upcoming...
15:48
Armenian analyst: Russia's influence in region reduced during 2020 war
Russia’s influence in the South Caucasus may decline, but it will never vanish, political analyst Alexander Iskandaryan claims. He...
15:09
MP Hugh McDermott calls out international and Australian silence on Artsakh blockade
The New South Wales State Member for Prospect, Dr Hugh McDermott MP, has risen in the New South Wales Legislative Assembly to warn the...
14:35
Yerevan airport customs staff foils drug smuggling attempt
Customs officers at Yerevan’s Zvartnots International Airport have thwarted an attempt to smuggle methamphetamine to Australia. In a...
13:55
Baku, Yerevan 'on the threshold of peace', Azeri FM says
Azerbaijan and Armenia are "on the threshold of peace," Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov said on Tuesday, TASS...
13:36
Canada's Trudeau meets with Catholicos Aram I
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has met with His Holiness Catholicos Aram I of the Great House of Cilicia. "The Armenian...
13:07
World Bank forecasts 4.4% economic growth for Armenia in 2023
Global growth has slowed sharply and the risk of financial stress in emerging market and developing economies (EMDEs) is intensifying amid...
12:35
Situation on Armenian-Azeri border relatively stable, says deputy minister
The situation along the Armenian-Azerbaijani border is relatively stable, Armenia’s Deputy Defense Minister Arman Sargsyan said on...
12:00
World U8-18 Rapid Chess Championships: Three Armenian players scored 3 points
The first game day of the World Under 8-18 Rapid Chess Championships 2023 ended in Batumi, Georgia on Tuesday. After 3 rounds, three...
11:34
Pashinyan off to Russia
Nikol Pashinyan has travelled to Russia on a working visit from June 7-9, the Armenian premier’s office reported. Pashinyan is...
11:15
Advice to Aliyev: Continue destroying Azerbaijan's reputation
By Harut Sassounian Publisher, The California Courier Even though Azerbaijan, with the help of Turkish and Israeli weapons and hired...
11:00
Armenian FM, top U.S. diplomat discuss regional security and stability
Armenia's Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan on Tuesday had a telephone conversation with U.S. Acting Assistant Secretary of State for...
17:00
Temperatures set to drop in Armenia
Showers and thunderstorms will persist in Armenia throughout the week. Hail is possible in some parts of the country, the weather service...
16:45
Patriarch Sahak Mashalian arrives at Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin
His Eminence Archbishop Sahak Mashalian, Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople, arrived at the Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin on Tuesday. On...
16:30
Biden has good chance of re-election, Germany's Scholz says
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz said on Tuesday he is confident that Joe Biden will be re-elected president of the United States when the country...
16:15
Governor welcomes plans to open Russian consulate in Syunik
Syunik Governor Robert Ghukasyan claims the planned opening of a Russian consulate in Armenia’s southern province would help enhance its...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}